Book · 1991
A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus
Annemarie Weyl Carr and Laurence J. Morrocco
Austin: University of Texas Press, with the Menil Foundation
A study of the thirteenth-century murals from the church of St. Themonianos at Lysi: their iconography, style and date, Cyprus in the thirteenth century, and the reconstruction of the dome and apse paintings.
The Lysi murals were removed from the church of St. Themonianos and recovered for conservation and an extended loan to the Menil Foundation in Houston. The book gives Carr's study of the paintings, which places them in the architectural and artistic traditions of Cyprus, considers their imagery and style and asks what they indicate about Cypriot art in the thirteenth century. Morocco's account of the technical work on the fragments and their preparation for transport and display follows. Davezac's introduction tells how the murals were identified and recovered and how their conservation and loan were arranged.
Carr's evidence is the church's domed-hall plan, the surviving fragments of its dedication inscription, the arrangement of the apse and dome imagery, and comparisons with churches and icons in Cyprus and elsewhere. Morocco works from measurements, photographs from Cyprus and templates.
How it is organised
After Davezac's introduction and Carr's preface, Carr's study has four chapters: "The Monument and Its Message," "The Style and Its Attribution," "Cyprus in the Thirteenth Century," and "Lysi and Thirteenth-Century Art in Cyprus." The third draws on accounts of the Latin conquest, relations between the Latin and Orthodox Churches, and evidence for artistic patronage and icon production (pp. 83–98).
Morocco's "The Reconstruction and Restoration of the Lysi Murals" proceeds from the curvature of the dome and the fitting of fragments through preparation of the backs, a visit to Cyprus, removal of facings, restoration and transport (pp. 127–157). He reconstructs the dome and apse curvature from measurements, photographs and templates, and records animal glue, Ethafoam templates, plaster molds, facings, ragboard strips, gauze and a glass-fibre support system. The fragments were aligned, cleaned, filled and inpainted, the saw cuts and losses filled, and a cleaning patch and graffiti left in place while major losses were retouched. The dome and apse were crated for shipment to Houston in 1988.
The argument
Carr identifies the church as a small domed-hall building and reads it as a private votive chapel dedicated by the hieromonk and abbot Lawrence, whose institution is not named in the surviving inscription (pp. 39–42). She reads the apse and dome together, with the Virgin's intercessory and protective role facing the dome's imagery of Christ as judge and saviour. Comparing the paintings with other Cypriot churches and icons, she argues that their forms remain Byzantine even as other works on the island combine Byzantine, Syrian and Western elements, and she analyses composition, line, modelling and colour against Lagoudera, Kato Lefkara, Moutoullas and Asinou.
She uses the murals to challenge an account of Cypriot artistic production as having fallen silent after the Latin conquest.
Dating
Carr offers two possible datings. Stylistic comparisons place the murals in the thirteenth century, perhaps its middle or second half, while several features could support a date around its beginning. She compares their style with works assigned to around 1200, the dated murals at Moutoullas of 1280, and the third Asinou style, which she associates with 1332/3 and later. Her stylistic comparisons connect the murals to a Cypriot tradition related to twelfth-century painting, and she treats the precise decade as unresolved.
What it records
- Yanni Petsopoulos provided two photographs of Byzantine murals to Davezac in London in June 1983.p. 7
- The alleged collector who presented the murals in Munich is identified by Davezac as Aydin Dikman.p. 8
- The Menil Foundation engaged Herbert Brownell and Lord, Day & Lord, Barrett Smith in June 1983 to represent it in matters concerning the murals.p. 10
- The Republic of Cyprus identified the photographs as showing murals removed from the church of St. Themonianos near Lysi sometime between 1974 and 1983.p. 11
- The Menil Foundation arranged for the murals to be restored under its auspices and loaned to it for display, with the Church of Cyprus retaining ownership.p. 12
- A final protocol entrusted custody of the murals to the Menil Foundation for fifteen years from 1 January 1986.p. 12
- Carol Mancusi-Ungaro, chief conservator of The Menil Collection, consulted on the restoration.p. 12
- The church's dedication inscription records Lawrence as a hieromonk and abbot, but the name of his institution was not legible.p. 40
- Carr argues that the pointed arches show the Lysi church was built no earlier than the second half of the twelfth century.p. 40
- Carr dates the Lysi church's pointed-arch architecture broadly from around 1150 to the early 1300s.p. 40
- Carr interprets the Lysi church as a private chapel, probably built as Lawrence's personal votive foundation.p. 41
- Carr argues that the stylistic evidence supports a thirteenth-century date for the murals while leaving their precise place within it unresolved.p. 76
- The dome fragments' measured artificial baseline totalled 785.4 centimetres.p. 127
- The apse base of the Lysi church was about fifteen inches narrower than the initial estimate.p. 149
- The restored dome, without its crate, measured approximately 109 inches in diameter by 48 inches high and weighed 325 pounds.p. 156
Where to read
- Church architecture, dedication and the votive reading of the muralspp. 39–42
- Apse and dome imagery, inscriptions and theological interpretationpp. 43–55
- Stylistic comparisons and dating of the Lysi muralspp. 69–78
- Cyprus's thirteenth-century church history and artistic patronagepp. 83–98
- Fragment reconstruction, curvature calculations and fittingpp. 127–141
- Cleaning, inpainting and shipment to Houstonpp. 149–156
Contents
- Introduction7
- The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus15
- The Monument and Its Message39
- The Style and Its Attribution63
- Cyprus in the Thirteenth Century83
- Lysi and Thirteenth-Century Art in Cyprus99
- The Reconstruction and Restoration of the Lysi Murals115
- Determination of the Curvature of the Dome127
- Reshaping the Fragments into Their Original Curvature132
- Fitting the Fragments135
- Turning Over the Dome142
- Preparation of Backs to Receive Supportive Shells143
- Visit to Cyprus145
- Adjustment of Dimensions149
- Removal of Facings151
- Preparation for Transport154
- Final Comments157
Objects published here
2- Lysi dome mural with Christ Pantokrator and angels, The Menil Collection, Church of St. Themonianos, Lysi, Plates 5–13 (p. 63)
- Lysi apse mural with the Virgin and archangels, The Menil Collection, Church of St. Themonianos, Lysi, Plates 1–4, 23 (p. 43)
People, places and institutions
People
- Bertrand Davezacintroduced the project and recovery
- Aydin Dikmanpresented the murals in Munich
- Yanni Petsopoulosconveyed photographs and assisted recovery
- Dominique de Menilapproved the effort to identify the owners
- Walter Hoppsdirected the Menil Collection
- Carol Mancusi-Ungaroconsulted on mural conservation
- Herbert Brownelllegal representative for the foundation
- Peter Riceconsulted on the restoration
- Doula Mourikistudied Cypriot icons and painting
- Rupert Gunnisdescribed the church in 1936
- Theodore Apseudespainter used for stylistic comparison
- Lawrencededicated the church to Themonianos
- Richard the Lion Heartconquered Cyprus in 1191
- Aimery de Lusignanestablished the Latin kingdom
Institutions
- Church of Cyprusowner of the Lysi murals
- Menil Foundationarranged recovery, restoration and loan
- The Menil Collectiondisplayed the restored murals
Places
- Lysichurch and source of the murals
- St. Themonianoschurch from which the murals came
- TrikomoCypriot comparison for the imagery
- Asinouchurch and stylistic comparison
- Lagouderamural cycle used for comparison
- Kato Lefkarachurch used for stylistic comparison
- Moutoullasdated mural cycle and icon comparison
- KalopanayiotisCypriot mural comparison
- Rizokarpassochurches cited among thirteenth-century works
- PerachorioCypriot mural comparison
- Church of Christ Antiphonites at KalogreaCypriot mural and icon comparison
Also named: Lord, Day & Lord, Barrett Smith, Konstantin Leventis, David Winfield, Philip Grierson, Miltades Basil Efthimiou, St. Mihalarias, John and Dominique de Menil, Houston.
Extent 40 pls, figs 1–83; map of Cyprus, plans and section drawings
Defines domed-hall church, Pantokrator, Hetoimasia, Deesis, Platytera, chrysography, Celestial Liturgy, Christ Antiphonites
MedievalModernIconographyReligion and CultArchitectureMuseumsHistory of Archaeology
Who did what
17 recordsBuying, selling and giving 8
- 1988 · p. 8
Aydın DikmenSold
The author reported that Aydin Dikman sold mosaic fragments removed clandestinely from Panagia Kanakaria to agents for Peg L. Goldberg.
With agents for Peg L. Goldbergsixth-century mosaic fragments from the Panagia Kanakaria
- 1983 · p. 10
Herbert BrownellAgent forMenil Foundation
Herbert Brownell represented the Menil Foundation in matters concerning the Lysi murals.
- p. 11
Constantine LeventisConnected withDominique de Menil
Konstantin Leventis advised Dominique de Menil on Cyprus in connection with the recovery effort.
Lysi murals
- 1983 · p. 12
Dominique de MenilAgent forChurch of Cyprus
Dominique de Menil was authorized to redeem the Lysi murals on behalf of the Church of Cyprus.
Lysi fresco murals
- 1983 · p. 12
Yanni PetsopoulosAgent forChurch of Cyprus
Yanni Petsopoulos was the intermediary through whom Dominique de Menil was authorized to redeem the murals on behalf of the Church of Cyprus.
Lysi fresco murals
- p. 12
Vassos KarageorghisConnected withDominique de Menil
Vassos Karageorghis invited Dominique de Menil to Nicosia to review the matter of the Lysi murals.
- p. 12
Walter HoppsWorked withHerbert Brownell
Walter Hopps drafted the arrangements concerning the murals in consultation with Herbert Brownell.
Lysi murals
- p. 12
Walter HoppsWorked withVassos Karageorghis
Walter Hopps drafted the arrangements concerning the murals in consultation with Vassos Karageorghis.
Lysi murals
Recording and study 6
- 1983 · p. 7
Yanni PetsopoulosPassed objects toBertrand Davezac
Yanni Petsopoulos passed two photographs of the murals to Bertrand Davezac.
two photographs of Byzantine muralsLondon
- p. 11
Yanni PetsopoulosRecorded
Yanni Petsopoulos searched the Courtauld Institute for photographs and reached the same conclusion about the murals' origin.
photographs of the Lysi muralsLondon; Courtauld Institute
- p. 12
Laurence J. MoroccoWorked withPeter Rice
Laurence Morrocco restored the murals in consultation with Peter Rice.
Lysi murals
- p. 12
Laurence J. MoroccoWorked withCarol Mancusi-Ungaro
Laurence Morrocco restored the murals in consultation with Carol Mancusi-Ungaro.
Lysi murals
- p. 141
Bryan EvansWorked withLaurence J. Morocco
Bryan Evans designed a flexible template used in the restoration work.
Lysi fresco fragments
- p. 148
Laurence J. MoroccoPhotographed
Laurence Morrocco measured the church and photographed its interior and exterior.
interior and exterior of the churchLysi
Posts and family 3
- p. 7
Walter HoppsEmployed byThe Menil Collection
Walter Hopps was curator of contemporary art at the Menil Collection in Houston.
- 1952–1989 · p. 12
Vassos KarageorghisEmployed byDépartement des Antiquités de Chypre
Vassos Karageorghis attended the congress as interim director of the Department of Antiquities of Cyprus.
Paris
- p. 12
Carol Mancusi-UngaroEmployed byThe Menil Collection
Carol Mancusi-Ungaro was chief conservator of The Menil Collection.
People it is cited for
16 people- Dominique de Menil14 citations
- Yanni Petsopoulos12 citations
- Aydın Dikmen10 citations
- Bertrand Davezac9 citations
- Carol Mancusi-Ungaro7 citations
- Walter Hopps7 citations
- Herbert Brownell5 citations
- Constantine Leventis3 citations
- Stavros Mihalarias3 citations
- David Winfield2 citations
- Ernest Hawkins2 citations
- Miltiades B. Efthimiou2 citations
- Philip Grierson2 citations
- Doula Mouriki
- Erica Cruikshank Dodd
- Michel van Rijn
Institutions it is cited for
4 institutions- Menil Collection22 citations
- Church of Cyprus4 citations
- Lord, Day & Lord, Barrett Smith2 citations
- Southern Methodist University2 citations
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.