Patron · Epigrapher · Scholar

Ernest Renan

Joseph Ernest Renan

1823–1892 · France

Head of the 1860 Mission de Phénicie who steered Melchior de Vogüé's 1862 Cyprus campaign from Paris and later, as editor of the Corpus Inscriptionum Semiticarum, sought Cypriot inscriptions.

Biography

Ernest Renan directed the Mission de Phénicie, and in December 1861 he handed its Cyprus campaign to Melchior de Vogüé by letter2. He told Vogüé that the firman and a letter from Fuad Pasha were held by Charles Gaillardot, that Sosthène Grasset was to be attached to the party, and that the budget was about 8,000 francs. Vogüé was to take squeezes of every inscription. Renan wrote that "our mission is one of exploration, not purchase" and that purchases should be made with reserve and only for objects of real scientific interest2. On 10 April 1862 he reported that the Academy was pleased with Vogüé's first letter from Cyprus and that the Cypriot inscription "must be had at any price"3.

On 1 August 1862 Renan wrote that he hesitated to cut the inscriptions out of their tombs at Nea Paphos, citing the memory of Lord Elgin. Grasset had offered the statue from Athienou at 500 francs, and Renan left the price and the decision to Vogüé, saying that a purchase from the mission's own budget would be too heavy and that he would pass Vogüé's opinion to the Louvre3. Vogüé bought it with his own money; it reached France in 1866 and he gave it to the Louvre in 18803. In the same letter he promised a Book V of the Mission's publication on Cyprus; on 15 Oct 1863 he wrote that he was still working on it, and it never appeared3.

Renan met Luigi Palma di Cesnola in Paris in 1876, when Cesnola showed the Curium gold to the Louvre authorities and to Renan in person5. In 1876 he also wrote that Julius Euting's copies of Cypriot inscriptions were so inexact that he supposed a Cypriot forger was trying to deceive European science, as Marangou paraphrases the article5. On 11 May 1880, as editor of the Corpus Inscriptionum Semiticarum, he asked Alexander Palma di Cesnola for photographs of the Phoenician lead rolls and inscribed jars of the Lawrence-Cesnola collection before the Cyprus chapter went to press6. He was born at Tréguier in 1823 and died in Paris on 2 October 18921.

Life and work

  1. 18 December 1861
    Replied to Vogue's letter of 17 Dec 1861 and handed him the Cyprus campaign: firman and Fuad Pasha's letter held by Gaillardot, Grasset to be attached, a budget he put at 8000 francs, instructions to take squeezes of all inscriptions. He wrote that 'our mission is one of exploration, not purchase', buying with reserve and only objects of real scientific interest, and told Vogue to do the same.

    ParisBonato 1998

  2. 10 April 1862
    Told Vogue the Academy was pleased with his first Cyprus letter, that the Beirut station commander would be ordered to collect everything found in Cyprus at the end of the campaign, and that the Cypriot inscription 'must be had at any price'.

    ParisBonato 1999

  3. 1 August 1862
    On the inscriptions at Nea Paphos Renan hesitated to cut them out ('the memory of Lord Elgin'); promised a Book V of the Mission on Cyprus; and, offered the Athienou statue by Grasset at 500 francs (Vogue then wrote of 1000), left the price and the decision to Vogue, saying a purchase from the mission's own budget would be too onerous and that he would pass Vogue's opinion to the Louvre.

    ParisBonato 1999

  4. December 1862
    The Athienou seated-woman funerary stele ('la statue de M. Grasset') was bought for 600 francs, of which the Mission was to pay 300; Vogue finally bought it with his own money; held in customs for years, it reached France in 1866 and was given by Vogue to the Louvre in 1880.

    LarnacaBonato 1999

  5. 15 October 1863
    Wrote to Vogue that he was working on the publication of the Mission and that Book V would deal with Cyprus; the volume never appeared.

    ParisBonato 1999

  6. 1876
    Described (in the article that also noted the Lanitis acquisitions) Euting's copies of Cypriot inscriptions as so inexact that he supposed a Cypriot forger was trying to deceive European science.

    Marangou 2000

  7. 1876
    Met Cesnola in Paris when Cesnola showed the Curium gold to the Louvre authorities and 'Ernest Renan in person'.

    ParisMarangou 2000

  8. 19 February 1879
    Cesnola answered Renan's request for information about inscriptions, adding that his letter would enrich Madame Cesnola's album of autographs.

    New YorkMarangou 2000

  9. 11 May 1880
    As editor of the Corpus Inscriptionum Semiticarum, urged Alexander Palma di Cesnola to let him have photographs of the Phoenician lead rolls and inscribed jars of the Lawrence-Cesnola collection before the Cyprus chapter went to press (in six weeks or two months).

    ParisCesnola 1881

Connections

11 people

Sales, gifts & bequests

Fieldwork & employment

Disputes & the law

Scholarship

Colleagues & contacts

On Ancient Cyprus

2 pages

Sources

  1. 1.Ernest Renan (Wikidata/GND authority record). Online
  2. 2.Lucie Bonato (1998). “Chypre dans les archives de Melchior de Vogüé (I) : à l'origine de la mission de 1862”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 28, 103-112.
  3. 3.Lucie Bonato (1999). “Chypre dans les archives de Melchior de Vogüé, II : correspondance de la « mission Vogüé » reçue au cours de l'année 1862”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 29, 141-166. Online
  4. 4.Annie Caubet (1993). “Les antiquités chypriotes au Musée du Louvre”. Kinyras : l'archéologie française à Chypre. Lyon. Online
  5. 5.A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
  6. 6.A. P. di Cesnola (1881). Lawrence-Cesnola Collection. Cyprus Antiquities excavated by Major Alexander Palma di Cesnola, 1876 to 1879. London, W. Holmes & Son.
  7. 7.Alexander Palma di Cesnola (1884). Salaminia (Cyprus): The History, Treasures, and Antiquities of Salamis in the Island of Cyprus. London, Whiting and Company.
  8. 8.M. K. Toumazou (ed.), P. N. Kardulias (ed.), D. B. Counts (ed.) (2011). Crossroads and Boundaries: The Archaeology of Past and Present in the Malloura Valley, Cyprus.