Chapter · 2023
In Fear of Blacklisting. How the Division Shaped Archaeology in Cyprus
Lâtife Summerer; edited by L. Summerer, M. Kiessel and H. Kaba
In New Approaches toward Recording, Preserving and Studying Cultural Heritage in Divided Cyprus. Kyrenia: ARUCAD Press
An article on how the division of Cyprus has shaped archaeology, covering Turkish Cypriot archaeology, excavations in the north, blacklisting, research access and proposals for bicommunal cooperation.
Summerer follows archaeology in Cyprus from nineteenth-century antiquarianism through the Turkish invasion of 1974 and the founding of the Turkish Cypriot Department of Antiquities and Museums (DoAM) of the illegitimate "TRNC" (recognised only by Turkey) in 1975, to the 2019 conference at Kyrenia and 2021 proposals on cultural heritage administration. The chapter moves from the shaping of Hellenist archaeology and the emergence of Turkish Cypriot archaeology to excavations and surveys in the occupied north since 1974, the methods of blacklisting, cooperation through the Committee on Missing Persons and the Technical Committee on Cultural Heritage, and a legal framework she calls engagement without recognition. It rests on published excavation reports, theses, newspaper accounts and institutional records.
The evidence
Summerer summarises DoAM rescue work, including the recovery of tomb contexts and finds, and the short-term excavations at Kirni/Krini-Merra and Lambousa. The longer projects are Salamis, Kral Tepesi/Vasili and Akanthou-Arkosyko, with surveys in Kyrenia, Morphou and the Karpas peninsula (pp. 40–48). Figures 1 and 2 tabulate the reported excavations and surveys, and many rescue projects are known chiefly through brief press accounts, with little reporting of survey methods. The examples run from Neolithic settlement at Akanthou to Bronze Age finds at Kral Tepesi/Vasili and tombs and settlements of later periods.
Figure 3 reproduces a 2019 letter from the Department of Antiquities urging recipients not to take part in the Kyrenia conference.
The argument
Summerer argues that blacklisting and restrictions on research and publication have excluded Turkish Cypriot archaeologists and data from scholarship, leaving what she describes as a divided and uneven account of the island's archaeology. She relates this to the promotion of a Hellenist interpretation and to the limited participation of Turkish Cypriots before 1974, and her examples include the contested treatment of excavations at Salamis, Kral Tepesi/Vasili and Akanthou, and objections to citing or publishing research undertaken in the north (pp. 34–47).
For the two bicommunal bodies she describes their roles in fieldwork, conservation and cooperation. She discusses restrictions on participation and on the recording of archaeological material during Committee on Missing Persons investigations, and the limited involvement of archaeologists in the decisions and projects of the Technical Committee (pp. 63–66).
She concludes that separate administrations and mutual non-recognition have contributed to a gap between research in the two parts of the island, and that material from northern excavations and surveys remains largely unstudied or excluded from the official archaeology she describes. Her proposals are that researchers and institutions make Turkish Cypriot publications accessible and support the publication of excavation results, and that an independent bicommunal working group, whose members are not appointed by political leaders, develop shared principles, recommend joint projects and compile a GIS database of excavated, surveyed and looted sites (pp. 66–70).
What it records
- The first Turkish Cypriot antiquities administration was founded in Nicosia in 1975, with Nurettin Yardımcı as director.p. 38
- Ankara University and Eastern Mediterranean University established the AKVAM research centre in 1997, with a focus on Salamis.p. 39
- The first Department of Archaeology and Art History in the "TRNC" was established at Eastern Mediterranean University in 1998 and closed in 2011.p. 40
- Summerer reports that the excavations at Salamis were finalized in 2013.p. 44
- A Bronze Age hoard of 34 metal vessels and tools was discovered at Kral Tepesi/Vasili in 2004.p. 45
- Müge Şevketoğlu's excavations at Akanthou have produced evidence of occupation in the tenth millennium and of contacts with Central Anatolia.p. 46
- The Department of Antiquities and Museums excavated a rock-cut tomb at Kumyal/Koma tou Gialou in 2008.p. 59
- Summerer identifies Eustathios Raptou as the first to publish the Kumyal/Koma tou Gialou tomb, with a photograph.p. 59
- The Committee on Missing Persons was initiated in 2006 with a humanitarian mandate and EU financing.p. 63
- Summerer reports that around 50 archaeologists from both sides of Cyprus were being trained in forensic archaeology for the Committee on Missing Persons.p. 63
- The Technical Committee on Cultural Heritage had carried out 33 large and 25 smaller projects, mostly conservation.p. 64
Where to read
- Historical development of Cypriot archaeology and Turkish Cypriot participationpp. 34–40
- DoAM rescue excavations, including Kirni/Krini-Merra and Lambousapp. 40–43
- Salamis, Kral Tepesi/Vasili and Akanthou excavationspp. 43–47
- Surveys and university theses on excavated materialspp. 47–48
- Committee on Missing Persons and the Technical Committee on Cultural Heritagepp. 63–66
- Proposed bicommunal working group and joint archaeological projectspp. 66–70
Contents
- In Fear of Blacklisting. How the Division Shaped Archaeology in Cyprus33
- Introduction33
- Shaping Hellenist Archaeology in Cyprus34
- Emerging Turkish Cypriot Archaeology37
- Archaeological Activities in the North since 197440
- Short-Term Excavations42
- Kirni/Krini-Merra42
- Lapta/Lambousa43
- Long-Term Excavations43
- Salamis43
- Kral Tepesi/Vasili45
- Tatlısu-Çiftlikdüzü/Akanthou-Arkosyko46
- Surveys47
- University Theses on Rescue-Excavated Materials48
- Synthetic Studies48
- Tradition of Blacklisting Methods in Cypriot Archaeology49
- Blacklisted, Disempowered and Marginalized: The Inconspicuous Archaeological Community of the TRNC55
- Unfree Archaeology in “Free” Cyprus56
- Inconsequential Denial of “Illegal Archaeology” in the North59
- Failed and Successful Co-operation61
- Committee on Missing Persons63
- Technical Committee on Cultural Heritage64
- Engagement without Recognition – A Legal Framework for Bicommunal Archaeology?66
- Conclusion68
- Acknowledgement71
- Bibliography71
People, places and institutions
People
- Vassos Karageorghisdirector of the Department of Antiquities
- Nurettin Yardımcıfirst director of the Turkish Cypriot antiquities administration
- Tuncer Bağışkanjoined the Turkish Cypriot antiquities department in 1975
- Ekrem Akurgalled a post-ceasefire delegation of archaeologists
- Müge Şevketoğlusurveyed and excavated at Akanthou
- Uwe Müllerbegan rescue excavation at Kral Tepesi/Vasili
- Martin Bartelheimworked on the Kral Tepesi/Vasili excavation
- Ernst Pernickametallurgy specialist and laboratory researcher
- Samuel Hardywrote on ethics and archaeology in Cyprus
- Alan Simmonsexcavated Ais Giokis and discussed Neolithic Cyprus
- Hazar Kabastudied Soloi tombs and reports harassment
- Reyhan Sabrichallenged the identification of Salamis Gymnasium
- Annette Zeischka-Kenzlerparticipated in the Lambousa excavation
- Eustathios Raptoupublished a photograph of the Kumyal tomb
- Andreas Fouliaspublished research on Panagia tis Kyras
Institutions
- Department of Antiquities and MuseumsTurkish Cypriot antiquities administration
- Department of AntiquitiesRepublic of Cyprus antiquities authority
- Ankara Universitypartner in archaeological research at Salamis
- Eastern Mediterranean Universityhosted archaeology department and research centres
- Committee on Missing Personsbicommunal investigations and excavations
- Technical Committee on Cultural Heritagebicommunal heritage conservation projects
- ARUCADhosted the 2019 conference
- Mersin Universityparticipated in survey and excavation research
- University of Tübingenteam in Kral Tepesi/Vasili excavations
- Cyprus International Universityhosted an archaeology and conservation centre
Places
- Salamissite of contested excavation and publication
- Kral Tepesi/VasiliBronze Age excavation and hoard site
- Akanthou-ArkosykoNeolithic settlement excavated since 2000
- Kirni/Krini-Merrasite of salvage excavations in 1988 and 1992
- Lambousasite of DoAM excavations and theses
- Soloisite of excavated elite tombs
- Kumyal/Koma tou Gialousite of a rock-cut tomb excavated in 2008
- Panagia tis Kyraschurch and subject of published investigations
- Morphouarea of prehistoric and Bronze Age surveys
- Karpas peninsulaarea of several archaeological surveys
Also named: Ankara Hacı Bayram Veli University, UNESCO, Keramikmuseum Westerwald, Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, Ais Giokis.
Extent pp. 33–85, 3 figs
ModernNeolithicEarly Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricRomanHistory of ArchaeologyLooting and the LawMuseumsSettlementsChronology and Dating
Excavations it is cited for
6 projects- 1979–1986Maa-Palaeokastro: the Department excavationsDirected by Vassos Karageorghis, Martha Demas and Gordon ThomasExcavation
- 1995–1997Kyrenia district: Şevketoğlu's survey of Neolithic and Chalcolithic sitesDirected by Müge ŞevketoğluSurvey
- 1998–2013Salamis: the Ankara University excavationsDirected by Ahmet Coşkun ÖzgünelExcavation
- 2003–2009Livadhia: Foulias's exploration of the channel system under Panagia tis KyrasDirected by Andreas FouliasSurvey
- 2004–todayKral Tepesi/Vasili (Galinoporni-Vasili): the hoard rescue and excavationDirected by Uwe Müller and Bülent KızıldumanExcavation
- 2011–2019Aphendrika: Kiessel's non-invasive surveyDirected by Marko Kiessel, Ahmet M. Saymanlier and Meray TaluģSurvey
Who did what
30 recordsExcavation 11
- p. 36
Vassos KarageorghisExcavated
Vassos Karageorghis excavated at Maa-Paleocastro and found evidence of the first Greek-speaking colonists.
- 2004 · p. 45
Ernst PernickaExcavated
Ernst Pernicka was included in the team involved in Uwe Müller's rescue excavation.
Bronze Age hoard with 34 metal vessels and toolsKral Tepesi/Vasili
- 2004 · p. 45
Martin BartelheimExcavated
Martin Bartelheim joined the team involved in Uwe Müller's Kral Tepesi/Vasili rescue excavation.
Bronze Age hoard with 34 metal vessels and tools
- 2004 · p. 45
Uwe MüllerDirected excavations
Uwe Müller began a rescue excavation at the Kral Tepesi/Vasili hilltop after the accidental discovery of a Bronze Age hoard.
Bronze Age hoard with 34 metal vessels and toolsKral Tepesi/Vasili, near Kaleburnu/Galinoporni
- 1996 · p. 46
While surveying around Kyrenia, Müge Şevketoğlu found the site in partly disturbed condition.
Tatlısu-Çiftlikdüzü/Akanthou-Arkosyko, area around Kyrenia
- 2001 · p. 47
Serra DurugönülSurveyed
Serra Durugönül conducted a short-term survey for a comparative study of settlement patterns in Cyprus and Cilicia.
Karpas Peninsula
- 2016 · p. 47
Marko KiesselSurveyed
Marko Kiessel began the archaeological-architectural heritage rescue survey project at Aphendrika.
archaeological and architectural heritage across all epochs
- 2020 · p. 47
Erge YurtdaşSurveyed
Erge Yurtdaş surveyed prehistoric sites in the Morphou area.
- p. 63
Hazar KabaFound
Hazar Kaba discovered the sanctuary at Sykhari-Lakkin while excavating with a CMP team in the Kyrenia mountains.
- 1995–2003 · p. 84
Müge Hüseyin ŞevketoğluSurveyed
Müge Şevketoğlu conducted surveys in the Keryneia District.
- 2004–2005 · p. 84
Bülent KızıldumanSurveyed
Bülent Kızılduman surveyed Güzelyurt/Morphou.
Recording and study 13
- p. 43
Müge Hüseyin ŞevketoğluStudied
Müge Şevketoğlu contextualized the Kirni/Krini excavation findings in her doctoral thesis.
findings from the Kirni/Krini excavation
- p. 44
Ahmet Coşkun ÖzgünelStudent ofEkrem Akurgal
Çoşkun A. Özgünel, the new Salamis excavation director, was a student of Ekrem Akurgal.
- 2012 · p. 46
Alan H. SimmonsPublished
Alan Simmons included the Tatlısu/Akanthou discoveries in an article discussing Neolithic Cyprus.
discoveries at Tatlısu/Akanthou
- p. 46
N. P. Stanley PriceStudied
Nicholas Stanley-Price first identified the Tatlısu-Çiftlikdüzü/Akanthou-Arkosyko site a few years before the Turkish invasion of 1974.
- 1999 · p. 47
Müge Hüseyin ŞevketoğluStudent ofEdgar J. Peltenburg
Müge Şevketoğlu completed her dissertation under Eddie Peltenburg's supervision.
University of Edinburgh
- 1999 · p. 47
Müge Hüseyin ŞevketoğluStudent ofT. F. Watkins
Müge Şevketoğlu completed her dissertation under Trevor Watkins's supervision.
University of Edinburgh
- p. 47
Erhan ÖztepeCatalogued
Erhan Öztepe catalogued 60 previously known sites in the survey area.
Karpas Peninsula
- 2015 · p. 48
Hazar KabaStudied
Hazar Kaba studied elite tombs excavated by DoAM at Soloi for his dissertation.
Late Classical/Early Hellenistic elite tombs and their inventories
- p. 51
Martin BartelheimPublished
Martin Bartelheim published material from the Kral Tepesi/Vasili excavation.
excavated materials from Kral Tepesi/Vasili
- p. 59
Eustathios RaptouPublished
Eustathios Raptou first published a photograph of the Kumyal tomb.
rock-cut tomb with a carved helmeted headKumyal/Koma tou Gialou
- 2003–2009 · p. 60
Andreas FouliasStudied
Andreas Foulias investigated the channel system beneath Panagia tis Kyras in 2003 and 2009.
six-meter-deep channel system beneath the churchPanagia tis Kyras, Livadia, Famagusta
- 2016 · p. 60
Andreas FouliasPublished
Andreas Foulias published the results of his investigations at Panagia tis Kyras.
findings from Panagia tis KyrasLivadia, Famagusta
- p. 63
Hazar KabaStudied
Hazar Kaba researched the sanctuary at Sykhari-Lakkin.
sanctuary and votive statuettes from Sykhari-Lakkin
Posts and family 6
- 1952–1989 · p. 35
Vassos KarageorghisEmployed byDépartement des Antiquités de Chypre
Vassos Karageorghis attended the congress as interim director of the Department of Antiquities of Cyprus.
Paris
- 1992–1996 · p. 35
Vassos KarageorghisEmployed byUniversity of Cyprus
Vassos Karageorghis was professor of archaeology at the university until 1996.
- p. 35
Vassos KarageorghisEmployed byLeventis Foundation
Vassos Karageorghis later became the archaeological director of the Leventis Foundation.
- 1975 · p. 38
Nurettin YardımcıEmployed byEski Eserler Dairesi
Nurettin Yardımcı was director of the first Turkish Cypriot administration for antiquities, founded in 1975.
Nicosia
- 1975 · p. 38
Tuncer BağışkanEmployed byDoAM
Tuncer Bağışkan returned to Cyprus and joined the newly founded Turkish Cypriot Antiquities Department.
- p. 38
Nurettin YardımcıEmployed byMuseum of Bodrum
Nurettin Yardımcı had previously directed the Museum of Bodrum.
People it is cited for
67 people- Bülent Kızılduman21 citations
- Müge Hüseyin Şevketoğlu15 citations
- Tuncer Bağışkan14 citations
- Ahmet Coşkun Özgünel10 citations
- Marie-Louise Winbladh10 citations
- Martin Bartelheim10 citations
- Uwe Müller10 citations
- Vassos Karageorghis10 citations
- Ernst Pernicka9 citations
- Erge Yurtdaş8 citations
- Nurettin Yardımcı8 citations
- Ekrem Akurgal7 citations
- Ö. Lefkonuklu7 citations
- Aliye Öznergiz6 citations
- Annette Zeischka-Kenzler6 citations
- F. Caner6 citations
- Erhan Öztepe5 citations
- Rasime Öner5 citations
- Sabine Rogge5 citations
- V. Şahoğlu5 citations
- Andreas Foulias4 citations
- Gabriele Koiner4 citations
- I. Hansen4 citations
- Luca Zavagno4 citations
- Mehmetcan Soyluoğlu4 citations
- Reyhan Sabri4 citations
- Alan H. Simmons3 citations
- Andres Arvidsson3 citations
- C. M. Erek3 citations
- Ekin Kozal3 citations
37 more
- H. Tekel3 citations
- M. Özerenler3 citations
- Marc Fehlmann3 citations
- Marina Solomidou-Ieronymidou3 citations
- Rainer Feldbacher3 citations
- Robin Cormack3 citations
- Rıza Tuncel3 citations
- S. Behrendt3 citations
- Samuel Andrew Hardy3 citations
- Serra Durugönül3 citations
- T. F. Watkins3 citations
- Ymenus van der Werff3 citations
- Alexander Gillespie2 citations
- Alexander von Kienlin2 citations
- Antigoni Zournatzi2 citations
- Demetrios D. Triantaphyllopoulos2 citations
- Deniz Kahraman2 citations
- Deniz Yaşin2 citations
- Despina Pilides2 citations
- Doria Nicolaou2 citations
- Fabian Heil2 citations
- Mehmet Şöföroğlu2 citations
- N. P. Stanley Price2 citations
- Naciye Doratlı2 citations
- Olga Gorzunova2 citations
- Pontus Hellström2 citations
- Quiaowei Wei2 citations
- Reinhard Senff2 citations
- Sturt W. Manning2 citations
- Theodoros Mavrojannis2 citations
- Ali Tuncay
- Eustathios Raptou
- Franz Georg Maier
- Jacques Dalibard
- Michael J. K. Walsh
- Peg Goldberg
- Stella Diakou
Institutions it is cited for
18 institutions- Department of Antiquities and Museums (Turkish Cypriot administration)44 citations
- Eastern Mediterranean University15 citations
- Ankara University12 citations
- Eberhard Karls Universitaet Tuebingen7 citations
- ARUCAD (Arkin University of Creative Arts and Design)5 citations
- Department of Antiquities of Cyprus5 citations
- Istanbul University4 citations
- Committee on Missing Persons in Cyprus3 citations
- Cyprus International University3 citations
- Technical Committee on Cultural Heritage3 citations
- Ankara Hacı Bayram Veli University2 citations
- Keramikmuseum Westerwald2 citations
- Mersin University2 citations
- Queen's University Belfast2 citations
- Museum of Bodrum
- Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe
- UNESCO (United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization)
- University of Edinburgh
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.