Dealer
Peg Goldberg
b. 1939 · United States
Indiana art dealer who bought four mosaics from the Panagia Kanakaria in Geneva in 1988 and lost them to the Church of Cyprus in a civil case decided in 1989 and upheld in 1990.
Key factsBorn 1939–1940
- Born
- 1939–1940
- Nationality
- United States
- Roles
- Dealer
- Institutions
- Merchants National Bank (Indianapolis)lender: letter of intent for GBP 3 million (Modigliani pretext, early 1988), then a $1.2m loan for the mosaics; chaired by Otto N. Frenzel III, with a Mr Massey also named (Hofstadter), July–July 1988
- Baker & Daniels (Indianapolis law firm)her defence counsel in Cyprus v. Goldberg (Joe Emerson); recommended by Frenzel, March 1989 – 1990
- Arnold & Porter (Washington law firm)retained for the Supreme Court petition after the appeal; Hofstadter says the firm is on retainer to the American Association of Dealers in Ancient, Oriental, and Primitive Art, and that who paid it was not disclosed to him, 1990–1991
- Places
- Indianapolis, Geneva (free port, airport), Panagia Kanakaria church, Lythrankomi (source of the mosaics)
- Also known as
- Goldberg; Goldberg & Feldman Fine Arts
Biography
800 words · about 3 minutes
Peg Goldberg was an art dealer with a gallery in Carmel, Indiana, who in July 1988 bought four early Christian mosaics taken from a church in northern Cyprus and lost them to the Church of Cyprus in the American courts9.
The sources disagree on where she was born: Fred Swift, in a 2014 local newspaper column, gives Spencer, Indiana, in 193910. The IFAR Reports of 1989 give Bloomington5. Dan Hofstadter writes that she grew up in Owen County, in southern Indiana, playing the organ for her church3. She took a B.A. cum laude in sociology and psychology at Indiana University, where she was elected to Phi Beta Kappa, and in 1961 enrolled in the M.A. programme at Christian Theological Seminary, studying psychological counselling3. She then worked as a caseworker for the Marion County welfare department, and from 1970, for eight years, as director of special services for the county's retarded citizens3. She had assembled a small collection, mostly prints and drawings, and dealt in nineteenth- and twentieth-century art3,5. In the spring of 1986 she ran for county commissioner and won, aided by her neighbour Otto N. Frenzel III, of an Indiana banking family3.
Amsterdam and Geneva
In late June 1988 Goldberg went to Amsterdam in pursuit of a Modigliani for a client5. There Robert Fitzgerald, another Indiana dealer and a "casual friend", led her to consider the purchase of four mosaics9. Michel van Rijn told her they had been retrieved from the rubble of a church in northern Cyprus destroyed during the Turkish invasion of 1974, and guessed she could have them for about three million dollars3. The IFAR report of 1990 says she knew that van Rijn had been convicted in absentia in France for forging a Chagall signature11.
On 3 July 1988 she agreed to buy the mosaics from Aydın Dikmen3. The appeals court records that she, van Rijn, Fitzgerald and the lawyer Faulk agreed on a price of $1,080,000 and a split of any resale profit of 50 per cent to her, 22.5 per cent each to Fitzgerald and van Rijn, and 5 per cent to Faulk9. Faulk had already signed, as van Rijn's agent, a contract to buy the pieces from Dikmen for $350,0009. The sources give the bank loan differently: Hofstadter and the appeals court say $1.2 million from Merchants National Bank, arranged through Frenzel, while IFAR gives $1,224,0003,5,9. She telephoned UNESCO's office in Geneva to ask whether any treaties barred the removal of items from northern Cyprus to Germany9.
On 5 July she inspected four crates at Geneva airport beside a man she took to be Dikmen3. On 7 July she handed over $1,080,000 in $100 bills to Faulk and Fitzgerald and kept $120,000; the court found that $350,000 of it went to Dikmen9. She flew home with the mosaics on 8 July and declared them, at $1.2 million, and the cash on entering the United States5,9. Geza von Habsburg offered them to the Getty Museum for $20 million, which Goldberg said was done without her knowledge3,5.
The case
In March 1989 the Republic of Cyprus and the Church of Cyprus sued her and her firm5. The trial opened in Indianapolis in late May 1989 before Judge James E. Noland3. On 3 August 1989 Noland ruled that the mosaics belonged to the Church and must be delivered to it: under Indiana law she had acquired no valid ownership3. He called the circumstances "highly suspicious", found her checking inadequate for a good-faith purchaser under Swiss law, and held that her export document was unrelated to the pieces5. Her only record of her calls to the authorities was a note in her rolodex reading "IFAR-OK" and "UNESCO-no treaties"5. Hofstadter argues that a $1.2 million bill of sale she had shown her bank made it hard for the court not to conclude she had knowingly joined a contract with a false price; she testified that she had told Frenzel she would withhold $120,000, which Frenzel in deposition denied knowing3. Goldberg told Hofstadter she did not feel she had done any wrong3.
She appealed, and the Seventh Circuit affirmed on 24 October 1990 on Indiana law alone9. A concurring opinion found that she "does not appear to have been a good faith purchaser"9. Hofstadter dates the Supreme Court's refusal to hear her both to "the spring of 1991" and to "late February 1991"3.
Hofstadter judges that "in some perilously passive way she played along" with the middlemen3. An article in the International Journal of Cultural Property says she bought after "only the most cursory of investigations"12. Swift writes that she later married a Richmond musician, moved to Naples, Florida, opened a gallery there, and was widowed in 200310. She died in 2012, according to Swift, and an IFAR review of that year says she had "just recently died"10,13.
Life and work
13 events, 1981–1990
1981
- Left social work and began dealing in nineteenth- and twentieth-century art.
1986
- Won election as county commissioner (Indianapolis area), helped by neighbour Otto N. Frenzel III.
1988
1 July
In Amsterdam, after the Modigliani she had come to see (offered by dealer Jack Vecht) proved in her view a fake, Fitzgerald introduced Ronald Faulk as his lawyer and, next day at lunch, Michel van Rijn, who showed her photographs of four mosaics (Hofstadter). Hoover dates the Amsterdam meetings 1 July 1988.AmsterdamDan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux; Deborah Hoover (1990). Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet. Journal of Arts Management and Law 20, 37-62. Routledge, p. 11-12
3 July
Agreed to buy the four mosaics from the seller (Aydin Dikmen, whom Faulk had visited in Munich) for 'a little over a million dollars'; unsigned purchase agreement pending inspection in Geneva. Gallery to own the pieces outright; Fitzgerald and van Rijn to share half of resale proceeds (22.5% each) and Faulk 5% of that half. She hoped to bargain the price down once the $1.2m Merchants Bank loan reached a Geneva correspondent bank. Dikmen had first been said to want about $3m.5 July
Faxed Merchants National Bank (Frenzel and Massey) a description of the mosaics, ending 'All are depicted in the publication of Dumbarton Oaks, a copy of which will be given to you upon my return'. At trial Kline used it against her claim that she learned of the Dumbarton Oaks monograph only some six weeks after returning to the US. The fax misnamed two of the pieces (St Paul, St Luke) where the inscriptions read James and Matthew.5 July 1988 – 8 July 1988
In Geneva (Hotel des Bergues) she phoned customs offices and agencies about thefts but, per Hofstadter, called no Greek or Turkish Cypriot government office; on 5 July she inspected the four crates at the airport freehold section, with a man she took to be Dikmen; the money was paid in cash and the sale completed (Hoover: by 8 July); she flew home with the mosaics. Hofstadter's second-hand account of the cash handover (two gym bags, Faulk carrying Dikmen's share) is Savo Kujundzic's reconstruction, not testimony.GenevaDan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux; Deborah Hoover (1990). Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet. Journal of Arts Management and Law 20, 37-62. Routledge, p. 12; Patty Gerstenblith (2015). For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution. International Journal of Cultural Property
1988–1989
Marion True, Getty antiquities curator, warned of possible flaws in title after Habsburg's offer, and notified Cyprus (Karageorghis) that four Early Christian works had appeared on the market (Hofstadter, Gerstenblith). The Embassy of Cyprus then took steps; Cyprus filed suit for recovery in federal court, Indianapolis, on 29 March 1989.IndianapolisPatty Gerstenblith (2015). For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution. International Journal of Cultural Property; Deborah Hoover (1990). Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet. Journal of Arts Management and Law 20, 37-62. Routledge, p. 12; Dan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux
1988–1991
Indianapolis dealer who bought the Kanakaria mosaics for ~$1.08m in Geneva (1988); US courts ruled for Cyprus (Church of Cyprus v. Goldberg, 1989–90); returned 1991.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade, p. 188
1989
April–May
Depositions: hers taken by Kline in late April-May 1989. Deponents included Constantine Leventis (Cyprus's UNESCO ambassador), Walter Hopps and Dominique de Menil (the Menil Foundation had bought the Lysi frescoes from Dikmen in 1983-84 and Hopps testified Petsopoulos had arranged the return of the two Kanakaria roundels in 1984), Faulk and Fitzgerald. These went to her argument that Cyprus knew of Dikmen and sat on its rights.Indianapolis; HoustonDan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux
2 June
At trial Kline asked Fitzgerald if van Rijn had paid Dikmen only $350,000; Faulk had produced in discovery a secret agreement among the three middlemen showing that figure and said he received $80,000 of the difference. Fitzgerald testified $70,000-odd went to a London attorney and $580,000 was divided between himself and van Rijn, and that he refused to tell her because it was none of her business. Hofstadter reports this as testimony and an exhibit.3 August
Judge James E. Noland (S.D. Indiana) ruled that the four mosaics belonged to the Church of Cyprus and were to be delivered to it. Court findings as reported by Hofstadter: Indiana law applied, so she had acquired no valid title since the Church never sold or gave them; in the alternative, under Swiss law her due diligence was inadequate for six stated reasons (war-torn country, sacred/immovable nature, price below appraisals suggesting a hot origin, unknown seller reputation, suspect middlemen, undue haste). Trial was in late May-June 1989 (Church's witness Father Pavlos Maheriotis; expert Gary Vikan; Fitzgerald on 2 June; Goldberg on the penultimate day); Cyprus counsel Thomas Kline (Manatt, Phelps), hers Joe Emerson and Jay Yeager (Baker & Daniels).IndianapolisDan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux; Deborah Hoover (1990). Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet. Journal of Arts Management and Law 20, 37-62. Routledge, p. 11-14
Named
Her contentions, as reported by Hofstadter: she appealed in the belief that Cypriot officials had 'dirty hands' and had struck bargains with Dikmen, and she later sought evidence of collusion (Ahmet Aziz, Mehmet, Kujundzic); her counsel Emerson argued Cyprus had 'slept on its rights' since 1979 (the 1982 Ortam article with a photo of the mosaics). Not findings; Noland allowed the trial to go forward and Hofstadter reports the Court of Appeals upheld the decision.
1990
May
Savo Kujundzic gave a videotaped deposition for her appeal (Kline boycotted it as untimely); on 3 Aug 1990 Emerson filed a motion to set aside the judgment, denied about three months later because even if wholly true the statement 'did not radically undermine the Cypriot case'. The Court of Appeals had meanwhile upheld Noland's decision.
Trade and objects
27 records · 1 object
Through their hands
27 recordsCame from
- 1988Purchase
PurchaseAllegedFincham alleged that Dikmen sold looted sixth-century mosaics to Peg Goldberg.
Bought from Aydın Dikmensixth-century mosaics looted from a separate Church in CyprusFincham 2015, p. 305
- 1988Purchase
PurchasePeg Goldberg agreed to buy the mosaics from the Turk for a little over a million dollars.
Bought from Aydın Dikmena little over a million dollarsGerstenblith 2015, p. 358Hofstadter 1994, p. 44Hofstadter 1994, p. 163Hoover 1990, p. 46
- 1988Purchase
PurchasePeg Goldberg gave Ronald Faulk cash in exchange for claim tickets to the pieces.
Bought from Ronald FaulkGenevaHofstadter 1994, p. 161
- 1988Help
HelpIcons and church artRobert Fitzgerald informed Peg Goldberg that the four mosaics were available.
Helped by Robert FitzgeraldAmsterdamHofstadter 1994, p. 217Hoover 1990, p. 45Sullivan 1991, p. 234
- 1988Purchase
PurchaseIcons and church artMichel van Rijn sold mosaics to Peg Goldberg as part of the transaction in which she paid the dealers $1.08 million.
Bought from Michel van Rijnfour 6th-century Byzantine mosaics$282,500the free-port area of the Geneva airportHofstadter 1994, p. 217Kaiser 1990, p. 206
- 1988Meeting
MeetingPeg Goldberg met Robert Fitzgerald while she was on a buying trip in Amsterdam.
Met Robert Fitzgeraldfour mosaicsHoover 1990, p. 45
- 1988Meeting
MeetingPeg Goldberg met Michel van Rijn about the mosaics.
- 1988Meeting
MeetingPeg Goldberg met Ronald Faulk about the mosaics.
- 1988Purchase
PurchaseRobert Fitzgerald sold mosaics to Peg Goldberg as part of the transaction in which she paid the dealers $1.08 million.
Bought from Robert Fitzgeraldfour 6th-century Byzantine mosaics$282,500the free-port area of the Geneva airportKaiser 1990, p. 206
- 1988Purchase
PurchaseIcons and church artPeg Goldberg bought the mosaics from an art dealer in 1988 for 1,080,000.
With an art dealer from IndianapolisKanakaria church apse mosaics1,080,000Free-port area of Zurich airportBlake 1994, p. 286
- 1988Record
RecordIcons and church artThe four mosaics were located in Peg Goldberg's possession in Indianapolis.
four mosaics depicting the child Christ, an archangel and the apostles James and MatthewIndianapolis, USALyssiotis 2008, p. 52
- 1989Note
NoteThe Republic of Cyprus filed a recovery action against Peg Goldberg for the mosaics.
Connected with Republic of Cyprusfour Kanakariá mosaicsIndianapolisHofstadter 1994, p. 54
Show 15 moreShow fewer
- 1989Note
NoteJudge Noland ruled that the mosaics belonged to the Church of Cyprus and should be delivered into its custody.
Connected with Church of Cyprusfour mosaicsHofstadter 1994, p. 82
- 1989Purchase
PurchaseIcons and church artA purchase agreement dated July 3, 1989 showed Peg paid $1.08 million for the mosaics.
With the middlemen$1.08 millionHofstadter 1994, p. 81
- 1989Record
RecordIcons and church artA new agreement allowed Peg and the other signatories to buy the items by exercising Michel's option.
With the Turkish gentlemanthe Hand and Feet plus AndrewHofstadter 1994, p. 50
- n.d.Sale
SaleIcons and church artPeg Goldberg tried to sell the mosaics initially to the Getty Trust.
- n.d.Agency
AgencyGeza von Habsburg proposed arranging a private sale of Peg Goldberg's mosaics.
Represented by Geza von HabsburgHofstadter 1994, p. 49
- n.d.Meeting
MeetingPeg Goldberg, Robert Fitzgerald, and Ronald Faulk met Aydin Dikman in Geneva.
Met Aydın Dikmenthe mosaicsHoover 1990, p. 46
- n.d.Sale
SalePeg Goldberg offered the mosaics for $20 million when she contacted Geza von Hapsburg.
Sold to Geza von Habsburg$20 millionKaiser 1990, p. 206
- n.d.Note
NoteVan Rijn told Goldberg the Kanakaria mosaics were available.
Connected with Michel van RijnAmsterdamSullivan 1991, p. 235
- n.d.Help
HelpFrenzel helped arrange a loan so Goldberg could make the purchase.
Helped by Otto N. Frenzel IIIloan for Goldberg's purchase of the mosaicsUS1,224,000Sullivan 1991, p. 235
- n.d.Sale
SaleGoldberg marketed the mosaics to the Getty Museum for US$20 million, but the offer was declined.
Sold to Getty Museummosaic fragmentsUS$20 millionMalibu, CaliforniaSullivan 1991, p. 236
- n.d.Lawsuit
LawsuitIcons and church artGoldberg was sued by the Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus over the mosaics.
In litigation with Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of CyprusKanakaria mosaicsIndianaSullivan 1991, p. 233
- n.d.Lawsuit
LawsuitGoldberg was sued by the Republic of Cyprus over the mosaics.
In litigation with Republic of CyprusKanakaria mosaicsIndianaSullivan 1991, p. 233
- n.d.Purchase
PurchaseIcons and church artPeg Goldberg bought four Early Christian devotional mosaics in Europe for a little more than a million dollars, using money borrowed from an Indiana bank.
four Early Christian devotional mosaics, each about two feet squarea little more than a million dollarsHofstadter 1994, p. 17
- n.d.Record
RecordPeg Goldberg entered into side agreements with various parties to divide the resale profits.
With various partiesthe mosaicsHoover 1990, p. 59
- n.d.Purchase
PurchasepossiblyGoldberg's transaction for the mosaics was consummated, but the bill of sale did not identify Dikman as the seller.
With Aydin Dikman (or someone claiming to be him)portions of the mosaic compositionGenevaSullivan 1991, p. 235
Objects
1 objectFour mosaics from the apse of the Panagia Kanakaria church: Christ Child, Archangel Michael, apostles James and Matthew (c. 530 per Hoover)
From Panagia Kanakaria, LythrankomiByzantine Museum, Nicosia (Makarios III Foundation) after return; per Hofstadter seen in a back room of the Byzantine Museum in Sept 1991July 1988
Patty Gerstenblith (2015). For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution. International Journal of Cultural Property; Deborah Hoover (1990). Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet. Journal of Arts Management and Law 20, 37-62. Routledge, p. 11-12; Lâtife Summerer (2023). In Fear of Blacklisting. How the Division Shaped Archaeology in Cyprus. New Approaches toward Recording, Preserving and Studying Cultural Heritage in Divided Cyprus. Kyrenia, ARUCAD Press; Dan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux
Connections
22 people
Sales, gifts & bequests
- Bought from Aydın DikmenAllegedFincham alleged that Dikmen sold looted sixth-century mosaics to Peg Goldberg. Fincham 2015, p. 3051988–1989
- Represented by Geza von HabsburgGeza von Habsburg proposed arranging a private sale of Peg Goldberg's mosaics. Hofstadter 1994, p. 491988–1989
- Agent for Geza von HabsburgDan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1988–1989
- Bought from Michel van RijnIcons and church artMichel van Rijn sold mosaics to Peg Goldberg as part of the transaction in which she paid the dealers $1.08 million. Hofstadter 1994, p. 217Kaiser 1990, p. 2061988–1998
- Financed by Otto N. Frenzel IIIMerchants National Bank loan for the mosaics; later took over the note D. Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1988–1991
- Bought from Robert FitzgeraldRobert Fitzgerald sold mosaics to Peg Goldberg as part of the transaction in which she paid the dealers $1.08 million. Kaiser 1990, p. 2061988
- Bought from Ronald FaulkPeg Goldberg gave Ronald Faulk cash in exchange for claim tickets to the pieces. Hofstadter 1994, p. 1611988
- Received from Michel van RijnGoldberg sale to the tune of $250,000 www.ourivesariaportuguesa.info, Culture Without Context, Nº1 to 201990
- Represented by Aydın DikmenKanakaria mosaics Non-State Actors in the Protection of Cultural Heritage (2021), p. 72
- Sold to Geza von HabsburgPeg Goldberg offered the mosaics for $20 million when she contacted Geza von Hapsburg. Kaiser 1990, p. 206
Fieldwork & employment
- Employed Joe Emersondefence counsel in the Kanakaria mosaics case Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1988–1990
- Employed by Myron VoraxKanakaria mosaics Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters (1991), p. 2351988
Disputes & the law
- Subject of testimony by Constantine Leventisdeposition for Cyprus in Cyprus v. Goldberg Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade1989
- In litigation with Constantine LeventisDan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989
- Testified about Dominique de MenilDeposed in Houston; the Menil Foundation had bought the Lysi frescoes from Dikmen and ransomed them for Cyprus Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989
- Subject of testimony by Gary Vikantestified against her purchase of the Kanakaria mosaics Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989
- Testified about Gary VikanWalters Art Gallery curator, expert witness for the plaintiffs; said he would have 'walked' Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989
- In litigation with James E. NolandTrial judge James E. Noland, S.D. Indiana; ruled 3 Aug 1989 Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989
- In litigation with Thomas R. KlineKline (Manatt, Phelps, Washington) was chief counsel for Cyprus and the Church; cross-examined her at trial Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989–1990
- Testified about Walter HoppsMenil curator whose deposition said Petsopoulos got Dikmen to return two Kanakaria roundels in 1984 and that Cyprus had dealt with Dikmen; resigned within hours of testifying (Hofstadter) Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989
- Subject of testimony by Walter HoppsCyprus v. Goldberg; Goldberg's lawyer subpoenaed Hopps D. Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989
- In litigation with Republic of CyprusAnne McC. Sullivan, 1991, Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters, p. 233
Scholarship
- Corresponded with Özgen AcarpossiblyHofstadter says Goldberg obtained information from Acar's reporting; the page read says only that Acar's series existed and 'it was absurd to suppose the Greek Cypriots did not monitor such reports' Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989
Colleagues & contacts
- Connected with Marion TrueKanakaria mosaic fragments; Kanakaria mosaics litigation IFAR Journal Incorporating Stolen Art Alert (2012)1986–1989
- Worked with Michel van RijnByzantine mosaics The Parthenon Sculptures and Cultural Justice (2012), p. 10031988
- Met Michel van RijnPeg Goldberg met Michel van Rijn about the mosaics. Hoover 1990, p. 451988
- Connected with Otto N. Frenzel IIIKanakaria purchase; banker friend; arranged/assisted loan from Merchants Bank for the mosaics purchase; later creditor Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1988–1991
- Worked with Otto N. Frenzel IIILaw and diplomacy in cultural property matters (1991), p. 2351988
- Connected with Republic of CyprusKanakaria mosaics Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade, p. 54; Kulturgüter als res extra commercium im internationalen Sachenrecht (2001), p. 137; IFAR Reports, Formerly the Stolen Art Alert and Art Research News (1989)1988–1990
- Met Robert FitzgeraldPeg Goldberg met Robert Fitzgerald while she was on a buying trip in Amsterdam. Hoover 1990, p. 451988
- Helped by Robert FitzgeraldIcons and church artRobert Fitzgerald informed Peg Goldberg that the four mosaics were available. Hofstadter 1994, p. 217Hoover 1990, p. 45Sullivan 1991, p. 2341988
- Connected with Robert FitzgeraldByzantine mosaics The Goldberg Case: A Confirmation of the Difficulty in Acquiring Good Title to Valuable Stolen Cultural Objects (1992), p. 1531988
- Worked with Robert FitzgeraldByzantine mosaics The Parthenon Sculptures and Cultural Justice (2012), p. 10031988
- Met Ronald FaulkPeg Goldberg met Ronald Faulk about the mosaics. Hoover 1990, p. 451988
- Worked with Ronald FaulkDeborah Hoover, 1990, Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet, p. 11-12; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1988
- Worked with Stewart BickIndianapolis physician who bought half of van Rijn's and Fitzgerald's resale interests for $780,000; co-signed the 10 Feb 1989 option agreement Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1988–1989
- Connected with Vassos KarageorghisNotified of the mosaics by the Getty; Cypriot Director of Antiquities Patty Gerstenblith, For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1988–1989
Show 8 moreShow fewer
- Connected with Özgen AcarpossiblyTurkish journalist whose 1989 Cumhuriyet series on Dikmen and Cypriot looting fed her argument that Cyprus knew of Dikmen Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989
- Connected with Stavros MihalariaspossiblyLondon restorer named by van Rijn as intermediary for an icon, and by Savo as present at a London Sotheby's meeting with Dikmen and Leventis; no dealings with Goldberg Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989–1990
- Connected with Yanni PetsopoulosLondon dealer named in testimony as intermediary between Dikmen and Cyprus/Menil; Leventis said he arranged the 1984 return of two roundels; he did not testify (Hofstadter) Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989
- Connected with Aydın Dikmenmosaics of Judas and Thomas from Panagia Kanakaria www.ourivesariaportuguesa.info, Culture Without Context, Nº1 to 201990–1997
- Met Aydın DikmenPeg Goldberg, Robert Fitzgerald, and Ronald Faulk met Aydin Dikman in Geneva. Hoover 1990, p. 46
- Met Dan Hofstadterinterviews; he describes talking to her after the 1991 Supreme Court refusal Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade
- Connected with Michel van RijnVan Rijn told Goldberg the Kanakaria mosaics were available. Sullivan 1991, p. 235
- Helped by Otto N. Frenzel IIIFrenzel helped arrange a loan so Goldberg could make the purchase. Sullivan 1991, p. 235
Mentions
Where else on Ancient Cyprus this person appears
Mentioned in
38 mentionsDocuments · 9
- Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade
Purchase · 1988 · 44, 163; p. 161; p. 54; p. 82; p. 81; p. 50; p. 17
Peg Goldberg agreed to buy the mosaics from the Turk for a little over a million dollars.
Hofstadter 1994
Also in Gerstenblith 2015; Hoover 1990
- About Cyprus
1988 · p. 52
The four mosaics were located in Peg Goldberg's possession in Indianapolis.
Lyssiotis 2008
- The Protection of Turkey's Underwater Archaeological Heritage - Legislative Measures and Other Approaches
Purchase · 1988 · p. 286
Peg Goldberg bought the mosaics from an art dealer in 1988 for 1,080,000.
Blake 1994
- The Antiquities Market
Sale · 1990 · p. 206
Peg Goldberg offered the mosaics for $20 million when she contacted Geza von Hapsburg.
Kaiser 1990
- Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters
Sale, purchase · 1991 · pp. 235, 236
Goldberg marketed the mosaics to the Getty Museum for US$20 million, but the offer was declined.
Sullivan 1991
- The Rescue, Stewardship, and Return of the Lysi Frescoes by the Menil Foundation
2015
bought Cypriot mosaics
Fincham 2015
On Ancient Cyprus · 2
Institutions · 11
- J. Paul Getty Museum
Sold · 1987
Sullivan 1991, p. 236
- Merchants National Bank
1988
Peg Goldberg's letters and a faxed description (5 July 1988) went to Merchants National Bank for a loan to buy four Byzantine mosaics from Cyprus; the bank's…
Hofstadter 1994
- Baker & Daniels
1989
Retained as Peg Goldberg's counsel (Joe Emerson and Jay Yeager) on Nick Frenzel's recommendation, ahead of Cyprus's federal suit in Indianapolis (filed 29…
Hofstadter 1994
- Byzantine Museum and Art Gallery, Archbishop Makarios III Foundation
Object from them · 1989
The four Kanakaria apse mosaics (Christ Child, Archangel Michael and others), lost by Peg Goldberg at the 1989 Indianapolis trial and later shown in…
Hofstadter 1994; Hoover 1990, p. 11-12
- Church of Cyprus
1989
Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus v. Goldberg, Indianapolis: Judge Noland held the four Kanakaria mosaics belonged to the Church of Cyprus, which…
Hofstadter 1994
- Goldberg & Feldman Fine Arts, Inc.
Owner · 1989
Named as defendant firm in Cyprus's replevin suit in federal court in Indianapolis over the four Kanakaria mosaics bought by Peg Goldberg
Gerstenblith 2015; Hofstadter 1994
- People · 16listed under Connections
Sources
43 works and documents
- 1.Patty Gerstenblith (2015). “For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution”. International Journal of Cultural Property. Online
- 2.Deborah Hoover (1990). “Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet”. Journal of Arts Management and Law 20, 37-62. Routledge. Online
- 3.Dan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
- 4.Lâtife Summerer (2023). “In Fear of Blacklisting. How the Division Shaped Archaeology in Cyprus”. New Approaches toward Recording, Preserving and Studying Cultural Heritage in Divided Cyprus. Kyrenia, ARUCAD Press.
- 5.Constance Lowenthal (1989). “Cyprus Wins Mosaics in Indiana Court”. IFAR Reports 10, 3-4.
- 6. (1991). Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters. p. 235.
- 7.Culture Without Context (n.d.). “Culture Without Context, nos. 1 to 20”.
- 8. (1992). “The Goldberg Case: A Confirmation of the Difficulty in Acquiring Good Title to Valuable Stolen Cultural Objects”. p. 154.
- 9.United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit (1990). “Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus and the Republic of Cyprus v. Goldberg and Feldman Fine Arts, Inc., and Peg Goldberg”. Federal Reporter, Second Series 917, 278-300. Online
- 10.Fred Swift (2014). “Ancient art had hidden costs for Carmel art dealer”. Current in Carmel (Current Publishing). Online
- 11.Constance Lowenthal (1990). “Goldberg Appeal Denied in Cyprus Mosaics Case”. IFAR Reports 11, 8.
- 12.[author not read]. “[Article on the Kanakaria mosaics case]”. International Journal of Cultural Property (doi 10.1017/S094073911500017X).
- 13.[unsigned in the index text] (2012). “[Review of Jason Felch and Ralph Frammolino, Chasing Aphrodite]”. IFAR Journal Incorporating Stolen Art Alert 13.
- 14.Derek Fincham (2015). “The Rescue, Stewardship, and Return of the Lysi Frescoes by the Menil Foundation”. International Journal of Cultural Property. Online
- 15.Anne McC. Sullivan (1991). “Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters”. Museum Management and Curatorship 10, 219-243. Routledge. Online
- 16.Timothy Kaiser (1990). “The Antiquities Market”. Journal of Field Archaeology 17, 205-210. Online
- 17.Janet Blake (1994). “The Protection of Turkey's Underwater Archaeological Heritage - Legislative Measures and Other Approaches”. International Journal of Cultural Property 3. Online
- 18.Polly Lyssiotis (2008). About Cyprus.
- 19.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 20.Derek Fincham, 2015, The Rescue, Stewardship, and Return of the Lysi Frescoes by the Menil Foundation.
- 21.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade; Timothy Kaiser, 1990, The Antiquities Market.
- 22.www.ourivesariaportuguesa.info, Culture Without Context, Nº1 to 20.
- 23.Non-State Actors in the Protection of Cultural Heritage (2021).
- 24.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade.
- 25.IFAR Journal Incorporating Stolen Art Alert (2012).
- 26.Anne McC. Sullivan, 1991, Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters.
- 27.Timothy Kaiser, 1990, The Antiquities Market; Anne McC. Sullivan, 1991, Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade.
- 28.The Parthenon Sculptures and Cultural Justice (2012).
- 29.D. Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 30.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 31.Patty Gerstenblith, 2015, For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution, p. 358; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade, p. 44; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 32.Deborah Hoover, 1990, Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet.
- 33.Timothy Kaiser, 1990, The Antiquities Market.
- 34.Patty Gerstenblith, For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution; Deborah Hoover, 1990, Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet, p. 12; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 35.Deborah Hoover, 1990, Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet, p. 11-12; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 36.Deborah Hoover, 1990, Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet, p. 11; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 37.Patty Gerstenblith, For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 38.Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters (1991).
- 39.Kulturgüter als res extra commercium im internationalen Sachenrecht (2001).
- 40.IFAR Reports, Formerly the Stolen Art Alert and Art Research News (1989).
- 41.Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus v. Goldberg, 717 F. Supp. 1374 (S.D. Ind. 1989).
- 42.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade, p. 217; Deborah Hoover, 1990, Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet.
- 43.The Goldberg Case: A Confirmation of the Difficulty in Acquiring Good Title to Valuable Stolen Cultural Objects (1992).
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.