Book · 2013

Love's Obsession: The Lives and Archaeology of Jim and Eve Stewart

Judy Powell

Kent Town, South Australia: Wakefield Press

A biography of Jim and Eve Stewart covering their Cyprus excavations, Jim's work at Sydney University and the Nicholson Museum, and Eve's efforts to publish his unfinished research.

Jim Stewart (James Rivers Barrington Stewart) and Eve Stewart (Dorothy Evelyn) are followed from their early lives in England, Australia and Cyprus through their archaeological work, marriage and professional careers. Eve Stewart's archive of correspondence, diaries, photographs and working papers links their personal decisions to excavations, museum collections and the growth of academic archaeology in Australia. Cyprus stays in focus throughout, from the Stewarts' excavations and collecting to Eve's later work to publish Jim's research.

How it is organised

After a prologue, Part 1, “The Old World, 1914–47”, covers Eve's childhood and early archaeological work, Jim's education and travels, their excavations before the war, Jim's military service and imprisonment, and their return to Cyprus. Part 2, “A New World, 1947–62”, follows their move to Australia, the Nicholson Museum, Mount Pleasant, later travel and excavations, and Jim's final years. Part 3, “Wentworth Falls”, follows Eve's work after Jim's death (pp. 5–6, 99, 217).

An epilogue, an appendix on the archive, a timeline, notes, references, a list of Stewart publications and an index close the volume. The twelve chapters run chronologically, with chapter headings marking changes of place and period, and excavations and research recur within the life rather than forming separate technical sections. The timeline sets the Stewarts beside events in Cyprus and in archaeology (pp. 268–270).

The argument

Powell presents Jim's collecting, fieldwork and plans for a Cypriot pottery typology as part of a drive to classify and possess archaeological material, and links that drive to his reluctance to publish without what he regarded as complete evidence. His ambitions are set against the financial, institutional and political circumstances that repeatedly obstructed them, among them his proposals for a Cyprus survey and for an archaeological centre at Mount Pleasant (pp. 48–50, 80–83, 145–148).

Powell traces Eve's excavation experience, her drawing and editorial skills, and her gradual assumption of responsibility for the corpus and other unfinished publications. She also examines the consequences of the Stewarts' collecting and of distributing excavation finds to institutions, including the problems that arose when context, ownership and publication were not resolved (pp. 220–230).

The evidence

Powell draws chiefly on the Stewarts' letters and personal papers, above all the archive Eve maintained, and adds diaries, military records, excavation accounts, institutional correspondence, interviews and recollections from colleagues, students and Cypriot associates. The appendix describes how the letters are arranged by correspondent and chronology, notes that some were annotated or duplicated, and identifies gaps where the couple were together or where only one side of an exchange survives (pp. 262–266).

The Stewarts' Cypriot fieldwork is placed in the history of excavation and antiquities administration. Eve worked at Ayios Philon and Aphendrika, Jim and Eleanor Stewart excavated at Vounous, and Jim had earlier worked in Turkey at Babaköy and Kusura. Vounous supplies the background to Jim's developing interest in connecting Cypriot and Anatolian pottery. The field report, published as Vounous 1937–38, appeared in 1950 after war, imprisonment and the move to Australia, and Powell describes the criticism of its limited interpretive discussion and of its reliance on a pottery corpus that remained unfinished (pp. 22–24, 43–55, 125–127).

The 1955 excavations at Vasilia and Ayia Paraskevi are told through the Stewarts' letters and diaries: the rapid shift between sites, the damage looting did to contexts, and the division of finds. The 1961 work at Lapatsa and Palealona receives a fuller account covering the team, land access, the pace of excavation, field recording, tombs and finds, among them the relief later called the Mary Ann and a tomb with a Kamares-style cup. Powell follows the transport, storage, repair and publication of this material (pp. 159–164, 198–207).

Dating

Period terms in use include Neolithic, Chalcolithic, Early Cypriot, Middle Cypriot, Late Bronze Age and Roman. Jim's principal archaeological project was a classification of Early Cypriot pottery, and his work on the Philia material concerns its relationship to the first phase of the Early Bronze Age. The 1961 tomb discussion connects a Cypriot context with Middle Minoan II pottery and Kamares ware, and the book attributes the chronological interpretations to Jim (pp. 204–205).

Wentworth Falls

Jim's The Early Cypriote Bronze Age appeared posthumously in 1962, while Eve went on preparing manuscripts and excavation reports. Parts of the corpus and the 1955 excavation reports were published after years of work, among them Ayia Paraskevi and Vasilia in 1988 (pp. 237–244).

The closing chapters trace the later disposition of Jim's papers, library, coins and archaeological collections, alongside Eve's efforts to complete his publications and her unsuccessful proposal for a research centre at Tjiklos. The library and coin collection were eventually sold, and Eve later supported the Cyprus American Archaeological Research Institute. The final account returns to the limits of Jim's collecting and to Eve's role in preserving and completing parts of their shared work (pp. 223–250).

What it records

  • At Vounous, Jim and Eleanor Stewart excavated eighty-four Early Cypriot rock-cut tombs in two burial grounds over a year and a half.p. 57
  • Jim Stewart proposed a three-year survey of Cyprus taking in sites on the North Coast and in the districts of Paphos, Limassol and Famagusta.p. 63
  • The Stewarts' 1950 Vounous volume was criticised for omitting a general analysis and for relying on an unfinished pottery corpus.p. 125
  • A recommendation was made to reject the offer of Mount Pleasant for an archaeological centre and to seek premises in Sydney instead.p. 147
  • In the 1955 division of finds, Cyprus kept the Vasilia tomb with the large alabaster bowl and the largest Ayia Paraskevi tomb.p. 164
  • On 2 August 1960 the University of Sydney appointed Jim Stewart to its inaugural Chair of Near Eastern Studies.p. 192
  • Work at Lapatsa began on 27 February 1961 and finished on 24 March, with Lapatsa and Palealona excavated simultaneously for several weeks.p. 200
  • The 1961 Lapatsa excavation employed twelve labourers, a donkey man and a night watchman.p. 203
  • Tomb 6 at Palealona held a bas-relief figure cut into the wall of the tomb entrance.p. 204
  • The Palealona relief was named Mary Ann after Mary Ann Meagher, a Sydney University student.p. 204
  • The last day of the 1961 excavations produced an unlooted Middle Cypriot tomb with a faience bead and a cup from Crete.p. 204
  • Powell reports that Jim Stewart believed the Kamares cup, by linking a datable period in Crete to an undated one in Cyprus, solved chronological problems of the whole Near East.p. 205
  • The University of Sydney's library assessment put Jim Stewart's collection at 580 linear feet.p. 224
  • The university librarian recommended buying Jim Stewart's library for £15,000.p. 224
  • Eve Stewart could not obtain permission to complete the Palealona excavations during her 1967 visit to Cyprus.p. 233
  • Eve Stewart described her work on the corpus as first following Jim's decisions, with her own judgement developing after his death.p. 244
  • Eve Stewart's sale of Tjiklos helped fund a building in Nicosia for the Cyprus American Archaeological Research Institute.p. 257
  • Ayia Paraskevi and Vasilia is listed in the index and references as published in 1988.p. 271

Where to read

  • Jim Stewart's excavations at Vounous and the publication of the field reportpp. 53–58
  • The proposed Australian Cyprus Expedition and the Mount Pleasant research centrepp. 63–65
  • The 1955 excavations at Vasilia and Ayia Paraskevipp. 160–164
  • The 1961 Lapatsa and Palealona excavations, including the relief and Kamares cuppp. 200–206
  • Eve Stewart's work on Jim's corpus and unfinished publicationspp. 219–244
  • The Stewart archive and its correspondencepp. 262–266

Contents

  • Prologue1
  • Part 1: The Old World, 1914–475
  • England, Egypt and Cyprus, 1914–367
  • England and Cyprus, 1936–3925
  • England, Cyprus and the Near East, 1930–3835
  • War, 1940–4560
  • England and Cyprus, 1945–4786
  • Part 2: A New World, 1947–6299
  • Australia, 1947–50101
  • Mount Pleasant, 1951–54128
  • Travels, 1955–56149
  • Mount Pleasant and Sydney, 1957–60171
  • Australia and Cyprus, 1960–62189
  • Part 3: Wentworth Falls217
  • Australia, 1962–90219
  • Wentworth Falls, 1990236
  • Epilogue: Legacies247
  • Appendix: The D.E. (Eve) Stewart Archive, in Praise of Handwriting262
  • Timeline268
  • Notes272
  • References298
  • Stewart Publications300
  • Index311

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

Places

  • VounousEarly Cypriot cemetery excavated by the Stewarts
  • Ayios Philonbasilica excavated by Joan du Plat Taylor
  • AphendrikaHellenistic tombs excavated by Eve and Kim
  • VasiliaBronze Age cemetery excavated in 1955
  • Ayia Paraskevisite excavated by Jim and Eve Stewart
  • Lapatsacemetery excavated in 1961
  • Palealonacemetery excavated in 1961
  • KarmiBronze Age cemetery excavation area
  • TjiklosTom Dray's property near Kyrenia

Also named: Andreas Diamantis, American School of Classical Studies in Athens, Powerhouse Museum, Lund University.

Extent 1 map; timeline; references (pp. 298–302); index (pp. 311–316)

ModernEarly Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeNeolithicChalcolithicRomanMedievalHistory of ArchaeologyCollectingPotteryBurialMuseums

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

9 pages · 1 object

Excavations it is cited for

7 projects

Who did what

59 records

Buying, selling and giving 19

Show 4 more

Excavation 16

Show 1 more
  • Dorothy Evelyn Stewart (née Dray)Recorded

    Eve applied for a permit to complete the Palealona excavations, but it does not appear to have been granted.

    two extra tombs east of Tomb 9No. Tomb 9

    p. 233

Recording and study 20

Show 5 more
  • Dorothy Evelyn Stewart (née Dray)Employed byNicholson Museum

    Eve Stewart was employed for a few years as a technical assistant at the Nicholson Museum.

    p. 265
  • James Rivers Barrington StewartPublished

    James R. Stewart published an account of excavations at Vounous, Cyprus.

    1937 · p. 300
  • James Rivers Barrington StewartPublished

    James R. Stewart published a study of three Cypriot Iron Age jugs in the Biblical Museum, Melbourne.

    Three jugs of the Cypriot Iron Age

    1940 · p. 300
  • Eleanor StewartPublished

    Eleanor Stewart and James Stewart published the field report on the Vounous excavations.

    Vounous 1937–38 excavations

    1950 · p. 300
  • James Rivers Barrington StewartPublished

    Eleanor Stewart and James Stewart published the field report on the Vounous excavations.

    Vounous 1937–38 excavations

    1950 · p. 300

Posts and family 4

People it is cited for

60 people
30 more

Institutions it is cited for

18 institutions

Mentioned in

24 mentions

Tomb records · 7

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.