Article · 2016

Studies on the provenances of the stele of Sargon II from Larnaca (Kition) and the two so-called Dhali (Idalion) silver bowls in the Louvre

Robert Stuart Merrillees

Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 46 349-386

An article on where the Sargon II stele from Larnaca and two Phoenician silver bowls in the Louvre were found, how they were acquired and where they may have come from.

Merrillees reassesses the findspot and modern history of the stele of Sargon II found at Larnaca, then turns to two Phoenician silver bowls in the Louvre, the so-called Dhali (Idalion) bowls AO 20135 and AO 20134. The evidence is nineteenth-century accounts and correspondence, museum records, maps and later studies. The sections follow the discovery of the stele, Niven Kerr's correspondence, a list of the people involved, the silver bowls in the Louvre, and the origin of the stele.

The argument

Merrillees argues that the stele was found in the southern part of ancient Kition, in Scala near Phaneromeni, and not at Bamboula. He weighs Sakellarios's accounts, Lang's descriptions, early topographical observations and the Berlin accession entry, noting discrepancies in the reported directions. A mound near the south-western section of the ancient city wall is a possible findspot, though he says the precise location cannot be proved (pp. 352–359).

The stele passed from the Mattei family to the Berlin museums, set against efforts by British and French officials to acquire it. It was found in or shortly before October 1845 and reached Berlin in 1846, while the bowls entered the Louvre in 1851 and 1853 (pp. 359–377).

For the bowls, Merrillees argues that AO 20135 is more plausibly from Kition than from Idalion, though its precise provenance remains unproven, and that AO 20134 has no established provenance. The two objects had separate acquisition histories, and he finds no connection between the stele and AO 20135 (pp. 371–377).

On the stele's origin, Merrillees considers it unlikely that the monument was erected on Stavrovouni and proposes that it may have been brought to Cyprus as a finished monument from the western Asiatic mainland. He treats this as a hypothesis awaiting scientific examination of the stone (pp. 377–379).

The evidence

For the findspot, Merrillees compares accounts by Sakellarios and Lang with descriptions by Mas Latrie, Pease and Cesnola, and uses nineteenth-century maps to interpret references to the garden of Minas, windmills, Phaneromeni and Scala. The Vorderasiatisches Museum accession entry and correspondence involving Niven Kerr, the British Museum, Jacob Mattei and Marcello Cerruti document the competing purchase efforts and the transfer to Berlin (pp. 352–371).

The bowls are followed through descriptions by Longpérier, Perrot and others, museum records and reports of metal vessels found at Idalion. Merrillees compares the accounts of AO 20135's acquisition by Félix de Saulcy with the separate reports on AO 20134 and on a cache at Idalion. For the stone of the stele, he reviews published geological analyses of basalt artefacts and what they can and cannot establish about its source (pp. 371–378).

What it records

  • The stele of Sargon II from Larnaca is dated to the third year of the king's reign, 707 BCE.p. 349
  • The Berlin accession entry records that the stele was found in late autumn 1845, in a heap of rubble being searched for old building material for a new church.p. 357
  • Merrillees argues from Sakellarios's accounts that the stele was found at the southern end of Kition, on the west side of Scala, near Phaneromeni.p. 359
  • Niven Kerr reported in November 1846 that the stele's proprietor had already sold it to the Prussian Consular Agent for 7,000 francs, for a museum in Berlin.p. 362
  • The stele was bought for 3,000 florins, equivalent to 2,042 thalers, and cost 2,844 thalers in total with transport, according to Berlin records.p. 371
  • Agents buying the stele for the Königliche Museen had a slab about 13 cm thick sliced off its back to ease shipment to Berlin.p. 371
  • Félix de Saulcy presented the incomplete silver bowl AO 20135 to the Louvre in 1851.p. 372
  • Merrillees argues that the silver bowl AO 20135 is more plausibly from Kition than from Idalion, though its provenance remains unproven.p. 376
  • The Louvre acquired the silver bowl AO 20134, dated to the 8th–7th centuries BCE, in 1853.p. 376
  • Merrillees considers the attribution of the silver bowl AO 20134 to Idalion unconfirmed, and that the bowl has no established provenance.p. 377
  • The stele measures 211 cm high, 71 cm wide and 33 cm deep.p. 379

Where to read

  • The competing accounts of the stele's findspot around Scala and Phaneromenipp. 352–359
  • Niven Kerr's correspondence about the stele and the British Museum's purchase effortspp. 359–363
  • The stele's sale, acquisition by Berlin and transportpp. 367–371
  • The acquisition histories and proposed provenances of Louvre bowls AO 20135 and AO 20134pp. 371–377
  • The proposed material source and original location of the Sargon stelepp. 377–379

Contents

  • Discovery of the stele354
  • Niven Kerr's Correspondence359
  • Dramatis personae363
  • Silver bowls in the Louvre371
  • Origin of the stele377
  • Conclusion378
  • Acknowledgements379
  • Bibliography380

Objects published here

3
  • Stele of Sargon II, Vorderasiatisches Museum, Berlin, Larnaca (Kition), precise findspot disputed, VA 968, Fig. 7 (p. 357)
  • Incomplete Phoenician silver bowl, proposed from Kition, Musée du Louvre, Kition, proposed, AO 20135 (also AO 5974; N 3454), Fig. 8 (p. 372)
  • Phoenician silver bowl of unestablished provenance, Musée du Louvre, Unestablished; attributed to Idalion in some accounts, AO 20134 (also N 3455), Fig. 9 (p. 372)

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

Places

  • Kitionproposed findspot of the stele and bowl AO 20135
  • Larnacawhere the stele was found and acquired
  • Bamboulaproposed findspot Merrillees rejects
  • Scalaarea of the proposed stele findspot
  • Phaneromenilandmark near the proposed findspot
  • Idalionproposed provenance of the Louvre bowls

Also named: Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres, Stavrovouni.

Extent pp. 349–386, figs 1–9 including maps (figs 1–3); French résumé; bibliography

ModernCypro-ArchaicCollectingHistory of ArchaeologyMetalworkForeign Contacts

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

1 page

Excavations it is cited for

1 project

Who did what

12 records

Buying, selling and giving 10

Excavation 1

Recording and study 1

  • Adrien de LongpérierPublished

    Longpérier published the first descriptions of the Louvre's silver bowl and accounts of its acquisition.

    silver bowl AO 20135No. AO 20135

    1853 · p. 374

People it is cited for

54 people
24 more

Institutions it is cited for

18 institutions

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.