Dealer · Collector
Aydın Dikmen
1937–2020 · Türkiye
Turkish dealer in Munich who sold the Lysi frescoes to the Menil Foundation and the Kanakaria mosaics to Peg Goldberg; police seized thousands of objects from his flats in 1997.
Key factsBorn 15 October 1937; died 2020
- Born
- 15 October 1937
- Died
- 2020
- Nationality
- Türkiye
- Roles
- Dealer, Collector
- Places
- Konya, Munich, Kanakaria (Lythrankomi), Panagia Kanakaria, Lysi, church of St Euphemianos / Themonianos, Kyrenia, Geneva, Famagusta District
- Also known as
- Aydin Dikmen
- Elsewhere
Biography
1,500 words · about 6 minutes
Aydın Dikmen was the Turkish dealer living in Munich who sold the Lysi frescoes to the Menil Foundation and the Kanakaria mosaics to the dealer Peg Goldberg, and from whose Munich flats Bavarian police recovered more than 4,000 antiquities4,12,13.
Konya and the first charges
Wikipedia gives his birth date as 15 October 19379. Dan Hofstadter writes that a man calling himself Aydin Dikmen first drew international notice in the late 1960s over thefts from the excavation of Çatal Hüyük, when he boasted to the British journalists Kenneth Pearson and Patricia Connor1. Hofstadter describes him then as a young technical draughtsman and part-time jazz drummer living in Konya1. Samuel Andrew Hardy, citing Erbil, writes that Dikmen was perhaps first arrested in 1966 over looting at Çatalhöyük and Hacılar, and, citing Acar, that police raided his home in Konya and seized 296 cultural objects on 18 October 196617. According to Erbil, as Hardy reports, a record for antiquities trading kept Dikmen from getting a collecting permit in Turkey17.
Hofstadter says that from 1963 Dikmen made contacts in Cyprus, meeting the smuggler Ali Mehmet Ali and the antiquities merchant Yekta Remzi1. In Hofstadter's account, Dikmen stepped up his buying and smuggling after the Turkish invasion of 1974, and in 1977 Turkish police traced a trunk of icons bound for Yugoslavia to his associate Atilla Önder in the Grand Bazaar1. Hardy, citing Acar, writes of a 1977 case of antiquities found in suitcases on a bus in Munich, in which Önder and Yaşar Tekin, held in Istanbul, named Dikmen as the owner, and that he and his wife escaped the police17. Hofstadter adds that the police raided Dikmen's villa in Konya in 1977, but that he escaped and bribed his way back into good standing1.
The churches of the north
Hofstadter judges that it was "almost certainly" Dikmen's team that stripped many of the most important Byzantine churches in Cyprus, naming Lysi, Kanakaria, Ayios Giorgios, Ayios Varnavas, Panayia Theotokos, the Armenian Church and Antiphonitis1. Hofstadter thinks it "possible, even probable" that Dikmen was not present at most of these operations, but writes that "the scent of his money seems to have triggered them"1. Hofstadter calls him "the most destructive art thief to appear in Europe since the end of World War II"1. Hardy writes that Dikmen's gang took works of art from at least fifty religious heritage sites and other cultural heritage institutions in the areas under Turkish occupation17. Acar, as Hardy cites him, called Dikmen the "International Boss" and Mehmet Ali İlkman his "Local Boss"17.
Derek Fincham writes that Dikmen organised a team of looters who systematically robbed churches, employing agents who scouted sites and collected pieces, men who carried the materials for stripping frescoes and mosaics, and a retired policeman as lookout4. Michel van Rijn, as Fincham reports, described the alleged method: frescoes covered with gauze and plaster, backed with stiff material, cut into sections and taken off the walls4. Fincham says Dikmen oversaw the smuggling to the Turkish mainland, after which the objects were stored in flats in Munich4. Van Rijn, cited by Hardy, says Dikmen's links with senior Turkish army officers had him jokingly called the "official archaeologist" of the occupying force17. Leah Marangos, citing O'Connell-Schizas, reports eyewitness accounts that the Turkish army told Dikmen of plans to destroy churches so that he could take "things that mattered"18.
Hofstadter writes that Turkish Cypriot police arrested Dikmen in 1982, and Hardy that he was quickly released1,17. The Turkish Cypriot newspaper Ortam alleged, as Judge Noland paraphrased it and Hardy reports, that his wife, Konstantina ("Coco") Dikmen, paid a large sum into a judge's bank account17. Hardy notes a record of 1989 that the Turkish Cypriot administration under Denktaş gave Dikmen citizenship17.
Lysi and Kanakaria
Fincham writes that the seller of the Lysi frescoes offered to the Menil in 1983 was Dikmen, who did not give their true origin4. At the Munich meeting, in Fincham's account, Dikmen told the party that a contractor in southern Anatolia had found the murals under the rubble of a derelict church, and he showed free-hand drawings of a church and a forged Turkish export permit4. Dominique de Menil agreed to pay him a small sum for the right to acquire the frescoes later, and Fincham gives the purchase price as near $520,0004. The sources differ on the year: Fincham has the offer in 1983, while Archaeology reported in 1998 that Dikmen sold the frescoes in 1984, with the approval of the Cypriot church on condition that they would return to Cyprus4,19. Walter Hopps testified, Hofstadter writes, to an "enormous emotional explosion" between Yanni Petsopoulos and Dikmen over his hiding of the frescoes' origin1. Van Rijn has claimed that Dikmen was used as an adviser on the Menil's new chapel, to give the layout of the Lysi church4. Fincham judges that "the Menil bought illicit material, and Dikmen's looting network profited"4.
Timothy Kaiser wrote in 1990 that the Kanakaria mosaics apparently spent at least eight years in Dikmen's possession in Munich20. According to Hofstadter, Goldberg agreed on 3 July 1988 to buy them for a little over a million dollars, and on 5 July, at Geneva airport, she met beside four crates a man whom she took to be Dikmen1. The lawyer Ronald Faulk went to Munich to speak with Dikmen and came back with assurances of legal export and of provenance from an "extinct" church12. In the trial papers, Hofstadter notes, the name was spelled "Dikmen", "Dikman" or "Diekman", and the signature varied a lot1. Robert Fitzgerald testified that of the $1.08 million he gave Dikmen only $350,00012,20. On 3 August 1989 Judge James E. Noland ordered Goldberg to return the mosaics, ruling that they were stolen and that she had not inquired enough into Dikmen's capacity to transfer ownership12. At the trial, Hofstadter writes, Emerson argued that Cyprus should have suspected Dikmen by 1982, when Ortam published an article connecting him with the theft of Christian art from a castle in Kyrenia1.
The Munich seizure and the courts
The sources disagree on the date of the Munich raid: Cyprus Today gives 10 October 1997, and Peter Watson in Culture Without Context also puts the sting in October 1997, while the Cyprus Mail says March 1997 and Wikipedia March 19989,13,21,22. Wikipedia credits Tasoula Hadjitofi, Honorary Consul of Cyprus in the Netherlands, with starting the eight-month sting9. Culture Without Context reports that van Rijn, described as a former accomplice, helped the police, and that three of Dikmen's flats yielded over 4,000 antiquities said to be worth more than $40 million, including over 400 objects from Greek Orthodox churches in northern Cyprus and frescoes from Antiphonitis13. Archaeology said the treasures were found in a flat he rented under a false name and taken to the Bavarian National Museum19. Athanasios Papageorgiou of the Archbishopric told Reuters that they had caught "the mastermind of the whole smuggling operation"19. His list for the German authorities, Cyprus Today reports, traced Dikmen's holdings to 51 churches of occupied Cyprus21.
Watson reported that Dikmen faced up to fifteen years in prison if convicted and that Cyprus sought his extradition13. Hardy writes that in 1998 van Rijn, after death threats, refused to testify, and the period for prosecution then ran out17. Marc Fehlmann says the German authorities had enough evidence for a case of illegal possession, but the statute of limitations had expired and Dikmen was released after a few months in custody in Munich3. Fehlmann adds that neither Turkish Cypriot nor Turkish authorities ever indicted him for any Cypriot antiquity3.
The sources disagree on his convictions. Ferdi Sabit Soyer said in 1997 that he had been "convicted of these crimes many times in Turkey", while his lawyer Ercan Canımoğlu said in 2010 that he had never been convicted of antiquities smuggling at home or abroad; Hardy thinks the lawyer may be technically right17. Hardy, citing Der Spiegel, writes that he had been convicted of tax evasion in Germany17.
The Cyprus Mail says the legal battle began in 2004 and was resolved in 2010 by the decision of the Munich District Court22. Greek Reporter, citing the Abendzeitung, wrote in 2013 that Dikmen was asking the courts to declare the Cypriot treasures his wife's dowry23. After his appeal, 173 relics went back to Cyprus in July 2013 and 85 in August 2015, by the Cyprus Mail's count, while Cyprus Today gives 178 items ordered returned21,22. The Turkish Cypriot administration's foreign ministry site reported on 18 March 2015, from the Greek Cypriot daily Alithia, that the Munich Higher Regional Court had ordered 34 artefacts returned to Cyprus and 49 to Dikmen24. Hardy writes that the antiquities still in his hands were taken to Turkey in his wife's name in 2008 and given to the Science and Literature Museum of Selçuk University in Konya17.
Bishop Christophoros of Karpasia said in 2024 that Dikmen died in 2020; Wikipedia gives the date as 8 April 20209,22. The Cyprus Mail reported in July 2024 that a recently signed repatriation agreement, which it called the final chapter of the Dikmen case, had brought 60 more looted items back to Cyprus22.
Life and work
20 events, 1963–2013
1963
- Per Hofstadter, from 1963 began making contacts in Cyprus, including a smuggler he calls Ali Mehmet Ali and merchant Yekta Remzi.
1965
1960s
Hofstadter describes him in the late 1960s as a young technical draughtsman and part-time jazz drummer in Konya who boasted to journalists Pearson and Connor that Catalhoyuk artefacts were in his house.
1977
- A trunkload of icons found en route to Yugoslavia was traced by Turkish police to Atilla Önder, said by Hofstadter to be Dikmen's associate; Hofstadter says the Konya villa was also raided and Dikmen bribed his way back into good standing.
March
Hofstadter, reporting Özgen Acar's 1989 Cumhuriyet series, says Dikmen made Turkish headlines in March 1977 over twenty-one illegally exported Cypriot icons, and Hürriyet printed a photograph of his private museum in Konya.
1982
Named
Hofstadter reports he was arrested by Turkish Cypriot police in 1982 and arraigned at Kyrenia, and that Ortam linked him with the theft of Christian art from Kyrenia castle (Hofstadter's report; court outcome not stated).
1983
June
Menil party (Dominique de Menil, Walter Hopps, Petsopoulos, the unsigned Menil author and others) met Dikmen in a Munich hotel lobby and were shown fragments in a dark rented flat without electricity; Dikmen then told them the frescoes came from a church uncovered by bulldozer near Bin Bir Kilise in Anatolia, supported by drawings, a 1971 book by Semavi Eyice and an export permit. The Menil author calls this 'a fantastic fabrication' and records their suspicion that Dikman was lying. Dikmen said his principal business was buying derelict ships in Europe for scrap in Turkey.MunichAnnemarie Weyl Carr, Laurence J. Morrocco (1991). A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus. Austin, University of Texas Press, with the Menil Foundation; Dan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux
- Per Gary Vikan's trial testimony as reported by Hofstadter, Petsopoulos first offered the frescoes to Dumbarton Oaks for $600,000 with Dikmen's Anatolian cover story and a crude drawing of a fictional church; Petsopoulos denies offering them, saying he only asked for advice.
- Dominique de Menil's deposition (per Hofstadter) said that on her 1983 visit to Dikmen's Munich flat she acquired two further objects besides the Lysi frescoes, one a jewel-studded Sumerian idol.
1984
January
The Lysi fragments were moved from Munich to London after funds had been placed in a Swiss escrow account; release to Dikmen was conditional on laboratory verification in London.
1988
- Before the Goldberg sale, Karl von Habsburg (Habsburg Fine Art) and Peg Goldberg phoned a man purporting to be Dikmen, who sounded willing to sell the Hand of Mary, Feet of Christ and St Andrew roundel; Habsburg also offered the mosaics to the Getty for $20 million, and Marion True warned Cyprus.
July
IFAR (1989) reports that the seller of the four Kanakaria mosaics, bought in Geneva for $1.08 million in July 1988, was Aydin Dikmen, a Turk living in Munich, introduced to Goldberg by Robert Fitzgerald and Michel van Rijn; Ronald Faulk travelled to Munich to speak with him. The court ruled Goldberg never acquired good title.
1989
3 August
Judge Noland (S.D. Indiana) held that the four mosaics belonged to the Church of Cyprus and should be delivered into its custody; Goldberg's inquiry into whether Dikmen had title was found inadequate (Hofstadter's report of the judgment). Dikmen was not a party; he is named in the evidence.IndianapolisDan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux; (1989). Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus v. Goldberg (S.D. Ind.), judgment of 3 August 1989; Aydın Dikmen. Wikipedia; Leah Marangos. Beyond the Destruction: Cultural Diplomacy on the Island of Cyprus. The Future of the Past: From Amphipolis to Mosul, New Approaches to Cultural Heritage Preservation in the Eastern Mediterranean, 31-38. Archaeological Institute of America, Site Preservation Program, p. 6
May
The Independent (Geraldine Norman) published a photograph said to be Dikmen; Peg Goldberg judged it was not the man she saw in Geneva. Hofstadter says van Rijn gave Norman an old option agreement signed by Dikmen (Savo's account) and that Dikmen was furious at van Rijn for disclosing his name.1989–1990
Meetings in Amsterdam (autumn 1989) and Munich (March 1990) between Peg Goldberg and a man she took to be Dikmen, brokered by the Yugoslav 'Benjamin' (Savo Kujundzic). In Munich the man said he had sold her the mosaics believing they were for Constantine Leventis, and that he netted $150,000 not $350,000. Hofstadter and others doubt this was the real Dikmen.
1990
- Hofstadter reports that Bavarian customs intelligence raided one of Dikmen's apartments (Goethestrasse) about a year before his 1991 visit but found it empty after a tip-off, and compiled a 'Dikmen File' sent to the Munich I chief prosecutor, who told Hofstadter there was no such file. Hofstadter writes that Cyprus requested no action in Bavaria and that Dikmen 'seemed to enjoy a strange de facto immunity'.
1991
- Hofstadter reports that Turkish Cypriot informants told him a case against Dikmen for the theft of the Lysi frescoes had been opened in Famagusta District, but that the court could not try him in his absence; they also named Hasan Harman, Mustafa Avcibasi, Kemal Kose and Ahmet Kadir Dinc as the stripping crew, hired by 'a cunning fellow who was going around posing as some sort of state archaeologist'.
1997
- Culture Without Context describes the October 1997 sting masterminded by Michel van Rijn that led to Dikmen's arrest in Munich and the recovery of frescoes, mosaics and icons said to have been looted from Cypriot churches after 1974; a later item says van Rijn seemed unlikely to give evidence in the case.
2010
- Culture Without Context reports that Byzantine icons, mosaic and artefacts stolen from northern Cyprus over thirty years earlier were to be returned to the Republic of Cyprus after seven years of litigation; Dikmen had fought for them in the courts but could not prove ownership.
2013
July
173 objects repatriated from Germany to Cyprus after the German civil judgment found they had left Cyprus after 1974.JulyRuling
Courts concluded that 173 items were removed from Cyprus after the Turkish invasion of 1974 and so belonged to the Republic; repatriated July 2013 (Beyond the Destruction, citing Hickley 2013).
Fieldwork
1 record at 1 place
In the field
1 recordan ‘extinct church’
FoundpossiblyVan Rijn told Goldberg that Dikman had found the mosaics in a church used as a livestock pen.
Kanakaria mosaicsSullivan 1991, p. 235
Trade and objects
31 records · 5 objects
Through their hands
31 recordsWent to
- 1983–1985Sale
SaleAydin Dikmen offered the fresco fragments for purchase by the Menil.
Sold to Menil Foundationthirteenth century Byzantine mural fragmentsFincham 2015, p. 305Hoover 1990, p. 59Ioannides et al. 2012, p. VISullivan 1991, p. 235
- 1983Gift
GiftDominique de Menil acquired two objects besides the Lysi frescoes from Dikmen's Munich flat.
Gave to Dominique de Meniltwo objects, including a jewel-studded Sumerian idolHofstadter 1994, p. 103
- 1984Sale
SalepossiblyPeg said Dikmen told her that Leventis had paid him for four other Kanakariá mosaics in 1984.
Sold to Constantine Leventisabout 180,000 Deutsche marksHofstadter 1994, p. 97
- 1984Transfer
TransferprobablyIcons and church artAccording to Hopps, Dikmen returned mosaics that turned up in Cyprus in 1984.
With CyprusKanakariá mosaicsHofstadter 1994, p. 64
- 1988Partnership
PartnershipAllegedFincham alleged that Dikmen worked with Michel van Rijn in the sale of looted Cypriot mosaics.
Worked with Michel van Rijnsixth-century mosaics looted from a separate Church in CyprusFincham 2015, p. 305
- 1988Sale
SaleAllegedFincham alleged that Dikmen sold looted sixth-century mosaics to Peg Goldberg.
Sold to Peg Goldbergsixth-century mosaics looted from a separate Church in CyprusFincham 2015, p. 305
- 1988Sale
SalePeg Goldberg agreed to buy the mosaics from the Turk for a little over a million dollars.
Sold to Peg Goldberga little over a million dollarsGerstenblith 2015, p. 358Hofstadter 1994, p. 44Hofstadter 1994, p. 163Hoover 1990, p. 46
- 1988Sale
SaleAydin Dikmen supplied the four mosaics to the dealers in the transaction in which Goldberg paid $1.08 million.
Sold to Robert Fitzgeraldfour 6th-century Byzantine mosaics$350,000the free-port area of the Geneva airportKaiser 1990, p. 206
- 1988Sale
SaleThe author reported that Aydin Dikman sold mosaic fragments removed clandestinely from Panagia Kanakaria to agents for Peg L. Goldberg.
With agents for Peg L. Goldbergsixth-century mosaic fragments from the Panagia KanakariaCarr & Morrocco 1991, p. 8
- 1997Seizure
SeizureGerman police confiscated a large amount of looted antiquities from Aydin Dikmen.
With German policeHadjisavvas 2015, p. 128
- 1998Note
NoteAllegedIcons and church artMichel Van Rijn implicated his former associate Aydin Dikman in connection with looted church antiquities.
Connected with Michel van Rijnmosaics, icons, and frescoesMirbagheri 2010, p. 14
- n.d.Sale
SaleAllegedIcons and church artAydin Dikmen sold the detached frescoes to the De Menil Foundation.
Sold to De Menil Foundationfrescoes from the apse and the dome of the church of St EuphemianosChrysostomides & Dendrinos 2006, p. 107
Show 19 moreShow fewer
- n.d.Note
NoteDominique de Menil agreed to pay Dikmen a small sum to secure the right to acquire the frescoes in the future.
Connected with Dominique de Menila small sumMunichFincham 2015, p. 306
- n.d.Sale
SaleDominique de Menil decided to pay Dikmen for the murals at a purchase price near $520,000.
Sold to Dominique de Menilnear $520,000Fincham 2015, p. 307
- n.d.Consignment
ConsignmentSavo said Petsopoulos had taken many things on consignment from Dikmen to sell in London.
Took consignments from Yanni PetsopoulosHofstadter 1994, p. 132
- n.d.Note
NoteHopps said Petsopoulos pressed Dikmen to deliver the mosaics into Constantine Leventis's custody.
Connected with Yanni Petsopoulostwo Kanakariá mosaicsHofstadter 1994, p. 119
- n.d.Sale
SalepossiblyKline asked whether Michel van Rijn had paid Aydin Dikmen $350,000 for the mosaics.
Sold to Michel van Rijn$350,000Hofstadter 1994, p. 70
- n.d.Sale
SaleIcons and church artMichel van Rijn said Aydin Dikmen sold him the Saint Peter panel that later reached the British Museum.
Sold to Michel van RijnSaint Peter icon panelHofstadter 1994, p. 112
- n.d.Gift
GiftMichel van Rijn said he had obtained the Hand of Mary and Feet of Christ from Aydin Dikmen.
- n.d.Transfer
TransferpossiblyThe author said some prize items Dikmen obtained later found their way to Michel van Rijn.
Passed objects to Michel van Rijnprize items from the Kyrenia Castle robberyHofstadter 1994, p. 228
- n.d.Transfer
TransferPetsopoulos said Dikmen had sent him photographs of pieces that did not interest him.
Passed objects to Yanni Petsopoulosphotos of piecesHofstadter 1994, p. 228Hofstadter 1994, p. 212
- n.d.Meeting
MeetingPeg Goldberg, Robert Fitzgerald, and Ronald Faulk met Aydin Dikman in Geneva.
Met Peg Goldbergthe mosaicsHoover 1990, p. 46
- n.d.Meeting
MeetingRonald Faulk met Aydin Dikman in Munich during the negotiations.
Met Ronald Faulkthe mosaicsHoover 1990, p. 46
- n.d.Testimony
TestimonyVikan testified that the circumstances involving Dikman were highly suspicious.
Subject of testimony by Gary VikanKanakaria mosaicsSullivan 1991, p. 237
- n.d.Seizure
SeizureIcons and church artAydin Dikmen had fragments of frescoes confiscated by German authorities.
With German authoritiesfragments of frescoes from the Monastery of AntiphonetesGermanyChrysostomides & Dendrinos 2006, p. 103
- n.d.Record
RecordIcons and church artDetached fresco fragments were found in Aydin Dikmen's possession and were held by German authorities.
With German authoritiesdetached fragments of frescoes from the church of St SolomonChrysostomides & Dendrinos 2006, p. 112Chrysostomides & Dendrinos 2006, p. 122
- n.d.Smuggling
SmugglingAllegedFincham alleged that Dikmen oversaw the smuggling of objects from Cyprus to the Turkish mainland.
- n.d.Dealing
DealingThe document said the Turkish archaeologist also dealt in antiquities.
MunichHofstadter 1994, p. 41
- n.d.Record
RecordA case against Dikmen for the theft of the Lysi frescoes had been opened in Famagusta District.
- n.d.Record
RecordAllegedThe text alleges that Aydin Dikmen headed thieves who detached the church frescoes and cut them into 38 pieces.
the frescoes from the apse and the dome of the church of St. Euphemianoschurch of St. EuphemianosIoannides et al. 2012, p. VI
- n.d.Collection
CollectionIcons and church artAuthorities later found mosaics, icons, and frescoes worth more than US$40 million in Aydin Dikman's possession.
more than US$40 million worthMirbagheri 2010, p. 14
Objects
5 objectsThirteenth-century frescoes from the chapel of St Themonianos/Euphemianos near Lysi: 26 dome pieces and 12 apse pieces (38): Christ Pantokrator, angels, Hetoimasia, Virgin orans, St John the Baptist
From Lysi, church of St Euphemianos/Themonianos1983–1984
Derek Fincham (2015). The Rescue, Stewardship, and Return of the Lysi Frescoes by the Menil Foundation. International Journal of Cultural Property, pp. 1; Annemarie Weyl Carr, Laurence J. Morrocco (1991). A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus. Austin, University of Texas Press, with the Menil Foundation
Two Kanakaria mosaic roundels (St Jude and St Bartholomew), returned to Cyprus in 1984 with two fakes via Petsopoulos, left in a Frankfurt warehouse for the Cypriot embassy at Bonn
From Panagia Kanakaria1984
Seized from Munich apartments 1997: Antiphonitis frescoes (c. 30), Kanakaria St Thomas, icons; of c. 240 ordered returned by Landgericht Munich I, 173 returned July 2013
From Antiphonitis monastery, Kanakaria and other northern churches1997
Aydın Dikmen. Wikipedia; Leah Marangos. Beyond the Destruction: Cultural Diplomacy on the Island of Cyprus. The Future of the Past: From Amphipolis to Mosul, New Approaches to Cultural Heritage Preservation in the Eastern Mediterranean, 31-38. Archaeological Institute of America, Site Preservation Program, p. 6
Mosaic roundel of a saint's head seen by Petsopoulos and Hopps hanging over a red sofa in Dikmen's Munich flat, 1983 (possibly Kanakaria)
From Panagia Kanakaria (possibly)1983
Icon panel of St Peter, said by van Rijn to have come from a monastery in the occupied north (Dikmen's statement), sold to the British Museum for GBP 175,000 via Mihalarias
From monastery in the occupied north (as stated by Dikmen to van Rijn)British Museum1980s
Connections
19 people
Sales, gifts & bequests
- Sold to Dominique de MenilDominique de Menil decided to pay Dikmen for the murals at a purchase price near $520,000. Fincham 2015, p. 3071983–1984
- Gave to Dominique de MenilDominique de Menil acquired two objects besides the Lysi frescoes from Dikmen's Munich flat. Hofstadter 1994, p. 1031983
- Sold to Yanni PetsopoulosDan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade; Annemarie Weyl Carr and Laurence J. Morrocco, 1991, A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered, the Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus1983–1984
- Represented by Yanni PetsopoulosLysi frescoes Archaeology (Archaeological Institute of America), July/August 1998, Special Report: Church Treasures of Cyprus1983–1984
- Sold to Constantine LeventispossiblypossiblyPeg said Dikmen told her that Leventis had paid him for four other Kanakariá mosaics in 1984. Hofstadter 1994, p. 971984
- Represented by Michel van RijnKanakaria mosaics; Byzantine mosaics; Cypriot Byzantine mosaics Timothy Kaiser, 1990, The Antiquities Market; Anne McC. Sullivan, 1991, Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade; The Parthenon Sculptures and Cultural Justice (2012), p. 1003; The Goldberg Case: A Confirmation of the Difficulty in Acquiring Good Title to Valuable Stolen Cultural Objects (1992), p. 1531988
- Sold to Peg GoldbergAllegedFincham alleged that Dikmen sold looted sixth-century mosaics to Peg Goldberg. Fincham 2015, p. 3051988–1989
- Sold to Robert FitzgeraldAydin Dikmen supplied the four mosaics to the dealers in the transaction in which Goldberg paid $1.08 million. Kaiser 1990, p. 2061988
- Represented by Ercan Canımoğlulawyer's public statement Samuel Andrew Hardy, 2021, Organised Crime in Trafficking of Cultural Goods in Turkey and Interconnections between Antiquities Trafficking and Narcotics Trafficking, Arms Trafficking and Political Violence, in A. Traviglia, L. Milano, C. Tonghini and R. Giovanelli (eds), Stolen Heritage (Antichistica 29), Edizioni Ca' Foscari, Venice, pp. 113-1542010
- Represented by MezlerChurch of Cyprus and Republic v. Dikmen (LG Muenchen I); Church of Cyprus and Republic v. Dikmen (LG München I) taz, 30 September 2010, Prozess zu Kunstraub in Nordzypern: Die Apostel dürfen wieder nach Hause2010
- Sold to Michel van RijnpossiblyKline asked whether Michel van Rijn had paid Aydin Dikmen $350,000 for the mosaics. Hofstadter 1994, p. 70
- Passed objects to Michel van RijnpossiblypossiblyThe author said some prize items Dikmen obtained later found their way to Michel van Rijn. Hofstadter 1994, p. 228
- Gave to Michel van RijnMichel van Rijn said he had obtained the Hand of Mary and Feet of Christ from Aydin Dikmen. Hofstadter 1994, p. 117
- Agent for Peg GoldbergKanakaria mosaics Non-State Actors in the Protection of Cultural Heritage (2021), p. 72
Show 3 moreShow fewer
- Sold to Willem Otto Arie Lansfour Antiphonitis icons; four 16th-c. Antiphonitis iconostasis icons Christiana O'Connell-Schizas, 2014, The Dikmen Conspiracy: the Illicit Removal, Journey and Trade of Looted Ecclesiastical Antiquities from Occupied Cyprus, Journal of Art Crime, pp. 15-34
- Passed objects to Yanni PetsopoulosPetsopoulos said Dikmen had sent him photographs of pieces that did not interest him. Hofstadter 1994, p. 228Hofstadter 1994, p. 212
- Took consignments from Yanni PetsopoulosSavo said Petsopoulos had taken many things on consignment from Dikmen to sell in London. Hofstadter 1994, p. 132
Fieldwork & employment
- Employed by Michel van RijnCypriot Byzantine mosaics The Goldberg Case: A Confirmation of the Difficulty in Acquiring Good Title to Valuable Stolen Cultural Objects (1992), p. 1531970–1988
Disputes & the law
- Subject of testimony by Gary VikanVikan testified that the circumstances involving Dikman were highly suspicious. Sullivan 1991, p. 237
Colleagues & contacts
- Worked with Mehmet Ali İlkmanAcar's 'local boss' of the Dikmen gang; Hofstadter's 'Ali Mehmet Ali' may or may not be the same man Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1963–1989
- Connected with Vassos KarageorghispossiblypossiblySavo claimed that Karageorghis commissioned Dikmen to photograph Byzantine churches inaccessible to Greek Cypriot authorities. Hofstadter 1994, p. 1321964–1974
- Connected with Stavros MihalariasdisputedSavo says Mihalarias was at the Sotheby's meeting; van Rijn says Mihalarias cleaned and sold the Dikmen-sourced St Peter icon to the BM Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade1980
- Connected with Constantine LeventisdisputedSavo (via Hofstadter) says Dikmen and Leventis negotiated over the Lysi frescoes and Kanakaria pieces; Savo says Dikmen asked DM 90,000 per piece, which Leventis would not pay Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade1982–1988
- Met Walter HoppsMunich meeting; Hopps's 1989 deposition about Dikmen and Petsopoulos Annemarie Weyl Carr and Laurence J. Morrocco, 1991, A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered, the Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade1983
- Worked with Yanni Petsopoulosintermediary between Dikmen and the Menil party; Dikmen knew only his name; over the Kanakaria roundels Annemarie Weyl Carr; Laurence J. Morrocco (title page spells 'Morocco'); introduction by Bertrand Davezac, 1991, A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered, the Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade1983–1984
- Worked with Michel van RijnAllegedFincham alleged that Dikmen worked with Michel van Rijn in the sale of looted Cypriot mosaics. Fincham 2015, p. 3051988
- Worked with Robert FitzgeraldKanakaria sale Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade1988
- Worked with Ronald FaulkFaulk visited Dikmen in Munich before the sale and escorted him and the mosaics to Geneva Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade1988
- Met Ronald FaulkRonald Faulk met Aydin Dikman in Munich during the negotiations. Hoover 1990, p. 461988
- Connected with Özgen AcarAcar's 1989 Cumhuriyet series on Dikmen, as reported by Hofstadter Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade1989
- Connected with Peg Goldbergmosaics of Judas and Thomas from Panagia Kanakaria www.ourivesariaportuguesa.info, Culture Without Context, Nº1 to 201990–1997
- Connected with Ferdi Sabit Soyerassertion about Dikmen in the "TRNC" assembly debate on antiquities smuggling (attributed, unverified) Samuel Andrew Hardy, 2021, Organised Crime in Trafficking of Cultural Goods in Turkey and Interconnections between Antiquities Trafficking and Narcotics Trafficking, Arms Trafficking and Political Violence, in A. Traviglia, L. Milano, C. Tonghini and R. Giovanelli (eds), Stolen Heritage (Antichistica 29), Edizioni Ca' Foscari, Venice, pp. 113-1541997
- Connected with Michel van RijnAllegedIcons and church artMichel Van Rijn implicated his former associate Aydin Dikman in connection with looted church antiquities. Mirbagheri 2010, p. 141997–1998
Show 6 moreShow fewer
- Connected with Republic of Cyprusantiquities allegedly stolen from Northern Cyprus www.ourivesariaportuguesa.info, Culture Without Context, Nº1 to 201997
- Connected with Tasoula HadjitofiprobablyMunich sting that led to his arrest (initiated by her per Wikipedia) Aydın Dikmen; O. Rizopoulos, 2019, Cypriot Cultural Heritage: the case of The Frescoes of Panagia Apsinthiotissa1997–1998
- Connected with Dominique de MenilDominique de Menil agreed to pay Dikmen a small sum to secure the right to acquire the frescoes in the future. Fincham 2015, p. 306
- Connected with Gary Vikanmosaics sale Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters (1991), p. 237
- Met Peg GoldbergPeg Goldberg, Robert Fitzgerald, and Ronald Faulk met Aydin Dikman in Geneva. Hoover 1990, p. 46
- Connected with Yanni PetsopoulosHopps said Petsopoulos pressed Dikmen to deliver the mosaics into Constantine Leventis's custody. Hofstadter 1994, p. 119
Mentions
Where else on Ancient Cyprus this person appears
Mentioned in
35 mentionsDocuments · 14
- Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade
Transfer, sale, dealing · 1964 · p. 132; p. 64; p. 112; p. 228; 228, 212; p. 41
Savo claimed that Karageorghis commissioned Dikmen to photograph Byzantine churches inaccessible to Greek Cypriot authorities.
Hofstadter 1994
- Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters
Sale · 1983 · p. 235
Aydin Dikmen offered the fresco fragments for purchase by the Menil.
Sullivan 1991
Also in Hoover 1990; Ioannides et al. 2012; Fincham 2015
- A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus
Sale · 1988 · p. 8
The author reported that Aydin Dikman sold mosaic fragments removed clandestinely from Panagia Kanakaria to agents for Peg L. Goldberg.
Carr & Morrocco 1991
- The Antiquities Market
Sale · 1988 · p. 206
Aydin Dikmen supplied the four mosaics to the dealers in the transaction in which Goldberg paid $1.08 million.
Kaiser 1990
- Historical dictionary of Cyprus
Collected · 2010 · p. 14
Authorities later found mosaics, icons, and frescoes worth more than US$40 million in Aydin Dikman's possession.
Mirbagheri 2010
- "Sweet Land..." Lectures on the History and Culture of Cyprus
112, 122
Detached fresco fragments were found in Aydin Dikmen's possession and were held by German authorities.
Chrysostomides & Dendrinos 2006
Lectures and videos · 1
On Ancient Cyprus · 2
Institutions · 1
- Menil Collection
Seller (1983–1984), object from them · 1983
In the Indianapolis case over the Kanakaria mosaics, Walter Hopps and Dominique de Menil were deposed; her testimony showed the Menil Foundation had also…
Carr & Morrocco 1991; Hofstadter 1994
News · 1
- People · 16listed under Connections
Sources
60 works and documents
- 1.Dan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
- 2.Annemarie Weyl Carr, Laurence J. Morrocco (1991). A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus. Austin, University of Texas Press, with the Menil Foundation.
- 3.M. Fehlmann (2014). “Looting and Losing the Archaeological Heritage of Cyprus”. Islands of the Eastern Mediterranean: A History of Cross-Cultural Encounters, 144-170. London.
- 4.Derek Fincham (2015). “The Rescue, Stewardship, and Return of the Lysi Frescoes by the Menil Foundation”. International Journal of Cultural Property. Online
- 5.Timothy Kaiser (1990). “The Antiquities Market”. Journal of Field Archaeology 17, 205-210. Online
- 6.Leah Marangos. “Beyond the Destruction: Cultural Diplomacy on the Island of Cyprus”. The Future of the Past: From Amphipolis to Mosul, New Approaches to Cultural Heritage Preservation in the Eastern Mediterranean, 31-38. Archaeological Institute of America, Site Preservation Program.
- 7.M. Ioannides (ed.), D. Fritsch (ed.), J. Leissner (ed.), R. Davies (ed.) et al. (2012). Progress in Cultural Heritage Preservation: 4th International Conference, EuroMed 2012, Limassol, Cyprus, October 29 - November 3, 2012, Proceedings. Berlin and Heidelberg, Springer.
- 8.Sophocles Hadjisavvas. “Looting of the archaeological heritage of Cyprus”. Culture Without Context.
- 9.“Aydın Dikmen”. Wikipedia. Online
- 10.Wikidata Q4831094. Online
- 11. (1989). Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus v. Goldberg (S.D. Ind.), judgment of 3 August 1989.
- 12.IFAR (1989). “Cyprus Wins Mosaics in Indiana Court”. IFAR Reports, formerly the Stolen Art Alert and Art Research News.
- 13.Culture Without Context: The Newsletter of the Near Eastern Project of the Illicit Antiquities Research Centre, issues 1-20. McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research, Cambridge.
- 14.J. Chrysostomides; C. Dendrinos (eds) (2006). "Sweet Land..." Lectures on the History and Culture of Cyprus. 112, 295.
- 15. (2021). Non-State Actors in the Protection of Cultural Heritage. 72.
- 16. (2015). Private International Law, Art and Cultural Heritage. 69.
- 17.Samuel Andrew Hardy (2021). “Organised Crime in Trafficking of Cultural Goods in Turkey”. Stolen Heritage (Antichistica 29), 113-154. Edizioni Ca' Foscari. Online
- 18.Leah Marangos. “Beyond the Destruction: Cultural Diplomacy on the Island of Cyprus”. The Future of the Past: From Amphipolis to Mosul, New Approaches to Cultural Heritage Preservation in the Eastern Mediterranean, ed. K. Chalikias, M. Beeler, A. Pearce and S. Renette, 31-.
- 19.Mark Rose (1998). “[News brief on the Munich recovery of Cypriot church art]”. Archaeology (Archaeological Institute of America), online newsbriefs. Online
- 20.Timothy Kaiser (1990). “The Antiquities Market”. Journal of Field Archaeology 17, 205-210.
- 21.“[Article on the 1997 Munich case and Tasoula Hadjitofi]”. Cyprus Today (Press and Information Office, Nicosia), issue item 444-465.
- 22. (2024). “Returned items reflect struggle to recover cultural heritage”. Cyprus Mail. Online
- 23. (2013). “Turkish Smuggler Wants Cypriot Treasures”. Greek Reporter. Online
- 24. (2015). “Decision taken in case of Aydın Dikmen does not please the Greek Cypriots”. Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Turkish Cypriot administration (website). Online
- 25.Deborah Hoover (1990). “Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet”. Journal of Arts Management and Law 20, 37-62. Routledge. Online
- 26.Anne McC. Sullivan (1991). “Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters”. Museum Management and Curatorship 10, 219-243. Routledge. Online
- 27.Patty Gerstenblith (2015). “For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution”. International Journal of Cultural Property. Online
- 28.F. Mirbagheri (2010). Historical dictionary of Cyprus. Lanham, MD, Scarecrow Press.
- 29.J. Chrysostomides (ed.), Ch. Dendrinos (ed.) (2006). "Sweet Land..." Lectures on the History and Culture of Cyprus. Camberley, Porphyrogenitus.
- 30.S. Hadjisavvas (2015). “Perishing Heritage: The Case of the Occupied Part of Cyprus”. Journal of Eastern Mediterranean Archaeology and Heritage Studies 3, 128-140.
- 31.Derek Fincham, 2015, The Rescue, Stewardship, and Return of the Lysi Frescoes by the Menil Foundation.
- 32.Timothy Kaiser, 1990, The Antiquities Market.
- 33.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 34.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade, p. 228; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 35.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade; Timothy Kaiser, 1990, The Antiquities Market.
- 36.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade.
- 37.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade; Annemarie Weyl Carr and Laurence J. Morrocco, 1991, A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered, the Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus.
- 38.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade.
- 39.Annemarie Weyl Carr and Laurence J. Morrocco, 1991, A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered, the Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade.
- 40.www.ourivesariaportuguesa.info, Culture Without Context, Nº1 to 20.
- 41.The Goldberg Case: A Confirmation of the Difficulty in Acquiring Good Title to Valuable Stolen Cultural Objects (1992).
- 42.Non-State Actors in the Protection of Cultural Heritage (2021).
- 43.Derek Fincham, The Rescue, Stewardship, and Return of the Lysi Frescoes by the Menil Foundation, pp. 5-7; Annemarie Weyl Carr; Laurence J. Morrocco (with Menil Foundation introduction), 1991, A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered, the Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus.
- 44.Annemarie Weyl Carr and Laurence J. Morrocco, 1991, A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus, University of Texas Press, with the Menil Foundation, Austin.
- 45.Samuel Andrew Hardy, 2021, Organised Crime in Trafficking of Cultural Goods in Turkey and Interconnections between Antiquities Trafficking and Narcotics Trafficking, Arms Trafficking and Political Violence, in A. Traviglia, L. Milano, C. Tonghini and R. Giovanelli (eds), Stolen Heritage (Antichistica 29), Edizioni Ca' Foscari, Venice.
- 46.Anne McC. Sullivan, 1991, Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters.
- 47.Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters (1991).
- 48.Özgen Acar, 27 May 1989, İşte çete, Cumhuriyet.
- 49.taz, 30 September 2010, Prozess zu Kunstraub in Nordzypern: Die Apostel dürfen wieder nach Hause.
- 50.F. Mirbagheri, 2010, Historical dictionary of Cyprus.
- 51.Timothy Kaiser, 1990, The Antiquities Market; Anne McC. Sullivan, 1991, Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade.
- 52.The Parthenon Sculptures and Cultural Justice (2012).
- 53.Patty Gerstenblith, 2015, For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution, p. 358; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade, p. 44; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 54.Deborah Hoover, 1990, Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet.
- 55.Patty Gerstenblith, For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution; Deborah Hoover, 1990, Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet, p. 12; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 56.Aydın Dikmen; O. Rizopoulos, 2019, Cypriot Cultural Heritage: the case of The Frescoes of Panagia Apsinthiotissa.
- 57.D. Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 58.Christiana O'Connell-Schizas, 2014, The Dikmen Conspiracy: the Illicit Removal, Journey and Trade of Looted Ecclesiastical Antiquities from Occupied Cyprus, Journal of Art Crime.
- 59.Annemarie Weyl Carr; Laurence J. Morrocco (title page spells 'Morocco'); introduction by Bertrand Davezac, 1991, A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered, the Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade.
- 60.Archaeology (Archaeological Institute of America), July/August 1998, Special Report: Church Treasures of Cyprus.
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.