Scholar · Cataloguer
Cecilia Beer
fl. 1978–2002
Swedish classical archaeologist who catalogued the Cypriot temple-boy statuettes (1994) and wrote on votive sculpture from Idalion, Ayia Irini and Graz.
Biography
Cecilia Beer is a scholar of Cypriot votive sculpture whose catalogue of the statuettes known as temple-boys appeared in 19942.
Early papers
In 1978 Beer published a paper on two sculptures in the Medelhavsmuseet in Stockholm, a limestone temple boy from Oura (MM Acc. 631) and a head with a cap, which the museum inventory said came from the Swedish Cyprus Expedition of 19288. In 1984 she published "Quelques aspects des contacts de Chypre aux VIIIe et VIIe siècles avant notre ère" in Opus 39. Her paper "Cypriot Temple-Boys: Some Problems" was printed in the proceedings of the Second International Cyprological Congress, held at Nicosia in April 1982 and published in 198510.
Two papers followed in the Uppsala series Boreas: "Comparative votive religion: the evidence of children in Cyprus, Greece and Etruria" (1987) and "Ethnic diversity and financial differentiation in Cypriote sanctuaries" (1992)2. The Chronique of excavations in Cyprus for 1987 sent readers to the first of these for the recent discussion and earlier literature11. A reviewer in the Journal of Near Eastern Studies described the second as a study of inscriptions and votive offerings, especially sculptures, as a measure of the wealth of individuals, groups and ethnic communities at the sanctuaries of Idalion, Golgoi and Kition12. Between them came "Cultes chypriotes et éléments phéniciens?", given to the Phoenician and Punic congress at Rome in 1987 and printed in 19912.
The temple-boy corpus
Beer writes that the temple-boy work began at the Department of Oriental Antiquities of the Louvre, and she thanks Annie Caubet there2. Vassos Karageorghis gave her leave to publish the bulk of the temple-boys in the Cyprus Museum, and Stuart Swiny, Director of CAARI, lent her the institute's newly bought camera for much of the photography2.
Stockholm University lists Temple-boys: a study of Cypriote votive sculpture. P. 2, Functional analysis (1993) as her doctoral thesis in the Department of Classical Archaeology and Ancient History13. Part 1, the Catalogue, came out in 1994 as Studies in Mediterranean Archaeology 113, with 100 pages and 203 plates2. Accounts of Part 2 differ: the 1994 volume called it forthcoming, and in 1997 Beer still announced it as a forthcoming Jonsered volume under the title Contextual and Functional Analysis2,3. Caneva and Delli Pizzi cite Part 2 as published at Jonsered in 1993, while Hermary and Mertens say that only the first part was published10,14.
The counts of the catalogue differ: Beer describes 264 extant temple-boys in limestone and terracotta from museums in Europe, Asia and the United States2. Gilby speaks of 294 examples, and Wacławik of 301 figurines and 13 similar objects15,16. The Istanbul collection held at least 23, mostly unpublished, which she says she could study only superficially2. Olivier Masson noted that these, nos 141 to 163, appeared without illustrations, and he found four temple-boy statuettes on a Cesnola sale plate that her corpus lacks17. She entered a piece in Perugia as a gift of Luigi Palma di Cesnola, and wrote that some of the poorly documented ex-Wellcome pieces may have been brought to England by him2.
Idalion, Graz, Ayia Irini and Baubo
While preparing the terracottas from the Harvard excavations at Idalion of 1971-1980 for publication, Beer came across limestone fragments of seated kourotrophoi and temple-boys3. Her 1997 article catalogued thirty-two of the temple-boys, and she judged that they confirm Max Ohnefalsch-Richter's claim that his Kourotrophos sanctuary had yielded many "Tammuz-Adonis" figures3. There she read the temple-boy as an ordinary child at a point of transition, "possibly the moment of the circumcision", when extra divine care was sought3.
In 2002 Beer published a colossal female head said to have been acquired in Cyprus by Franz Unger, who toured the island with Theodor Kotschy in 1862; the head is in Schloss Eggenberg, Graz, and was allegedly found at Idalion18. She dated it to 370-325 BC and read its turreted crown as recalling the crown of Tyche18. The sources disagree on its stone: Beer calls it marble, while Hermary and Mertens say it is limestone14,18.
Writing from Stockholm University in 2009, Beer asked whether the cult at Ayia Irini, known for its masses of votive statuary, mainly terracottas, must have been run solely by a male deity, and pointed to Astarte's sanctuary at Lapethos, the city-state closest to Ayia Irini4. In 2015 she returned to a small collection of amulets given in 1936 by the Swedish consul Lukas Z. Pierides to the Crown Prince Gustav Adolf; the paper's summary dates the moulded-glass Baubo amulets from the 4th to the 1st century BC19.
Reception
Gilby calls the catalogue "definitive", and Caneva and Delli Pizzi call the two parts "the fundamental study"10,15. Gilby found Beer's 1985 reading of the exposed genitals "much less value-laden" and called her idea compelling15. Caneva and Delli Pizzi credit her pendant study with showing an Eastern Mediterranean koine, and rate her idea that the statues were made at the children's weaning as her most relevant interpretation10. They also criticise the attention paid to the genitals, noting that Beer herself admits only 30% of temple boys show them10. Hermary and Mertens record her question whether the offerings came mainly from the Phoenician population at circumcision rites, and judge that the rarity of temple boys in the sanctuaries of Kition does not support it14. Wacławik also says the circumcision theory should be revised: it assumes, without evidence in the material, that the boys are Phoenician, and the photographs Beer published show no sign of the practice16.
Life and work
1993
- Dissertation 'Temple-Boys. A Study of Cypriote Votive Sculpture, Part 2, Functional Analysis', Stockholm University.
1994
- Published Part 1 Catalogue of Cypriot temple-boy statuettes (SIMA 113); Masson notes it includes an ex-Cesnola temple boy in Perugia ('gift of L. P. di Cesnola') and that four terracotta temple boys on a Lawrence sale-catalogue plate are missing from it.
Olivier Masson (1996). La dispersion des antiquités chypriotes: les deux collections Cesnola. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 25, 3-32, pp. 11; Alicia Marie Dissinger (2017). Cypro-Archaic Bird Iconography: Types, Uses, and Meanings. University of Virginia
1997
- Published, while working towards publication of the Harvard Expedition's Idalion terracottas, two series of limestone fragments (seated kourotrophoi and temple-boys) from the Kourotrophos temenos at Idalion, American Expedition 1971-1980.
Undated
n.d.
- Wrote the article 'A Temple Boy and a Head with Cap from Cyprus' in this bulletin.
- named in Apsida: «The three limestone statuettes» (assembled about three hundred temple-boy statuettes)
Connections
1 personScholarship
- Published material of Luigi Palma di Cesnolatemple-boy catalogue incl. Perugia piece credited as his gift O. Masson, 1996, Les deux collections Cesnola: quelques compléments, p. 111994
Recording and study
2 records- Catalogued1
Cecilia Beer catalogued thirty-two fragmentary temple-boys from the American Expedition to Idalion.
32 fragmentary temple-boysNo. B 196/2/S 46; B 212/18/S 66; B 225/31/S 80; B 323/129/S 173; B 328/134/S 177; B 363/169/S 197; B 375/181/S 216; B 427/233/S 260Beer 1997, p. 49
- Published1
1994Beer republished five temple boys that formed part of the Liverpool series.
cinq temple boysNo. nos. 166-170Masson 1996, p. 25
Mentioned in
15 mentionsDocuments · 10
- Les deux collections Cesnola : quelques compléments
1994 · p. 25
Beer republished five temple boys that formed part of the Liverpool series.
Masson 1996
- The Kourotrophos temenos at Idalion (Cyprus). New evidence from the American Expedition 1971-1980
p. 49
Cecilia Beer catalogued thirty-two fragmentary temple-boys from the American Expedition to Idalion.
Beer 1997
- A head of a marble Tyche from Idalion
Beer 2002
- Ancient Cypriote Art in the National Archaeological Museum, Athens
Karageorghis 2003
- Cypriote Stone Sculpture: Proceedings of the Second International Conference of Cypriote Studies, Brussels-Liège, 17-19 May 1993
Vandenabeele & Laffineur 1996
- Cypro-Archaic Bird Iconography: Types, Uses, and Meanings
Dissinger 2017
On Ancient Cyprus · 1
Institutions · 3
- Stockholm University
Student (1993) · 1993
Cecilia Beer's dissertation on Cypriot temple-boys, recorded as a Stockholm University dissertation.
Karageorghis 2003
- Istanbul Archaeology Museums
1994
Cecilia Beer publishes (without illustrations) a series of Temple Boy statuettes in the museum, nos. 141-163 of her corpus, and announces a publication of the…
Masson 1996, pp. 9-10
- American Expedition to Idalion
1997
Cecilia Beer published new evidence from the expedition's 1971-1980 excavations on the Kourotrophos temenos at Idalion (limestone sculpture).
Beer 1997
- People · 1listed under Connections
Sources
- 1.C. Beer (1993). “Temple-Boys. A Study of Cypriote Votive Sculpture, Part 2, Functional Analysis”. Dissertation, Stockholm University.
- 2.C. Beer (1994). Temple-boys: A Study of Cypriote Votive Sculpture, Part 1. Catalogue. Jonsered, Paul Åströms Förlag.
- 3.Cecilia Beer (1997). “The Kourotrophos temenos at Idalion (Cyprus). New evidence from the American Expedition 1971-1980”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 27, 47-58. Online
- 4.C. Beer (2009). “Ayia Irini in the Iron Age: realm of Baal and/or Astarte?”. Finds and Results from the Swedish Cyprus Expedition 1927-1931: A Gender Perspective, 36-49.
- 5.Olivier Masson (1996). “La dispersion des antiquités chypriotes: les deux collections Cesnola”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 25, 3-32. Online
- 6.Alicia Marie Dissinger (2017). “Cypro-Archaic Bird Iconography: Types, Uses, and Meanings”. University of Virginia.
- 7.V. Karageorghis (2003). Ancient Cypriote Art in the National Archaeological Museum, Athens. Athens, Kapon Editions, for the A. G. Leventis Foundation.
- 8.Cecilia Beer (1978). “A "Temple Boy" and a Head with Cap from Cyprus”. Medelhavsmuseet Bulletin 13, 41-44.
- 9.Andrés T. Reyes (1994). Archaic Cyprus: A Study of the Textual and Archaeological Evidence. Oxford, Clarendon Press.
- 10.Stefano G. Caneva and Aurian Delli Pizzi (2014). “Classical and Hellenistic statuettes of the so-called 'Temple Boys': a religious and social reappraisal”. C. Terranova (ed.), La presenza dei bambini nelle religioni del Mediterraneo antico, Roma, 495-521.
- 11.V. Karageorghis (1988). “Chronique des fouilles et découvertes archéologiques à Chypre en 1987”. Bulletin de Correspondance Hellénique 112.
- 12.[Reviewer in JNES] (1997). “[Review of Linders and Alroth (eds), Economics of Cult in the Ancient Greek World]”. Journal of Near Eastern Studies 56.
- 13.Stockholm University (DiVA) (2026). “[DiVA search result for Cecilia Beer]”. DiVA, Stockholm University.
- 14.A. Hermary, J. R. Mertens (2014). The Cesnola Collection of Cypriot Art: Stone Sculpture. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art.
- 15.Dena Gilby (2009). “Head trip: 'Head of a Young Child' (Me. 676), childhood, and gender on Cyprus”. Medelhavsmuseet: Focus on the Mediterranean 5.
- 16.Maciej Wacławik (2017). “A few preliminary remarks on the Cypriot sculptures known as temple-boys”. Studies in Ancient Art and Civilization 21, 67-75.
- 17.Olivier Masson (1996). “La dispersion des antiquités chypriotes: les deux collections Cesnola”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 25, 3-32. Online
- 18.Cecilia Beer (2002). “A head of a marble Tyche from Idalion”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 32, 369-385.
- 19.Cecilia Beer (2015). “Baubo amulets around the Mediterranean. Some remarks”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 45, 339-349.
- 20.Olivier Masson (1996). “Les deux collections Cesnola : quelques compléments”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 26.
- 21.Medelhavsmuseet, Medelhavsmuseet Bulletin 13 (1978).
- 22.UNESCO and ERA Chairs on Digital Cultural Heritage - Digital Heritage Research Lab Cyprus University of Technology, Apsida (Cyprus University of Technology), creator Bank of Cyprus Cultural Foundation: «The three limestone statuettes», via Europeana. Online
- 23.O. Masson, 1996, Les deux collections Cesnola: quelques compléments.
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- Date of birth unknown
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.