Article · 1996
La dispersion des antiquités chypriotes: les deux collections Cesnola
Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 25 3-32
An article tracing the dispersal of the Cypriot antiquities collected by Luigi and Alessandro Palma di Cesnola, through gifts, museum purchases and auctions in Europe and the United States.
Masson separates the two collections formed on Cyprus by the brothers Luigi and Alessandro Palma di Cesnola and follows each into the museums, private hands and auction rooms where its objects ended up. The first part covers Luigi's activity and the movement of his objects to institutions in Europe and the United States. The second follows Alessandro's collection, known in London as the Lawrence-Cesnola Collection, through its publications and four sales. The sources are museum inventories, correspondence, sale catalogues, illustrated publications and later studies of individual objects.
Masson argues that the two collections must be kept apart, so that the histories and bibliographies of surviving objects are not conflated.
Luigi Palma di Cesnola
Masson dates Luigi's collecting on Cyprus from his arrival as American consul until his departure in 1876. His objects dispersed early, through sales in Paris and London and through gifts and purchases by museums, among them those of Berlin, the Louvre, the British Museum, Turin and Istanbul. An 1870 sale at the Hôtel Drouot, with a catalogue by Froehner, supplied the Louvre.
The Metropolitan Museum then acquired Luigi's first and second collections. Masson explains how its inventory, Cesnola's Atlas and Myres's Handbook overlap as reference systems, and he cautions that some findspot attributions need scrutiny while arguing against rejecting them all, since other publications or later finds can confirm particular provenances (pp. 13–17). Masson notes that many of the larger sculptures, representative vases, precious objects and inscriptions stayed in New York after the 1928 Anderson Galleries sale, which scattered other pieces to buyers such as John Ringling.
The Lawrence-Cesnola Collection
Alessandro worked on the island from 1874, and Edwin Henry Lawrence financed his collecting. Sotheby sold the collection in 1883, 1884, 1888 and 1892, and the objects passed to museums and private collections, with Pitt Rivers among the buyers. Masson works from annotated auction catalogues, read together with Cyprus Antiquities and Salaminia, to trace lots into later holdings in the British Museum, the Pitt Rivers Museum, the Ashmolean Museum and Bowdoin College, where Dana Estes had formed a collection from sale objects (pp. 18–27).
Auction descriptions and illustrations can help to identify objects, though provenance and identification often remain uncertain, and some pieces cannot now be located. Alessandro's publications and the auction records still make it possible to recognise objects that reappear in later collections.
What it records
- Luigi Palma di Cesnola arrived in Cyprus as American consul in the last days of 1865.p. 3
- Carl Friederichs travelled to Cyprus in autumn 1869 and acquired a series of pieces for the Berlin museum.p. 4
- The Louvre's purchases at the 1870 sale are listed in inventory N, numbers 3519–3532.p. 5
- The British Museum acquired 127 objects from Luigi Palma di Cesnola, inventoried in September 1876 as 1876.9-9, 1 to 127.p. 9
- A lot of antiquities from Luigi Palma di Cesnola reached Turin in June 1870, after the finds at Golgoi; it was given to the Academy of Sciences and passed to the Museum of Antiquities.p. 10
- The definitive Metropolitan Museum inventory for the Cesnola Collection runs from 74.51.0001 to 74.51.6714, with a supplementary group in the 74.57 series.p. 14
- The Anderson Galleries sale of March and April 1928, which included the Cesnola collection, comprised 965 lots in two sale catalogues.p. 16
- The museum of the American University of Beirut received a gift of Cypriot pottery from Luigi Palma di Cesnola in 1868.p. 17
- Alessandro Palma di Cesnola himself dates his collecting activity on Cyprus to 1876–79.p. 18
- Alessandro Palma di Cesnola's collection was shown in London at Edwin Henry Lawrence's house in Holland Park and became known as the Lawrence-Cesnola Collection.p. 18
- Lot 625 in the 1892 sale was a medieval tympan, 61.5 by 104 cm, from a church in Larnaca.p. 26
- The four sales of Alessandro Palma di Cesnola's collection brought Lawrence and his family 975 pounds in total.p. 27
Where to read
- Luigi Palma di Cesnola’s early sales and European museum acquisitionspp. 4–12
- The Metropolitan Museum collection’s numbering and reference systemspp. 13–15
- The 1928 Anderson Galleries sale and later dispersalpp. 16–17
- Alessandro Palma di Cesnola’s publications and the Lawrence-Cesnola auctionspp. 18–22
- Objects traced through the 1892 auction cataloguepp. 22–26
Contents
- I3
- A) Berlin, Staatliche Museen.4
- B) Vienne, Kunsthistorisches Museum.5
- C) Musée du Louvre.5
- D) France, musées de province.5
- E) Oxford, Pitt Rivers Museum.8
- F) Londres, British Museum.9
- G) Turin, Musée des Antiquités.10
- H) Boston, Museum of Fine Arts.10
- I) Istanbul, Musée d'archéologie.10
- K) Athènes, Musée National.11
- L) Munich, Staatliche Antikensammlung und Glyptothek.11
- M) Oxford, Ashmolean Museum.11
- N) Cambridge, Fitzwilliam Museum.12
- O) Genève, Musée d'art et d'histoire.12
- P) Pérouse, Musée archéologique.12
- Q) Musée divers.12
- II18
- Illustrations des planches27
Objects published here
8- Berlin vase F. 71, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, 8478, Furtwängler 71, pl. III, 1 (p. Pl. III)
- Berlin vase F. 72, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Ant. 10813, Furtwängler 72, pl. III, 2 (p. Pl. III)
- Votive objects from Golgoi, Metropolitan Museum of Art, Golgoi, pl. II, 1–4 (p. 27)
- Vase with human face on the neck, Musée d'Archéologie nationale, possibly Idalion, 22.231, 31 (p. 7)
- Vase with bull, man and bird, Pitt Rivers Museum, 1884.38/2803, 48 (p. 8)
- Head-shaped vase from Idalion, Ashmolean Museum, Idalion, 1974.437 (p. 12)
- Cypriot terracotta bathtub, British Museum, 1981.8-10.8, 623 (p. 25)
- Medieval tympan from a church in Larnaca, Victoria and Albert Museum, a church in Larnaca, A-2-1982, 625, CA, pl. [LVII]; Salamina, pl. IXa (p. 26)
People, places and institutions
People
- Luigi Palma di CesnolaAmerican consul; formed the first collection
- Alessandro Palma di Cesnolaformed the second collection, sold in London
- Hiram Hitchcockreceived a gift of antiquities
- Carl Friederichsacquired Cypriot objects for Berlin
- Rollinantiquary and buyer at the auctions
- Feuardentantiquary involved in the sales
- W. Froehnerwrote the 1870 sale catalogue
- Samuel BirchBritish Museum correspondent of Cesnola
- John Taylor Johnstonadvanced funds for the first New York purchase
- W. T. BlodgettTrustee involved in the New York purchase
- John Ruskinreceived antiquities from Luigi Palma di Cesnola
- A. H. L. Fox Pitt Riversbought objects at several of the sales
- Edwin Henry Lawrencefinanced Alessandro's collecting
- John Ringlingbought objects at the 1928 sale
- Dana Estesformed a collection from sale objects
- W. Gladstonereceived a funerary inscription
Institutions
- American University of Beirutreceived Cypriot pottery from Cesnola
- Anderson Galleriesconducted the 1928 sale
- Musée de Berlinacquired objects through Friederichs
- British Museumacquired objects through sales and gifts
- Musée du Louvrebought objects at the 1870 sale
- Metropolitan Museum of Artacquired Luigi's collections
- Hôtel Drouotvenue of the 1870 sale
- Sothebyconducted the London auctions
- Pitt Rivers Museumreceived objects collected by Pitt Rivers
- Ashmolean Museumreceived objects through later transfers
- Museo di Antichità di Torinoreceived objects donated in Turin
- Académie des Sciencesreceived a gift of antiquities
- Musée Impérial Ottomanreceived gifts from Luigi Palma di Cesnola
- Bowdoin Collegereceived objects bequeathed by Dana Estes
- Victoria and Albert Museumreceived objects from Alessandro's collection
- John and Mable Ringling Museumholds objects bought by John Ringling
- Museum of Fine Artsreceived Temple boys bought at auction
- Fitzwilliam Museumholds former Cesnola objects
- Musée archéologique de Genèvereceived objects through Louis Castan
- Société archéologique d'Athènesheld vases later transferred to Athens
Places
Also named: Bechbech, A. Furtwängler, George Bancroft, Ch. Newton, Henri Claudet, Denis Feissel, Musée archéologique.
Extent pp. 3–28, 6 pls (I–VI)
ModernEarly Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeCypro-ArchaicRomanMedievalCollectingMuseumsHistory of ArchaeologyPotterySculpture
Who did what
47 recordsBuying, selling and giving 32
- p. 3
Bostantus BeshesAgent forLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Cesnola's account says Besbes applied for an export permit for him as Russian Consul.
Cesnola's antiquities
- p. 3
Luigi Palma di CesnolaFormed a collection
Cesnola assembled antiquities from Larnaca and its surroundings, buying from inhabitants and subsidizing small excavations.
objects from Larnaca and its surroundings
- 1868 · p. 4
Luigi Palma di CesnolaOffered for sale
possiblyAccording to his biographer, a sale was reportedly arranged in 1868 through a catalogue of Cesnola’s small collection.
small collection of antiquitiesBeyrouth
- 1869 · p. 4
George BancroftHelpedLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Bancroft helped Cesnola obtain the Berlin museum’s dispatch of Friederichs to Cyprus.
Chypre
- 1869 · p. 4
Karl (Carl) FriederichsAcquired
Friederichs acquired a substantial series of Cypriot antiquities for Berlin.
With unknown sellers in Cyprusstone objects, bronzes, terracottas, engraved stones and glasswareCyprus
- p. 4
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toNew York Historical Society
possiblyCesnola considered trying to sell his “Phoenician Museum” to the New York Historical Society.
- p. 4
Luigi Palma di CesnolaPassed on
possiblyCesnola apparently sent a lot of antiquities to the Paris antiquaries Rollin and Feuardent.
With Rollin et Feuardent
- 1870 · p. 5
Luigi Palma di CesnolaAuctioned
Cesnola’s antiquities were sold at public auction in Paris.
With unnamed buyersCypriot antiquities from excavations made in 1868Hôtel Drouot, Paris
- p. 7
Alexandre BertrandBought fromLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Al(exandre) Bertrand bought objects at the Cesnola sale for the Musée des Antiquités nationales.
objects from Cesnola’s saleNo. 15132 à 15169
- 1883–1892 · p. 8
Augustus Henry Lane Fox Pitt RiversBought
Pitt Rivers made numerous purchases at the Lawrence-Cesnola sales.
With unnamed sellers at the Lawrence-Cesnola salesobjects from the Lawrence-Cesnola salesLondon
- 1871–1876 · p. 9
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toBritish Museum
Cesnola sold a substantial series of antiquities directly to the British Museum through Birch.
more than eighty vases, terracottas and other objectsNo. 1876.9-9, 1 à 127300 livresLondon
- p. 9
Samuel BirchAgent forBritish Museum
Birch acted as intermediary for the British Museum’s direct purchase from Cesnola.
a series of antiquitiesNo. 1876.9-9, 1 à 127300 livresLondon
- 1873–1876 · p. 10
Luigi Palma di CesnolaGave toImperial Ottoman Museum at Constantinople
Cesnola said that he voluntarily gave several thousand Cypriot antiquities to the Ottoman Imperial Museum.
Constantinople
- 1877 · p. 10
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaGave toSociété Piémontaise d'archéologie et Beaux-arts
Alessandro gave a small collection of antiquities to the Société Piémontaise d'archéologie et Beaux-arts.
a small collection of Cypriot antiquitiesTurin
- 1938 · p. 11
Robin George CollingwoodGave toAshmolean Museum
Collingwood gave objects from the Ruskin collection to the Ashmolean Museum.
sculptures and heads given to Ruskin by CesnolaNo. inv. 1938.347 and 348Oxford
Show 17 moreShow fewer
- p. 11
Luigi Palma di CesnolaGave toArchaeological Society at Athens
Cesnola presented antiquities to the Archaeological Society at Athens.
various specimens
- 1870–1876 · p. 13
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toMetropolitan Museum of Art
Cesnola agreed to sell his collection to the Metropolitan Museum for £1,200.
£1,200New York
- 1871–1872 · p. 13
Luigi Palma di CesnolaGave toHiram Hitchcock
Cesnola gave fifty-nine lamps to Hiram Hitchcock.
- p. 13
Emily Howe HitchcockBequeathed
Hitchcock’s widow bequeathed the antiquities to Dartmouth College.
With Dartmouth Collegethe antiquities kept at HanoverHanover
- p. 13
John Taylor JohnstonFinancedMetropolitan Museum of Art
John Taylor Johnston advanced the funds for the first collection’s purchase.
purchase of the first Cesnola collectionNew York
- p. 13
Luigi Palma di CesnolaGave toJohn Ruskin
Cesnola gave antiquities to Ruskin in thanks for Ruskin’s gift of 1000 livres.
- 1928 · p. 16
John RinglingBought
Ringling was the buyer whose name appeared most often in the annotated sale catalogue.
With unnamed sellers at the Anderson Galleries saleCypriot antiquities from the Cesnola CollectionNew York
- 1883–1892 · p. 18
Edwin Henry LawrenceDispersed a collection
The Lawrence-Cesnola collection was sold through four auctions.
With unnamed auction buyersLondon
- 1883–1892 · p. 18
Edwin Henry LawrenceDispersed a collection
The collection was dispersed through four auctions, the last after Lawrence's death.
With unnamed buyersLawrence-Cesnola collection
- p. 18
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaPassed on
Alessandro sent most of his collection to London before the British arrived in Cyprus.
- 1884 · p. 19
Edwin Henry LawrenceSold toBritish Museum
The British Museum acquired inscribed stones directly from Lawrence.
inscribed stones, mostly in Cypriot syllabaryNo. 1884.4 - 19, 1-10London
- p. 22, 26
Augustus Henry Lane Fox Pitt RiversBought
Pitt Rivers bought the tympanum for 31 livres; it later entered the Victoria and Albert Museum.
With unnamed seller at the salemedieval tympanum from a church in LarnacaNo. lot 625; V&A no. A-2-198231 livresLondon
- p. 23
C. RollinBought
Rollin bought the bronze patera for more than 13 livres; it later entered the British Museum.
With unnamed seller at the salebronze patera engraved with Phoenician and Egyptian mythological subjectsNo. lot 285; British Museum inv. 1892.5-19.1plus de 13 livresLondon
- p. 23
Palmer (buyer, 1892)Bought
Palmer bought the two amphorae.
With unnamed seller at the saletwo Phoenician amphoraeNo. lot 594London
- 1892 · p. 25
Dana EstesAcquired
Lots from the 1892 sale became part of Estes’s collection.
With unnamed sellers at the salelots from the Lawrence-Cesnola collectionLondon
- 1902 · p. 25
Dana EstesBequeathed toBowdoin College
Estes bequeathed his collection objects to Bowdoin College.
objects from the Lawrence-Cesnola saleBrunswick, Maine
- p. 26
Luigi Palma di CesnolaGave toWilliam Ewart Gladstone
Cesnola gave Gladstone the funerary inscription, which remained at Hawarden Castle.
funerary epigram for PhileasNo. Salamina, p. 104; Corpus no. 192
Excavation 3
- 1870–1879 · p. 18
Edwin Henry LawrenceFinancedAlessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola
Lawrence supplied Cesnola with money to begin excavating on his own account.
a sum of moneyCyprus
- 1873 · p. 18
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaDug forLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Alessandro assisted his brother as chief digger and partner.
Cypriot antiquitiesCyprus
- 1876–1879 · p. 18
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaExcavated
Alessandro carried out archaeological research and collecting between 1876 and 1879.
Cypriot antiquitiesCyprus
Recording and study 9
- 1885 · p. 4
Adolf FurtwänglerCatalogued the collection ofKönigl. Museen zu Berlin
Furtwängler catalogued vases in the Berlin museum’s collection.
No. vases 71 and 72
- p. 5
Wilhelm FroehnerPublished material ofLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Froehner wrote the catalogue for the Paris public sale of Cesnola’s antiquities.
Catalogue of antiquities from Cesnola’s 1868 excavationsHôtel Drouot, Paris
- 1870 · p. 10
Johannes DoellCatalogued the collection ofLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Doell catalogued Cesnola’s collection in Larnaca.
Cesnola collection
- 1914 · p. 14
John Linton MyresCatalogued the collection ofLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Myres catalogued and described objects from the Cesnola collection in his Handbook.
No. Handbook, nos. 1 à 5985New York
- p. 15
Ernst CurtiusPublished material ofLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Curtius wrote the introduction to the Atlas of Cesnola’s collection.
Cesnola collection Atlas
- p. 15
Isaac Holister HallWorked withLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Hall collaborated on the Atlas, with his contribution acknowledged for its inscriptions volume.
inscriptions in volume III of the AtlasNew York
- 1882–1884 · p. 18
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaPublished
Alexander Palma di Cesnola published the inscription on the funerary stele in Salaminia.
Inscription on small funerary stele (No. 7)No. Estes Coll. Acc. no. 1902.22
- p. 18
Henri ClaudetPhotographed
Claudet photographed objects for the Cyprus Antiquities album commissioned by Cesnola.
objects reproduced in the Cyprus Antiquities albumLondon
- p. 26
Denis FeisselStudied
Feissel noticed the inscription’s location in Gladstone’s former collection.
funerary epigram for PhileasNo. Corpus no. 192Hawarden Castle
Posts and family 3
- p. 3
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaSibling ofLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Scott-Stevenson identified Major Cesnola as the Consul's brother.
Larnaca
- 1877–1879 · p. 13
Luigi Palma di CesnolaEmployedMetropolitan Museum of Art
Cesnola became secretary of the Metropolitan Museum in 1877 and its director in 1879.
New York
- 1874 · p. 18
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaHeld a post
Alessandro was appointed honorary United States vice-consul at Paphos.
People it is cited for
71 people- Luigi Palma di Cesnola63 citations
- Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola22 citations
- Edwin Henry Lawrence22 citations
- Augustus Henry Lane Fox Pitt Rivers17 citations
- C. Rollin13 citations
- John Ruskin10 citations
- Dana Estes8 citations
- Gaston Louis Feuardent7 citations
- John Taylor Johnston7 citations
- Karl (Carl) Friederichs7 citations
- Georges Nicole6 citations
- Leland Stanford6 citations
- Louis Castan6 citations
- Alexandre Bertrand5 citations
- F. W. Collins5 citations
- John Ringling5 citations
- Mrs W. E. Hall5 citations
- Robin George Collingwood5 citations
- Charles Newton4 citations
- George Bancroft4 citations
- Henri Claudet4 citations
- Henri Hoffmann4 citations
- Hiram Hitchcock4 citations
- Joseph Owens4 citations
- K. Digby-Jones4 citations
- Kevin Herbert4 citations
- Louis Constantin Henri François-Xavier de Clercq4 citations
- Mason4 citations
- Richard Meister4 citations
- Samuel Birch4 citations
41 more
- William Ewart Gladstone4 citations
- William Talbot Ready4 citations
- Denis Feissel3 citations
- F. G. Lo Porto3 citations
- Gunn3 citations
- Hall Esq. (forename unknown)3 citations
- Heinrich Brunn3 citations
- Jackson (buyer, 1892)3 citations
- L. Badre3 citations
- Ludwig Meister3 citations
- W. Peek3 citations
- Adolf Furtwängler2 citations
- Cecilia Beer2 citations
- Demetrios Pierides2 citations
- Eugène Piot2 citations
- General Fox (numismatist)2 citations
- Haluk Ergüleç2 citations
- Isaac Holister Hall2 citations
- J. M. Albert Barre2 citations
- King (forename unknown)2 citations
- Lord Ranelagh2 citations
- Palmer (buyer, 1892)2 citations
- Reginald Stuart Poole2 citations
- Sidney Colvin2 citations
- Takor (?)2 citations
- Veronica Tatton-Brown2 citations
- W. Loftie2 citations
- Bostantus Beshes
- Ernst Curtius
- Felix-Bienaime Feuardent
- G. Neumann
- Georges Colonna Ceccaldi
- Gisela Marie Augusta Richter
- Robert Weeks de Forest
- Thomas Backhouse Sandwith
- Arturo Palma di Cesnola
- Auguste-Emile Boysset
- J. S. Morgan
- Wilhelm Froehner
- William Ransom
- William Tilden Blodgett
Institutions it is cited for
37 institutions- Metropolitan Museum of Art26 citations
- Rollin et Feuardent15 citations
- Sotheby's12 citations
- Istanbul Archaeology Museums9 citations
- Pitt Rivers Museum9 citations
- Museo di Antichità di Torino8 citations
- Antikensammlung, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin7 citations
- Bowdoin College7 citations
- Hôtel Drouot7 citations
- Ashmolean Museum of Art and Archaeology6 citations
- Bowdoin College Museum of Art6 citations
- Musée d'Archéologie méditerranéenne6 citations
- Staatliche Museen zu Berlin6 citations
- British Museum5 citations
- Cantor Arts Center5 citations
- Museum of Fine Arts, Boston5 citations
- Museum of Fine Arts, Roanoke5 citations
- Accademia delle Scienze di Torino4 citations
- John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art4 citations
- American University of Beirut3 citations
- Anderson Galleries3 citations
- Musée d'Archéologie nationale3 citations
- Musée d'art et d'histoire de Genève3 citations
- Società Piemontese di Archeologia e Belle Arti3 citations
- United States Legation, Prussia3 citations
- Victoria and Albert Museum3 citations
- Archaeological Society of Athens2 citations
- Fitzwilliam Museum2 citations
- Kunsthistorisches Museum Wien2 citations
- Musée du Louvre2 citations
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.