Chapter · 2025
Over the landscape, in the landscape? Knowledge and agency in Cypriot archaeology, 1870-1910
Michael Given; edited by T. Kiely, A. Reeve and L. Crewe
In Empire & Excavation: Critical perspectives on archaeology in British-period Cyprus, 1878-1960. Leiden: Sidestone Press
A chapter on colonial and local agency in Cypriot archaeology between 1870 and 1910, using maps, excavation accounts, place-names, agricultural practice and Orthodox traditions.
Archaeological knowledge and practice in Cyprus between about 1870 and 1910 took shape through colonial practitioners, local communities and the physical landscape. Given contrasts the authoritative maps, plans and excavation narratives of the period with local knowledge grounded in village life, work, place-names and religious practice. His examples run from Kitchener's survey and the excavations at Kourion, Salamis and Tamassos to community memories attached to Kaloriziki and the use of ancient objects in churches. The sections move from imperial views and mapping to local knowledge, then to the agricultural year and to the reuse of ancient objects in Orthodox settings, before a conclusion.
The evidence
Given compares published accounts, maps, photographs, excavation notebooks and archival reports. Cesnola's images and narratives portray the commanding view and the excavator's authority, whereas the British Museum notebook map of tombs at Kourion records the process behind claims to precise provenance. Kitchener's Survey of Cyprus joins topographic detail to Greek and Turkish place-names and to labels for settlements, churches and ancient sites (pp. 37–40).
Local knowledge is traced through the accounts of antiquarians and government superintendents, cadastral place-names, workers' testimony and community memory. Given discusses the Tamassos reports of Sophocles Stavrinides and the villagers' information about the Chatsworth Head, and the names and testimony of workers associated with Cesnola. He also follows George McFadden's use of Socrates Stylianou's directions to relocate Tomb 40 at Kaloriziki in 1952, the agricultural calendars that halted digging, local explanations for unsuccessful excavation, and ancient objects incorporated into Orthodox religious settings (pp. 40–47).
The principal period is about 1870–1910, with Kitchener's survey of 1878–1882, excavations and mapping in the 1880s and 1890s, and cadastral plans from 1919. Later episodes, among them the 1952 relocation of Tomb 40 and the discussion of archaeological practice today, trace local knowledge that continued.
The argument
Given argues that archaeological authority was built through mapping, visual display and the presentation of observations as objective knowledge, and that these practices could hide the labour, local information and subjective decisions involved in fieldwork. Colonial and local knowledge, he argues, were not separate, fixed systems: maps took in local place-names, and excavators relied on guides, workers and community memories. Archaeology appears as collaborative, with agency distributed among people, landscapes, structures and artefacts.
He concludes that local landscape knowledge and agency were integral to the work even where published accounts credited foreign directors and concealed their sources. Place-names preserve knowledge of vegetation, land use, churches and archaeological remains, and oral recollections could guide excavators to particular features. Orthodox discovery narratives and the continued use of ancient objects are presented as ways of engaging with the past that are embedded in community practice. The closing section calls on archaeologists to recognise distributed agency and to build more inclusive relationships with local communities (pp. 41–48).
What it records
- Lieutenant H.H. Kitchener carried out the Survey of Cyprus in 1878–1882.p. 38
- Kitchener's map of the Kourion and Episkopi area names villages, localities, rural churches and ancient sites, including Curium and the Sanctuary of 'Apóllon'.p. 38
- Sophocles Stavrinides sent eight successive reports with lists of finds to the Chief Secretary's office during the Royal Berlin Museum excavations at Tamassos in 1889.p. 41
- Villagers told Sophocles Stavrinides that the bronze head later known as the 'Chatsworth Head' had been found in the Pedhiaios river bed.p. 41
- George McFadden located Socrates Stylianou, who said Tomb 40 at Kaloriziki lay on the scarp between a fig tree and a carob tree with three trunks.p. 43
- The Curium Expedition of the University of Pennsylvania went to Kaloriziki on 31 March 1952 and found a carob tree with three trunks and a fig tree 19 m apart.p. 43
- An old Turk who had watched Socrates, Markos and Mavrosavvas excavate the tomb 50 years earlier watched the expedition as it excavated Tomb 40, McFadden reports.p. 43
- Given notes that excavation in early Cyprus often stopped for the harvest, as it did for Luigi Palma di Cesnola at the Sanctuary of Apollo Hylates and for Charles Watkins.p. 44
- The church of Ayios Ermoyenis below the Acropolis at Kourion displays a Roman cippus beside the saint's tomb.p. 46
- In the discovery story the chapter recounts, Archbishop Anthemios found Saint Barnabas's tomb and a copy of the Gospel of Saint Matthew in about 488 AD.p. 46
Where to read
- Cesnola's commanding views and archaeological imagerypp. 37–38
- Kitchener's survey and mapped place-names around Kourionpp. 38–42
- Workers, local testimony and Tomb 40 at Kalorizikipp. 42–43
- Agricultural calendars and excavation workpp. 44–45
- Cippi, icons and Orthodox discovery narrativespp. 45–47
Contents
- Over the Landscape, in the Landscape? Knowledge and Agency in Cypriot Archaeology, 1870–191035
- Introduction: Agencies and Archaeologies35
- Archaeological Landscapes under Imperial Eyes37
- Landscape Technologies38
- Local Knowledge40
- A Carob Tree with Three Trunks42
- Harvesting the Landscape44
- Spolia and the Excavation of Saints45
- Conclusion: Archaeological Landscapes in the Late 19th Century and Today47
- Acknowledgments47
- Key Readings48
People, places and institutions
People
- Luigi Palma di Cesnolaexcavator and author of Cesnola-era accounts
- Alessandro Palma di Cesnolaexcavated at Salamis
- Gordon Hakesupervised excavations
- H.H. Kitchenerdirected the Survey of Cyprus
- Sophocles StavrinidesGovernment Superintendent at Tamassos
- Max Ohnefalsch-Richterexcavation director at Tamassos
- Lorenzo Warriner Peasevisited the Sanctuary of Apollo Hylates in 1839
- George McFaddenexcavated Tomb 40 at Kaloriziki
- Socrates Stylianoulocal digger and informant on Tomb 40
- Markos Elevtherioulocal digger at Kaloriziki
- Mavrosavvaslocal digger at Kaloriziki
- Christofi Christodulutestified about Cesnola's excavations
- Theocharis Kutzochairostestified about Cesnola's workers
- Gregorios Antonioudigger and excavation foreman
- Basil Bars'kyjpilgrim who recorded icon traditions
- Archbishop Anthemiosarchbishop in the Saint Barnabas discovery story
- Saint BarnabasCypriot saint in the discovery story
Institutions
- British Museumemployed archaeologists at Kourion
- South Kensington Museumsponsored excavations in Cyprus
- University of Pennsylvaniasponsored the Curium Expedition
- Colonial and Indian Exhibitiondisplayed a colonial tableau of Cyprus
- Ordnance Surveymapped Cyprus and collected place-names
Places
- Kourionsite of mapping and excavation examples
- Salamissite of Cesnola and Hake excavations
- Tamassossite of the 1889 excavations
- Episkopisource of local knowledge about Kaloriziki
- Kalorizikinecropolis and location of Tomb 40
- Sanctuary of Apollo Hylatessanctuary known through local place-names
- Ayios Ermoyenischurch beside a Roman cippus
- Mathiatisite of a church using a cippus
Also named: Demetrios Pierides, Veli Pasha, Lord Sligo, Ludwig Ross, Savas, John Myres, Leonard Woolley, Charles Watkins, A.H. Smith, Saint Paul, Saint Matthew, Royal Berlin Museum, Amathous, Marion, Polis, Enkomi.
Extent pp. 35–48, figs 2.1–2.6, map; bibliography
ModernCypro-GeometricRomanMedievalHistory of ArchaeologyLandscape and ClimateLooting and the LawReligion and CultDaily Life
Excavations it is cited for
8 projects- 1874–1875Kourion: Luigi Palma di Cesnola's excavationsDirected by Luigi Palma di CesnolaClearance and early digging
- 1876–1879Salamis and Enkomi: Alessandro Palma di Cesnola's excavationsDirected by Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola and Lazaris Philippi (supervisor on Cesnola's behalf)Clearance and early digging
- 1882Enkomi: the South Kensington Museum tomb excavationsDirected by George Gordon HakeExcavation
- 1885–1887Marion: the Ohnefalsch-Richter and Williamson syndicateDirected by Max Ohnefalsch-Richter and John William WilliamsonExcavation
- 1889–1890Marion: the Cyprus Exploration Fund excavationsDirected by John Arthur Ruskin Munro and H. Arnold TubbsExcavation
- 1889–1894Tamassos: Ohnefalsch-Richter's excavations for the Berlin Museums, 1889 and 1894Directed by Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavation
- 1893–1894Amathus: the British Museum (Turner Bequest) excavationDirected by Arthur Hamilton Smith and John Linton MyresExcavation
- 1934–1954Kourion: the Penn Museum excavations (Curium Expedition)Directed by George H. McFadden, Bert Hodge Hill, John Franklin Daniel and othersExcavation
Who did what
22 recordsBuying, selling and giving 3
- p. 42
Markos ElevtheriouHad objects seized
Markos Elevtheriou's finds were confiscated from a house in Larnaca and held at the Customs House.
their finds, including the famous gold and enamel sceptre
- p. 42
Socrates StylianouHad objects seized
Socrates Stylianou's finds were confiscated from a house in Larnaca and held at the Customs House.
their finds, including the famous gold and enamel sceptre
- p. 44
Gregorios AntoniouBought
Gregorios Antoniou purchased antiquities from unlicensed diggers.
With unlicensed diggers
Excavation 18
- 1882 · p. 38
George Gordon HakeDug forSouth Kensington Museum
Hake conducted most of the fieldwork for the South Kensington Museum's excavations, exploring about 45 tombs.
some 45 tombsbetween the monastery of St. Barnabas and the village of Enkomi
- 1882 · p. 38
Herbert KitchenerDug forSouth Kensington Museum
Kitchener directed excavations for the South Kensington Museum beginning in January 1882.
archaeological remainsCyprus
- 1889 · p. 41
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavated
Stavrinides reported that Max Ohnefalsch-Richter was digging in the Pedhiaios river bed outside the permitted area and without a landowner's contract.
Pedhiaios river bed, outside the area of Government permission
- 1889 · p. 41
Sophocles StavrinidesHeld a post
Sophocles Stavrinides was appointed Government Superintendent during the Tamassos excavations.
- p. 41
Sophocles StavrinidesRecorded
Sophocles Stavrinides sent eight reports to the Chief Secretary's office with lists of objects found.
objects found at TamassosTamassos
- 1876 · p. 42
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaExcavated
Cesnola dug near the ruins of Salamis with help from natives of two villages.
- p. 42
Luigi Palma di CesnolaEmployedChristofis Christodoulou
Luigi Palma di Cesnola employed Christofi Christodulu as a worker.
- p. 42
Luigi Palma di CesnolaEmployedTheocharis Koutsocheris
Luigi Palma di Cesnola employed Theocharis Kutzochairos as a worker.
- p. 42
Markos ElevtheriouExcavated
According to George McFadden, Markos Elevtheriou was one of three tomb robbers who looted a tomb at Kaloriziki.
- p. 42
SavvasFound
Savas from Pyrga originally found the tomb from which most of the 'Treasure' material came.
a tombplain close to the church of Ayios Ermoyenis
- p. 42
Socrates StylianouExcavated withMarkos Elevtheriou
Socrates Stylianou and Markos Elevtheriou looted a tomb at Kaloriziki with Mavrosavvas.
- p. 42
Socrates StylianouExcavated
According to George McFadden, Socrates Stylianou was one of three tomb robbers who looted a tomb at Kaloriziki.
- 1894 · p. 43
John Linton MyresWorked withGregorios Antoniou
Grigori was identified as an assistant working with John Myres at Amathous.
reject pots
- 1894 · p. 43
John Linton MyresWorked withTeacher
The Teacher was identified as an assistant working with John Myres at Amathous.
reject pots
- 1886 · p. 44
Charles F. WatkinsExcavated
Charles Watkins stopped excavating at Marion for the harvest.
Show 3 moreShow fewer
- 1889 · p. 44
Gregorios AntoniouExcavated
Munro and Tubbs noted Gregorios Antoniou's skill at tomb digging while he was excavating at Polis.
tombs
- p. 44
Luigi Palma di CesnolaExcavated
Luigi Palma di Cesnola's excavation at the Sanctuary of Apollo Hylates stopped for the harvest.
- p. 44
Sir Charles Leonard WoolleyEmployedGregorios Antoniou
Leonard Woolley employed Gregorios Antoniou, whom he described as a poacher turned gamekeeper.
Recording and study 1
- 1839 · p. 41
Lorenzo Warriner PeaseRecorded
Lorenzo Warriner Pease visited the Sanctuary of Apollo Hylates, where local people used the name ‘Apollonas’.
People it is cited for
139 people- Stephan G. Schmid15 citations
- Giorgos Papantoniou9 citations
- Christine E. Morris8 citations
- Lindy Crewe8 citations
- Silvana Di Paolo8 citations
- Jacques Lagarce6 citations
- Socrates Stylianou6 citations
- Stella Diakou6 citations
- A. Bernard Knapp5 citations
- A. Rogers5 citations
- Anastasia Christophilopoulou5 citations
- Anna Cannavò5 citations
- Anna Holly Reeve5 citations
- Giorgos Constantinou5 citations
- Adolf Furtwängler4 citations
- Alexandra Bounia4 citations
- C. Giangrande4 citations
- David A. Sewell4 citations
- E. M. Guest4 citations
- Ellen Herscher4 citations
- Fulvia Lo Schiavo4 citations
- George Gordon Hake4 citations
- James D. Muhly4 citations
- Kevin D. Fisher4 citations
- Lucia Vagnetti4 citations
- M. Bettelli4 citations
- Maria Mina4 citations
- Stella Demesticha4 citations
- Veronica Seton-Williams4 citations
- Aoife Fitzgerald3 citations
109 more
- Barbara Kling3 citations
- C. Verlinden3 citations
- David Frankel3 citations
- Eleni Vassilika3 citations
- G. Tucci3 citations
- George H. McFadden3 citations
- George Rapp3 citations
- Georgia Marina Andreou3 citations
- Giorgos Bourogiannis3 citations
- Gregorios Antoniou3 citations
- John Boardman3 citations
- Kenneth W. Schaar3 citations
- Kristian Göransson3 citations
- Mario Iozzo3 citations
- Martha Demas3 citations
- Polina Nikolaou3 citations
- Siobhán Hargis3 citations
- Sophia Antoniadou3 citations
- Susan Sherratt3 citations
- Theodora Moutsiou3 citations
- Theopisti Stylianou-Lambert3 citations
- Wolfgang Filser3 citations
- A. D. Grishin2 citations
- Alan H. Simmons2 citations
- Andrew McCarthy2 citations
- Angeliki Pieridou2 citations
- Anna Margherita Jasink2 citations
- Athanasios K. Vionis2 citations
- Bars'kyj2 citations
- Carole McCartney2 citations
- Christian Mühlenbock2 citations
- Christine Winkelmann2 citations
- Eilis M. Monahan2 citations
- Elisa Panero2 citations
- Erin Walcek Averett2 citations
- Ferdinand Dümmler2 citations
- George Jeffery2 citations
- Georges Perrot2 citations
- Helena Wylde Swiny2 citations
- Ioannis Taifacos2 citations
- Iosif Hadjikyriakos2 citations
- Lorenzo Warriner Pease2 citations
- Luca Bombardieri2 citations
- Ludovic Thély2 citations
- Margit Z. Krpata2 citations
- Markos Elevtheriou2 citations
- N. P. Stanley Price2 citations
- Nicolle E. Hirschfeld2 citations
- P. E. Pecorella2 citations
- Reyhan Sabri2 citations
- Savvas2 citations
- Sevasti Triantaphyllou2 citations
- Sophocles Stavrinides2 citations
- Susan Womer Katzev2 citations
- Teresa Bürge2 citations
- Vassiliki Kassianidou2 citations
- A. Malekos
- Adriano Orsingher
- Alex Knodell
- Anaïs Boucher
- Anna G. Marangou
- Anna P. Georgiadou
- Anthony Snodgrass
- Artemis Karnava
- Carl-Gustaf Styrenius
- Charles F. Watkins
- Christofis Christodoulou
- Claude Baurain
- Claude Delaval Cobham
- Constance von Rüden
- Derek B. Counts
- Despina Pilides
- Diane Bolger
- Dimitris Kyriakou
- Donald McDonald Creveling
- Edward Carletti
- Elizabeth Hoak-Doering
- Erin Gibson
- Ersin Hussein
- Eugen Oberhummer
- F. Whitling
- Francesca Chelazzi
- J. Adams
- Jan-Marc Henke
- Jennifer M. Webb
- Katja Walcher
- Kyriakou
- Linda Hulin
- Lucie Bonato
- Maria Cristina Preacco
- Maria Tolis
- Mavrosavvas
- Mrs E. Dohan
- N. C. Flemming
- Nancy Serwint
- Nathan K. Harper
- Nathan Meyer
- Philippa M. Steele
- Pierre Devambez
- R. Maddin
- Sarah Irving
- Sarah J. Monks
- Sherry C. Fox
- Sir Arthur John Evans
- Sir Charles Leonard Woolley
- Élisabeth Martin du Puytison-Lagarce
- Herbert Kitchener
- Sebastiano Soldi
- Theocharis Koutsocheris
Institutions it is cited for
17 institutions- British School at Athens3 citations
- Bryn Mawr College3 citations
- Vasilikos Valley Project3 citations
- Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche2 citations
- University of Cyprus2 citations
- University of Exeter2 citations
- Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres
- Land Registration and Survey Department
- National Geographic Society
- New Swedish Cyprus Expedition (Söderberg Expedition)
- Society for Cypriot Studies
- Trinity College Dublin
- University at Albany, State University of New York
- University of North Dakota
- British School of Archaeology in Jerusalem
- Royal Colonial Institute / Royal Empire Society library
- Society for the Promotion of Hellenic Studies
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.