Catalogue · 2014

The Cesnola Collection of Cypriot Art: Stone Sculpture

A. Hermary and J. R. Mertens

New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art

A catalogue of 635 stone sculptures and objects in the Cesnola Collection of The Metropolitan Museum of Art, arranged in 13 chapters by subject, type and material.

Hermary and Mertens catalogue 635 stone sculptures and other stone objects in the Cesnola Collection at The Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Cypriot antiquities that Luigi Palma di Cesnola formed and sold to the museum. An introduction on how the collection was built and where its pieces were found is followed by a chronology, 13 catalogue chapters, maps, an accession-number concordance and a bibliography. The introduction also takes up the place of the sculpture in museum and archaeological study.

Collection history

Cesnola's excavations and collecting on Cyprus included work at Idalion and the discoveries made near Ayios Photios in 1870. Hermary and Mertens compare his accounts with those of Robert Hamilton Lang, Georges Colonna-Ceccaldi and later investigators, and they weigh the uncertainty over the two sanctuary sites, the distribution of finds and the reliability of recorded provenances (pp. 13–19).

Cesnola agreed to sell the collection to the Metropolitan in 1873, the museum accepted the purchase in 1874, and it negotiated for a further group in 1876. The later history takes in restorations, early catalogues and handbooks, the sale of duplicates in 1928 and loans to other museums (pp. 20–22).

How it is organised

Chapters 1–6 cover male and female votaries, special series such as kourotrophoi, musicians, horsemen and banqueters, masked votaries, temple boys and temple girls, and other votive human figures (pp. 28–221).

Chapters 7–9 take gods and mythological figures, votive animals, anatomical reliefs and other offerings, among them Herakles, Zeus Ammon, Apollo, Pan, incense burners, lamps and anatomical ex-votos (pp. 222–305).

Chapters 10–13 treat architectural sculpture, reliefs on votive monuments, funerary monuments and other stone artefacts. The funerary chapter has stelai, limestone and marble sarcophagi, Roman funerary busts and cippi; the last chapter groups vessels, beads, pendants, possible mace heads, spindle whorls, mortars, pestles, whetstones and other objects (pp. 306–415).

The catalogue

Each entry gives the catalogue number and object type, material and dimensions, a proposed date, the findspot where known, the Myres number and the Cesnola Collection accession number, then a description and references. Longer commentaries take up restoration, inscriptions, iconography, comparisons and provenance. The entries on the Amathus and Golgoi sarcophagi cover their discovery, decoration and dating (pp. 353–370). Maps, an accession-number concordance and a bibliography close the volume.

What it records

  • The Metropolitan Museum acquired the Cypriot collection from Luigi Palma di Cesnola between 1874 and 1876.p. 13
  • Cesnola obtained official Ottoman permission to excavate at Idalion in 1868.p. 13
  • Cesnola's 1870 account describes a sanctuary area 60 English feet long and 30 feet wide, where he said about one thousand statues were found.p. 14
  • Slightly fewer than 700 sculptures in the round came from the two Ayios Photos sites, in Hermary's estimate.p. 16
  • Apollo is the principal god of the Golgoi-Ayios Photos sanctuary by the beginning of the Hellenistic period at the latest, Hermary argues.p. 18
  • The Metropolitan Museum agreed to buy Cesnola's collection for £1,200 during his stay in New York in 1873.p. 20
  • The 1928 sales of duplicates from the collection took place at Anderson Galleries in two sessions, in March and April.p. 22
  • For works without a more precise proposed date, Hermary uses the ranges Early Hellenistic, late Hellenistic and Early Roman.p. 25
  • Cesnola's letter states that the Amathus sarcophagus was found in 792 fragments, the largest measuring less than two feet.p. 353
  • The plinth beneath a servant in funerary group Cat. 489 bears the signature of Zoilos of Golgoi.p. 353
  • A letter cited in the catalogue says the Golgoi sarcophagus was found in November 1873 in the necropolis, and that the discovery damaged its east side.p. 363
  • The bibliography covers publications through 2010, with a few additions concerning specific objects.p. 421

Where to read

  • Cesnola's acquisitions, excavation history and early salespp. 13–22
  • The sanctuary sites, offerings and cult at Golgoi-Ayios Photiospp. 14–19
  • Dating framework for Cypriot stone sculpturepp. 23–25
  • Male votaries with conical helmets and the priest with dovepp. 28–46
  • Male votaries in Cypriot shorts and rosette diademspp. 47–57
  • Egyptianizing votaries, crowns and inscriptionspp. 58–74
  • Bearded votaries with wreaths and offeringspp. 84–98
  • Beardless votaries and statues of boyspp. 99–159
  • Female votaries and kourotrophoipp. 160–180
  • Musicians, horsemen, chariots and banqueterspp. 181–193
  • The Amathus and Golgoi sarcophagi: discovery, decoration and datingpp. 353–370
  • Stone vessels, small objects and accession-number concordancepp. 388–420

Contents

  • Director's Foreword
  • Foreword
  • Acknowledgments
  • Introduction
  • Building the Collection of Sculpture
  • Sculptures Discovered before 1870
  • The Sculptures and the Sanctuary/Sanctuaries of Golgoi-Ayios Photios
  • The Nature of the Offerings and the Cult of the Sanctuary of Golgoi-Ayios Photios
  • Other Findspots
  • The Cesnola Sculptures in the Metropolitan Museum of Art
  • From Their Arrival at the Museum to the Handbook of the Cesnola Collection of Antiquities from Cyprus by John L. Myres (1914)
  • The Place of the Cesnola Collection in the Study of Cypriot Sculpture
  • Chronology of Cypriot Sculptures
  • Catalogue
  • Chapter 1. Male Votaries (Cat. 1–186)
  • Male Votaries with Conical Helmets (Cat. 1–18)
  • Male Heads with Other Types of Helmets (Cat. 19–24)
  • Male Votaries with “Cypriot Shorts,” Heads with a Rosette Diadem (Cat. 25–39)
  • Male Votaries in Egyptianizing Dress or Heads with a Plain Headress (Cat. 40–61)
  • Young Votaries in the Ionian Tradition (Draped Kouroi) (Cat. 62–75)
  • Bearded Male Votaries with a Wreath of Leaves or a Diadem (Cat. 76–92)
  • Beardless Male Votaries with a Wreath of Leaves, Diadem, or Fillet (Cat. 93–137)
  • Male Votaries with Bare Heads (Cat. 138–143)
  • Statues and Statuettes of Boys (Cat. 144–168)
  • Various Votive Male Figures, or Fragments (Cat. 169–186)
  • Chapter 2. Female Votaries (Cat. 187–212)
  • Chapter 3. Special Series of Votive Figures (Cat. 213–246)
  • Statuettes of Women Nursing (Kourotrophoi) (Cat. 213–221)
  • Musicians, Male and Female (Cat. 222–234)
  • Horses, Horsemen, Chariots (Cat. 235–241)
  • Banqueters (Cat. 242–246)
  • Chapter 4. Masked Votaries (Cat. 247–251)
  • Chapter 5. “Temple Boys” and “Temple Girls” (Cat. 252–274)
  • Chapter 6. Varia (Cat. 275–299)
  • Chapter 7. Gods and Mythological Figures (Cat. 300–364)
  • Chapter 8. Votive Animals, Anatomical Reliefs, and Various Offerings (Cat. 356–378)
  • Chapter 9. Various Offerings (Cat. 379–431)
  • Chapter 10. Architectural Sculpture (Cat. 432–436)
  • Chapter 11. Sculptured Reliefs on Votive Monuments (Cat. 437–456)
  • Chapter 12. Funerary Monuments (Cat. 457–508)
  • Chapter 13. Other Stone Artifacts (Cat. 509–635)
  • Maps of Cyprus
  • Concordance
  • Bibliography

Objects published here

13
  • Colossal bearded head wearing a conical helmet, The Cesnola Collection, Golgoi-Ayios Photos, “near the temple”, 74.51.2857, Cat. 1 (p. 30)
  • Over-lifesize bearded male votary in Greek dress and a decorated helmet, the priest with dove, The Cesnola Collection, Sanctuary of Golgoi-Ayios Photios, “West side near the temple”, 74.51.2466, Cat. 22 (p. 42)
  • Statuette of a scribe wearing a falcon mask, The Cesnola Collection, Karpassia, 74.51.2516, Cat. 249 (p. 197)
  • Over-lifesize statue of a male votary holding a bull mask, with the name Pnytagoras scratched on the garment, The Cesnola Collection, Sanctuary of Golgoi-Ayios Photos, 74.51.2463, Cat. 251 (p. 198)
  • Statuette of a temple boy, The Cesnola Collection, “Found in the ruins of a temple at Curium”, 74.51.2754, Cat. 272 (p. 211)
  • Over-lifesize statue of Herakles as an archer, wearing the lion skin, The Cesnola Collection, Sanctuary of Golgoi-Ayios Photos, “first site”, 74.51.2455, Cat. 302 (p. 228)
  • Slab with Herakles and the cattle of Geryon, The Cesnola Collection, Sanctuary of Golgoi-Ayios Photos, “in the field west of the temple”, 74.51.2853, Cat. 440 (p. 312)
  • The Amathus sarcophagus, The Cesnola Collection, From the north necropolis of Amathus, Cat. 490 (p. 353)
  • The Golgoi sarcophagus, The Cesnola Collection, From the necropolis of Golgoi, 74.51.2451, Cat. 491 (p. 363)
  • Female anthropoid sarcophagus, The Cesnola Collection, From the necropolis of Amathus, 74.51.2452, Cat. 496 (p. 374)
  • Funerary group with the signature of Zoilos of Golgoi, The Cesnola Collection, From the necropolis of Golgoi, 74.51.2490, Cat. 489 (p. 353)
  • Alabastron with incised Phoenician letters and vertical lines, The Cesnola Collection, Citium, tomb, 74.51.2295a, Cat. 549 (p. 395)
  • Pendant with a smiling head, The Cesnola Collection, Amathus, 74.51.5010, Cat. 581 (p. 403)

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

  • The Metropolitan Museum of Artholds the Cesnola stone sculpture collection
  • Hermitage Museumconsidered and declined the collection
  • British Museumconsidered Cesnola's sale proposals
  • Academy of Sciences in Turinreceived Cesnola's sculpture donation
  • Anderson Galleriesheld sales of collection duplicates in 1928
  • Cyprus Museumholds loaned Cesnola sculptures
  • Nasher Museum of Art at Duke Universityholds loaned Cesnola sculptures
  • Louvreholds sculptures from Cyprus

Places

  • Golgoi-Ayios Photiossanctuary and major sculpture findspot
  • Golgoicity, sanctuary and necropolis findspot
  • Athienoumodern locality near Golgoi
  • Idalionsite of Cesnola's excavations and a sanctuary
  • Pylasite of a sanctuary dedicated to Apollo
  • Amathussource of a sarcophagus and other sculpture
  • Kourionsource of sanctuary and tomb sculpture
  • Mallourasanctuary and sculpture findspot
  • Arsossanctuary with female votaries
  • KitionCypriot city and sculpture findspot
  • Salamiskingdom and sculpture findspot
  • Lefkonikosanctuary and sculpture findspot
  • Palaepaphos-Koukliasource of siege-mound sculpture
  • Samoscomparative sanctuary and chronology source
  • Amritsanctuary with comparable sculpture
  • Naucratistrading post and sculpture context
  • Ayia Irinisanctuary and terracotta findspot

Also named: Paul Åström, Kyriakos Nicolaou, Andreas Vondiziano, Giorgi Sotiri, Carl Friedrichs, Melchior de Vogüé, Adolf Furtwängler, Clarence Cook, Thomas P. Campbell, Detlev Kreikenbom, Theocritus, Lycophron, Terence B. Mitford, Museum of Fine Arts in Boston, Michael C. Carlos Museum, Princeton University Art Museum, Virginia Museum of Fine Arts, Liverpool museum, Kythrea, Kition-Bamboula, Tamassos-Phrangissaa.

Extent 436 pp.; maps of Cyprus, p. 416; bibliography, pp. 421–434

Defines Male Votaries with Conical Helmets, “Cypriot shorts”, Egyptianizing, Kourotrophoi, Early Hellenistic, late Hellenistic, Early Roman, perizoma, temple boys, “alabaster”

Cypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicCypro-ClassicalHellenisticRomanLate Bronze AgeModernSculptureFigurinesReligion and CultBurialCollecting

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

17 pages · 219 objects

Objects (219, first 48 shown)

Alabaster inscribed "alabastron"Bronze bowlBronze bowl with handles terminating in lotusesBronze handles and rim of a cauldronBronze lampstandChlorite amphoriskos (small jar)Chlorite pendant in the form of the head of a Black AfricanDonkey figurineFragment of a limestone group of Herakles, Iolaos, and the HydraFragment of a limestone relief with a tree and birds of preyFragment of a limestone statue of a male votary (worshipper)Fragment of an male limestone votary with an Egyptianizing kiltFragmentary silver bowlGold fibula (safety pin)Head of a boyHorse and riderLimestone GeryonLimestone Head of a Beardless Votary in a Conical HelmetLimestone Head of a Boy, probably from a Temple Boy StatuetteLimestone Head of a Votary with a WreathLimestone HeraklesLimestone altarLimestone bearded head with a Corinthian helmetLimestone bearded head with a wreath of leavesLimestone beardless male head with ivy wreathLimestone bust of a flute-playerLimestone bust of a lyre-playerLimestone female headLimestone figure of kneeling HeraklesLimestone finial of a funerary stele with a seated lionLimestone finial of a funerary stele with two seated lionsLimestone finial of a funerary stele with volutes and the head of HathorLimestone flute-playerLimestone footstoolLimestone fragment of an altar with a reliefLimestone funerary stele with antithetical sphinxesLimestone funerary stele with volutes and a Hathor headLimestone grave markerLimestone group of a male banqueter and a womanLimestone group: banquetLimestone head of ApolloLimestone head of a bearded male wearing a conical helmetLimestone head of a bearded male with a plain headdressLimestone head of a bearded male with a wreath of flowersLimestone head of a bearded male with a wreath of leavesLimestone head of a bearded manLimestone head of a bearded man wearing a wreathWeathered Limestone Head of a Votary in a Tall Pointed Cap

Excavations it is cited for

8 projects

Who did what

44 records

Buying, selling and giving 11

  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toMetropolitan Museum of Art

    Cesnola agreed to sell his collection to the Metropolitan Museum for £1,200.

    £1,200New York

    1870–1876 · p. 7, 20
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toHamilton Fish

    Cesnola offered his 1,600-piece “Phoenician Museum” to Hamilton Fish for $15,000.

    “Phoenician Museum”, 1600 pieces$15,000

    1868 · p. 13
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaGave toAcademy of Sciences of Turin

    Luigi Palma di Cesnola donated a small collection of antiquities to the Royal Academy of Sciences in Turin.

    1870 · p. 13
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold

    Ninety-two limestone works were sold in Paris, including 48 heads found at Dali.

    With buyers at the Paris sale92 limestone works, including 48 heads found at Dali

    1870 · p. 13
  • Captain FothergillGave toLiverpool Public Museums

    Captain Fothergill presented the Cypriote collection to Liverpool Public Museums.

    Cypriote collection, including temple-boysNo. 16.5.72.9, 16.5.72.11, 16.5.72.17–19

    1872 · p. 17
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaGave

    Almost 400 stone objects were given over to the Turkish authorities after they declined to renew the firman.

    With Turkish authorities

    1873 · p. 17
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaPassed objects toJohn Ruskin

    Some of Cesnola’s duplicate sculptures were dispersed to his friend John Ruskin.

    p. 17
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaPassed objects toHiram Hitchcock

    Some of Cesnola’s duplicate sculptures were dispersed to his friend Hiram Hitchcock.

    p. 17
  • Karl (Carl) FriederichsRecorded

    Friedrichs advised against the museum in Saint Petersburg buying Cesnola’s collection.

    With museum in Saint Petersburg

    p. 20
  • W. Gedney BeattyBequeathed

    W. Gedney Beatty bequeathed the head, as recorded in its provenance.

    Under-lifesize head of a male votaryNo. 41.160.411

    1941 · p. 104, 108, 116, 161, 162, 165
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaGave toRobert Hamilton Lang

    Cesnola gave Lang three inscribed alabaster vases from Golgoi-Ayios Photos.

    Three alabaster vases bearing syllabic inscriptions, including a dedication to Apollo

    p. 384

Excavation 18

  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaExcavated

    Cesnola conducted excavations at Idalion.

    1868 · p. 13
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaHeld a permit to dig

    The Ottoman authorities officially permitted Cesnola to excavate at Idalion.

    1868 · p. 13
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaFound

    Cesnola reported finding a colossal stone statue at Golgos.

    colossal stone statue, with head and feet broken, holding an ox head

    1868 · p. 13
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaFound

    Cesnola recounted the discovery of a group of limestone sculptures near Ayios Photos.

    region of Athienou, near the chapel of Ayios Photos

    1870 · p. 14
  • Melchior de VogüéDirected excavations

    De Vogüé directed a French excavation at the principal site near Golgoi.

    1862 · p. 15
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaGuidedGeorges Colonna Ceccaldi

    Cesnola showed Colonna-Ceccaldi the Golgoi site.

    1870 · p. 15
  • Robert Hamilton LangExcavated

    Lang discovered an important collection of sculptures at Idalion.

    p. 15
  • Kyriakos NicolaouDirectedCyprus Survey

    Nicolaou directed the Cyprus Survey’s investigation at Ayios Photios.

    1961 · p. 16
  • Kyriakos NicolaouSurveyed

    The Cyprus Survey found sculpture fragments and terracottas in the Ayios Photios area under Nicolaou’s direction.

    about 100 limestone sculpture fragments and some terracottas

    1961 · p. 16
  • Andreas VondizianoDug forLuigi Palma di Cesnola

    Vondiziano supervised excavations for Cesnola.

    Ayios Photios

    p. 16
  • Edmond DuthoitFound

    Duthoit found 500 to 600 heads and thousands of fragments at Golgoi.

    500 à 600 têtes, puis « des milliers et des milliers de fragments de toutes espèces »

    1865 · p. 17
  • Robert Hamilton LangFound

    Lang discovered the votive statue in a sanctuary at Pyla.

    Votive statue from the sanctuary at PylaNo. cat. no. 76

    1868 · p. 19
  • George H. McFaddenRecorded

    McFadden directed an American expedition conducting supplementary investigations at the site.

    site of the “temple boys”Kourion

    1935 · p. 19
  • John Linton MyresExcavated

    Myres excavated at Lefkoniko and brought to light almost 600 pieces of limestone sculpture.

    1913 · p. 22
  • Melchior de VogüéDirectedFrench expedition

    De Vogüé directed the French expedition that excavated at Golgoi-Ayios Photios.

    1862 · p. 199
Show 3 more
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaFound

    Cesnola made major discoveries at Golgoi-Ayios Photios.

    1870 · p. 199
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaFound

    Cesnola found two inscribed plinths at the sanctuary of Zeus Labranios.

    two inscribed plinths with the feet of a figuresanctuary of Zeus Labranios on the hill of Phasoula, near Limassol

    p. 250
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaFound

    possiblyCesnola claimed to have found the crown fragment near Cape Greco, at a site he identified as Leucolla.

    fragment of a crown belonging to an over-lifesize statue of the Great GoddessNo. 74.51.2640region of Cape Greco

    p. 265

Recording and study 14

  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaEmployed byNew York Metropolitan Museum of Art

    The trustees hired Cesnola to unpack, arrange and classify the collection.

    $500 a monthNew York

    1877–1904 · p. 7
  • Olivier MassonStudied

    Masson established the probable location of the principal sanctuary at Ayios Photios.

    1960 · p. 16
  • V. Antoni LitrasGuidedOlivier Masson

    Litras led Masson to the site.

    Ayios Photios

    1960 · p. 16
  • V. Antoni LitrasGuidedPaul Åström

    Litras led Åström to the site.

    Ayios Photios

    p. 16
  • Hiram HitchcockConnected withLuigi Palma di Cesnola

    Hitchcock gave a lecture to promote the discoveries made by Cesnola.

    London

    1872 · p. 20
  • John Linton MyresPublished

    John L. Myres described bowls 4556 and 4557 and fragments 4558 and 4559 separately.

    Bowls and bowl fragmentsNo. MMA 74.51.4556, 4557, 4558, and 4559

    1914 · p. 20
  • Charles BalliardRestored

    Balliard added a piece cut from a Cyprus tombstone to the back of the statue for support.

    the statue Cat. 251No. 74.51.2463

    p. 21, 89, 106, 200, 264, 363, 337, 347
  • Adolf FurtwänglerStudied

    Furtwängler noted the Amathus sarcophagus, the Kition sarcophagus, and the group with a mother giving birth during his visit.

    Cesnola Collection sculpturesNo. Cat. 279Metropolitan Museum of Art

    p. 23
  • Hiram HitchcockPublished

    Hitchcock reproduced the figure in an article in Harper’s Magazine.

    the figure Cat. 251No. 74.51.2463

    1872 · p. 199, 228
  • Olivier MassonStudied

    Masson used Cesnola’s letter to establish the statue’s findspot and discovery date.

    the statue Cat. 251No. 74.51.2463Golgoi-Ayios Photios

    p. 199
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaCorresponded withHiram Hitchcock

    Cesnola wrote to Hiram Hitchcock about the discovery of the Amathus sarcophagus.

    1875 · p. 353
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaConnected withSamuel Birch

    Cesnola sent Birch photographs of the Amathus sarcophagus.

    photographs of the object

    1875 · p. 353
  • John Linton MyresRecorded

    Myres saw the tomb in 1894.

    Amathus

    1894 · p. 353
  • Lena SöderhjelmStudied

    Lena Åström distinguished two types among the stone objects.

    Stone objects identified as mace headsNo. Cat. 583–590

    p. 404

Posts and family 1

  • John Linton MyresEmployed byThe Metropolitan Museum of Art

    The Metropolitan Museum engaged Myres to study, rearrange, and label the Cesnola collection.

    Cesnola Collection of Cypriote Antiquitiesfive hundred dollars, plus his personal expenses

    1909 · p. 21

People it is cited for

6 people

Institutions it is cited for

1 institution

Mentioned in

76 mentions

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.