Book · 2016

The Political Museum: Power, Conflict, and Identity in Cyprus

Theopisti Stylianou-Lambert and Alexandra Bounia

Routledge

A study of how politics, conflict and different stakeholders shape museums in Cyprus, their collections and narratives, with case studies from archaeology, ethnography, history, religion and art.

Stylianou-Lambert and Bounia examine how museums in Cyprus take part in building identity and collective memory in a divided society. They follow political circumstances, community claims and individual initiatives through a museum's founding and collecting to its displays and visitor practices, and they ask how museums select and interpret material and what narratives and silences result. Some chapters take a broad view of groups of museums, others study single institutions, among them the Cyprus Museum, the St. Barnabas Icon Museum and the State Gallery of Contemporary Cypriot Art.

How it is organised

Ten chapters run from an introduction and a working account of politics, stakeholders and Cyprus's history to studies of national museums, archaeology and the politics of the past, folk museums, history and memorial museums, photography, icon museums and art. A concluding chapter draws together national identity, stakeholders, museum collections and context, international politics, change and cultural sustainability. Notes, references and an index follow (pp. 15–220).

The evidence

The case studies rest on museum visits and observations, interviews, archival research, official and promotional publications, museum guidebooks, exhibition material, photographs and published accounts. Museums in the northern and southern parts of the island are compared, and the cases include state, community, private and church museums as well as two temporary art exhibitions held in 2013 (pp. 18–20, 35–39).

The argument

Politics is defined as the activity through which groups articulate and negotiate competing claims, and museums take part in it because their authority, collections and everyday choices shape which histories become visible and how they are read. The approach reaches beyond exhibitions to foundations, funding, collecting, research and management, and treats stakeholders as a network whose members have unequal influence. In Cyprus the state and religious institutions often hold substantial influence, while private, local and community initiatives can bring different approaches (pp. 21–26, 211–213).

National museums in a divided society, the authors argue, tend to reinforce ethnic rather than civic identities. Greek Cypriot museums often emphasize archaeology, Hellenism, antiquity and Christianity, and Turkish Cypriot museums often foreground Ottoman history and Turkish Cypriot historical presence. The authors describe each community's narrative as selective, often excluding or downplaying the other's experience. The authors propose more inclusive narratives and shared remembrance, and hold that museums cannot become politically neutral by presenting themselves as such (pp. 43–47, 214–220).

A historical survey divides the development of state and national museums into three overlapping phases. Before 1955, colonial interests and local claims to heritage accompanied the promotion of archaeology and Hellenic identity. From 1955 to 1974, history museums supported separate accounts of struggle, suffering and community presence. After 1974, museums in the south kept their emphasis on archaeology and added folk and art museums, while northern authorities set up further history and icon museums. The authors identify the phases as layers whose priorities persist rather than replace one another (pp. 58–68).

History museums, in the authors' reading, memorialize victims and heroes while casting the other community as an enemy or leaving its experience out. In the photography chapter a single image takes on different meanings through captions and context, and images presented as evidence can reinforce selective collective memory. At St. Barnabas, Greek Cypriot women use a museum space as a church through prayer, offerings and refusal to pay admission, practices the authors connect with religious belief and with political claims about ownership and authority (pp. 117–178).

The art chapter contrasts the State Gallery's emphasis on a local artistic lineage with the 2013 exhibitions “The World of Cyprus” and “displays”. The first presented Adamantios Diamantis's painting as a shared cultural reference. The second invited participants to select and reinterpret works from the State Gallery collection, including material little shown in its permanent display. The conclusion calls on museums to acknowledge omissions and competing interpretations, and to support more inclusive forms of cultural memory (pp. 179–206).

Limits of the evidence

Little published information on northern cultural policy was available to the authors, and they could not conduct formal interviews with northern officials (pp. 18–20).

What it records

  • A 2013 study, as reported by the authors, identified 108 museums in the southern part of Cyprus.p. 35
  • The Greek Cypriot authorities run 17 museums.p. 49
  • The Turkish Cypriot authorities run 17 museums: six history museums, five icon or Byzantine museums, three archaeological and three ethnographic.p. 57
  • In 1927, an amendment to the antiquities law allowed 65 per cent of the Swedish Cyprus Expedition's finds to be exported to Sweden.p. 79
  • The Cyprus Museum was formally established on 15 June 1882, following a petition approved by the British High Commissioner, Sir Robert Biddulph.p. 81
  • The Museum Committee appointed H. H. Kitchener the Cyprus Museum's Curator and Honorary Secretary.p. 81
  • The Musée Lapidaire in Nicosia was completed in 1928 with a collection of 100 architectural fragments.p. 88
  • The Society of Cypriot Studies was founded on 17 April 1936 by 24 Greek Cypriot intellectuals.p. 100
  • The Cyprus Folk Art Museum opened to the public in December 1950 in a room on the ground floor of the Archbishopric.p. 103
  • The Church of Cyprus purchased Maria Eleftheriou-Gaffiero's collection in 2009 to donate it to the Cyprus Folk Art Museum.p. 103
  • The two Struggle Museums use the same photograph to support different narratives of the 1955–59 struggle, in the authors' account.p. 151
  • The Turkish Cypriot authorities reopened the St. Barnabas monastery and church as a museum in 1991.p. 159
  • Nine women took part in the St. Barnabas religious ceremony on 11 June 2012 and agreed to be interviewed later.p. 169
  • The first artwork purchased in 1962 for the future State Gallery was by Christoforos Savva.p. 190
  • The State Gallery of Contemporary Cypriot Art was inaugurated on 28 June 1990.p. 191
  • When it opened in 1990, the State Gallery displayed 120 of the approximately 1,000 artworks it owned.p. 192
  • The 2013 exhibition “The World of Cyprus” centred on a painting by Adamantios Diamantis measuring 17.50 by 1.75 metres and including 67 figures.p. 195
  • The first room of the Byzantine Museum was inaugurated on 18 January 1982, and the museum reached its present form in 1986.p. 226

Where to read

  • How politics, authority and stakeholders shape museum practicespp. 21–39
  • The three phases of Cypriot state and national museumspp. 58–67
  • Founding of the Cyprus Museum and the Lapidary Museumpp. 72–91
  • Society of Cypriot Studies and folk-art museumspp. 100–115
  • Four history and memorial museums and their displayspp. 119–138
  • Photographic narratives in war-related museumspp. 139–158
  • St. Barnabas Icon Museum and the Women of St. Barnabaspp. 159–177
  • State Gallery, “The World of Cyprus” and “displays”pp. 188–206

Contents

  • Introduction15
  • Museums, Politics, Stakeholders, and Conflict21
  • National Museums: Heritage and Identity41
  • Archaeology and the Politics of the Past69
  • Defining “Cypriotness”: Folk Museums, Communities, Patrons, and Collectors93
  • History and Memory: Victims, Heroes, and Enemies117
  • Visualizing War: Photography and Museums139
  • Cultural “Wars,” Religious Artifacts, and Visitors: Icon Museums and the Women of St. Barnabas159
  • Art and Politics and the Politics of Art179
  • Conclusions207

Objects published here

1
  • “The World of Cyprus”, monumental painting by Adamantios Diamantis, Figure 9.5; Figure 9.6 (p. 195)

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

  • Cyprus Museumarchaeological museum and case study
  • Lapidary Museummedieval museum founded by George Jeffery
  • St. Barnabas Icon and Archaeological Museummuseum and contested religious site
  • A. G. Leventis Foundationsupported the return of Diamantis's painting
  • A. G. Leventis Galleryhouses “The World of Cyprus”
  • Academy of Athensprovided expertise on Byzantine heritage
  • Byzantine Museum and Art Gallery of the Archbishop Makarios III Foundationreligious-art museum in southern Cyprus
  • Church of Cyprusmuseum patron and heritage stakeholder
  • Church of Panagia Phaneromeni in Nicosiaheld an early collection of icons
  • Department of Antiquitiesmanages state archaeological museums
  • Evkafmanaged religious property, supported the Lapidary Museum
  • Greek Community Assemblycreated the Cultural Development Department
  • Legislative Councilpassed the 1905 Antiquities Law
  • Leventis Municipal Museumhosted the 2013 Diamantis exhibition
  • Ottoman PorteOttoman authority concerned with antiquities
  • Society of Cypriot Studiesfounded the Cyprus Folk Art Museum
  • Swedish Cyprus Expeditionexcavated in Cyprus from 1927 to 1931

Also named: Istanbul Military Museum, Larnaca District Museum, Musée de Cluny, Ethnography and Archaeology Museum of Cambridge, Museums Association, Open University of Cyprus, Paphos Ethnographic Museum, Pitt Rivers Museum, Dr. Murray, Andrea Bruno, Andreas Zimboulakis, Basil Stewart, Mr. Enlart, Hitchens, D. W. Hermand, Edgar Feneck, E. Bovill, Dr Dümmler, Fouad Efeendi, Frangoullides, Vikan, G. S. Eliades, Georgios Vassiliou, Hakki Effendi, Ioannis Chaldoupis, Ioannis Economides, Ioannis Iliades, Lellos Demetriades, Loukia L. Hadjigavriel, Louloupis, Mustafa Akinci, Panagiotis Kavvadias, Pascal Konstantinidis, Porphyrios Dikaios, Rasiefsky, Safvet Pasha, S. Brown, Simos Menardos, Balderstone, Major T. Chamberlayne, Theodore N. Fotiadis, Peristianis, W. Corby.

Extent Notes pp. 221–232; references pp. 233–256; index pp. 257–271; figures 2.1–9.7c, map of Cyprus (Fig. 2.1)

Defines civic nationalism, ethnic nationalism, keimelia

ModernMedievalMuseumsHistory of ArchaeologyCollectingReligion and CultIconography

Excavations it is cited for

1 project

Who did what

57 records

Buying, selling and giving 17

  • Edmond DuthoitAgent forLouvre

    Edmond Duthoit acquired the Amathusian vase on behalf of the Louvre with his associates.

    the famous Amathusian vaseCyprus

    1862 · p. 73
  • Henry William WaddingtonAgent forLouvre

    William Waddington acquired the Amathusian vase on behalf of the Louvre with his associates.

    the famous Amathusian vaseCyprus

    1862 · p. 73
  • Melchior de VogüéAgent forLouvre

    Marquis Melchior de Vogüé acquired the Amathusian vase on behalf of the Louvre with his associates.

    the famous Amathusian vaseCyprus

    1862 · p. 73
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toMetropolitan Museum of Art

    Cesnola agreed to sell his collection to the Metropolitan Museum for £1,200.

    £1,200New York

    1870–1876 · p. 74
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaAuctioned

    Cesnola’s antiquities were sold at public auction in Paris.

    With unnamed buyersCypriot antiquities from excavations made in 1868Hôtel Drouot, Paris

    1870 · p. 74
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaOwned

    Luigi di Cesnola had his collection of objects from Dali, Athienou, and Amathus in his private museum in Larnaca.

    p. 74
  • George JefferyConnected withCyprus Museum Committee

    The Cyprus Museum Committee placed medieval tombstones in Jeffery’s care for preservation.

    1906 · p. 88
  • L. H. Dudley BuxtonGave toBritish Museum

    L. H. Dudley Buxton donated his collection to the British Museum, among other institutions.

    collection of folk artifacts and traditional pottery

    1913 · p. 95
  • L. H. Dudley BuxtonGave toPitt Rivers Museum

    L. H. Dudley Buxton donated his collection to the Pitt Rivers Museum, among other institutions.

    collection of folk artifacts

    1913 · p. 95
  • L. H. Dudley BuxtonGave toBankfield Museum

    L. H. Dudley Buxton donated his collection to the Bankfield Museum, among other institutions.

    collection of folk artifactsHalifax

    1913 · p. 95
  • L. H. Dudley BuxtonFormed a collection

    L. H. Dudley Buxton collected traditional artifacts from the areas where the excavations took place.

    Lapithos, Nicosia, Salamina

    p. 95
  • Max Ohnefalsch-RichterConnected withMagda H. Ohnefalsch-Richter

    Max and Magda Ohnefalsch-Richter accumulated an important collection of ethnographic objects together.

    Cyprus

    p. 96
  • Antigone Tavernari-IoannidouGave toCyprus Folk Art Museum

    Antigone Tavernari-Ioannidou donated forty old embroideries to the Museum.

    1946 · p. 102
  • Maria GaffieroSold toChurch of Cyprus

    Maria Eleftheriou-Gaffiero’s collection was purchased by the Church of Cyprus for donation to the Museum.

    collection of traditional handicrafts

    2009 · p. 103
  • Antigone Tavernari-IoannidouGave toBenaki Museum

    Antigone Tavernari-Ioannidou donated handicrafts from her collection to the Benaki Museum.

    Athens

    p. 103
Show 2 more

Excavation 11

Recording and study 25

  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaConnected withMetropolitan Museum of Art

    The Metropolitan Museum financed Cesnola to conduct further research for antiquities on the island.

    Cyprus

    p. 74
  • Demetrios PieridesFoundedMusée de Chypre

    Dimitri Piérides was one of the founders of the Musée de Chypre in 1882.

    1882 · p. 76
  • Alexander Stuart MurrayPublished

    Nikolaos Lanitis reported that Dr. Murray’s report was published in London before the objects were transferred there.

    his studious report

    p. 78
  • Herbert KitchenerEmployed byCyprus Museum

    Kitchener was appointed Curator and Honorary Secretary of the Cyprus Museum.

    1882 · p. 81
  • John Linton MyresCatalogued the collection ofCyprian Museum

    Myres co-authored the Catalogue of the Cyprus Museum, recording its material.

    material owned by the Cyprus museum

    1894–1899 · p. 82
  • Edgar FeneckConnected withCyprus Museum

    Edgar Feneck submitted a design plan for the new Cyprus Museum.

    architectural design plansNicosia

    1906 · p. 84
  • Theodore N. FotiadisConnected withCyprus Museum

    Theodore N. Fotiadis submitted a design plan for the new Cyprus Museum.

    architectural design plansNicosia

    1906 · p. 84
  • Georgios SoteriadisConnected withCyprus Museum

    Georgios Soteriadis was invited to help with arrangements of the new museum.

    Nicosia

    p. 85
  • Nikolaos BalanosWorked withGeorge Jeffery

    Nikolaos Balanos and George Jeffery collaborated on the execution of the Cyprus Museum building plan.

    Nicosia

    p. 85
  • Panagiotis KavvadiasConnected withCyprus Museum

    Panagiotis Kavvadias was invited to help with arrangements of the new museum.

    Nicosia

    p. 85
  • George JefferyFoundedLapidary Museum

    George Jeffery established the Lapidary Museum in Nicosia.

    100 architectural fragments

    1928 · p. 88
  • Georgios SoteriouStudied

    Icons and church artG. Soteriou and the Church Committee studied the Phaneromeni collection of icons.

    the Phaneromeni collection of 112 iconsChurch of Panagia Phaneromeni, Nicosia

    p. 90
  • Georgios SoteriouCurated

    Icons and church artG. Soteriou prepared a plan to display the Phaneromeni icon collection at the Byzantine Museum.

    the Phaneromeni collection of 112 icons

    p. 90
  • Yiorgos FrangoudesConnected withPatriotic Association of Cypriots

    Georgios Fragoudis was the mastermind behind an exhibition organized by the Patriotic Association of Cypriots in Athens.

    archaeological artifacts and ethnographic objects

    1901 · p. 98
  • Yiorgos FrangoudesRecorded

    Georgios Fragoudis masterminded an exhibition of Cypriot artifacts and crafts in Athens.

    archaeological artifacts and ethnographic objects

    1901 · p. 98
Show 10 more

Posts and family 4

People it is cited for

66 people
36 more

Institutions it is cited for

30 institutions

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.