Article · 2012
I. Chypre dans les études historiques des XIXe et XXe siècles. Découverte de l'antique, construction du passé
Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 42 423-457
An article on how scholarship on Cyprus from the nineteenth century used travellers' records, collections and excavations, from early collectors to Gjerstad's Iron Age synthesis and the Cypriot kingdoms.
Cannavò surveys the early history of Cypriot archaeology and the place of Cyprus in studies of ancient history, from nineteenth-century travellers and collectors to Einar Gjerstad's work on the Iron Age. The article first treats travellers, collectors, excavators and historians before Gjerstad, then the accounts of Cyprus in ancient-history studies from the middle of the nineteenth century to the Second World War, then Gjerstad's synthesis, and finally his reading of the Cypriot kingdoms. It follows changing accounts of the island's populations, political history and cultural connections, and asks how Gjerstad's synthesis shaped later discussion of the kingdoms.
The evidence
Travel accounts, maps, inscriptions, archaeological objects and excavation records stand beside historical syntheses published from the nineteenth century to the Second World War. Cannavò notes that early collecting and excavation lost much contextual documentation, while travellers' records preserve sites and inscriptions that later disappeared. Among the collectors and excavators are Ross, who visited in 1845, the duc de Luynes, De Clercq, Lang, Cesnola, Ohnefalsch-Richter and Myres, and the Cyprus Museum's first catalogue (pp. 424–432).
For Gjerstad, Cannavò describes the classification of architecture, pottery, sculpture and minor arts, with relative and absolute chronology and evidence for foreign relations. She also examines his two articles of 1944 on Iron Age chronology and foundation legends, which tied the archaeological evidence to a scheme of two settlement waves at the end of the Bronze Age (pp. 446–449).
The argument
Cannavò argues that the historiography should be read in its intellectual and political settings, without reducing it to a single ideological project, and treats earlier errors and ideological assumptions as part of the history of scholarship. Interpretations moved from describing Cyprus chiefly as a Phoenician colony, as Movers did, towards accounts stressing Mycenaean and Greek settlement, with Meyer, Busolt, Beloch, Glotz, Casson and Hill each revising the picture as finds and new texts altered it (pp. 433–446).
Accounts of Cypriot kingship were tied to arguments about ethnic origins and outside influence. Gjerstad proposed that kingship was introduced by Mycenaeans and later transformed by Syro-Anatolian influence. His 1948 volume is presented as a turning point in the scientific study of Iron Age Cyprus: its classification and chronology gave a framework for the material, and its historical account gave Greek settlers cultural and political dominance, with later Phoenician and Syro-Anatolian arrivals as further components. Cannavò concludes that his reading of kingship stayed influential and left the kingdoms without a general synthesis at the time of writing (pp. 449–452).
Dating
Earlier authors placed Greek colonisation in the fourteenth or thirteenth centuries BC. Gjerstad dated two settlement waves to the end of the Late Bronze Age, put the beginning of the Iron Age around 1050 BC from the pottery, and set the first Phoenician settlement at Kition in the late ninth century BC (pp. 437–449).
What it records
- Gjerstad's 1948 volume is a founding work for the scientific study of Iron Age Cyprus, in Cannavò's account.p. 423
- Ludwig Ross visited Cyprus in 1845 and is credited with identifying the sanctuaries of Apollo Hylates at Kourion and Tamassos.p. 426
- The duc de Luynes bought the Idalion tablet in 1850–1851, after farmers found it at the sanctuary of Athena on Idalion's west acropolis.p. 427
- Louis De Clercq formed the core of his collection by buying Cypriot objects gathered earlier by Antoine Péretié.p. 427
- Part of the De Clercq collection entered the Louvre and the Cabinet des Médailles in 1967 through a donation by Henri de Boisgelin.p. 427
- Robert Hamilton Lang excavated at Idalion and found a bilingual inscription that contributed to the first decipherment of the Cypriot syllabary.p. 428
- The 1862 mission led by Melchior de Vogüé included William Waddington and Edmond Duthoit, and its finds formed the core of the Louvre's Cypriot collections.p. 429
- Luigi Palma di Cesnola sold his collection to the Metropolitan Museum between 1874 and 1876.p. 429
- Ohnefalsch-Richter excavated at Tamassos in 1885, 1889 and 1894; Cannavò argues that his discoveries were not satisfactorily documented.p. 430
- The Cyprus Museum opened in 1883, and Myres and Ohnefalsch-Richter produced its first catalogue in 1899.p. 430
- The British Antiquities Law of 1905 restricted the export of objects found on the island.p. 432
- Movers argued that Cyprus was essentially Phoenician before the Ptolemaic period.p. 434
- In his revised account Eduard Meyer placed the Phoenician arrival after the Greeks and limited Phoenician foundations to Kition and Lapethos.p. 440
- Gjerstad placed the beginning of the Cypriot Iron Age around 1050 BC, using archaeological evidence, especially pottery.p. 447
- Gjerstad dated the first Phoenician settlement in Cyprus to the late ninth century BC and identified Kition as its sole Cypro-Geometric III colony.p. 449
- Gjerstad described Cypro-Archaic as an era of powerful kingship.p. 450
Where to read
- Early travellers, collectors and excavatorspp. 424–432
- Changing accounts of Phoenician and Greek settlementpp. 434–445
- Gjerstad’s 1944 colonisation model and 1948 synthesispp. 446–450
- Interpretations of the Cypriot kingdoms and kingshippp. 450–452
Contents
- Avant Gjerstad : voyageurs, collectionneurs, archéologues, historiens424
- Chypre dans les études d'histoire ancienne : entre le milieu du XIXe siècle et la Seconde Guerre mondiale433
- La synthèse d'E. Gjerstad446
- « The time of powerful kingship » : les royautés chypriotes450
- Bibliographie452
People, places and institutions
People
- Einar Gjerstadclassified and interpreted Iron Age Cyprus
- Ludwig Rossvisited Cyprus and excavated at Kourion and Tamassos
- Demetrios Pieridesformed a Cypriot antiquities collection
- Honoré Albert de Luynescollected antiquities and bought the Idalion tablet
- Louis De Clercqformed the De Clercq collection
- Antoine Péretiégathered Cypriot objects later bought by De Clercq
- Melchior de Vogüéled an archaeological mission in 1862
- Edmond Duthoittook part in the 1862 mission
- Robert Hamilton Langexcavated at Idalion and Pyla
- Georges Colonna-Ceccaldiresided in Cyprus between 1866 and 1871
- Luigi Palma di Cesnolacollected and sold Cypriot antiquities
- Alessandro Palma di Cesnolaexcavated at Salamis between 1876 and 1878
- Max Ohnefalsch-Richterexcavated widely and co-authored a museum catalogue
- John L. Myresexcavator and co-author of the Cyprus Museum catalogue
- I.K. Peristianesworked at Rantidi and published on Cyprus
- Menelaos MarkidesCyprus Museum curator and excavator at Polis
- Wilhelm Heinrich Engelwrote a text-based study of Cyprus
- Franz Karl Moversargued for Phoenician control of ancient Cyprus
- Alexander Enmannchallenged the Phoenician theory of Aphrodite
- Georg Busoltwrote successive accounts of Greek history
- Eduard Meyerrevised his account of Phoenician and Greek settlement
- Karl Julius Belochwrote a history of Greece
- Gustave Glotzdescribed Cypriot Hellenisation in two stages
- Arthur Evanslinked Cretan and Cypriot Bronze Age scripts
- Stanley Cassonargued for Greek influence and Mycenaean colonisation
- George Francis Hillwrote a history of Cyprus
Institutions
- Cabinet des Médaillesreceived objects from the De Clercq collection
- Metropolitan Museumbought Cesnola's collection
- Cyprus Museumopened in 1883; catalogue of 1899
Places
- KourionApollo Hylates sanctuary and excavations
- Tamassosexcavated by Ross and Ohnefalsch-Richter
- Idalionfindspot of the tablet; Lang's excavations
- KitionPhoenician settlement and kingdom
- Salaminesite in foundation legends and histories
- Amathonteexcavation site and centre of debate
- Polisexcavation site
- Rantidisanctuary excavated in the early twentieth century
Also named: Henri de Boisgelin, William Waddington, George Smith, Eugen Oberhummer, Paul Perdrizet, Paul-Louis Couchoud.
Extent pp. 423–457, figs 1–7; bibliography pp. 452–457
Late Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicCypro-ClassicalModernHistory of ArchaeologyCollectingChronology and DatingForeign ContactsKingship and Politics
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 pageExcavations it is cited for
15 projects- 1867–1869Idalion, Goshi and Pyla: Robert Hamilton Lang's excavations (sanctuary of Apollo)Directed by Robert Hamilton LangClearance and early digging
- 1876–1879Salamis and Enkomi: Alessandro Palma di Cesnola's excavationsDirected by Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola and Lazaris Philippi (supervisor on Cesnola's behalf)Clearance and early digging
- 1879–1882Kition: Ohnefalsch-Richter's Excavations for the British MuseumDirected by Max Ohnefalsch-RichterClearance and early digging
- 1883Chytroi (Kythrea) and Voni: Ohnefalsch-Richter's sanctuary excavations for the Cyprus Museum (1883)Directed by Max Ohnefalsch-Richter and Hugh SinclairExcavation
- 1885–1887Marion: the Ohnefalsch-Richter and Williamson syndicateDirected by Max Ohnefalsch-Richter and John William WilliamsonExcavation
- 1888Amargeti: the Cyprus Exploration Fund (1888)Directed by David George HogarthExcavation
- 1888–1895Idalion: the Berlin Museums' excavations under Ohnefalsch-RichterDirected by Max Ohnefalsch-Richter and Adolf FurtwänglerExcavation
- 1888Palaepaphos: the Cyprus Exploration Fund at KoukliaDirected by Ernest Arthur Gardner and David George HogarthExcavation
Show all 15 projects
- 1889–1894Tamassos: Ohnefalsch-Richter's excavations for the Berlin Museums, 1889 and 1894Directed by Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavation
- 1890Salamis: the Cyprus Exploration Fund excavationDirected by H. Arnold Tubbs and John Arthur Ruskin MunroExcavation
- 1893–1894Amathus: the British Museum (Turner Bequest) excavationDirected by Arthur Hamilton Smith and John Linton MyresExcavation
- 1895Kourion: British Museum Turner Bequest excavationsDirected by Henry Beauchamp WaltersExcavation
- 1896Enkomi: the British Museum excavations of 1896Directed by Alexander Stuart Murray, Percy Christian and Arthur Hamilton SmithExcavation
- 1910Rantidi-Lingrin tou Dhigeni: Robert Zahn's excavation for the Berlin AcademyDirected by Robert ZahnExcavation
- 1916–1927Marion: Cyprus Museum excavations at Polis (Markides and Gunnis)Directed by Menelaos Markides and Rupert Forbes GunnisExcavation
Who did what
45 recordsBuying, selling and giving 9
- p. 426
Ludwig RossGave tomusée de Berlin
Ross donated the first nucleus of the Berlin museum's Cypriot collections.
le premier noyau des ses collections chypriotes
- p. 426
Ludwig RossPassed objects toMusée de Berlin
Ross was responsible for purchasing and sending the recently discovered Sargon II stela to the Berlin museum.
la stèle de Sargon II
- 1850–1851 · p. 427
Honoré Théodoric d'Albert, duc de LuynesBought
De Luynes bought the Idalion tablet, which peasants had found with a group of bronzes at the sanctuary of Athena.
With des paysansla tablette d'Idalion
- 1967 · p. 427
Henri (Louis) de Boisgelin, comte de BoisgelinGave tomusée du Louvre
Boisgelin donated part of the De Clercq collection to the Louvre.
la collection De Clercq
- 1967 · p. 427
Henri (Louis) de Boisgelin, comte de BoisgelinGave toCabinet des Médailles
Boisgelin donated part of the De Clercq collection to the Cabinet des Médailles.
la collection De Clercq
- p. 427
Louis Constantin Henri François-Xavier de ClercqBought fromNapoléon Antoine Aimé Péretié
De Clercq bought Cypriot objects that Péretié had gathered in preceding years.
objets chypriotes
- 1870–1876 · p. 429
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toMetropolitan Museum of Art
Cesnola agreed to sell his collection to the Metropolitan Museum for £1,200.
£1,200New York
- 1902 · p. 432
Paul-Louis CouchoudAcquired
Couchoud acquired a number of objects during a journey to Cyprus.
un certain nombre d’objetsl’île
- p. 432
Paul-Louis CouchoudGave tomusée du Louvre
Couchoud donated objects he had acquired during his Cyprus journey to the Louvre.
un certain nombre d’objets
Excavation 22
- 1860–1865 · p. 428
Henry William WaddingtonExcavated withEdmond Duthoit
Waddington and Duthoit conducted archaeological campaigns that excavated and exploited sanctuary sites in Cyprus.
sanctuary sites at Athienou-Malloura, Golgoi-Agios Photos, Idalion and Arsos
- 1860–1865 · p. 428
Melchior de VogüéExcavated withHenry William Waddington
de Vogue and Waddington conducted archaeological campaigns that excavated and exploited sanctuary sites in Cyprus.
sanctuary sites at Athienou-Malloura, Golgoi-Agios Photos, Idalion and Arsos
- 1860–1865 · p. 428
Melchior de VogüéExcavated withEdmond Duthoit
de Vogue and Duthoit conducted archaeological campaigns that excavated and exploited sanctuary sites in Cyprus.
sanctuary sites at Athienou-Malloura, Golgoi-Agios Photos, Idalion and Arsos
- p. 428
Robert Hamilton LangFound
Lang found the bilingual inscription at Idalion.
la fameuse inscription bilingueNo. ICS² 220 / CIS I 89
- 1876–1878 · p. 429
- 1879 · p. 430
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavated
Ohnefalsch-Richter excavated at Kition.
- 1883 · p. 430
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavated
Ohnefalsch-Richter excavated at Chytroi and Voni.
- 1885–1894 · p. 430
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavated
Ohnefalsch-Richter excavated at Tamassos in 1885, 1889 and 1894.
- 1885–1886 · p. 430
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavated
Ohnefalsch-Richter excavated at Polis.
- 1894 · p. 430
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavated
Ohnefalsch-Richter excavated at Idalion.
- 1887–1888 · p. 431
David George HogarthDug forCyprus Exploration Fund
Mr. D. G. Hogarth excavated the sanctuary for the Cyprus Exploration Fund.
Stone statuettes and terracottasNo. C. M. 5901-27Amargétti
- 1888 · p. 431
Ernest Arthur GardnerExcavated withDavid George Hogarth
Gardner and Hogarth carried out the British excavations at the Temple of Aphrodite together in 1888.
ruinesKouklia
- 1888 · p. 431
Ernest Arthur GardnerDug forCyprus Exploration Fund
Gardner directed the excavation of the sanctuary of Aphrodite at Paphos under the Fund’s auspices.
- 1889–1891 · p. 431
H. Arnold TubbsDug forCyprus Exploration Fund
H. A. Tubbs carried out the Salamis expedition funded by the Cyprus Exploration Fund.
archaeological expedition and excavations at Salamis
- 1889–1891 · p. 431
John Arthur Ruskin MunroDug forCyprus Exploration Fund
J. A. R. Munro carried out the Salamis expedition funded by the Cyprus Exploration Fund.
archaeological expedition and excavations at Salamis
Show 7 moreShow fewer
- 1889–1890 · p. 431
John Arthur Ruskin MunroExcavated withH. Arnold Tubbs
J. A. R. Munro and H. A. Tubbs carried out the Salamis archaeological expedition together.
archaeological expedition and excavations at Salamis
- 1893–1894 · p. 431
Arthur Hamilton SmithExcavated withJohn Linton Myres
Arthur Smith and John Myres excavated tombs 100 to 110 together for a few days.
tombes 100 à 110Amathonte
- 1895 · p. 431
Henry Beauchamp WaltersExcavated
Walters excavated at Kourion.
- 1896 · p. 431
Alexander Stuart MurrayExcavated
Murray excavated at Enkomi.
- 1910 · p. 432
Ieronymos K. PeristianisDug forRobert Zahn
Peristianes assisted Zahn during the Rantidi excavation.
- 1913 · p. 432
Menelaos MarkidesDug forJohn Linton Myres
Markides assisted Myres during excavations in 1913.
- 1916–1918 · p. 432
Menelaos MarkidesExcavated
Markides carried out excavations at Polis.
Recording and study 12
- 1852 · p. 427
Honoré Théodoric d'Albert, duc de LuynesPublished
The Duc de Luynes published a study and list of known Cypriote inscriptions.
- p. 428
George SmithStudied
Smith used the bilingual inscription to make the first decipherment of the Cypriot syllabary.
la fameuse inscription bilingueNo. ICS² 220 / CIS I 89Idalion
- 1877–1904 · p. 429
Luigi Palma di CesnolaEmployed byNew York Metropolitan Museum of Art
The trustees hired Cesnola to unpack, arrange and classify the collection.
$500 a monthNew York
- 1894–1899 · p. 430
John Linton MyresCatalogued the collection ofCyprian Museum
Myres co-authored the Catalogue of the Cyprus Museum, recording its material.
material owned by the Cyprus museum
- 1899 · p. 430
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterWorked withJohn Linton Myres
Ohnefalsch-Richter and J.L. Myres reorganized the Cyprus Museum together.
Nicosia
- 1899 · p. 430
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterCatalogued the collection ofMusée de Chypre
Ohnefalsch-Richter co-wrote the first catalogue of the Cyprus Museum.
le premier catalogue du Musée de Chypre
- 1896 · p. 432
Paul PerdrizetFound
Perdrizet discovered two large Eteocypriot inscriptions at Amathonte.
les deux grandes inscriptions étéochypriotesNo. ICS² 194 et 195
- 1896 · p. 432
Paul PerdrizetStudied
Perdrizet studied two large Eteocypriot inscriptions at Amathonte.
les deux grandes inscriptions étéochypriotesNo. ICS² 194 et 195
- p. 432
Demetrios PieridesRecorded
Pierides was among the Cypriot scholars and intellectuals who pressed the British authorities in connection with creating the Cyprus Museum.
With les autorités britanniques
- 1937 · p. 444
Stanley CassonPublished
Casson wrote Ancient Cyprus: Its Art and Archaeology, a synthesis of Cypriot art, archaeology, and history.
l'art et l'archéologie chypriotesLondres
- 1940 · p. 445
George HillPublished
Hill published the first volume of A History of Cyprus, covering the ancient period.
l'histoire de l'îleCambridge
- 1948 · p. 446
Einar Nilson GjerstadPublished
Gjerstad published a typological and chronological study of Cypriot material from the Iron Age and Classical period.
Cypro-Geometric, Cypro-Archaic and Cypro-Classical archaeological materialStockholm
Posts and family 2
- 1912–1931 · p. 432
- 1931–1936 · p. 445
George HillEmployed byBritish Museum
Hill was director of the British Museum.
People it is cited for
2 peopleInstitutions it is cited for
1 institution- Cabinet des médailles2 citations
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.