Scholar · Critic / journalist
Samuel Andrew Hardy
fl. 2008–2021 · United Kingdom
British cultural property criminologist whose thesis and 2014 article argued that Greek Cypriots as well as Turkish Cypriots looted antiquities in Cyprus in 1963-1974.
Biography
Samuel Andrew Hardy is a cultural property criminologist, in his own description, who has worked with UNESCO, civil society organisations, universities and research institutes6. His doctoral thesis and a run of papers between 2008 and 2015 dealt with looting, destruction and archaeological ethics in Cyprus7.
Training and the thesis
By his own account he took a BA in Archaeology and Prehistory at Sheffield (2000-2003), an MA in Cultural Heritage Studies at University College London (2003-2004) and an MSc in Social Research Methods at Sussex (2004-2005)6. His CV gives a DPhil in Law Studies at Sussex, 2005-2010, on an ESRC studentship, passed without corrections, and he studied Modern Greek at the University of Ioannina in 2009-2010 on an IKY scholarship6. In the abstract he writes that the ruins of the Yugoslav Wars moved him to study archaeology in conflict, and that, unable to do such work in Kosovo, he went to Cyprus8. Marie Dembour was among his supervisors8.
In Cyprus his CV lists work as a heritage database assistant for SAVE in Nicosia and Famagusta in June-August 2006, and as a fieldworker on the Souskiou-Laona Settlement Project in March-April 20076.
The sources disagree on the year of the thesis, 2010 or 2011: his CV and Thomas Kiely give 2010, while his own publication list gives 2011 and the Sussex record a publication date of 12 August 20115,6,7,9. The 288-page thesis, Interrogating archaeological ethics in conflict zones, asks whether it is legal and ethical to do archaeological work in occupied and secessionist territories9. One chapter treats the theft and "rescue" of antiquities in 1963-1974, with sections on "antiquities, heroin, and terrorism" and "a silent accord with greedy collectors", and a section on the detention and death of Stephanos Stephanou8. On the excavation at Galinoporni-Vasili/Kaleburnu-Kraltepe in the north, he describes a campaign by southern Cypriot heritage workers to end it and to boycott and blacklist anyone involved8. He wrote that Michael Jansen "can only be considered a Hellenist source"8.
Papers on Cyprus
He gave papers on Cyprus at the World Archaeological Congress in Dublin in 2008, in Brussels in November 2008, in Cambridge in March 2009 on a suppressed UNESCO report, and in Vienna in April 2010 on the death of Stephanos Stephanou7. The Brussels paper became the chapter "Destruction, theft and rescue of archaeological artefacts in Cyprus, 1963-1974", which argues that Turkish nationalist criminal networks consolidated the illicit trade after 1974 and that Greek Cypriot archaeological policy contributed to it10. In it he says he erased the Turkish Cypriot place-names because of an amendment to the toponyms law of the Republic of Cyprus10. The sources give its year differently: R. S. Merrillees cited "Hardy forthcoming" in 2014, Hardy lists it as 2015, and the volume prints it from p. 3297,11,12.
His chapter in Heritage crime (Palgrave Macmillan, 2014) traces the destruction of both communities' property back at least to the burning of the cemeteries at Vasilia in 19557,13. A 2013 paper argued that leaving inconvenient facts out of archaeological and official texts is unprofessional and has led to the implicit denial of violence intended to cause ethnic cleansing14.
The 2014 article
His article in the European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 20(4), published online on 27 June 2014, studied the Cypriot civil war1,7. Citing Vassos Karageorghis, Hardy describes a government "silent accord" that let Greek Cypriots with access to the Turkish Cypriot enclaves buy illicit antiquities to "rescue" them from the market, a programme the state ended with an amnesty in 19731. He argues that the accord protected a revenue stream that incentivised pillage1.
By his count, of 16 conflict antiquities with find-spots in the 1973 Pierides catalogue, ten were probably looted by Turkish Cypriots and six by Greek Cypriots; for the 1985 catalogue he counts nine and eight1. He notes that the Severis collection, at one point over 2,500 antiquities, was formed "mainly" under the accord, after Karageorghis1. He concludes that Greek Cypriots within government control as well as Turkish Cypriots outside it pillaged the island's heritage, and argues that Greek Cypriot archaeologists blamed Turkish Cypriots for crimes committed by both communities1.
Reception and career
Neil Brodie and Simon Mackenzie called the paper "a rich historical review" of looting and collecting in Cyprus15. Lâtife Summerer says Hardy was the first to emphasise the need for open discussion of blacklisting in Cypriot archaeology, and that he found compelling evidence of objects "rescued" to the south through government engagement4. Summerer writes that, despite a highly praised dissertation, he met obstacles in his career because of his criticism of nationalist archaeological communities in Cyprus4. In his own 2014 account, an institutional contact withdrew support for an application hours before the deadline because of his thesis claims, and another institution told him he would need the prior permission of another state's antiquities department to apply16.
His CV lists him as an honorary member of the UCL Institute of Archaeology from 2013 to 2025, adjunct professor at the American University of Rome from 2014 to 2020, a UNESCO consultant in 2016, and a postdoctoral fellow of the University of Oslo at the Norwegian Institute in Rome from 2019 to 20226.
Life and work
2011
- Sussex DPhil thesis 'Interrogating archaeological ethics in conflict zones: Cultural heritage work in Cyprus' (dated 2010 in Kiely 2017 bibliography).
BrightonSamuel Andrew Hardy (2014). Using Open-Source Data to Identify Participation in the Illicit Antiquities Trade: A Case Study on the Cypriot Civil War. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 20, p. 15; T. Kiely (2017). Britain and the archaeology of Cyprus II: 1914 to the present day. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 47, 253-310
2014
27 June
Published 'Using Open-Source Data to Identify Participation in the Illicit Antiquities Trade: A Case Study on the Cypriot Civil War' (open access). Analyses find-spot and acquisition-date data in four collection catalogues: two Louvre catalogues (Caubet, Karageorghis & Yon 1981; Caubet, Hermary & Karageorghis 1992), the Pierides Foundation catalogues (1973, 1985) and the Severis catalogues (1999, 2010).- Argues from the catalogue data that Greek Cypriots as well as Turkish Cypriots looted during the 1963-74 conflict: of 16 conflict antiquities with find-spots in the 1973 Pierides catalogue 10 (62.5%) were 'probably looted by Turkish Cypriots' and 6 (37.5%) by Greek Cypriots; 288 Severis objects, 77 with find-spots, 211 with none.
- States that the 1963-74 'silent accord' (state-tolerated purchase by Greek Cypriots of antiquities from the Turkish Cypriot enclaves), named as such by Karageorghis in the 1999 Severis catalogue, ended in a 1973 amnesty legalising the collections.
Connections
4 peopleColleagues & contacts
- Connected with Pavlos Flourentzoscites Flourentzos 1977 (Athienou terracotta) as an example of uncertain find-spot statements Samuel Andrew Hardy, 2014, Using Open-Source Data to Identify Participation in the Illicit Antiquities Trade: A Case Study on the Cypriot Civil War, p. 62014
- Connected with Stella M. Lubsen-Admiraalcites her 2003 Zintilis catalogue (CCA 25) as evidence archaeologists published looting-derived find-spot data Samuel Andrew Hardy, 2014, Using Open-Source Data to Identify Participation in the Illicit Antiquities Trade: A Case Study on the Cypriot Civil War, pp. 6-72014
- Connected with Thanos N. Zintilisanalysis of the Zintilis catalogue's find-spot records; no personal contact documented Samuel Andrew Hardy, 2014, Using Open-Source Data to Identify Participation in the Illicit Antiquities Trade: A Case Study on the Cypriot Civil War, pp. 6-72014
- Connected with Vassos KarageorghisHardy names him as author of the four catalogues analysed Samuel Andrew Hardy, 2014, Using Open-Source Data to Identify Participation in the Illicit Antiquities Trade: A Case Study on the Cypriot Civil War2014
Mentioned in
9 mentionsDocuments · 2
- In Fear of Blacklisting. How the Division Shaped Archaeology in Cyprus
2023
wrote on ethics and archaeology in Cyprus
Summerer 2023
- Britain and the archaeology of Cyprus II: 1914 to the present day
Kiely 2017
On Ancient Cyprus · 3
Institutions · 1
- University of Sussex
Student (by 2011)
Hardy 2014, p. 14
- People · 3listed under Connections
Sources
- 1.Samuel Andrew Hardy (2014). “Using Open-Source Data to Identify Participation in the Illicit Antiquities Trade: A Case Study on the Cypriot Civil War”. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 20. Online
- 2.Samuel Andrew Hardy (2011). “Interrogating archaeological ethics in conflict zones: Cultural heritage work in Cyprus”. University of Sussex. Online
- 3.S. A. Hardy (2014). “Destruction, theft and rescue of archaeological artefacts in Cyprus, 1963-1974: From the intercommunal conflict until the foreign invasions”. Cypriot material culture studies: From picrolite carving to proskynetaria. Proceedings of the 8th Annual Postgraduate Cypriot Archaeology Conference. Göteborg, Paul Åströms Förlag.
- 4.Lâtife Summerer (2023). “In Fear of Blacklisting. How the Division Shaped Archaeology in Cyprus”. New Approaches toward Recording, Preserving and Studying Cultural Heritage in Divided Cyprus. Kyrenia, ARUCAD Press.
- 5.T. Kiely (2017). “Britain and the archaeology of Cyprus II: 1914 to the present day”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 47, 253-310. Online
- 6.Samuel Andrew Hardy (2026). “CV”. conflict antiquities (blog). Online
- 7.Samuel Andrew Hardy (2026). “Publications”. conflict antiquities (blog). Online
- 8.Samuel Andrew Hardy (2011). “Interrogating archaeological ethics in conflict zones: cultural heritage work in Cyprus”. DPhil thesis, University of Sussex. Online
- 9.University of Sussex (2023). “Interrogating archaeological ethics in conflict zones: cultural heritage work in Cyprus [thesis record]”. University of Sussex, Sussex Research Online / Figshare. Online
- 10.Samuel Andrew Hardy (2015). “Destruction, theft and rescue of archaeological artefacts in Cyprus, 1963-1974: from the bombs of the coup to the 'Turkish' invasion”. postprint of chapter, VUBPRESS volume. Online
- 11.Robert Stuart Merrillees (2014). “George Basil Palma, Chemist and Collector of Cypriote Antiquities in Famagusta, Cyprus, in the 20th Century A.D.”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 44, 401-429. Online
- 12.A. Jacobs and P. Cosyns (eds.) (2015). Cypriot material culture studies, from picrolite carving to proskynitaria analysis: Proceedings of the 8th Annual Postgraduate Cypriot Archaeology Conference. VUBPRESS.
- 13.Samuel Andrew Hardy (2013). “Threats to cultural heritage in the Cyprus Conflict”. draft of chapter in Heritage Crime (Palgrave Macmillan, 2014). Online
- 14.Samuel Hardy (2013). “Maintained in Very Good Condition or Virtually Rebuilt? Destruction of Cultural Property and Narration of Violent Histories”. Papers from the Institute of Archaeology 23(1): 14, pp. 1-9. Online
- 15.Neil Brodie and Simon Mackenzie (2014). “Trafficking Cultural Objects: Introduction”. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 20. Online
- 16.Samuel Andrew Hardy (2014). “Obstacles to Career Progression in Archaeology: Precarious Labour and Unemployment”. Papers from the Institute of Archaeology 24(1): 21, pp. 1-6. Online
- 17.Samuel Andrew Hardy, 2014, Using Open-Source Data to Identify Participation in the Illicit Antiquities Trade: A Case Study on the Cypriot Civil War.
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- Date of birth unknown
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.