Dealer · Agent

Robert Fitzgerald

fl. 1981–1989 · United States

Indianapolis art dealer who brought Peg Goldberg to the Kanakaria mosaics in Amsterdam in 1988, took a share in their resale and testified for Cyprus at the 1989 trial.

Biography

Robert Fitzgerald, known as Bob, was the Indiana art dealer who in 1988 enticed Peg Goldberg in the Netherlands to consider buying four early Christian mosaics, as the Seventh Circuit found1,2. Fitzgerald later took the stand for Cyprus in the 1989 trial1.

A life as he told it

Almost everything known of Fitzgerald's early life comes from what he told the writer Dan Hofstadter, who spent time with him in Indianapolis about a year after the 1989 trial1. Hofstadter, writing in the early 1990s, put him in his late fifties, and quotes him saying "I'm a hustler"1. He told Hofstadter he was a Depression baby, whose parents split up when he was a toddler; his maternal grandparents brought him and his mother to Pocatello1. In his mid-teens, he said, he left Pocatello for an aunt and uncle in Erlanger, Kentucky, where he took up buying and selling big cats1. He claimed that Nevada passed a special law against him that barred bringing big animals into the state, and that at about twenty-two he set off alone to find animals and got as far as Nicaragua1.

By his own account he then sailed from Genoa to Buenos Aires and began buying and selling pre-Columbian Peruvian pottery, wood carvings and gold1. He told Hofstadter that he once bought a load of art for practically nothing in Peru, bribed the customs officials and flew a suitcase of the best pieces to a gallery on La Cienega Boulevard in Los Angeles1. Of that trade he said: "Nowadays, they'd call you a smuggler, but it was accepted then"1. He sold ancient Peruvian art to European and American dealers and exhibited at an Amsterdam gallery owned by the dentist and connoisseur Lou van Rijn1. While he was living in Buenos Aires, he said, he married the first of his six wives1.

Fitzgerald also said he once moved a ten-ton Easter Island head from Chile to Amsterdam only to find it was fake, and that after ten years in Argentina he went to Cuiabá in the Amazon1. In the Peruvian Andes, he said, village clergy cut old church paintings from their frames for him for a modest tip, and three society women bought the pictures for the Delgado Museum, now the New Orleans Museum of Art1. Sullivan, writing in 1991, said that his deals had included exotic birds and cats, shrunken heads from the Amazon and a ship salvage off Nicaragua made possible by his friendship with Anastasio Somoza3. Michel van Rijn, Lou's son, disputed the smuggling tales: Fitzgerald, he told Hofstadter, had a bird shop in Los Angeles with his friend Lynn Harris, "and that's all they ever smuggled"1.

Indianapolis and the mosaics

In 1981 Fitzgerald began coming into the poster-and-print shop where Goldberg worked to have framing done; he told her he was an art dealer who had searched for artefacts all over the world, above all in Latin America, and had settled in Indianapolis because of a few very rich clients1. His condominium held pre-Columbian, African and Oceanic pieces, Nazca pottery, Senufo figures, New Guinea masks and gold1. Hofstadter writes that clients bought art from him for distinguished collections and well-known museums, and Goldberg sometimes researched the provenance of a possible purchase for him1. By early 1988 he had married Barbara, a seventeen-year-old he had met selling hot dogs on Monument Circle, and they had a little boy, Evan1.

That year Fitzgerald told Goldberg of a Modigliani in Holland, owned, he said, by the Dutch dealer Jack Vecht, and she flew to Amsterdam, where he was to join her1. Goldberg judged the painting wrong, and Fitzgerald came round to her view1. The Seventh Circuit found that Fitzgerald arranged a meeting in Amsterdam for 1 July 1988, at which he introduced Goldberg to Michel van Rijn and the California attorney Ronald Faulk, who was in Europe to represent Fitzgerald and van Rijn2. Deborah Hoover's shorter account has Goldberg meeting Fitzgerald in Amsterdam on a buying trip and learning from him that the mosaics were available4.

In Hofstadter's account neither Fitzgerald nor van Rijn put money into the price or took a finder's commission; they took shares in the resale value instead1. Hofstadter has Goldberg agreeing on 3 July 1988 to buy the mosaics from Aydın Dikmen, and the court has a document splitting any resale profits executed on 4 July, with Goldberg holding 50 percent, Fitzgerald and van Rijn 22.5 percent each and Faulk 5 percent1,2. With Fitzgerald's and van Rijn's help Goldberg obtained three appraisals valuing the mosaics at $3 to $6 million, and she and Fitzgerald hurried to Geneva2. Sullivan says Fitzgerald assured her the resale would bring $5 to 6 million3. Back in Indiana, IFAR reported, Fitzgerald sold half of their interest to the physician Stewart Bick for $780,0005. On 10 February 1989 Goldberg, Fitzgerald, van Rijn and Bick signed a new agreement for further pieces1.

The trial

Cyprus's counsel Thomas R. Kline argued that the peculiar nature of the intermediaries, Fitzgerald, van Rijn and Faulk, should have warned Goldberg, while her defence called Fitzgerald and van Rijn mere finders1. Kline called Fitzgerald to the stand on the morning of 2 June 19891. Fitzgerald testified that he took Goldberg's $1.08 million in cash to a bank across the street from the one where she handed it to him5.

The accounts of where the money went disagree: in the testimony Hofstadter prints, $70,000 went to a London attorney for van Rijn and Fitzgerald and $580,000 was divided between the two men1. IFAR and Timothy Kaiser instead give Dikmen $350,000 and Fitzgerald and van Rijn $282,500 each, while the Seventh Circuit gives Fitzgerald $297,500 and van Rijn $282,5002,5,6. Asked by Goldberg's counsel Jay Yeager why he had not told her how little reached Dikmen, Fitzgerald said: "Because I told her it wasn't any of her business"1. Goldberg, asked at trial, listed the names he had used: Bob Jones, Robert Evan Jones, Robert E. Jones, Robert Fitzgerald and Fitzgerald Jones1. Sullivan judged that his reputation "contributed to the disapproving tone of the court's decision"3.

After the trial

In September 1989 Fitzgerald was charged with conspiracy in the 1984 burglary of an Indiana art collector's home1. Hofstadter writes that the trial was repeatedly postponed, that the case rested largely on two convicted felons turned state's witnesses, and that Fitzgerald had no criminal record, and he does not give the outcome1. Sullivan reported in 1991 that he and van Rijn were being sued together in Great Britain over a modello claimed to have been used by Michelangelo for the David3.

By Hofstadter's interviews Fitzgerald had divorced Barbara, and he said he and van Rijn had come to blows in Indianapolis1. Van Rijn later called him his worst enemy and accused him of warning the police and Interpol; Fitzgerald denied it and said van Rijn "walked out of St. Louis with a million bucks"1. Fitzgerald told Hofstadter that van Rijn, not Dikmen, had sold Goldberg the mosaics, and that because of van Rijn many people in Indianapolis no longer wanted to know him; van Rijn answered that it was he who had masterminded the deal1.

Life and work

  1. 1981

    1. Began visiting Peg Goldberg's framing shop; said he was an art dealer who had searched for artefacts worldwide (Latin America); his condo held pre-Columbian, African and Oceanic pieces; she understood he had been a 'background picker' for antiquities galleries.

      IndianapolisDan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux

  2. 1988

    1. June–July

      Took Goldberg to Amsterdam, mentioned the Kanakaria mosaics, introduced van Rijn and Faulk; Goldberg agreed 3 July 1988 to buy for a little over $1m; he and van Rijn each had a 22.5 percent stake in resale proceeds.

      AmsterdamDan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux

    2. Indianapolis dealer, co-seller of the Kanakaria fragments to Peg Goldberg in 1988 ($297,500 plus resale share). Never charged.

      Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus v. Goldberg, 717 F. Supp. 1374 (S.D. Ind. 1989)

  3. 1989

    1. 2 June

      Testified for Cyprus's side (called by Kline). Asked where the $650,000 gap between Dikmen's $350,000 and Goldberg's price went, said it was divided between himself and van Rijn; Hofstadter reckons the two netted $580,000 as brokers, plus later earnings from selling their back-end interests to Stewart Bick.

      IndianapolisDan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux

    2. SeptemberCharged

      Charged with conspiracy in the 1984 burglary of an Indiana art collector's home (not a Cypriot matter); trial repeatedly postponed; the case depended largely on two convicted felons turned state's witnesses; Hofstadter notes Fitzgerald himself had no rap sheet. Outcome not stated in the passage read.

      Dan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux

Through their hands

8 records

Came from

Robert Fitzgerald
SaleGift or bequestWho objects came from and went to, as the sources record it
  1. 1988

    HelpIcons and church artRobert Fitzgerald informed Peg Goldberg that the four mosaics were available.

    Helped Peg GoldbergAmsterdamHofstadter 1994, p. 217Hoover 1990, p. 45Sullivan 1991, p. 234

  2. 1988

    MeetingPeg Goldberg met Robert Fitzgerald while she was on a buying trip in Amsterdam.

    Met Peg Goldbergfour mosaicsHoover 1990, p. 45

  3. 1988

    SaleRobert Fitzgerald sold mosaics to Peg Goldberg as part of the transaction in which she paid the dealers $1.08 million.

    Sold to Peg Goldbergfour 6th-century Byzantine mosaics$282,500the free-port area of the Geneva airportKaiser 1990, p. 206

  4. 1988

    PurchaseAydin Dikmen supplied the four mosaics to the dealers in the transaction in which Goldberg paid $1.08 million.

    Bought from Aydın Dikmenfour 6th-century Byzantine mosaics$350,000the free-port area of the Geneva airportKaiser 1990, p. 206

  5. n.d.

    AgencyRonald Faulk represented Bob Fitzgerald in connection with the proposed purchase.

    Represented by Ronald FaulkmosaicsHofstadter 1994, p. 37

  6. n.d.

    SaleStewart Bick acquired half of Bob's interest in the mosaics.

    Sold to Stewart BickHofstadter 1994, p. 48

  7. n.d.

    GiftpossiblyIcons and church artMichel said Bob offered him a suitcase containing fifty thousand Swiss francs after returning from Geneva.

    Gave to Michel van Rijna suitcase with money from the mosaics dealfifty thousand Swiss francsAmsterdamHofstadter 1994, p. 218

  8. n.d.

    SaleRobert Fitzgerald sold half of his interest in Goldberg's anticipated profits for $375,000.

    With unnamed buyers$375,000Kaiser 1990, p. 206

Connections

6 people

Mentioned in

9 mentions

Documents · 3

Sources

  1. 1.Dan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
  2. 2.United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit (Cudahy, J.) (1990). Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus v. Goldberg & Feldman Fine Arts, Inc., 917 F.2d 278. Online
  3. 3.Anne McC. Sullivan (1991). “Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters”. Museum Management and Curatorship 10, 219-243. Routledge. Online
  4. 4.Deborah Hoover (1990). “Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet”. Journal of Arts Management and Law 20, 37-62. Routledge. Online
  5. 5.International Foundation for Art Research (1989). “Cyprus Wins Mosaics in Indiana Court”. IFAR Reports 10, no. 8.
  6. 6.Timothy Kaiser (1990). “The Antiquities Market”. Journal of Field Archaeology 17, 205-210.
  7. 7.Timothy Kaiser (1990). “The Antiquities Market”. Journal of Field Archaeology 17, 205-210. Online
  8. 8.Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus v. Goldberg, 717 F. Supp. 1374 (S.D. Ind. 1989).
  9. 9.Timothy Kaiser, 1990, The Antiquities Market.
  10. 10.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade.
  11. 11.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
  12. 12.Timothy Kaiser, 1990, The Antiquities Market; Anne McC. Sullivan, 1991, Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: an adventure in the antiquities trade.
  13. 13.Deborah Hoover, 1990, Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet.
  14. 14.Deborah Hoover, 1990, Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet, p. 11; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
  15. 15.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade, p. 217; Deborah Hoover, 1990, Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet.
  16. 16.The Goldberg Case: A Confirmation of the Difficulty in Acquiring Good Title to Valuable Stolen Cultural Objects (1992).
  17. 17.The Parthenon Sculptures and Cultural Justice (2012).

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Date of birth unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.