Patron

Robert Weeks de Forest

1848–1931 · United States

New York lawyer and President of the Metropolitan Museum from 1913 to 1931, in whose name the Museum's Cesnola duplicates were auctioned at the Anderson Galleries in 1928.

Biography

Robert Weeks de Forest was a New York lawyer and President of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and the Cesnola duplicates the Museum auctioned in 1928 were "sold by order of the Trustees of the Metropolitan Museum of Art New York City Robert W. de Forest, President"1.

The 1928 auction

The New York Times reported that this first auction in the Museum's history was announced on 24 February 1928 by the Director, Edward Robinson5. The circumstances were set out in a letter from de Forest to Mitchell Kennerley of the Anderson Galleries, which the Museum's Bulletin reprinted6. Winifred E. Howe, the Museum's historian, calls it "Mr. de Forest's letter" and notes that it was printed both in the Bulletin and in the Galleries' catalogue7. Dated 14 February 1928, the letter recalled that the Museum had bought the Cesnola Collection "in 1874 and 1876", and that many similar objects were still held but not on exhibition1. Rather than keep them in storage "where they perform no useful service", it said, the Trustees had decided to sell them at auction in March and April "so that other museums and private collectors can obtain them"1. The Trustees had considered sharing them among American museums, but the letter says this would have raised "questions of discrimination" and delayed freeing space the Museum urgently needed1. Olivier Masson says the two sale catalogues, with 965 lots in all, carried a preface by the Museum's president2.

Part One, 654 lots, was sold on 30 and 31 March 19281,8. The sources disagree on the dates of Part Two. The Museum's Bulletin and Howe give 19-20 April, the New York Times of 21 April reports the first session as held the day before, and Antoine Hermary and Joan R. Mertens give 21-22 April6,7,9,10. The Art News reported that Part One brought prices "far in excess of even optimistic hopes", and that about three-quarters of it went to John Ringling for his museum at Sarasota11. The New York Times put the total for both parts at $121,71212. Howe names among the museum buyers Lucy M. Taggart for the John Herron Art Institute, Russell A. Plimpton for Minneapolis and Blake-More Godwin for Toledo, and says press comment "appears to have been uniformly favorable"7.

Before and after

The auction followed earlier sales. In 1916 the Museum sold eighty-two Cesnola pieces to the Toledo Museum of Art, and Hermary and Mertens date the sale of the duplicates from 1916 to 192610,13. In October 1925, the Trustees released a further supply that now included limestone sculptures and terracottas14. The Trustees' report for 1928 says they had "never before acted upon their right to dispose of property of this character", and did so to make the objects useful to others and save storage space15. Howe quotes de Forest on why museums hold more gifts than they can show: "In the beginning they could not wisely refuse anything", and having now to dispose of some gifts "is no necessary criticism of an original acceptance"7.

Masson judges that some of the pieces that went to John Ringling were not true duplicates, such as statuettes from Pyla that came from R. H. Lang through Cesnola, and that the sale greatly widened the dispersal of Cypriot antiquities, though the most important pieces stayed in New York2. Frieda Vandenabeele followed four jugs with a figure holding an oinochoe, lots 506-509: one reached the Walters Art Gallery in Baltimore, one the Ringling Museum, and Mertens saw no way to follow the two bought by J. A. Plimpton and Arnold Genthe16. Hermary and Mertens say some sold objects came back to the Met as gifts in 194110.

Life

De Forest was born in New York City on 25 April 1848 and graduated from Yale with honours in 187017. The sources disagree on his mother's name: Julia Brasher Weeks in an encyclopaedia of 1900, Julia Mary Weeks on Wikipedia3,17. He took a law degree at Columbia in 1872, was general counsel for the Central Railroad of New Jersey, and was president of the Hackensack Water Company from 1885 and first president of the Provident Loan Society17. On 12 November 1872 he married Emily Johnston, eldest daughter of John Taylor Johnston, the Museum's first President17,18. Elected a trustee in 1889, he became Secretary in 1904 and President on 20 October 1913, after the death of J. Pierpont Morgan7,18,19. The couple gave the Museum its American Wing; Howe dates the gift to 1920, H. W. Kent to 19227,18. He died on 6 May 1931, "in the eighty-fourth year of his life"18. Emily de Forest gave the Museum a Cypro-Geometric III flask in 191820.

Life and work

  1. 1928

    1. 14 February

      Wrote to Mitchell Kennerley, President of the Anderson Galleries, announcing that the Trustees had decided to sell by auction in March and April the Met's duplicate classical antiquities, including Cesnola-collection material, rather than keep them in storage. The letter is printed in the sale catalogue. The Trustees had considered distributing them to other American museums but rejected this because of questions of discrimination and delay in vacating needed space.

      New YorkAnderson Galleries (1928). Cypriote & Classical Antiquities: Duplicates of the Cesnola & Other Collections, Part One (sale number 2253, New York, 30-31 March 1928). New York, Anderson Galleries

    2. 30 March 1928 – 31 March 1928

      Anderson Galleries sale 2253, Part One, 'Cypriote & Classical Antiquities: Duplicates of the Cesnola & Other Collections', 'sold by order of the Trustees of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, Robert W. de Forest, President'; public exhibition from 24 March. Masson counts two catalogues with 965 lots in all for the March-April 1928 sales.

      New YorkAnderson Galleries (1928). Cypriote & Classical Antiquities: Duplicates of the Cesnola & Other Collections, Part One (sale number 2253, New York, 30-31 March 1928). New York, Anderson Galleries; Olivier Masson (1996). La dispersion des antiquités chypriotes: les deux collections Cesnola. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 25, 3-32

Through their hands

1 record
  1. 1928

    OfferAs president of the Trustees, Robert W. De Forest put four jugs from the Cesnola collection up for public sale as duplicates.

    With acheteurs non nommésquatre cruches avec une figurine tenant une oinochoéNo. 506, 507, 508 et 509New York CityVandenabeele 1994, p. 29

Connections

1 person

Mentioned in

8 mentions

Institutions · 2

  • Metropolitan Museum of Art

    President (1928) · 1889

    Deaccession and auction of Cesnola duplicates at the Anderson Galleries, New York (March-April 1928; 965 lots in two catalogues; preface by Museum president…

    Masson 1996; Karageorghis 2001; Galleries 1928

  • Anderson Galleries

    Consignor (1928) · 1928

    The Metropolitan Museum's president wrote to Mitchell Kennerley, president of the Anderson Galleries, that the Trustees had decided to dispose of Cesnola…

    Galleries 1928

Sources

  1. 1.Anderson Galleries (1928). Cypriote & Classical Antiquities: Duplicates of the Cesnola & Other Collections, Part One (sale number 2253, New York, 30-31 March 1928). New York, Anderson Galleries.
  2. 2.Olivier Masson (1996). “La dispersion des antiquités chypriotes: les deux collections Cesnola”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 25, 3-32. Online
  3. 3.“Robert W. DeForest”. Wikipedia (English). Online
  4. 4.“Robert W. DeForest (1848-1931), American lawyer, financier, and philanthropist”. Wikidata Q56440239. Online
  5. 5. (1928). “Museum Plans Auction: Metropolitan to Sell Part of Cesnola Collection of Cyprian Antiquities”. The New York Times, 25 February 1928.
  6. 6.Metropolitan Museum of Art (1928). “Auction Sales of Classical Antiquities”. Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 23, no. 3 (March 1928), 70.
  7. 7.Winifred E. Howe (1946). A History of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, vol. II: 1905-1941. Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  8. 8. (1928). “Museum's Auction Today: Metropolitan Offers 654 Lots of Duplicated Antiquities”. The New York Times, 30 March 1928.
  9. 9. (1928). “[Report of the first session of Part II of the sale of Metropolitan Museum duplicates]”. The New York Times, 21 April 1928.
  10. 10.A. Hermary, J. R. Mertens (2014). The Cesnola Collection of Cypriot Art: Stone Sculpture. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  11. 11. (1928). “Cypriote Sculpture Brings High Prices”. The Art News, vol. 26, no. 27 (7 April 1928).
  12. 12. (1928). “$121,712 for Cypriote Art: Final Session in Sale of Museum Duplicates”. The New York Times, 22 April 1928.
  13. 13.Metropolitan Museum of Art. The Cesnola Collection of Cypriot Art: Terracotta Oil Lamps. Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  14. 14.Metropolitan Museum of Art (1925). “Duplicates from the Cesnola Collection on Sale”. Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 20, no. 10 (October 1925).
  15. 15.Metropolitan Museum of Art (1929). “Report of the Trustees for the Year 1928 [extracts]”. Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 24, no. 2 (February 1929).
  16. 16.Frieda Vandenabeele (1994). “Ohnefalsch-Richter - Cesnola: ou la recherche des cruches à terres cuites tenant une oinochoe”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 22, 19-31.
  17. 17.Mitchell C. Harrison (comp.) (1900). New York State's Prominent and Progressive Men: An Encyclopaedia of Contemporaneous Biography.
  18. 18.Metropolitan Museum of Art (1931). “In Memoriam: Robert W. de Forest; Robert W. de Forest (by H. W. Kent)”. Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 26, no. 6 (June 1931), 138-139.
  19. 19. (1922). “The Encyclopedia Americana”. article Art Museums / Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  20. 20.Metropolitan Museum of Art. “Terracotta flask, Cypro-Geometric III, 18.82.2”. The Met Collection online. Online
  21. 21.Anderson Galleries, 1928, Cypriote & Classical Antiquities: Duplicates of the Cesnola & Other Collections [Part One].
  22. 22.Howe, Winifred E. (Winifred Eva), 1876-; Kent, Henry Watson, 1866-1948, A history of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, (1913).
  23. 23.Winifred E. Howe, A History Of The Metropolitan Museum Of Art Vol-iii 1905-1941 (1946).
  24. 24.Anderson Galleries, 1928, Cypriote & Classical Antiquities: Duplicates of the Cesnola & Other Collections [Part One], sale 2253, New York, 30-31 March 1928.

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.