Article · 2015
The Rescue, Stewardship, and Return of the Lysi Frescoes by the Menil Foundation
Derek Fincham
International Journal of Cultural Property
An article on the Lysi frescoes from the Church of Themanianos: their acquisition by the Menil Foundation, conservation and display in Houston, and return to Cyprus.
Fincham follows the thirteenth-century Lysi frescoes from the offer made to the Menil Foundation in 1983 to their return to Cyprus in 2012. He sets the arrangement against the vulnerability of churches and cultural objects in the occupied north after the Turkish invasion of 1974, drawing on accounts by Menil staff and conservators, reported negotiations, and the frescoes' treatment and display.
The 38 fragments, of which 26 came from the dome, were reassembled by Laurence J. Morrocco's team, who for most of the work had no access to the original chapel. The Menil built a purpose-made chapel in Houston to house them. In 1987 the Menil and the Autocephalous Church of Cyprus agreed an initial fifteen-year custodianship, with conservation and display by the Menil, and the frescoes went back in 2012. Fincham sets this outcome beside the Menil's acquisition of mosaic fragments linked to Zeugma, which were returned to Turkey.
Fincham argues that the Menil's temporary stewardship, negotiated with the Church of Cyprus, offers a pattern for relations between museums and source communities. He also names an ethical tension: the Menil paid Aydin Dikmen, whom he describes as the leader of a looting network, for the frescoes, while seeking the Church's permission and arranging their eventual return.
What it records
- The thirteenth-century murals decorated the dome and apse of a small chapel near Lysi.p. 301
- The Menil Foundation was offered the fresco fragments in 1983 by the dealer Aydin Dikmen.p. 305
- Cyprus, Turkey and Lebanon each claimed the frescoes after Herbert Brownell sent them a letter and photographs, and only Cyprus supplied documentary evidence of the location of the Church of Themanianos.p. 307
- The purchase price paid for the frescoes was near $520,000.p. 307
- A 1987 agreement allowed the Menil to act as custodian of the frescoes for an initial fifteen years.p. 307
- The frescoes had been separated into 38 pieces, among them 26 from the dome, which the conservator Laurence J. Morrocco had to put back together.p. 308
- The frescoes were displayed in Houston for fifteen years and returned to Cyprus in 2012.p. 309
- Sections of a mosaic floor from the Zeugma region were returned to Turkey and are displayed at the Gaziantep museum.p. 310
Where to read
- The offer, due diligence and agreement with Cypruspp. 305–307
- Conservation and Houston display of the frescoesp. 308
- Return of the frescoes and the Menil’s other mosaic acquisitionspp. 309–310
Contents
- Introduction301
- Cyprus and the Chapel of St. Themanianos303
- Acquisition, Preservation, and Display of the Frescoes305
- Purchasing Illicit Art with the Owner's Permission308
- Conclusion311
Objects published here
1- Thirteenth-century frescoes from the Church of Themanianos, Menil Collection, Church of Themanianos near Lysi, Fig. 1 (p. 301)
People, places and institutions
People
- Aydin Dikmendealer who offered the frescoes
- Dominique de Menilnegotiated acquisition and custodianship
- Michel van Rijndescribed Dikmen's methods
- Bertrand Davezacfirst director of the Menil
- Herbert Brownellnegotiated the acquisition
- Laurence J. Morroccoconservator in charge of restoration
- Peg Goldbergbought Cypriot mosaics
Institutions
- Menil Foundationacquired, conserved and displayed the frescoes
- Autocephalous Church of Cyprusowner and party to the custodianship agreement
Places
- Church of Themanianoschapel from which the frescoes were removed
- Lysilocation of the chapel
- Zeugma regionorigin of mosaic fragments
- Houstonlocation of the Menil display
Also named: Department of Antiquities of Cyprus, Yiannis Petsopoulos, Andreas Jacovides, Paul Goldberger, Byzantine Museum in Nicosia, Gaziantep museum.
Extent pp. 301–314, 1 fig.; bibliography
MedievalModernCollectingMuseumsLooting and the LawReligion and Cult
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 pageWho did what
14 recordsBuying, selling and giving 10
- 1983–1985 · p. 305
Aydın DikmenSold toMenil Foundation
Aydin Dikmen offered the fresco fragments for purchase by the Menil.
thirteenth century Byzantine mural fragments
- 1988 · p. 305
Aydın DikmenWorked withMichel van Rijn
AllegedFincham alleged that Dikmen worked with Michel van Rijn in the sale of looted Cypriot mosaics.
sixth-century mosaics looted from a separate Church in Cyprus
- 1988 · p. 305
Aydın DikmenSold toPeg Goldberg
AllegedFincham alleged that Dikmen sold looted sixth-century mosaics to Peg Goldberg.
sixth-century mosaics looted from a separate Church in Cyprus
- 1983 · p. 306
Bertrand DavezacMetYanni Petsopoulos
Bertrand Davezac met Yiannis Petsopoulos, who showed him photographs of the fresco fragments.
England
- p. 306
Aydın DikmenSmuggled
AllegedFincham alleged that Dikmen oversaw the smuggling of objects from Cyprus to the Turkish mainland.
- p. 306
Dominique de MenilConnected withAydın Dikmen
Dominique de Menil agreed to pay Dikmen a small sum to secure the right to acquire the frescoes in the future.
a small sumMunich
- p. 306
Herbert BrownellAgent forDominique de Menil
Herbert Brownell negotiated the acquisition of the frescoes for Dominique de Menil.
- p. 307
Dominique de MenilBought fromAydın Dikmen
Dominique de Menil decided to pay Dikmen for the murals at a purchase price near $520,000.
near $520,000
- p. 307
Dominique de MenilConnected withDepartment of Antiquities of Cyprus
Dominique de Menil negotiated with the Department of Antiquities of Cyprus before purchasing the frescoes.
the fresco fragments
- p. 307
Dominique de MenilConnected withAutocephalous Church of Cyprus
Dominique de Menil negotiated with the Autocephalous Church of Cyprus and gained its assent before purchasing the frescoes.
the fresco fragments
Recording and study 2
- 1984 · p. 308
Laurence J. MoroccoStudied
Laurence J. Morrocco first examined the fresco fragments in London.
- p. 308
Laurence J. MoroccoRestored
Laurence J. Morrocco and his team used conservation techniques in London that ultimately undid damage to the murals.
the murals, separated into 38 pieces
Posts and family 2
- p. 302
Dominique de MenilMarried toJohn de Menil
Jean de Menil was Dominique de Menil's husband.
- p. 306
Bertrand DavezacEmployed byMenil Foundation
Bertrand Davezac was the Menil's first director.
People it is cited for
3 people- Dominique de Menil16 citations
- Aydın Dikmen6 citations
- Michel van Rijn
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.