Restorer / conservator · Photographer

Charles Balliard

fl. 1870–1910

Savoyard watchmaker who restored Cesnola's Cypriot sculptures at the Metropolitan Museum from 1879, testified in the 1884 libel suit and later became the Museum's photographer.

Key factsRestorer / conservator, Photographer · fl. 1870–1910
Active
1870–1910
Roles
Restorer / conservator, Photographer
Institutions
Places
New York (Metropolitan Museum, Central Park)
Also known as
Mr. Charles Balliard; Balliard (Ch.)
See in the network

Biography

1,100 words · about 4 minutes

Charles Balliard was the Geneva-trained watchmaker whom the Metropolitan Museum of Art engaged in 1879 to restore the Cypriot objects it had recently bought from Luigi Palma di Cesnola12. He was born at Fillinges in Savoy on 6 March 184120,22. An Annecy notice quoted by Robert Stuart Merrillees names him Charles-Alexandre, son of Alexandre Balliard, then an aspiring notary, and Louise Stéphanie Prévost, and says his mother kept her Protestant faith while the couple's six children were baptised by the priest of Fillinges22. The census found him a student in Geneva in 1857 and a watchmaker there in 1866, aged 2522. In the United States he worked first for Tiffany and Company as a repairer of watches and objects of art12.

Restoring the Cesnola sculptures

A statement printed in the New York Times in 1882, says he was engaged in the early summer of 1879 with Vallosio as his helper, redid the work of Theodore Gehlen, and pleased Cesnola more13. Hermary and Mertens date the restorations to about 1879-80, after the move to the new building7. Balliard later testified that his first work was treating bronzes against oxidation, and that he then undid Gehlen's work and rebuilt the collection under Cesnola's direction22. In 1880 he told a reporter that, in reuniting heads and bodies, he consulted Cesnola where his own judgement failed23. The American Architect mocked the Tribune for citing as its "expert" a man known only to have "done some intricate work for Messrs. Tiffany & Co."23.

Gaston Louis Feuardent wrote that Balliard told him on 17 May 1880 that the mirror had been carved over faint lines, and later denied it, telling the World the mirror was plain when given to him and the Tribune that cleaning revealed a disk the director called a mirror24. Balliard later said Feuardent had mistaken the French gratte, to scrape, for grave, to cut22.

The sources disagree on the sarcophagus: in a sworn statement quoted by Feuardent in 1881, the photographer George C. Cox swore that the added parts of the hunting scene on the Athienou sarcophagus were "so skilfully made and engraved by Mr. Baillard" that no restoration showed, and that he saw him do part of the engraving3. Feuardent titled his article "The Cesnola-Baillard Sarcophagus"3. Balliard's own later report says the sarcophagus was repaired with metal rods and fills and that "no restorations were made"7. A letter in the New York Times of 1881 says he was called as a witness for Cesnola before the Museum's committee25. The anonymous writer, on Feuardent's side, said Balliard was "a person of such antecedents that his word does not deserve the least consideration", even under oath, and offered to back this with proofs, which he did not give25. The same writer called "falsehoods" what Balliard told the committee about Cox, "that he was always half intoxicated" and had to be got rid of25.

The libel suit

Balliard was examined as a witness in the libel suit15. For Feuardent, Charles Henkel testified that Balliard made a new leg for the Hercules, put the hand and patera on the priest and carved to fill gaps on reliefs and sarcophagi1. Dickson B. Alley testified that Balliard took the Venus statuette away one Sunday and brought it back with the mirror changed1. Cox testified that Balliard cut figures with a graver at his suggestion, to bring out lines for photography2. Savage testified that Balliard removed a plaster finger from the bearded Venus on Cesnola's orders2.

Balliard himself was examined on 8 and 9 January 188415,22. He called himself "repairer in chief" and "a jack of all trades", and defined an archaeologist as "a man who builds or repairs ancient statues"22. The Times reported that he had never worked in stone except on this collection, that Cesnola gave him the pieces said to belong together, and that his wash was milk, glycerine, shellac and powdered stone15. He denied inserting foreign pieces15. Merrillees judges him "scarcely more qualified or proficient" than Feuardent or Cesnola22.

Later work at the Museum

Allan Marquand credited Balliard's "very skilful cleaning" with bringing the design of the Kourion silver patera to view26. Balliard copied each character of the Kourion bracelet inscriptions on a separate die22. Richter wrote that the green patina on two bronze water-spouts, said in the Cesnola Atlas to come from Curium, was artificial, "added by Mr. Baillard"27. Cesnola used him as go-between with the Louvre: on 19 May 1884 he wrote to Léon Heuzey, and in 1889 Cesnola accepted the exchange of Cypriot antiquities for casts that Balliard had arranged22. For a time he ran his own business in Clinton Place before returning as repairer and mounter12.

The sources disagree on when he became the Museum photographer: the Museum's Bulletin says 1894, the Gers Bulletin 189712,20. In 1903 he helped Cesnola piece together the Monteleone chariot, using Chinese paper to stabilise cracks17.

The statement on his work

Hermary and Mertens write that in 1907 he left notes from which a report in the Museum's Archives was written7. John Linton Myres wrote that before the cleansing was "begun, or even projected" the Museum obtained his full statement, and that he was still at hand in 19094. Hermary, writing in 2001, puts the 1909 cleaning itself in Balliard's hands6. Myres held that removing the stone-wash confirmed his memory4. In 1954 Myres wrote that Balliard stated in 1909 that Cesnola ordered him to hide traces of colour with crushed fragments and gum arabic, a mixture other than the one he named in 188415,28. Hermary and Mertens judge that his report "understates the amount of intervention" on one relief7. Joan Connelly writes that he restored the Golgoi sculptures "rather creatively"29.

Gifts to Annecy

Balliard gave gifts to Annecy, including more than a hundred objects of American archaeology brought on a visit in 1883, reproductions of the Kourion bracelets in 1893 and a plaster model of a votive chariot from Curium in 190410,22,30. He was made corresponding member of the Académie florimontane on 23 September 1882 and honorary member on 10 March 1897, though a 1974 account gives 188621,22. The Gers Bulletin counts 226 pieces of his collection at Auch20.

Ill health led him to take leave, and he left the Museum ill in 190812,20. He died on 15 April 1916; the sources disagree on the place, Plainpalais in Geneva in the Savoy obituary and the Annecy notice, Reignier in the Museum's Bulletin12,22. The Annecy notice says he was buried in the family vault at Fillinges22.

Life and work

11 events, 1880–1909

  1. 1880

    1. c. 1880

      Alley's testimony (p. 24): he did not see Gehlen but saw Balliard, 'several months at work' at the Park museum, taking statues apart and restoring them with Cesnola directing; Balliard prepared the bath that brightened the bronzes to new-bronze colour, put them in a kettle that made them look old again, sawed legs off statues and bases off objects, removed stone legs for plaster on sphinx no. 35, knocked off the plaster nose of the 'Egyptian warrior' after the Art Amateur controversy began, and used tobacco juice to hide a fresh scratch. On the Sunday after the Art Amateur's article he took the statuette of Venus away and returned it on the Monday with the mirror changed; Alley told him jokingly that carving it was the way out of the scrape.

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 24

    2. 1880–1881

      Cox (Jan. 1884 report, p. 55) said the repair-room was kept locked; when Balliard was down-town Prime brought friends in, and Balliard, offended, had a new lock fitted: he had no objection to Prime, who often came with Cesnola, seeing the work, but did object to his friends. Cox saw a new stone leg made for Hercules, a new base for the bearded Venus (one finger too many removed after Earl Shinn noticed it), a red ribbon painted on the sphinx's neck and blue points on the sarcophagus; figures were cut with a graver by Balliard 'at his suggestion' (the pronoun is ambiguous: Cox's or Balliard's) to bring out the lines for photography.

      New York(1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, p. 55

    3. Savage's testimony (Jan. 1884 report, pp. 55-56): while preparing a catalogue he noticed that a finger of the bearded Venus was plaster; he told Cesnola and 'by his orders Balliard removed it'. Savage also said Cesnola told him that the first he knew of any restoration was on returning from his 1880 vacation at Richfield Springs, when Balliard informed him restorations had been discovered; that he had ordered Balliard to change all so-restored figures back to their original condition, and that the collection was then entirely free from restorations. Savage built his Evening Post interview denying Feuardent's charges on that assurance.

      New York(1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, pp. 55-56

  2. 1881

    1. May

      Feuardent's article 'The Cesnola-Baillard Sarcophagus' quotes Cox's sworn statement that the hunting-scene side of the Athienou (Golgoi) sarcophagus, broken in pieces, was repaired and the engraving on added parts made 'by Mr. Baillard', who was 'very proud' of the work and asked for a photograph of it; Cox saw him do part of the engraving. The title attaches Balliard's name to the sarcophagus.

      New YorkG. L. Feuardent (1881). The Cesnola-Baillard Sarcophagus. The Art Amateur 4, 113-114, pp. 113-114

  3. 1885

    1. 1880s

      Per Charles Henkel's testimony as reported in The Art Amateur (plaintiff-sympathetic), Cesnola instructed his 'newly employed restorers, Messrs. Balliard and Vallosio' at the Central Park museum to remove the dirt and plaster of earlier restorations from statues that had broken in transit; afterwards the pieces were 'turned over' to them for the treatment 'to re-convert them into first-class antiquities': hammer, chisel, wire brush and a coloured wash. Henkel said Balliard made a new leg for the Herakles from Golgoi stone, replacing the one Gehlen had made. A photograph showing Henkel, Balliard and Vallosio in the repairing-room was shown in court.

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, pp. 23-24

    2. 1880s

      Henkel (p. 24) also said Balliard cut off the sandals Gehlen had put on a priest statue and replaced them, worked on the bearded Venus, priests nos. 21-22 and two double sphinxes (one given a new head), the little Hercules (stone leg for Gehlen's wooden one), bathed bronzes in acid, and, one Sunday after the controversy began, broke plaster noses and ears off statues on exhibition with Henkel's help. Cesnola's order to 'his newly employed restorers' included the stripping of earlier restorations from statues soaked in the tank.

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 24

  4. 1904

    1. Gave the Musée d'Annecy a plaster model of the limestone votive chariot with two figures and two horses from the temple at Curium (original 750-700 BC) and seven small Egyptian funerary statuettes; listed in the Société florimontane's members as "Balliard Charles, à New-York".

      Annecy(1904). [Proceedings of the Académie florimontane and museum accessions]. Revue savoisienne 45

  5. 1907

    1. Hermary and Mertens (2014) say Balliard 'left notes' in 1907 from which a report was written, now in the Metropolitan Museum's Archives; they quote it in catalogue entries (stele with sphinxes: 'repairs and restorations by Balliard'; a sarcophagus: 'Nothing has been done to the sarcophagus at the Museum, but repairs were made in Cyprus by General Cesnola. The plaster restoration of the lid was made by Cicogna about five years ago'; another piece: Gehlen put it together about two years before Balliard's repairs, and pieces joined by Gehlen were not in their proper places). They add that Balliard 'had left the association of a head with a body to Cesnola' and was still employed in 1909 when Myres began his study.

      New YorkA. Hermary, J. R. Mertens (2014). The Cesnola Collection of Cypriot Art: Stone Sculpture. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art

  6. 1909

    1. Before the 1909 cleaning of the Cesnola sculptures, the Museum obtained from Balliard 'a full statement of his recollection of the state in which the sculptures were when he first took them in hand, and of what he did to them'. Myres (Handbook, p. xxii) says the later removal of the stone-wash confirmed the accuracy of his memory; he was 'actively concerned in the original installation'. Marangou lists Balliard's 'Report to the Metropolitan Museum of Art', MMA Bulletin June 1907 (sic) as a source.

      New YorkJ. L. Myres (1914). Handbook of the Cesnola Collection of Antiquities from Cyprus. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art, p. xxii; A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 143, p. 380

    2. Hermary notes that Myres stressed the cleaning of the objects carried out in 1909 'par Charles Balliard' was necessary; in the next sentence he says Myres admitted 'a few mistakes' in the collection.

      New YorkA. Hermary (2001). Sculptures de la collection Cesnola: le prêtre à la tête de taureau. Cyprus in the 19th Century AD: Fact, Fancy and Fiction, 153-155, p. 153

    3. 1909–1910

      Gave the Metropolitan Museum a full statement of his recollections of the repairs and restorations he carried out on the Cesnola sculptures and of their state when he found them, before the cleansing of 1909. A later source says he stated in 1909 that Cesnola ordered him to cover traces of colour.

      New York(1910). Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 5(10). Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 5; (1974). [Article on the collections of the Annecy museum]. Revue savoisienne, p. 187

Study

4 records of study

Recording and study

4 records
Restored2
Employed by1
Other work1
  • Balliard made moulds of archaeological pieces and scale models of ancient monuments.

    archaeological pieces and models of ancient monumentsMetropolitan Museum of ArtMerrillees 2010, p. 123

Trade and objects

7 records · 2 objects

Through their hands

7 records
SaleGift or bequestWho objects came from and went to, as the sources record it
  1. 1884

    AgencyBalliard wrote to Heuzey on Cesnola’s behalf, asking him to return the crate of terracottas sent to the Louvre.

    Agent for Luigi Palma di Cesnolaa crate of terracottasMerrillees 2010, p. 116

  2. 1884

    LettersBalliard wrote to Heuzey requesting the return of a crate of terracottas sent to the Louvre.

    Corresponded with Léon HeuzeyMerrillees 2010, p. 116

  3. 1889

    NoteBalliard arranged with Heuzey an exchange of Cypriot antiquities for plaster casts.

    Connected with Léon HeuzeyMerrillees 2010, p. 116

  4. 1893–1914

    GiftAccording to Mme Sophie Vassogne, Charles Balliard donated the two bracelets to the Musée-château d’Annecy in July 1893.

    Gave to Musée-château d’Annecytwo reproduction braceletsNo. Inv. Nos. 12090 and 12091Merrillees 2010, p. 101

  5. n.d.

    Gift receivedpossiblyThe exhibition catalogue said it was possible that Cesnola gave pieces from his personal collection to Balliard.

    Received from Luigi Palma di Cesnolapieces from Cesnola’s ‘fonds personnel’Merrillees 2010, p. 114

  6. n.d.

    PurchasepossiblyThe exhibition catalogue said it was possible that Cesnola sold pieces from his personal collection to Balliard.

    Bought from Luigi Palma di Cesnolapieces from Cesnola’s ‘fonds personnel’Merrillees 2010, p. 114

  7. n.d.

    PurchaseprobablyThe author considered Feuardent the likely source of Balliard’s coins.

    Bought from Gaston Louis FeuardentMerrillees 2010, p. 119

Objects

2 objects

Connections

14 people

Mentions

Where else on Ancient Cyprus this person appears

Mentioned in

29 mentions

Documents · 14

Institutions · 2

  • Metropolitan Museum of Art

    Staff (c. 1880–1909) · 1879

    Gaston Feuardent publishes charges (Art Amateur, August and October 1880) that Cesnola had improperly restored and altered objects in the Cesnola Collection…

    The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial 1883, p. 23

  • Musée-château d'Annecy

    Donor (from 1904), object from them · 1893

    Charles Balliard gave objects to Musée-château d'Annecy.

    Revue savoisienne 1904; Revue savoisienne 1904, p. 235; Merrillees 2010, p. 101

Sources

66 works and documents

  1. 1. (1883). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24. Online
  2. 2. (1884). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56. Online
  3. 3.G. L. Feuardent (1881). “The Cesnola-Baillard Sarcophagus”. The Art Amateur 4, 113-114.
  4. 4.J. L. Myres (1914). Handbook of the Cesnola Collection of Antiquities from Cyprus. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  5. 5.A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
  6. 6.A. Hermary (2001). “Sculptures de la collection Cesnola: le prêtre à la tête de taureau”. Cyprus in the 19th Century AD: Fact, Fancy and Fiction, 153-155.
  7. 7.A. Hermary, J. R. Mertens (2014). The Cesnola Collection of Cypriot Art: Stone Sculpture. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  8. 8. (1884). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56. Online
  9. 9. (1883). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24. Online
  10. 10. (1904). “[Proceedings of the Académie florimontane and museum accessions]”. Revue savoisienne 45.
  11. 11. (1910). “Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 5(10)”. Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 5.
  12. 12. (1916). “Charles Balliard”. Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 11, 181. Online
  13. 13. (1882). “[Statements of Charles Henkel and Dickson B. Alley on the Cesnola collection]”. The New York Times, 10 April 1882.
  14. 14. (1883). “The New York Times, 9 November 1883”. The New York Times.
  15. 15. (1884). “The Di Cesnola Libel Suit: the testimony of Mr. Balliard and Mr. Ward, the sculptor”. The New York Times, 10 January 1884.
  16. 16. (1880). “The Art Amateur 3(4), September 1880”. The Art Amateur 3.
  17. 17. (2011). “[The Monteleone chariot: history and conservation]”. Metropolitan Museum Journal 46.
  18. 18.T. B. Mitford (1971). The Inscriptions of Kourion. Philadelphia, American Philosophical Society.
  19. 19. (1881). “Revue savoisienne (Association florimontane d'Annecy)”. Revue savoisienne, p. 253.
  20. 20. (1982). “[Article on the American collections of the museum at Auch]”. Bulletin de la Société archéologique, historique, littéraire et scientifique du Gers.
  21. 21. (1974). “[Article on the collections of the Annecy museum]”. Revue savoisienne.
  22. 22.R. S. Merrillees (2010). “Another Cesnola Puzzle: a pair of reproduction bracelets from Kourion in the Musée-château d'Annecy”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 40.
  23. 23. (1880). “[Editorial note on the Cesnola restorations]”. The American Architect and Building News, 14 August 1880 8.
  24. 24.Gaston L. Feuardent (1880). “[Letter on the Cesnola charges]”. The Art Amateur 3.
  25. 25. (1881). “Manners and Morals at the Metropolitan Museum”. The New York Times, 10 April 1881.
  26. 26.Allan Marquand (1887). “A Silver Patera from Kourion”. American Journal of Archaeology 3. Online
  27. 27.Gisela M. A. Richter (1915). Greek, Etruscan and Roman Bronzes. Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  28. 28.John L. Myres (1954). “A Painted Graeco-Phoenician Vase from Ormidhia in Cyprus”. American Journal of Archaeology 58.
  29. 29.Joan Breton Connelly (1988). Votive Sculpture of Hellenistic Cyprus.
  30. 30. (1883). “[Proceedings of the Académie florimontane]”. Revue savoisienne.
  31. 31.R. S. Merrillees (2010). “Another Cesnola Puzzle: A pair of reproduction bracelets from Kourion in the Musée-château”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 40, 101-123.
  32. 32.J. L. Myres (1910). “The Cesnola collection of Cypriote antiquities: Third report. Note”. Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 5, 229-233.
  33. 33.J. L. Myres (1954). “A Painted Graeco-Phoenician Vase from Ormidhia in Cyprus”. American Journal of Archaeology 58, 39-44.
  34. 34.J. B. Connelly (1988). Votive Sculpture of Hellenistic Cyprus. New York, New York University Press.
  35. 35.1884, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (continued).
  36. 36.R. S. Merrillees, 2010, Another Cesnola Puzzle: A pair of reproduction bracelets from Kourion in the Musée-château.
  37. 37.A. G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
  38. 38.1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial.
  39. 39.J. L. Myres, 1914, Handbook of the Cesnola Collection of Antiquities from Cyprus.
  40. 40.1884, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial.
  41. 41.1882, The New York Times, 10 April 1882, n.p.; 1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial.
  42. 42.The New York Times 1881-01-06: Vol 30 Iss 9151 (1881).
  43. 43.The New York Times 1882-04-10: Vol 31 Iss 9544 (1882).
  44. 44.The Art Amateur 1880-09: Vol 3 Iss 4 (1880).
  45. 45.The New York Times 1882-03-15: Vol 31 Iss 9522.
  46. 46.The New York Times 1881-03-17: Vol 30 Iss 9211 (1881).
  47. 47.Feuardent, Gaston L., The Cesnola-Baillard Sarcophagus (1881).
  48. 48.The Christian Union 1886-06-10: Vol 33 Iss 23 (1886).
  49. 49.Académie florimontane (Annecy), Revue savoisienne : journal publié par l'Association florimontane d'Annecy : histoire, sciences, arts, industrie, littérature (1881).
  50. 50.Société archéologique, historique, littéraire et scientifique du Gers, Bulletin de la Société archéologique, historique littéraire & scientifique du Gers (1982-07).
  51. 51.Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 1916-08: Vol 11 Iss 8 (1916).
  52. 52.Repertorium für kunstwissenschaft (1876).
  53. 53.Repertorium für Kunstwissenschaft 1884: Vol 7 (1884).
  54. 54.Marangou 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola.
  55. 55.The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (1883).
  56. 56.A. Hermary and J. R. Mertens, 2014, The Cesnola Collection of Cypriot Art: Stone Sculpture.
  57. 57.1884, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial, JSTOR 25628080.
  58. 58.The Art Amateur 1881-08: Vol 5 Iss 3 (1881).
  59. 59.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904.
  60. 60.Marangou 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnolap. 142.
  61. 61.J. L. Myres, 1910, The Cesnola collection of Cypriote antiquities: Third report. Note.
  62. 62.J. L. Myres, 1954, A Painted Graeco-Phoenician Vase from Ormidhia in Cyprus.
  63. 63.1982, Bulletin de la Société archéologique, historique, littéraire et scientifique du Gers (July 1982).
  64. 64.Lang 1878, Cyprus: its History, its Present Resources, and Future Prospects, pp. 36-37, 213, 332-338; G. L. Feuardent, 'The Cesnola-Baillard Sarcophagus', Art Amateur 4 (May 1881).
  65. 65.The New York Times 1883-11-09: Vol 33 Iss 10040 (1883).
  66. 66.The Art Amateur 1883-12: Vol 10 Iss 1.

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Dates of birth and death unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.