Article · 1990

The Antiquities Market

Timothy Kaiser

Journal of Field Archaeology 17(2) 205-210

An article on the antiquities trade, with four legal cases from Cyprus, Peru, Britain and Mexico and an argument about how scarcity, elite display and negotiated authenticity give antiquities their value.

Kaiser surveys rising prices and expanding demand in the antiquities market, then takes four cases of disputed or stolen objects, from Cyprus, Peru, Britain and Mexico, to examine legal remedies and the social forces that give antiquities their market value.

In the Cyprus case four sixth-century Byzantine mosaics were removed from the church of the Panagia Kanakaria and bought in 1988 by Peg Goldberg through dealers including Aydin Dikmen and Michel van Rijn, and a US court then ruled on Goldberg's title (pp. 205–206). The Sipan case follows artifacts taken from a Moche tomb in Peru and their alleged movement through Bolivia and Britain, with US proceedings against the Swetnams and a separate civil action brought by Peru, and Kaiser describes how Peruvian patrimony and export laws affected the recovery claim. Roman bronzes believed to have been taken from John Browning's farm in Suffolk, and later offered for sale in New York, form the Icklingham case; Kaiser contrasts the difficulty of establishing their provenience with the recovery of documented objects stolen from Mexico's National Museum of Anthropology.

Kaiser concludes that national recovery efforts depend partly on documentation and on whether other governments recognise a country's ownership laws. He argues that limited supply and association with valued cultural heritages contribute to prices, that dealers, scholars, experts and consumers negotiate authenticity socially, and that knowledge surrounding particular cultures affects demand for their objects. The cases also show that legal title, provenance and authenticity are contested within a market shaped by economic interests and social values (pp. 206–210).

What it records

  • Apparently, the Kanakaria mosaics spent at least eight years in the possession of Aydin Dikmen.p. 206
  • Michel van Rijn received $282,500 from the $1.08 million payment for the four mosaics.p. 206
  • The US court ruled that the four mosaics were stolen and that Goldberg had no legal title to them.p. 206
  • Grave robbers removed approximately 300 ceramic and metal artifacts from a fifth-century warrior-priest's tomb near Sipan in 1986.p. 206
  • Peruvian law requires government permission to export artifacts.p. 207
  • Sixteen Icklingham pieces, including a statue of Vulcan and an inlaid cheetah, apparently surfaced in New York and were offered for sale.p. 208
  • Mexican police recovered 111 of the objects stolen from the National Museum of Anthropology; 13 remained unaccounted for.p. 209
  • Kaiser describes antiquities as luxury goods used by Western elites to display social distinction.p. 209

Where to read

  • The Panagia Kanakaria mosaics and court rulingpp. 205–206
  • The Sipan artifacts and Peru’s recovery claimpp. 206–207
  • Commoditization, elite distinction and authenticitypp. 209–210

Contents

  • Dealing for Dollars205
  • Introduction: Profiting from the Past205
  • Four Cases: Notes from the Underground205
  • The Cyprus Mosaics205
  • The Moche Artifacts of Sipan206
  • The Icklingham Bronzes207
  • A Recovery in Mexico208
  • Discussion209

People, places and institutions

People

  • Aydin Dikmenheld the mosaics before their 1988 sale
  • Michel van Rijndealer in the mosaics transaction
  • Peg Goldbergdealer who bought the mosaics
  • Robert Fitzgeralddealer in the mosaics transaction
  • David Swetnamdealer charged in the Sipan case
  • Jacquelyn Swetnamdealer charged in the Sipan case
  • Michael Kellyinformant in the Sipan investigation
  • John Browningfarmer seeking return of bronzes
  • Carlos Perches Treviñonamed by Mexico’s Attorney General
  • Ramon Sardina Garcianamed as Perches’ alleged accomplice

Institutions

Places

  • Panagia Kanakariachurch from which mosaics were removed
  • Sipanarea of the Moche tomb and artifacts

Also named: Geza von Hapsburg, Marion True, Salvador “Corporal” Gutierrez.

Extent pp. 205–210; bibliography

Defines commodities

ModernLate AntiqueRomanNeolithicTradeCollectingMuseumsLooting and the LawHistory of Archaeology

Who did what

8 records

Buying, selling and giving 6

  • Aydın DikmenSold toRobert Fitzgerald

    Aydin Dikmen supplied the four mosaics to the dealers in the transaction in which Goldberg paid $1.08 million.

    four 6th-century Byzantine mosaics$350,000the free-port area of the Geneva airport

    1988 · p. 206
  • Michel van RijnSold toPeg Goldberg

    Icons and church artMichel van Rijn sold mosaics to Peg Goldberg as part of the transaction in which she paid the dealers $1.08 million.

    four 6th-century Byzantine mosaics$282,500the free-port area of the Geneva airport

    1988 · p. 206
  • Robert FitzgeraldSold toPeg Goldberg

    Robert Fitzgerald sold mosaics to Peg Goldberg as part of the transaction in which she paid the dealers $1.08 million.

    four 6th-century Byzantine mosaics$282,500the free-port area of the Geneva airport

    1988 · p. 206
  • Michel van RijnSold

    Michel van Rijn sold half of his interest in Goldberg's anticipated profits for $375,000.

    With unnamed buyers$375,000

    p. 206
  • Peg GoldbergSold toGeza von Habsburg

    Peg Goldberg offered the mosaics for $20 million when she contacted Geza von Hapsburg.

    $20 million

    p. 206
  • Robert FitzgeraldSold

    Robert Fitzgerald sold half of his interest in Goldberg's anticipated profits for $375,000.

    With unnamed buyers$375,000

    p. 206

Recording and study 2

  • Geza von HabsburgConnected withMarion True

    Geza von Hapsburg consulted Marion True about the mosaics.

    p. 206
  • Marion TrueRecorded

    Marion True alerted the Cypriot authorities after consulting about the mosaics.

    With the Cypriot authorities

    p. 206

People it is cited for

2 people

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.