Critic / journalist
Clarence Cook
fl. 1865–1895 · United States
American art critic whose pamphlet attacked the restorations and stated find-spots of the Cesnola statues from Cyprus in the Metropolitan Museum.
Biography
Clarence Chatham Cook, an American art critic, author and journalist, wrote the pamphlet Transformations and Migrations of Certain Statues in the Cesnola Collection, an attack on the Cypriot antiquities of the Metropolitan Museum of Art and on Luigi Palma di Cesnola6.
Cook was born at Dorchester, Massachusetts, on 8 September 1828, the fourth son of Zebedee and Caroline (Tuttle) Cook, and graduated from Harvard in 18496,13. He studied architecture at Newburgh, N.Y., but gave it up for teaching and journalism, and in September 1853 married Louisa (De Windt) Whittemore, a widow, in New York6. The American Architect says the poem "The Legend of Abou Ben-Adhem" first introduced him to the public14. He wrote an art column in the New York Tribune from 1863 to 1869, and Greeley then sent him to Paris as special correspondent until the war of 1870 drove him home6. His most successful book was The House Beautiful (1878)6.
Salamis photographs and the pamphlet
Marangou says he wrote a glowing Herald review of Cesnola's first exhibition, and that Cesnola sent him a letter with photographs of his finds at Salamis1. Masson calls Cook first a partisan of Cesnola and then an ally of Gaston Feuardent, and records two letters to him: one dated Larnaca, 27 February 1874, which Cook published in full, and one from Curium, 23 August 1875, which Henri de Morgan reproduced in French translation15.
The New York Times reported that Cook issued the illustrated pamphlet on 18 March 18828. The sources disagree on its year: Myres and Cobham give New York, 1882, while Adelson cites it as New York, 18812,16,17. Cook wrote that the collection held, with one exception, no statuary of value as art, and that his business was "the question of locality"1. He argued that the Aphrodite and Eros was "a fraudulent patchwork of unrelated parts", that nothing proved it came from Golgoi, and that nobody but Cesnola was known to have seen the "temple"; he noted that Johannes Doell, who catalogued the collection before it left for London, did not mention the statue1. The New York Times wrote in 1895 that Cook printed twelve antiquities catalogued as from Golgoi of which, he declared, he held photographs Cesnola had sent him from Cyprus in 1874, marked "From Salamis"18. One of his conclusions reported Feuardent's belief that the Trustees could claim at least $30,000 from Cesnola1.
On 28 March 1882 Cesnola and the trustees' Executive Committee placed the Aphrodite and Eros and the Male Votary Holding a Bull's Head in the Great Hall19. Cook restated the Salamis case in the Times on 5 November 1882, writing that objects were assigned "to whatever locality best suits the business purposes of their discoverer"20.
The Tribune and the trial
The sources disagree on when Cook left the Tribune. The DAB says the connection ceased in the early 1870s, partly because Whitelaw Reid had curtailed his space6. The Boston Globe's New York correspondent wrote in December 1883 that Cook had quit the paper the previous winter, partly over the Cesnola scandal; he wrote that Reid, a friend of Cesnola who would not have him attacked, had written editorially against Feuardent, and that Cook protested21.
At the libel trial of Feuardent against Cesnola in December 1883, Feuardent's testimony set out to prove the pamphlet's claim that the Golgoi temple was "a fraud, a fiction, and a myth"22. The sources disagree on whether Cook testified. The DAB says he did not, writing to the Times that he had no evidence to give of his own knowledge, and Martin prints Joseph H. Choate's summation asking "Where was Clarence Cook?"5,6. Strong writes instead that Choate discredited Cook's testimony and turned on him with "False, fleeting, perjured Clarence"23. The Art Amateur reported that the jury found for Cesnola on two of three counts, while a New York letter of 1884 said Cesnola had "worsted Mr. Feuardent and Clarence Cook"24,25. Cook edited The Studio from 1884 to 1892 and, the DAB says, kept up "vindictive attacks" on Cesnola there6.
Judgements
The DAB ranks Cook a "brilliant pioneer" of American art criticism, but says he and Feuardent "were not archeologists" and that later scholarship sustained Cesnola6. The American Architect thought he "probably injured his influence" by "over-enthusiastic partisanship", while allowing that Cesnola and his assistants probably sometimes joined pieces not originally connected14. Becker and Schorsch judge his patchwork charge "greatly exaggerated, if not totally without foundation"19. Hermary and Mertens write that Cook and Feuardent were "probably irritated by the outcome of the exhibition in London"26. Cook died at Fishkill Landing, New York, on 2 June 19006,13.
Life and work
1872
c. 1872
Wrote a glowing review in the Herald of Cesnola's first exhibition; Cesnola later sent him a letter with photographs of Salamis finds.New YorkA. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 127
1875
- Poet and journalist; sided with Feuardent and wrote 'Transformations and Migrations of Certain Statues in the Cesnola Collection' arguing the Golgoi statues were patched and mislocated; earlier Cesnola's correspondent (1875).
1880
- Gaston Feuardent opens the attack on the Cesnola Collection in the Art Amateur (August 1880); Cook was to repeat the charges in 1882.
1880–1883
Described by Martin, Choate's biographer, as 'art critic of the New York Tribune' who supported Feuardent in the contention that Cesnola's Cypriot pieces were so restored 'that they were of little or no value as antiquities'.
1882
- Published, through Feuardent, the pamphlet Transformations and Migrations of Certain Statues in the Cesnola Collection, arguing that the Golgoi statuary (centred on the 'Aphrodite and Eros', catalogue no. 39) was a patchwork, that Cesnola could not prove he found a temple at Golgoi, and that the collection was 'a fraud'.
New YorkA. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, pp. 311-317; J. L. Myres (1914). Handbook of the Cesnola Collection of Antiquities from Cyprus. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art, p. xix; A. Hermary (2001). Sculptures de la collection Cesnola: le prêtre à la tête de taureau. Cyprus in the 19th Century AD: Fact, Fancy and Fiction, 153-155, p. 153
- Pamphlet concluded that the statuary was largely unrelated fragments repaired, altered and painted, and that Feuardent held the Trustees could claim at least $30,000 damages from Cesnola. The Museum then put the two statues Cook named (Aphrodite and the Sacrificer) on open public view in spring 1882.
New YorkA. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, pp. 315-316; A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 324
Undated
n.d.
- Critic who amplified Feuardent's attack, calling the Met's 'Aphrodite and Eros' a patchwork and noting no witness had seen the Golgoi 'temple'.
The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, ed. A. G. Marangou, 2000, pp. 335-337
Connections
4 peopleSales, gifts & bequests
- Received from Luigi Palma di Cesnolaphotographs of Museum objects numbers 189, 42, 330, 386, 527, 680, 704, 754, 778, 1045; letter on Curium tomb; letter from Cyprus Courrier de l'art : chronique hebdomadaire des ateliers, des musées, des expositions, des ventes publiques... (1884-11-21), p. 30; Courrier de l'art : chronique hebdomadaire des ateliers, des musées, des expositions, des ventes publiques... (1884-11-28), p. 21; The New York Times 1895-03-06: Vol 44 Iss 13584 (1895)1875–1883
Disputes & the law
- Rival of Luigi Palma di Cesnolaattack on Cesnola Collection provenance and restorations; Cypriot statues 'Greek priest' and 'Aphrodite and Eros'; Cesnola collection of Cypriot statues Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, pp. 311-316; Fleischer, Richard. Red., Zeitschrift für die Gebildete Welt über das Gesammte Wissen Unserer Zeit und über Alle Wichtigen Berufszweige. Bd. 1, 1883; [Editorial] (1882)1865–1883
- Rival of Alexander D. SavageSamuel R. Crocker , Edward Abbott , Nicholas Paine Gilman , Madeline Vaughan Abbott Bushnell, Bliss Carman, Herbert Copeland, The Literary world (1882); Samuel R. Crocker, Edward Abbott, Nicholas Paine Gilman, Madeline Vaughan Abbott Bushnell, Bliss Carman, Herbert Copeland, The literary world (1870)1870–1882
- Rival of Gaston Louis Feuardentpolemic Vayson de Pradenne, André (1888-1939), Les fraudes en archéologie préhistorique : avec quelques exemples de comparaison en archéologie générale et sciences naturelles (1932), p. 16221875–1879
- Testified about Luigi Palma di Cesnolabull-head 'priest' MMA 74.51.2463 Hermary 2001, 'Sculptures de la collection Cesnola: le cas du prêtre à la tête de taureau', in Tatton-Brown (ed.), Cyprus in the 19th Century AD, p. 1531882
Scholarship
- Published material of Luigi Palma di CesnolaAntiquities discovered by Cesnola in Cyprus Nevins Memorial Library (Methuen, Mass.), Catalogue; (1887)1870
- Corresponded with Luigi Palma di CesnolaCesnola wrote to Clarence Cook about his Curium discoveries and claimed he had found a royal tomb and valuable objects. Masson 1984, p. 221872–1882
- Material published by Gaston Louis FeuardentTransformations and Migrations of Certain Statues in the Cesnola Collection A. Hermary, 2001, Sculptures de la collection Cesnola: le cas du prêtre à la tête de taureau, p. 1531882
Colleagues & contacts
- Connected with Luigi Palma di CesnolaCesnola collection statues; Cesnola collection of Cypriot statues; Cypriote excavations Catalogue de la bibliothèque de M. Ernest Renan (1895), p. 122; Stephen Denison Peet, The American Antiquarian and Oriental Journal (1882); Samuel R. Crocker , Edward Abbott , Nicholas Paine Gilman , Madeline Vaughan Abbott Bushnell, Bliss Carman, Herbert Copeland, The Literary world (1882)1870–1884
- Worked with Luigi Palma di Cesnolapromotion of his work Vayson de Pradenne, André (1888-1939), Les fraudes en archéologie préhistorique : avec quelques exemples de comparaison en archéologie générale et sciences naturelles (1932), p. 16221875–1879
- Worked with Gaston Louis FeuardentTransformations and Migrations pamphlet, published by Feuardent; Cypriot statues ('Greek priest', 'Aphrodite and Eros'); pamphlet attacking the Cesnola Collection Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, pp. 311-312; A. Hermary, 2001, Sculptures de la collection Cesnola: le cas du pretre a la tete de taureau, p. 153; Montezuma, My Note Book (1882); Dumas Malone, Dictionary Of American Biography (chanfrau To Cushing) Vol Iv (1935)1880–1882
- Connected with Gaston Louis Feuardentletters in Feuardent's possession; pamphlet; Cesnola Collection [Editorial] (1882); The Atlanta Constitution 1882-05-03: Vol 14 (1882); edward sandford martin, the life of joseph hodges choate (1927)1880–1882
- Worked with Hiram HitchcockCesnola collection article The New York times (1918)
Objects
Colossal limestone statue of a 'priest' holding a bull's head (Cesnola Collection), denounced in Cook's pamphlet for 'impudent restorations'
From GolgoiMetropolitan Museum of Art, New York 74.51.2463
Mentioned in
10 mentionsDocuments · 5
- Sculptures de la collection Cesnola: le prêtre à la tête de taureau
2001
criticised attributions and restorations
Hermary 2001
- The Cesnola Collection of Cypriot Art: Stone Sculpture
2014
Hermary & Mertens 2014
- Handbook of the Cesnola Collection of Antiquities from Cyprus
Myres 1914
- The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958
Adelson 1958
- The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds
Marangou 2000
Institutions · 1
- Rollin et Feuardent
1880
Gaston Feuardent attacks the authenticity and restoration of Cesnola's sculptures at the Metropolitan Museum (Art Amateur, August 1880); the 'Feuardent v…
Tatton-Brown 2001; Masson 1992, p. 153
- People · 4listed under Connections
Sources
- 1.A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
- 2.J. L. Myres (1914). Handbook of the Cesnola Collection of Antiquities from Cyprus. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art.
- 3.A. Hermary (2001). “Sculptures de la collection Cesnola: le prêtre à la tête de taureau”. Cyprus in the 19th Century AD: Fact, Fancy and Fiction, 153-155.
- 4.Clarence Cook (1882). Transformations and Migrations of Certain Statues in the Cesnola Collection. New York, Gaston L. Feuardent.
- 5.Edward Sandford Martin (1920). The Life of Joseph Hodges Choate, as gathered chiefly from his letters.
- 6.Allen Johnson; Dumas Malone (eds) (1930). “Cook, Clarence Chatham”. Dictionary of American Biography, vol. 4 (Chanfrau to Cushing). Charles Scribner's Sons.
- 7.New York Times (1884-02-12). “The Discredited Cesnola Collection (letter to the editor)”.
- 8.The New York Times (1882). “Those Cypriote Statues: Their Transformations and Migrations”. The New York Times, 19 March 1882.
- 9.The Critic (1882-03-25). “Notice of Cook pamphlet”.
- 10.The Literary World (1882). “Note on the controversy over the Cesnola collection”.
- 11.The Art Amateur (1882-04). “Cesnola Collection notice, vol. 6 no. 5”.
- 12.W. L. Kingsley (ed.) (1881). “The New Englander”.
- 13.The Harvard Graduates' Magazine (1900). “[Obituary notice of Clarence Chatham Cook]”. The Harvard Graduates' Magazine 9.
- 14.The American Architect and Architecture (1900). “[Editorial note on the death of Clarence Cook]”. The American Architect and Architecture 68.
- 15.Olivier Masson (1992). “[Letters of Luigi Palma di Cesnola and Alessandro Palma di Cesnola]”. Cyprus and the East Mediterranean in the Iron Age (Proceedings of the Seventh British Museum Classical Colloquium).
- 16.Claude Delaval Cobham (1900). An Attempt at a Bibliography of Cyprus.
- 17.Howard L. Adelson (1958). The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958. American Numismatic Society.
- 18.The New York Times (1895). “[Di Cesnola's many critics: retrospect of the Cesnola controversy]”. The New York Times, 4 March 1895.
- 19.Lawrence Becker; Deborah Schorsch. “The Practice of Objects Conservation in The Metropolitan Museum of Art (1870–1942)”.
- 20.Clarence Cook (1882). “[Letter on the Cesnola Collection and the Salamis photographs]”. The New York Times, 5 November 1882.
- 21.Boston Weekly Globe (1883). “[New York letter: Cesnola's purgatory; Clarence Cook and Reid]”. Boston Weekly Globe, 25 December 1883.
- 22.The New York Times (1883). “[Feuardent-Di Cesnola case: Mr. Feuardent contrasts the General's own statements]”. The New York Times, 5 December 1883.
- 23.Theron George Strong (1917). Joseph H. Choate, New Englander, New Yorker, Lawyer, Ambassador.
- 24. (1884). “The End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 96-97. Online
- 25.The New York Times (1884). “The Cesnola Verdict: Mr. Stillman on the Cypriote Antiquities”. The New York Times, 26 October 1884.
- 26.A. Hermary, J. R. Mertens (2014). The Cesnola Collection of Cypriot Art: Stone Sculpture. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art.
- 27.O. Masson (1984). “Cesnola et le trésor de Curium (I)”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 1.
- 28.Marangou 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola, pp. 335-339, 402; Cahiers CEC 1 (1984) p. 8.
- 29.The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, ed. A. G. Marangou, 2000.
- 30.Samuel R. Crocker , Edward Abbott , Nicholas Paine Gilman , Madeline Vaughan Abbott Bushnell, Bliss Carman, Herbert Copeland, The Literary world (1882).
- 31.Samuel R. Crocker, Edward Abbott, Nicholas Paine Gilman, Madeline Vaughan Abbott Bushnell, Bliss Carman, Herbert Copeland, The literary world (1870).
- 32.Hermary 2001, 'Sculptures de la collection Cesnola: le cas du prêtre à la tête de taureau', in Tatton-Brown (ed.), Cyprus in the 19th Century AD.
- 33.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, pp. 311-312; A. Hermary, 2001, Sculptures de la collection Cesnola: le cas du pretre a la tete de taureau.
- 34.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
- 35.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 127; Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
- 36.The Literary World, 1882.
- 37.[Editorial] (1882).
- 38.Fleischer, Richard. Red., Zeitschrift für die Gebildete Welt über das Gesammte Wissen Unserer Zeit und über Alle Wichtigen Berufszweige. Bd. 1, 1883.
- 39.Montezuma, My Note Book (1882).
- 40.Vayson de Pradenne, André (1888-1939), Les fraudes en archéologie préhistorique : avec quelques exemples de comparaison en archéologie générale et sciences naturelles (1932).
- 41.Catalogue de la bibliothèque de M. Ernest Renan (1895).
- 42.Courrier de l'art : chronique hebdomadaire des ateliers, des musées, des expositions, des ventes publiques... (1884-11-21).
- 43.Courrier de l'art : chronique hebdomadaire des ateliers, des musées, des expositions, des ventes publiques... (1884-11-28).
- 44.Stephen Denison Peet, The American Antiquarian and Oriental Journal (1882).
- 45.Nevins Memorial Library (Methuen, Mass.), Catalogue; (1887).
- 46.The Atlanta Constitution 1882-05-03: Vol 14 (1882).
- 47.The New York Times 1895-03-06: Vol 44 Iss 13584 (1895).
- 48.edward sandford martin, the life of joseph hodges choate (1927).
- 49.Dumas Malone, Dictionary Of American Biography (chanfrau To Cushing) Vol Iv (1935).
- 50.Marangou 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola.
- 51.A. Hermary, 2001, Sculptures de la collection Cesnola: le cas du prêtre à la tête de taureau.
- 52.Howard L. Adelson, 1958, The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958, pp. 88-89; Edward Sandford Martin (ed.), 1920, The Life of Joseph Hodges Choate, as gathered chiefly from his letters.
- 53.The Century illustrated monthly magazine (1871).
- 54.Marangou 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola, pp. 263, 328-352, 361, 402 (notes); Cahiers CEC 40 (2010) p. 20.
- 55.The New York times (1918).
- 56.O. Masson, 1984, Cesnola et le trésor de Curium (I).
- 57.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds(pp. 311-315).
- 58.2012, Art History Supplement 2(2), March 2012.
- 59.Art Histories Society, Art History Supplement, vol.2, no. 2, March 2012 (2013).
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- Dates of birth and death unknown
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.