Book · 2012
Religion and Social Transformations in Cyprus: From the Cypriot Basileis to the Hellenistic Strategos
Leiden and Boston: Brill
A study of how sanctuaries, cult at Soloi and Amathous, and portrait-like sculpture show Cyprus passing from the Cypriot Basileis to a Ptolemaic Strategos.
Papantoniou traces how Cyprus passed from rule by local Basileis to island-wide government under a Ptolemaic Strategos, using the archaeology of religion as his route into the change. He sets island-wide discussion of sacred landscapes beside case studies of cult and votive material at Soloi and Amathous and an analysis of Cypriot Hellenistic portrait-like sculpture. The two case studies examine how cult and material forms could communicate authority and accommodate local and wider religious traditions. Religion is treated as bound up with social power, political structures and everyday identities, and the persistence and adaptation of local practices are weighed alongside change.
The evidence combines archaeological topography, sanctuary remains, architecture, votive sculptures and terracottas, inscriptions, textual sources, settlement patterns and survey data. Two appendices set out selected sanctuary-site tables by period, a table of sanctuary life-spans and a table of 54 inscribed statue bases from Palaipaphos, with proposed portrait identifications. Papantoniou describes these catalogues as representative of sanctuaries through time and not exhaustive, and explains how he handles combined, excluded and uncertain sites (pp. 79–85, 373–393).
How it is organised
An introduction frames the transition and the research questions. Chapter One, ‘Setting the Scene’, covers historical narratives, theoretical considerations and a methodology for interpretation; Chapter Two studies sacred landscapes from the city-kingdoms into the Hellenistic period. Chapter Three presents the Soloi and Amathous case studies and Chapter Four takes up Cypriot ‘portraits’, with Chapter Five giving the conclusions on religion, power and ideology, the move from a Cypriot to a Hellenistic koine, and new avenues for research. An epilogue carries the history into Roman rule, and the two appendices hold the sanctuary and statue-base tables. The Hellenistic I and Hellenistic II phases and the terms Basileia and Strategia are defined near the start (pp. 1–72).
The argument
Papantoniou argues that the transition involved interaction between forces within and beyond the Cypriot cultural system, with local traditions and agents shaping how Ptolemaic structures were received. A long-term, multi-temporal approach relates material and religious change to political history, social practice and human experience (pp. 2–5, 355–356).
Sanctuaries are read as parts of wider social and political landscapes. Extra-urban sanctuaries could be tied to the territorial and political organisation of the city-kingdoms, though Papantoniou cautions that the evidence cannot establish territorial claims conclusively. The later prominence of urban and peri-urban sanctuaries is considered together with the changing political role of cult, royal associations and social memory (pp. 84–116, 157–162).
In his conclusion Papantoniou argues that political unification in Hellenistic II accompanied a longer-term cultural and religious integration that formed through processes reaching beyond short-term political events. He describes Cypriot Hellenistic culture as shaped by exchanges between local and wider traditions, with regional and social differences continuing, and presents social change as coming through negotiation with Ptolemaic power. He presents religion as central to the legitimation and communication of authority, and argues that the sacred and the political cannot be separated cleanly. Papantoniou names further work needed on settlement, tombs, epigraphy, pottery, sculpture, sacred architecture, ritual, priesthoods and burial archaeology (pp. 356–367).
Sacred Landscapes
The island-wide survey of sanctuaries rests on Ulbrich's catalogue of 206 sanctuary sites and cult rooms, whose figures for discontinuity and disruption of cult Papantoniou reports (pp. 79–85).
He then takes the sanctuaries of the city-kingdoms, their territorial claims and the regional styles of their votive material, before the Hellenistic sanctuaries and the continuity of settlement and cult (pp. 86–140).
Kafizin, with its inscribed pottery, potters and cult associations, and the sanctuary on Geronisos, with its proposed cult function, are the two cases through which the chapter asks whether Ptolemaic ideologies can be seen there (pp. 141–151).
Soloi-Cholades
Papantoniou reviews the excavation history and the temple complex, then the architectural phases, sculpture and inscriptions, in relation to the cults proposed for the site and to interpretations of local and Hellenistic practice. The material serves to consider how religious identifications, Ptolemaic power and local traditions related to one another (pp. 166–208).
Amathous
The Amathous study covers excavation history, the building called the ‘palace’, proposed sanctuaries and the sanctuary of Aphrodite. It takes in votive deposits, among them the terracotta figurines of deposit MX 318, together with inscriptions, water installations, architecture and animal remains. The finds are related to changing cult practices and political meanings, and Papantoniou acknowledges the interpretative limits of the material (pp. 208–294).
Cypriot 'Portraits'
Chapter Four reviews Ptolemaic royal cult and scholarship on Hellenistic royal sculpture before turning to inscribed statue bases and limestone portrait-like images. Identification and dating raise problems, and the sculptures are approached through their contexts, styles and possible roles in visual communication. Papantoniou's discussion moves attention from secure royal identification toward the part elite-style images played in relationships of power (pp. 295–354).
Dating
Papantoniou takes Hellenistic I as the phase from 310 BC to 217 BC and Hellenistic II as the phase from 217 BC to 30 BC, set apart by the death of the last Cypriot Basileus and the first secure evidence for Strategia. Sanctuary evidence is followed across the Late Bronze Age, Iron Age, Hellenistic and Roman periods. The epilogue argues for long-term chronological frameworks, within which the Cypro-Classical and early Hellenistic periods, and the late Hellenistic and early Roman periods, can each be taken together as broader conjunctures (pp. 371–393).
What it records
- Hellenistic I runs from 310 to 217 BC and Hellenistic II from 217 to 30 BC in Papantoniou's scheme, which takes the death of the last Cypriot Basileus and the first secure evidence for Strategia as the dividing points.p. XIII
- Papantoniou argues that Cyprus's development from the city-kingdoms to the Hellenistic period resulted from processes within the Cypriot cultural system and from processes outside it.p. 4
- The island-wide survey of sanctuary evidence rests on a catalogue of 206 sanctuary sites or cult rooms compiled by Ulbrich.p. 79
- Ulbrich's catalogue shows discontinuity of cult at about 41 sites and disruption at a further 12, as Papantoniou reports.p. 108
- Definitive evidence for a sanctuary founded to stake territorial claims is missing from Cyprus, and Papantoniou treats any interpretation of the matter as theoretical.p. 114
- The Kafizin inscriptions comprise 309 inscribed pottery fragments catalogued by Mitford, dated to seven Ptolemaic regnal years, 225–218 BCE.p. 142
- Of the Kafizin texts, 66 are in the syllabic script.p. 142
- The temple complex at Soloi-Cholades was in continuous use from about 250 BCE to the fourth century CE.p. 167
- The British Museum mission opened 312 tombs at Amathous in 1893–94, and the Swedish Cyprus Expedition excavated another 26 in 1930.p. 209
- The Amathous 'palace' was first built in the ninth century BCE, received further building work in the sixth century BCE, and had a final phase dated to about 500–300 BCE.p. 210
- The complete monolithic stone vase at Amathous measured 1.87 m high and 3.19 m in diameter, weighed more than 12 tons and held 6,000 litres.p. 217
- Skeletal analysis at the Amathous sanctuary shows that sheep and goats were eaten more often than bovines, while bovine sacrifices grew in the fifth and fourth centuries BCE.p. 219
- Androkles, Basileus of Amathous in the fourth century BCE, dedicated statues of his sons Orestheus and Andragoras to the Cyprian Aphrodite.p. 221
- More than a thousand fragments of Hellenistic terracotta figurines were found on the Amathous 'acropolis', most of them in deposit MX 318.p. 222
- The tunnel beneath the lower city of Amathous is 120 m long, about 2.5 m wide and 4 m high, and was designed to cross the hill of the 'acropolis'.p. 225
- The layers associated with the abandonment of the Amathous 'palace' date between 301 and 294 BCE.p. 282
- Papantoniou argues that political unification in Hellenistic II accompanied a longer-term cultural and religious unification.p. 361
- Papantoniou argues that social change in Cyprus came after dialogue, exchange and negotiation with Ptolemaic power structures.p. 365
- In 58 BCE Cyprus became a praetorian province, at first attached to Cilicia, after a law carried by the tribune Publius Claudius Pulcher and implemented by Cato.p. 370
- The sanctuary catalogues in Appendix One are representative of the statistical presence of sanctuaries through time and are not exhaustive.p. 374
Where to read
- Definitions and chronology of Basileia, Strategia and Hellenistic I and IIpp. XIII–15
- Theoretical framework: social power, ideology and archaeology of religionpp. 54–72
- Sanctuary survey evidence, catalogue basis and limitationspp. 79–85
- City-kingdom sanctuaries, territorial claims and regional stylespp. 86–116
- Hellenistic sacred landscapes, settlement and sanctuary continuitypp. 117–140
- Kafizin inscriptions, potters and cult associationspp. 141–146
- Geronisos sanctuary and proposed cult functionpp. 147–151
- Soloi-Cholades temple phases, cult interpretations and sculpturepp. 166–207
- Amathous palace, proposed sanctuaries and Aphrodite depositpp. 208–233
- Amathous figurine types, cult agents and royal imagerypp. 234–294
- Cypriot portrait-like sculpture and elite-style interpretationpp. 309–354
- Sanctuary catalogues and the Palaipaphos statue-base tablepp. 373–403
Contents
- Introduction1
- 1. ‘Setting the Scene’: Historical Narratives, Theoretical Considerations and a Methodology for Interpretation7
- 1.1. From Basileis to Strategos: Telling the Story7
- 1.2. Continuities and Interruptions: Towards an Archaeology of Religion15
- 1.3. History of Research, Methodological Problems and Limitations21
- 1.4. From a Cypriot to a Pan-Hellenistic Context and Back: Hellenistic ‘Hellenisations’ and Cultural Koine28
- 1.5. From Cypriot to Hellenistic Koine52
- 1.6. Social Power and the Archaeology of Religion54
- 1.7. Methodology69
- 2. Sacred Landscapes73
- 2.1. Introduction73
- 2.2. Theoretical Background to the Study of Sacred Landscapes74
- 2.3. Survey Analysis and Its Implications for the Study of Cypriot Sacred Landscapes79
- 2.4. Cypriot Sacred Landscapes of the Transition84
- 2.4.1. The Sacred Landscapes of the Cypriot City-Kingdoms86
- 2.4.2. The Hellenistic Sacred Landscapes116
- 2.5. Concluding Remarks on the Cypriot Sacred Landscapes of the Transition160
- 3. Case Studies: Change and Variation163
- 3.1. Introduction163
- 3.2. Soloi166
- 3.2.1. History of Research and Topography166
- 3.2.2. The Temples at Cholades167
- 3.2.3. ‘Revisiting’ Soloi-Cholades: ‘Syncretism’ of Cults, Power and Ideology172
- 3.3. Amathous208
- 3.3.1. History of Research and Topography208
- 3.3.2. The ‘Palace’ and Its Sanctuaries209
- 3.3.3. The Sanctuary of Aphrodite214
- 3.3.4. The ‘Subterranean Cult Place’224
- 3.3.5. ‘Syncretism’ of Cults, Power and Ideology233
- 3.4. Concluding Remarks on Soloi and Amathous Studies290
- 4. Cypriot ‘Portraits’295
- 4.1. Introduction295
- 4.2. Ptolemaic Cult296
- 4.3. ‘Portraiture’ and Hellenistic Royal Sculptures302
- 4.4. Hellenistic ‘Portraits’ in a Cypriot Context309
- 4.4.1. History of Scholarship310
- 4.4.2. A Typological-Stylistic Approach314
- 4.4.3. Materialisation of Ideologies: An Alternative Approach?326
- 4.5. Concluding Remarks on Cypriot ‘Portraiture’351
- 5. Conclusions355
- 5.1. Religion and Social Transformations from Basileis to Strategos355
- 5.2. Power, Religion and Ideology356
- 5.3. From Cypriot to Hellenistic Koine: ‘Material Homogeneity’ and ‘Cultural Identities’358
- 5.4. From Segmentation to Unification: ‘Bridging the Gap’361
- 5.5. New Avenues for Cypriot and Mediterranean Archaeology365
- Epilogue369
- Appendix 1. Landscapes373
- Appendix 2. ‘Portraits’395
- Bibliography411
- Figures483
- Index591
Objects published here
12- Statue of Aphrodite with Eros from a temple at Golgoi, The Cesnola Collection, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, temple at Golgoi, 74.51.2464, Figure 47 (p. 533)
- Amathous sarcophagus, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, The Cesnola Collection, Amathous, 74.51.2453, Figure 69 (p. 554)
- Incense burner with a winged female, Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna, Voni, I 602, Figure 70 (p. 558)
- Cypro-Classical limestone sculpture of a male, identified as Kilikas, Cyprus Museum, Nicosia, Voni, C 14328-Inc. S 101, Figure 97 (p. 587)
- Cypro-Classical limestone sculpture from a temple at Golgoi, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, The Cesnola Collection, temple at Golgoi, 74.51.2461, Figure 98 (p. 589)
- Limestone ‘Hathor’ capital, Limassol District Museum, ‘Propylon’ ‘palatial’ sanctuary, Amathous, AM 805, fig. 25 (p. fig. 25)
- Limestone kouros, Limassol District Museum, ‘Kouros’ ‘palatial’ sanctuary, Amathous, AM 1762, fig. 27 (p. fig. 27)
- Limestone statuette interpreted as ‘priest with the mask’, Limassol District Museum, ‘Baetyl’ ‘palatial’ sanctuary, Amathous, AM 11, fig. 29 (p. fig. 29)
- Terracotta figurine of Aphrodite dressed, Limassol District Museum, deposit MX 318, Amathous, AM 1000, Figure 48 (p. 534)
- Terracotta figurine of naked Aphrodite holding her breasts, Limassol District Museum, deposit MX 318, Amathous, AM 982, Figure 51 (p. 537)
- Terracotta figurine of Isis, type 1, Limassol District Museum, deposit MX 318, Amathous, AM 893, Figure 56 (p. 541)
- Complete monolithic stone vase, Louvre, Amathous sanctuary, fig. 36 (p. 217)
People, places and institutions
People
- Aphroditegoddess and principal cult at Amathous
- Pierre Aupertcited for Amathous excavation and topography
- Anja Ulbrichcompiled the catalogue of sanctuary sites
- Mitfordcatalogued the Kafizin inscriptions
- Westholmpublished the Cholades temple excavations
- Maria Iacovoucited on Cypriot history and archaeology
- NikoklesBasileus of Paphos
- NikokreonBasileus of Salamis in the transition era
- Pumiyatonlast king of Kition
- Alexander the Greathis conquest frames the political transition
- Ptolemy IPtolemaic ruler in the cult and history discussed
- Ptolemy IIPtolemaic king associated with cult
- Arsinoe PhiladelphusPtolemaic queen whose cult is discussed
- AndroklesBasileus of Amathous who dedicated statues
- Antonyruler discussed in the epilogue
- Cleopatra VII PhilopatorPtolemaic ruler discussed in the epilogue
- Connellyauthor of a study of Cypriot votive sculpture
- Gjerstadsource of a chronological scheme; excavator
- Isisgoddess in the cult interpretations
- Cybelegoddess associated with Cholades
- Sarapisdeity in the cult evidence
- Erosdeity represented in sanctuary finds
- Artemisgoddess represented in figurines
Institutions
- Department of Antiquities of the Republic of Cyprusarchaeological authority and source of survey data
- Metropolitan Museum of Artholds Cesnola Collection sculpture
- Swedish Cyprus Expeditionexcavated Cypriot sites and Amathous tombs
- British Museumexcavated the Amathous tombs
- Cyprus Survey Inventorysource for sanctuary-site evidence
- Louvremuseum holding the Amathous vase and sculpture
Places
- Soloi-Choladessanctuary and temple complex case study
- Amathouscity, palace and Aphrodite sanctuary case study
- Kafizingrotto and Nymph sanctuary with inscriptions
- Geronisoslate Hellenistic sanctuary
- Kitioncity-kingdom and sanctuary case
- Paphoscity-kingdom and Hellenistic centre
- Nea PaphosHellenistic capital and sanctuary centre
- Palaipaphossanctuary and city-kingdom centre
- Salamiscity-kingdom and Hellenistic centre
- Amathous ‘acropolis’location of the palace and Aphrodite sanctuary
- Idalioncity-kingdom with sanctuary and sculpture
- Golgoisanctuary and sculpture centre
- Vounipalatial site with sanctuaries
- Kourioncity-kingdom with the Apollo Hylates sanctuary
- Marioncity-kingdom and settlement
- Athienou-Mallourasanctuary example in the survey discussion
- Arsossanctuary and sculpture findspot
- Vonisanctuary and portrait-like sculpture findspot
Also named: Onesilos, Publius Claudius Pulcher, Julius Caesar, University of Cyprus.
Extent 98 figures, 1 map; bibliography pp. 411–481; index pp. 591–604
Defines Basileia, Strategia, Hellenistic I, Hellenistic II, sacred landscapes, extra-urban, Hellenistic koine, social power, archaeology of religion, elite-style
Late Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicCypro-ClassicalHellenisticRomanReligion and CultArchitectureSculptureKingship and PoliticsChronology and Dating
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
8 pages- Houses for the GodsArticle
- Archaic Limestone StatuesCompendium
- Cypro-Archaic CyprusCompendium
- Hellenistic CyprusCompendium
- Herakles-MelqartCompendium
- The PhoeniciansCompendium
- The Statues of Ancient CyprusCompendium
- KitionSite
Excavations it is cited for
1 project- 1867–1869Idalion, Goshi and Pyla: Robert Hamilton Lang's excavations (sanctuary of Apollo)Directed by Robert Hamilton LangClearance and early digging
Who did what
20 recordsExcavation 9
- 1860–1865 · p. 22
Henry William WaddingtonExcavated withEdmond Duthoit
Waddington and Duthoit conducted archaeological campaigns that excavated and exploited sanctuary sites in Cyprus.
sanctuary sites at Athienou-Malloura, Golgoi-Agios Photos, Idalion and Arsos
- 1860–1865 · p. 22
Melchior de VogüéExcavated withHenry William Waddington
de Vogue and Waddington conducted archaeological campaigns that excavated and exploited sanctuary sites in Cyprus.
sanctuary sites at Athienou-Malloura, Golgoi-Agios Photos, Idalion and Arsos
- 1860–1865 · p. 22
Melchior de VogüéExcavated withEdmond Duthoit
de Vogue and Duthoit conducted archaeological campaigns that excavated and exploited sanctuary sites in Cyprus.
sanctuary sites at Athienou-Malloura, Golgoi-Agios Photos, Idalion and Arsos
- p. 23
Robert Hamilton LangExcavated
Sir Robert Hamilton Lang excavated a temenos at Idalion and Pyla and recorded and analysed sanctuary sites.
- 1913 · p. 25
John Linton MyresExcavated
Myres excavated at Lefkoniko and brought to light almost 600 pieces of limestone sculpture.
- 1920–1932 · p. 26
Einar Nilson GjerstadDirectedThe Swedish Cyprus Expedition
Einar Gjerstad led the Swedish Cyprus Expedition when it excavated at Enkomi in June and July 1930.
over two hundred tombs
- p. 166
Luigi Palma di Cesnola found the site of the theatre at Soloi.
- p. 166
Luigi Palma di CesnolaExcavated
Luigi Palma di Cesnola excavated tombs at Soloi.
- p. 350
Robert Hamilton LangFound
Lang found statues in Idalion that Senff later positioned in models.
Recording and study 10
- p. 23
Colonna Ceccaldi brothersStudied
Colonna-Ceccaldi studied statuary from Golgoi-Agios Photos and established a chronological system of style and typology.
statuary excavated from Golgoi-Agios Photos
- 1894–1899 · p. 25
John Linton MyresCatalogued the collection ofCyprian Museum
Myres co-authored the Catalogue of the Cyprus Museum, recording its material.
material owned by the Cyprus museum
- 1914 · p. 25
John Linton MyresPublished material ofMetropolitan Museum of Art
J.L. Myres published a scholarly catalogue of Cypriot antiquities stored in the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Cesnola Collection of Antiquities from CyprusNew York
- 1931 · p. 25
F. PrycePublished material ofBritish Museum
Pryce published the British Museum collection of Cypriote sculpture.
- p. 27
Joan ConnellyStudied
Connelly studied Hellenistic votive sculpture from four sites to identify regional schools.
Arsos, Voni, Idalion and Golgoi-Agios Photos
- p. 167, 172
Alfred WestholmPublished
Westholm published the temples at Cholades in detail.
- p. 167
Giorgos PapantoniouStudied
G. Papantoniou focused his analysis on finds related to the first four temples at Cholades.
- p. 310
John Linton MyresCatalogued
Myres described the colossal male head in his handbook of the Cesnola Collection.
colossal male head wearing a wreathNo. no. 1318Metropolitan Museum of Art
- p. 311
Alfred WestholmPublished
Westholm published a study of the Temples of Soloi.
- p. 313
Vassos KarageorghisPublished
Karageorghis published sculpture from the Potamia sanctuary and discussed its portrait-like heads.
limestone sculptures and Hellenistic portrait-like headsPotamia, near Idalion
Posts and family 1
- 1935–1960 · p. 26
Arthur Hubert Stanley MegawEmployed byDept. of Antiquities of Cyprus
Mr. A.H.S. Megaw directed the Department of Antiquities during most of the colonial period.
Cyprus
People it is cited for
1 person- Pierre Aupert5 citations
Mentioned in
14 mentionsTomb records · 5
- Amathus-Western Necropolis, SCE Tomb 11
Discussion · 2012 · p. 239
- Palaepaphos-Skales, Karageorghis Tomb 49
Discussion, passing mention · 2012 · p. 16
- Amathus-Diplostrati, Department of Antiquities Tomb 109
Passing mention · 2012 · p. 441
- Politiko-Chomazoudia, Berlin Museum Tomb IV-5
Passing mention · 2012 · p. 478
- Salamis-Tumulus 77, Department of Antiquities Tomb 77
Passing mention · 2012 · pp. 415, 422
- On Ancient Cyprus · 8listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
- Excavations · 1listed under Excavations it is cited for
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.