Scholar

Henry Engel

fl. 1841–1845 · Germany

German classical scholar and schoolmaster (1812-1875) who wrote Kypros. Eine Monographie (1841), a two-part account of ancient Cyprus built wholly from texts, without visiting the island.

Biography

Wilhelm Heinrich Engel was a German classical scholar and schoolmaster whose Kypros. Eine Monographie, published in Berlin in two volumes in 1841, gathered what ancient writers said about Cyprus3,4. Niven Kerr, reporting on Cyprus in 1845, called him "Henry Engel", a German author whose book "treats extensively of the antiquities of the Grecian period"5.

Engel was born in 1812 at Sembsin in Mecklenburg-Schwerin and went to relatives in Berlin at ten, where he was schooled6. The German national library's authority record alone gives the day, 7 January7. In 1832 he left the Gymnasium zum Grauen Kloster to study philology and history, spent his first summer at Rostock, and took his doctorate at Göttingen at Easter 1835 with the dissertation Quaestiones Naxiae6. In the preface to Kypros he wrote that he had sat at the feet of Karl Otfried Müller only a few years before, and that the book owed its origin to Müller's gift for awakening enthusiasm in his pupils8.

From 1836 Engel lectured as Privatdozent at Rostock, chiefly on Pindar and mythology; there he wrote Kypros6. He signed its preface at Rostock on 30 January 18418. Personal circumstances, which the school's account does not explain, moved him to leave Mecklenburg; he travelled for some time, spent a year of study at Greifswald and went to Berlin in 18426. There he was an assistant teacher at the Friedrich-Werder Gymnasium and from Easter 1845 held a post at the Friedrich-Wilhelms-Gymnasium6.

The book

Engel never visited Cyprus, and Kypros rested only on written sources3. The first part ran to X and 773 pages and the second to 6899. In the preface he wrote that, apart from a few points such as the Cypria poem, he had worked almost wholly without forerunners, and that he had worked "with pleasure and love"8. He also wrote there that he had still set the power of the Phoenicians on Cyprus too high8. A. Cannavò nonetheless notes that in Engel's book the Phoenicians were already the first historical people on the island, long before the Greeks3. The second part treats the cult of Aphrodite, which Engel called the chief cult of the land, and argues against the prevailing view that she was the Phoenician Astarte: she must be called a Greek goddess with the same right as the others10.

For places, Engel drew on travellers' reports, describing at Amathus two huge stone temple vessels, one sunk and shattered, the other almost undamaged8. He placed a temple of Apollo in the territory of Kourion, from whose rock anyone who touched it was thrown into the sea, and almost suspected that four places around Kourion were Argive8.

Readers and critics

A reviewer in the Allgemeine Literatur-Zeitung in 1843 found that Engel had worked "with love, diligence and learning" without earlier studies to lean on, but that a new manner of treatment among German archaeologists had led him in many places to false views9. The same reviewer judged the account of Aphrodite's cult perhaps the most welcome part of the work, and objected that Engel believed Isocrates on Evagoras though he knew Isocrates had distorted the truth9. George Grote, on the other hand, wrote in 1852 that Engel impugned Isocrates' account of Konon's visit to Cyprus without adequate reasons11.

A Vienna lecture of 1879 said that after L. Ross it was above all Engel who gave the first reliable knowledge of ancient Cyprus, while Cannavò writes that Ludwig Ross already used the book on his journey of 18453,12. The Academy said in 1876 that recent discoveries, largely Cesnola's own, had made the book "altogether obsolete"13. Luigi Palma di Cesnola himself, in 1878, named Engel as the modern writer to whom he was most indebted, and owed his acquaintance with the book to A. S. Murray1.

Zimmerer in 1892 called it the most comprehensive book on Cyprus, still unsurpassed if partly outdated; he speaks of three volumes, where the book appeared in two3,14. Alfred Westholm in 1936 called it a "brilliant study" that "still remains up to date in most particulars"15. George Hill in 1940 called Engel's attempt at Cypriot cultural history "gallant", but said that apart from his analysis of the Cypria it gave little more than a list of second- or third-rate authors16. Cannavò judges it fairly reliable and complete, lacking direct observation of the island but a fundamental source for its references to ancient literature3.

Stargard and Lichterfelde

Called on 11 October 1845 as third Oberlehrer of the Gymnasium at Stargard, Engel took up the post in January 18466. That year's school programme carried the first part of his De Evagora, on Evagoras of Salamis and his war against Artaxerxes6. In 1861 he dated Evagoras's war in a Stargard treatise that a reviewer of 1894 called valuable17. Engel retired from Stargard in August 1867 and afterwards taught at the Pädagogium in Lichterfelde near Berlin4,18.

He died on the morning of 14 July 1875, according to both his family's and his Lichterfelde colleagues' notices in the National-Zeitung19. Both say he died after a long illness19. His wife Helene Engel, née Mayer, signed the family notice with Gertrud and Konrad Engel, and the funeral left Lankwitzstraße 13 on 17 July19.

Life and work

  1. 1845

    1. Author of 'Kypros, eine Monographie', cited by Niven Kerr (1845) as treating Cyprus' Greek antiquities extensively.

      Merrillees 2016, 'Studies on the provenances of the stele of Sargon II...', CCEC 46, pp. 349–386

Connections

1 person

Mentioned in

4 mentions

Sources

  1. 1.L. P. di Cesnola (1878). Cyprus: Its Ancient Cities, Tombs, and Temples.
  2. 2.Engel (1841). Kypros, eine Monographie.
  3. 3.A. Cannavò (2012). “Chypre dans les études historiques des XIXe et XXe siècles. Découverte de l'antique, construction du passé”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 42.
  4. 4.W. Pökel (1882). Philologisches Schriftsteller-Lexikon. Alfred Krüger.
  5. 5.Robert Stuart Merrillees (2016). “Studies on the provenances of the stele of Sargon II from Larnaca (Kition) and the two so-called Dhali (Idalion) silver bowls in the Louvre”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 46, 349-386. Online
  6. 6.Gymnasium zu Stargard (K. F. H. Freese) (1846). “Zu der öffentlichen Prüfung der Zöglinge des Gymnasiums zu Stargard am 30. September 1846”. Stargard Gymnasium, Programm (with Engel, De Evagora ejusque bello contra Artaxerxem gesto, Part. I).
  7. 7.Deutsche Nationalbibliothek. Engel, Wilhelm (GND 1034403834). Online
  8. 8.Wilh. Engel (1841). Kypros. Eine Monographie. G. Reimer.
  9. 9. (1843). “[Review of W. Engel, Kypros. Eine Monographie]”. Allgemeine Literatur-Zeitung, Nr. 48-49 (March 1843).
  10. 10.Wilh. Engel (1841). Kypros. Eine Monographie. Zweiter Theil. G. Reimer.
  11. 11.G. Grote (1852). A History of Greece, vol. X. John Murray.
  12. 12. (1879). “[Lecture on Cyprus and Cesnola's work]”. Monatsblätter des Wissenschaftlichen Klub in Wien.
  13. 13.The Academy (1876). “[Notes and news: Cesnola's forthcoming work on Cyprus]”. The Academy, vol. 10, no. 231 (7 October 1876).
  14. 14.Zimmerer (1892). “Die engl. Generalstabskarte von Cypern”. Blätter für das Gymnasial-Schulwesen.
  15. 15.A. Westholm (1936). The Temples of Soli: Studies on Cypriote Art During Hellenistic and Roman Periods. Swedish Cyprus Expedition.
  16. 16.G. Hill (1940). A History of Cyprus, I: To the Conquest by Richard Lion Heart. Cambridge University Press.
  17. 17. (1894). “[Review on the date of Isocrates' Panegyricus]”. Wochenschrift für klassische Philologie 11.
  18. 18.Julius Tauscher (1868). “Jahresbericht über das Königliche und Gröning'sche Gymnasium von Ostern 1867 bis Ostern 1868”. Stargard Gymnasium, Programm.
  19. 19.National-Zeitung (Berlin) (1875). “[Death notice and colleagues' obituary notice of Dr. Wilhelm Engel]”. National-Zeitung (Berlin), 17 July 1875, p. 8. Online
  20. 20.Merrillees 2016, 'Studies on the provenances of the stele of Sargon II...', CCEC 46.
  21. 21.L. P. di Cesnola, 1878, Cyprus: Its Ancient Cities, Tombs, and Temples.

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Dates of birth and death unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.