Curator

Heinrich Brunn

fl. 1868–1885

Munich professor of archaeology (1822-1894) who argued in 1868 that the silver vessels found at Caere were imports from Cyprus, and in 1876 inventoried Munich's Cesnola vases.

Biography

Heinrich Brunn was the Munich professor of archaeology who argued in 1868 that the silver vessels found at Caere were imports from Cyprus, where Asiatic, Egyptian and Hellenic influences crossed2,3.

Bonn, Rome and Munich

Brunn was born at Wörlitz near Dessau on 23 January 18223,4. His father Heinrich was provost at Wörlitz, and his mother was Albertine Lindstedt3. In autumn 1839 he entered the University of Bonn to study philology, and he studied there until 1843 under Friedrich Gottlieb Welcker and the man NDB prints as Friedrich Wilhelm Rietschel3,5. He took his doctorate on 20 March 1843, a day he recalled fifty years later when he dedicated his history of Greek art to Welcker and Ritschl6,7.

From 1843 to 1853 Brunn lived in Rome4. In 1854 he became Kustos at the Bonn university library and qualified as Privatdozent5. From 1856 to 1865 he was again in Rome, as secretary of the archaeological institute4. Amelung says that in the year he arrived back in Rome the pernicious fever seized him too, and that he recovered, though not without lasting weakness6.

Flasch says Munich drew him with its Glyptothek and its rich collection of Greek and Etruscan vases, and that he moved there at Easter 18655. He came as professor of archaeology and, at the same time, curator of the coin cabinet3,5. The sources disagree on when he took charge of the vase collection: NDB and Freund give 18653,4. Flasch gives 18675. Amelung, in ADB, gives 18686. In autumn 1882 he received the Bavarian Order of the Crown and with it personal nobility6. He was rector of the university in the winter of 1885-866. In 1888 he became director of the Glyptothek, "technical director" in Flasch's words4,5. He married Ida Bürkner of Oranienbaum and they had two sons, among them Hermann, and two daughters3.

The Kition bowl and the Caere vessels

In Die Kunst bei Homer, published by the Bavarian Academy in 1868, Brunn told how he found in the Louvre a perfect counterpart to the Caere silver vessels, a bowl "one might think from the same hand", and learned there that it came not from Etruria but from Kition on Cyprus2,5. "The riddle was now solved", he wrote: the Caere vessels were not native work but ware imported from Cyprus2. He called their style a product of that mixture, though he did not wish to push them back into the Homeric period2. Amelung calls it a prelude to Helbig's work on the Homeric epic, and Emerson a prelude to Schliemann's discoveries in the Troad and Argolis6,8.

In 1874 Heinrich Schliemann reported that Brunn had written to him that he had shown the Trojan inscriptions to Professor Haug9. Haug, by Brunn's account, pointed to kinship with the Phoenician script and to analogies with the bronze tablet found at Idalion on Cyprus, then in the Cabinet des médailles in Paris9. Brunn added that links between the Trojan finds and Cyprus were in no way surprising and would fit very well with Homer, since in his opinion Cyprus was "the cradle of Greek art", the cauldron in which Asiatic, Egyptian and Greek ingredients were brewed together9,10.

The Cesnola vases in Munich

In March 1876, Olivier Masson records, "the curator Heinrich Brunn" drew up an inventory of about 90 pieces, inventory numbers 2029 to 21201. These are a series of vases whose provenance Munich gives only as "Cypern, Sammlung Cesnola", from the collection of Luigi Palma di Cesnola1. Masson adds that purchases also took place: no. 2121 (also 8068) is expressly noted as bought in Paris in 18761. Masson names only the curator; that he was the professor is our reading, from the post Brunn held over the vase collection by 1876 in every account3,4,5,6.

Max Ohnefalsch-Richter later wrote that on a European journey in 1884 he showed Brunn in Munich the photographs and excavation reports of his Cypriot finds, and that Brunn strengthened him orally in the direction of his observations11. Ohnefalsch-Richter says that already at the beginning of the 1880s he had been, "guided by Brunn", convinced by his finds11.

The 1893 history of Greek art

The first book of Brunn's Griechische Kunstgeschichte (1893) has a section "Kypros und die Phönicier" from p. 98 and one on Cypriot ceramics from p. 1267. There he wrote that the significance of Cyprus in the traffic of the ancient world was only now coming to light through extensive discoveries, and that the Caere vessels came from Cyprus7. Cyprus, he held, must have been a main seat of that metalworking7. The Phoenicians there did not rule alone but lived in close contact with Greeks of advanced intellectual development, and as evidence he cited the Greek writing system of Cyprus and the Kypria, the epic of a Cypriot poet7. He concluded that in the other fields of Cypriot art too it was Hellenes, not Phoenicians, behind the phase of development he had traced7. With Friedrich Bruckmann he also issued the Denkmäler griechischer und römischer Skulptur (Munich, 1888-1900), whose plates 201 and 206 reproduce sculptures from the Cesnola Collection12.

Critics and a supporter

In 1884 Wolfgang Helbig summarised Brunn's view that the silver vessels were made not by Phoenician metalworkers but by Cypriot Greeks, perhaps under Phoenician direction13. Helbig held that Brunn "decidedly underrated" the Phoenicians' own industry, that his ground was the free movement of the figures, which Brunn thought foreign to oriental art, and that he would logically have to extend his thesis to the related contents of the Sardinian necropoleis13. Frederik Poulsen in 1912 called Brunn's view "strangely wrong": instead of explaining the bowls' agreement with Cypriot monuments by the occupation of Cyprus, Brunn made the Cypriot Greeks the bearers of the mixed style14. Poulsen says Brunn pictured the Cypriot Greeks copying Egyptian and Assyrian models through a long apprenticeship until they made their own style in the sixth century, and that he made "the great mistake" of setting the Greeks on Cyprus level with the other Greeks14. Friedrich Wilhelm von Bissing thought that the Golgoi relief, which Brunn admitted stood on an Assyrian basis, proved nothing for his thesis of Greek influence on the Assurbanipal reliefs15. Ohnefalsch-Richter took the other side in 1909, calling Brunn's view of 1868 "the only correct one", held "with prophetic spirit", and saying that the photographs and descriptions of Cypriot finds he had supplied to Helbig spoke for Brunn11.

Emerson judged in 1894 that the visible fruit of Brunn's twenty-nine years in Munich had not met the high expectations of 18658. Amelung writes that in the summer of 1894 nephritis was added to his old ailment and his strength was broken; Flasch agrees5,6. Brunn died on 23 July 1894, aged 72 and a half, at Josephsthal near Schliersee, and was buried in the Northern Cemetery in Munich3,5,6. Adolf Furtwängler succeeded him in Munich11.

Life and work

  1. 1876

    1. March

      Drew up an inventory of the Munich vases labelled 'Cypern, Sammlung Cesnola', about 90 pieces, inv. 2029 to 2120; no. 2121 (also 8068) was noted as bought in Paris in 1876.

      MunichOlivier Masson (1996). La dispersion des antiquités chypriotes: les deux collections Cesnola. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 25, 3-32, p. 10

Connections

4 people
W. HelbigLuigi Palma di CesnolaMax Ohnefalsch-RichterDr. M. HaugHeinrich Brunn
DisputesScholarshipColleagues

Mentioned in

6 mentions

Institutions · 1

  • Staatliche Antikensammlungen und Glyptothek München

    Curator (1876) · 1876

    Curator Heinrich Brunn draws up an inventory of about 90 vases labelled 'Cypern, Sammlung Cesnola' (inv. 2029-2120); Masson notes that no. 2121 (also 8068) is…

    Masson 1996; Cesnola 1878, p. 548

Sources

  1. 1.Olivier Masson (1996). “La dispersion des antiquités chypriotes: les deux collections Cesnola”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 25, 3-32. Online
  2. 2.Heinrich Brunn (1868). “Die Kunst bei Homer und ihr Verhältniss zu den Anfängen der griechischen Kunstgeschichte”. Abhandlungen der k. bayer. Akademie der Wissenschaften, I. Cl., XI. Bd., III. Abth..
  3. 3.Gottfried von Lücken (1955). “Brunn, Heinrich von (seit 1882)”. Neue Deutsche Biographie 2, 679-680. Online
  4. 4.Wilhelm Freund. Triennium Philologicum; oder, Grundzüge der philologischen Wissenschaften.
  5. 5.Adam Flasch (1902). Heinrich von Brunn: Gedächtnissrede gehalten in der öffentlichen Sitzung der K. b. Akademie der Wissenschaften zu München.
  6. 6.Walther Amelung (1910). “Brunn, Heinrich”. Allgemeine Deutsche Biographie 55. Online
  7. 7.Heinrich Brunn (1893). Griechische Kunstgeschichte. Erstes Buch: Die Anfänge und die älteste decorative Kunst. Verlagsanstalt für Kunst und Wissenschaft vormals Friedrich Bruckmann.
  8. 8.Alfred Emerson (1894). “Heinrich von Brunn”. American Journal of Archaeology 9, 366-370.
  9. 9.Heinrich Schliemann (1874). Trojanische Alterthümer: Bericht über die Ausgrabungen in Troja.
  10. 10.Heinrich Schliemann; ed. Philip Smith (1875). Troy and its Remains. J. Murray.
  11. 11.Max Ohnefalsch-Richter (1909). “Das Homerische Epos aus den cyprischen Denkmälern erläutert”. Internationale Wochenschrift für Wissenschaft, Kunst und Technik 3.
  12. 12.A. Hermary, J. R. Mertens (2014). The Cesnola Collection of Cypriot Art: Stone Sculpture. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  13. 13.Wolfgang Helbig (1884). Das homerische Epos aus den Denkmälern erläutert: archäologische Untersuchungen.
  14. 14.Frederik Poulsen (1912). Der Orient und die frühgriechische Kunst.
  15. 15.Friedrich Wilhelm von Bissing (1912). “Beiträge zur Geschichte der assyrischen Skulptur”. Abhandlungen der Königlich Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Philosophisch-philologische und historische Klasse 26.
  16. 16.Masson 1996, "La dispersion des antiquités chypriotes: les deux collections Cesnola", CCEC 25.
  17. 17.O. Masson, 1996, La dispersion des antiquités chypriotes: les deux collections Cesnola.
  18. 18.Schliemann, Heinrich, 1822-1890, Troy and its remains : a narrative of researches and discoveries made on the site of Ilium, and in the Trojan Plain (1875).
  19. 19.Schliemann, Heinrich, 1822-1890, Troy and its remains; a narrative of researches and discoveries made on the site of Ilium, and in the Trojan Plain (1875).
  20. 20.Dr. Henry schliemann, Troy and its remains (1875).
  21. 21.Internationale Wochenschrift für Wissenschaft Kunst und Technik 3.1909.

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Date of birth unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.