Draughtsman / artist · Excavator · Expedition member · Museum buyer
Edmond Duthoit
Edmond Clément Marie Duthoit
1837–1889 · France
French architect who, left alone in Cyprus in 1862, dug at Athienou and Dali for the Vogüé mission, and in 1865 returned on a state commission and shipped the colossal Amathus vase to the Louvre.
Biography
When the Vogüé-Waddington mission left Cyprus for Syria in March 1862, the man who stayed behind to do the digging was its draughtsman, Edmond Duthoit. Foucart-Borville, who published his Cypriot letters, puts it in Duthoit's own words: left alone for a time, he had to take charge of everything, excavation and drawing1.
Duthoit was born at Amiens on 1 May 1837 into a family of sculptor-decorators, studied at Jesuit colleges, and in September 1857 entered the Paris agency of Viollet-le-Duc, where he stayed until about 18721. Viollet-le-Duc recommended him to Melchior de Vogüé. The three men divided the work: Vogüé took history, description and photography, Duthoit the drawings, and William Waddington the inscriptions1. They sailed from Marseille on 22 December 1861 and landed at Larnaca on 28 January 1862, where Duthoit lodged with the French consul1. After a six-week tour of the island, Vogüé and Waddington left on the day after 10 March, and Duthoit stayed for the excavations1.
From about 9 March he was settled at Athienou with a house, a dragoman, an accountant, a cook, a muleteer and a soldier, and 100 to 150 workmen on three points1. Golgoi, where Vogüé had expected most, gave only badly built foundations. On his own initiative he opened two further digs, at Ayios Photios and Malloura, and told Vogüé so; at Malloura the farmers said the heads Vogüé had bought came from the place4. By 24 March he had 60 to 80 heads and about fifteen limbless statues, and by May 150 to 200 heads1. He found the heads, limbs and torsos in separate pits and at first took this for deliberate destruction by a Christian sect of the third or fourth century. The editors of his letters read the pits as deposits of old votives cleared from sanctuaries1. He later moved on to Arsos, where he found phallic ex-votos with Greek dedications, and to Dali, where he dug a hill and tombs and found bronze arrow- and lance-heads and a scarab4.
Holding an imperial firman, he wrote, he made a peasant sell him a capital built into a wall for 20 francs, and that this scene had been repeated three or four times; he also bought heads at 10 to 20 sous1. At Soli, with Sosthène Grasset, he had the Cypriot syllabic inscription loaded over the objection of the local official, by his own account threatening to have him dismissed1. At Palaipaphos he cleared the Spilaion tis Reginas, and at Amathus he removed four inscriptions from house walls by force; in May a navy ship took the cases on board at Kouklia1. Vogüé wrote that Duthoit had overcome the ill will of officials and inhabitants by his great authority1. Grasset later called the Golgoi dig sterile, but Foucart-Borville treats that as jealous exaggeration1.
At Amathus he also cleared the two large vases, drew them, and had a wall built round the better one. The French vice-consul claimed it for France and the Pasha protested. The vases had been known for a long time; Duthoit's part was the claim and, later, the removal1.
In 1865 he returned on a state commission. A letter of 11 March 1865 from the Count of Nieuwerkerke sent him to survey Assos and then to Cyprus to complete the collection "according to the indications of M. de Longpérier", at 1,000 francs a month1. In July he found a new deposit of statues at Athienou, 50 paces from his trench of 1862: 500 to 600 heads and thousands of fragments over about 1,000 square metres, packed into more than twenty cases1. He took inscriptions at Polis tis Chrysochou and Lapithos1. The consul, Louis Dumesnil de Maricourt, tried behind his back to have a frigate lift the vase and failed. Duthoit wrote that until it reached France it was "my property", for which he answered to the government1. Maricourt then died of cholera, nursed by Duthoit; Duthoit was shunned in Larnaca for it and wrote of leaving a country he had come to hate1. The vase left on the navy vessel La Perdrix on 30 October 1865 and is in the Louvre as AO 228971,11. The cases of statuary waited at Larnaca until a state ship called in July 18661.
Vogüé insisted that a room at the Louvre bear the names of Vogüé and Duthoit; it was later renamed the Salle phénicienne et chypriote1. A bearded head with a vegetal crown, AM 2935, is probably the "Tête de Bacchus indien" of Duthoit's letter of 8 February 1862, according to the Louvre's record12. His intended publication on Cyprus never appeared. More than a hundred of his Cypriot drawings and watercolours are in the Musée de Picardie at Amiens, and he reported more than 1,200 drawings for the whole 1862 mission, most of them kept by Vogüé and since lost1,7.
He became attached to the Commission des monuments historiques in 1866, worked at Roquetaillade and Abbadia, and went to Algeria in 1872; he was architect in chief of its historic monuments from 1880 and received the Légion d'honneur in 1882 for his work there1,9. He worked on the church of Notre-Dame de Brebières at Albert and died at Amiens in June 18891,5.
Life and work
- 22 December 1861Sailed from Marseille with Vogüé and Waddington; Beirut 2 January 1862.
MarseilleFoucart-Borville 1985, p. 12
- 28 January 1862Landed at Larnaca; six weeks' riding tour of the whole island with Vogüé and Waddington (24 Feb to 9 Mar), ending at Larnaca.
- March–April 1862Left alone in Cyprus when Vogüé and Waddington went to Syria (11 March), he dug at Athienou (Golgoi, Ayios Photios, Malloura) with about 100-150 workmen from c. 9 March, then at Arsos, 'Alesso' and Dali; 8 carts and 23-24 mule loads of fragments sent to Larnaca. His own phrase: 'pendant l'absence de M. de Vogüé, et d'après ses ordres, j'ai fait fouiller'.
AthienouFoucart-Borville 1985, pp. 23-26Bonato 1999Toumazou et al. 2011, pp. 66-69
- April 1862Removed the Cypriot syllabic inscription at Soli (later Louvre AM 1861) with Grasset against the objection of the mudir, using the firman.
- May–June 1862Cleared the Spilaion tis Reginas at Palaipaphos (two Cypriot inscriptions found, taken to the Prométhée); took four inscriptions out of house walls at Amathus 'de force'; the navy aviso Prométhée embarked 52 cases.
- July 1862At the Amathus vases he cleared the colossal vase, built a protective wall round it and had the French vice-consul take possession in France's name; the Pasha protested.
AmathusFoucart-Borville 1985, p. 36
- 11 March 1865Nieuwerkerke charges him to go to Assos, survey it, and then to Cyprus to complete the collection of antiquities 'selon les indications de M. de Longpérier'; 1,000 francs a month, 8,000 plus a 2,000 supplement in total.
- 30 May 1865 – 8 August 1865Second Cyprus visit alone: moulded the vase handles, surveyed Venetian cannon for the Ottoman grand master of artillery, toured the island, took inscriptions at Polis tis Chrysochou and Lapithos, and found a new deposit of statues at Athienou 50 paces from his 1862 trench (5-600 heads, thousands of fragments; over twenty cases packed).
AthienouFoucart-Borville 1985, pp. 39-44
- July 1865Consul de Maricourt tried to remove the Amathus vase without him on a frigate (rear-admiral d'Aboville) and failed; Maricourt died of cholera on or about 26-27 July with Duthoit at his side, and Duthoit acted for the consulate and copied the 13th-century inscriptions of a Frankish cemetery found at Limassol.
- 30 October 1865After the June attempt failed, the Amathus vase was embarked on the navy vessel La Perdrix (La Mouette also named) and reached France; Louvre AO 22897. Other cases of antiquities left at Larnaca until a state ship called on 16 July 1866.
AmathusFoucart-Borville 1985, p. 49Vase d'Amathonte, Musée du…
- 1866Made chevalier of the Ottoman Medjidie for his inventory of Cypriot artillery, not for the cholera episode.
- 1882Légion d'honneur, granted on account of his Algerian missions.
- June 1889Died at Amiens while designing Notre-Dame de Brebières at Albert.
Connections
27 peopleSales, gifts & bequests
- Represented by Antonio Mattei1862–1866
- Financed by Melchior de Vogüé1862–1863
- Bought from Paul Tardieu1865
Family
- Left property to Geneviève Duthoit
Fieldwork & employment
- Employed by Melchior de Vogüé1861–1865
- Employed Antonio Mattei1862–1865
- Guided Laffon (former médecin-major)1862
- Guided by Laffon (former médecin-major)1862
- Dug for Melchior de Vogüé1862
- Excavated with Melchior de Vogüé1862
- Employed Procope1862
- Excavated with Sosthène Grasset d'Orcet1862
- Guided by Sosthène Grasset d'Orcet1862
- Employed by Alfred Émilien, comte de Nieuwerkerke1865
- Employed Clémentin Mattei1865
- Employed Costa1865
Disputes & the law
- Rival of Sosthène Grasset d'Orcet1862–1892
- Rival of Charles de Maricourt1865
- Rival of Dominic Ellis Colnaghipossibly1865
- Rival of Louis Dumesnil de Maricourt1865
Scholarship
- Corresponded with Acamas1862
- Corresponded with Alban Emmanuel Guillaume-Rey1862
- Corresponded with Melchior de Vogüé1862–1865
- Corresponded with Adrien de Longpérier1864–1870
- Teacher of Henri Bernard1889
- Material published by Camille Enlart1899
- Material published by Jacques Foucart-Borville1985
- Material published by Lucie Bonato1999–2001
Colleagues & contacts
- Met Adrien Santi Mattei1862
- Met Charles Gaillardot1862–1865
- Connected with Edouard du Tour1862
- Worked with Henry William Waddington1862–1865
- Worked with Melchior de Vogüé1862–1865
- Worked with Paul Tardieu1862–1865
- Worked with Sosthène Grasset d'Orcet1862
- Connected with S.A. Aali Pacha1865
- Connected with Camille Enlart1896–1899
- Connected with Athanasios A. Sakellariospossibly
- Connected with Dominique Albert Edouard Tiburce Colonna-Ceccaldi
Objects
Colossal limestone vase from Amathus, 3.2-3.5 m across, bull-handled
From Amathus (Palaia Limassol)Musée du Louvre AO 2289730 October 1865Vase d'Amathonte, Musée du…Foucart-Borville 1985, p. 49
Head of bearded man with vegetal crown, probably the 'Tête de Bacchus indien' of Duthoit's letter of 8 February 1862
From Athienou = Golgoi (?)Musée du Louvre AM 29351862Statue head, Musée du…
Cypriot syllabic inscription taken at Soli
From SoliMusée du Louvre AM 18611862Foucart-Borville 1985, pp. 26-28Bonato 1999
Great deposits of mutilated limestone statuary and heads from Athienou (Ayios Photios, Malloura, 'Golgoi')
From AthienouMusée du Louvre1862–1866Foucart-Borville 1985, pp. 24Toumazou et al. 2011, p. 69
Heads bought privately by him from peasants for 10-20 sous, kept for Vogüé or the government first
From Athienou area1862Foucart-Borville 1985, p. 25
Seated 'statue de M. Grasset', held in Larnaca customs 1865-66
From Athienou or DhaliMusée du Louvre1880Foucart-Borville 1985, p. 50
On Ancient Cyprus
4 pagesSources
- 1.Jacques Foucart-Borville (1985). “La correspondance chypriote d'Edmond Duthoit (1862 et 1865)”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 4, 3-60. Online
- 2.E. Duthoit (1865). “Report to Comte de Nieuwerkerke on the Cyprus mission, Larnaca 7 August 1865”. Archives nationales, F 21 4045.
- 3.Lucie Bonato (1998). “Chypre dans les archives de Melchior de Vogüé (I) : à l'origine de la mission de 1862”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 28, 103-112.
- 4.Lucie Bonato (1999). “Chypre dans les archives de Melchior de Vogüé, II : correspondance de la « mission Vogüé » reçue au cours de l'année 1862”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 29, 141-166. Online
- 5.Veronica Tatton-Brown (ed.) (2001). Cyprus in the 19th Century AD: Fact, Fancy and Fiction. Oxford, Oxbow.
- 6.M. K. Toumazou (ed.), P. N. Kardulias (ed.), D. B. Counts (ed.) (2011). Crossroads and Boundaries: The Archaeology of Past and Present in the Malloura Valley, Cyprus.
- 7.R. C. Severis (2001). “Edmond Duthoit: an artist and ethnographer in Cyprus, 1862, 1865”. Cyprus in the 19th Century AD, 32-. Oxford, Oxbow.
- 8.Annie Caubet (1993). “Les antiquités chypriotes au Musée du Louvre”. Kinyras : l'archéologie française à Chypre. Lyon. Online
- 9.“Edmond Duthoit”. Wikipédia. Online
- 10.Edmond Duthoit (Wikidata Q3047815). Online
- 11.“Vase d'Amathonte, Musée du Louvre AO 22897”. Louvre collections database.
- 12.“Statue head, Musée du Louvre AM 2935”. Louvre collections database.