Article · 1991

Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters

Anne McC. Sullivan

Museum Management and Curatorship 10(3) 219-243. Routledge

An article on the law and diplomacy of cultural property returns, reviewing US legislation and court decisions and ending with the case of the Panagia Kanakaria mosaics from Cyprus.

Sullivan surveys national and international approaches to the ownership and return of cultural property, then turns to US federal law, diplomatic returns and court cases, and ends with the claim by the Church and Republic of Cyprus for mosaics removed from the Panagia Kanakaria. She contrasts cultural nationalism, which prioritises the claims of countries of origin, with cultural internationalism, which supports wider circulation of art. Treaties and statutes, she argues, offer limited remedies, while diplomacy, national laws and court decisions shape actual returns, and she presents due diligence as the standard for buyers investigating provenance and for victims pursuing the recovery of stolen works.

Treaty provisions, US statutes and case histories make up the evidence. Sullivan describes emergency import restrictions under the 1983 Cultural Property Act, including measures for El Salvador, Bolivia and Peru, and reviews returns and disputes involving Quedlinburg, India, Thailand and US museums (pp. 225–230).

The Kanakaria account sets out the church's status under Cypriot law, the removal and sale of the mosaics, and the evidence about the purchase by Peg Goldberg. Sullivan explains the Indiana court's ruling on title and limitation and its assessment of the buyer's inquiry and of Cyprus's recovery efforts. She concludes that the decision affirmed Cyprus's claim and shows courts weighing wartime occupation and provenance, and she recommends documented provenance checks for buyers and sustained written notices from owners seeking the return of stolen objects (pp. 233–238).

What it records

  • 69 of Unesco's 161 member states had ratified the Convention by February 1991.p. 223
  • The 1983 US Convention on Cultural Property Implementation Act applies to cultural property stolen after 12 April 1983.p. 225
  • The Panagia Kanakaria is listed by the government as protected, although title vests in the Autocephalous Church of Cyprus.p. 234
  • Fragments of the Panagia Kanakaria mosaic were removed from the church ceiling and taken to Munich between 1976 and 1979, according to trial testimony.p. 234
  • Van Rijn told Goldberg the mosaics belonged to Aydin Dikman, who had found them in a church used as a livestock pen, Sullivan reports.p. 235
  • The Indiana court ruled the mosaics stolen and held that a good-faith purchaser could not obtain title from a thief under Indiana law.p. 236
  • Goldberg sought US$20 million from the Getty Museum for the mosaics, but the museum's curator declined and notified Cypriot officials.p. 236
  • After learning in 1979 that the mosaics were missing, Cyprus contacted Unesco, ICOM and the Council of Europe.p. 237

Where to read

  • Emergency import restrictions under the US Cultural Property Actpp. 225–227
  • Due diligence and New York court casespp. 231–233
  • The Panagia Kanakaria mosaics dispute and court decisionpp. 233–238

Contents

  • I. Ethical and Legal Policies220
  • Cultural Nationalism220
  • Cultural Internationalism221
  • International Law on Cultural Property: Unesco222
  • Protective Measures Taken by Member States223
  • Unidroit224
  • II. Laws and Treaties of the United States Federal Government224
  • Cultural Property Act225
  • United States Customs Service227
  • Bilateral Agreements228
  • III. Case Studies229
  • IV. Doctrines Applied in US Courts231
  • Statutes of Limitations231
  • New York Cases231
  • V. The Case of The Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus and The Republic of Cyprus v. Goldberg and Feldman, Fine Arts, Inc.233
  • Background233
  • The Decision of the Court236
  • VI. Concluding Observations238
  • Appendix239
  • Bibliography242
  • Legal References243

Objects published here

1
  • Mosaic fragments from the Panagia Kanakaria, Panagia Kanakaria, Cyprus (p. 236)

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

  • Autocephalous Church of Cyprusclaimant to the mosaics
  • Republic of Cyprusclaimant and advocate for recovery
  • "Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus"illegitimate entity in the occupied north, recognised only by Turkey, discussed in the case
  • Unescointernational organisation and treaty body
  • ICOMorganisation notified of the mosaics' loss
  • Menil Foundationbought Kanakaria frescoes and returned them

Places

  • Panagia Kanakariachurch from which the mosaics were removed

Also named: Robert Fitzgerald, Nick Frenzel, Myron Vorax, Dr Marion True, Getty Museum, Lythrankomi, Carpas peninsula.

Extent pp. 219–243, one illustration (p. 223); appendix; bibliography and legal references

Defines cultural nationalism, cultural internationalism, due diligence, replevin

ModernMedievalLate AntiqueRomanLooting and the LawMuseumsCollectingForeign Contacts

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

1 page

Who did what

17 records

Buying, selling and giving 10

  • Peg GoldbergIn litigation withAutocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus

    Icons and church artGoldberg was sued by the Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus over the mosaics.

    Kanakaria mosaicsIndiana

    p. 233
  • Peg GoldbergIn litigation withRepublic of Cyprus

    Goldberg was sued by the Republic of Cyprus over the mosaics.

    Kanakaria mosaicsIndiana

    p. 233
  • Robert FitzgeraldHelpedPeg Goldberg

    Icons and church artRobert Fitzgerald informed Peg Goldberg that the four mosaics were available.

    Amsterdam

    1988 · p. 234
  • Aydın DikmenSold toMenil Foundation

    Aydin Dikmen offered the fresco fragments for purchase by the Menil.

    thirteenth century Byzantine mural fragments

    1983–1985 · p. 235
  • Michel van RijnConnected withPeg Goldberg

    Van Rijn told Goldberg the Kanakaria mosaics were available.

    Amsterdam

    p. 235
  • Otto N. Frenzel IIIHelpedPeg Goldberg

    Frenzel helped arrange a loan so Goldberg could make the purchase.

    loan for Goldberg's purchase of the mosaicsUS1,224,000

    p. 235
  • Peg GoldbergBought

    possiblyGoldberg's transaction for the mosaics was consummated, but the bill of sale did not identify Dikman as the seller.

    With Aydin Dikman (or someone claiming to be him)portions of the mosaic compositionGeneva

    p. 235
  • Marion TrueRecorded

    True declined Goldberg's offer and notified Cypriot officials.

    Kanakaria mosaicsGetty Museum, Malibu, California

    p. 236
  • Peg GoldbergSold toGetty Museum

    Goldberg marketed the mosaics to the Getty Museum for US$20 million, but the offer was declined.

    mosaic fragmentsUS$20 millionMalibu, California

    p. 236
  • Gary VikanTestified aboutAydın Dikmen

    Vikan testified that the circumstances involving Dikman were highly suspicious.

    Kanakaria mosaics

    p. 237

Excavation 1

  • Aydın DikmenFound

    possiblyVan Rijn told Goldberg that Dikman had found the mosaics in a church used as a livestock pen.

    Kanakaria mosaicsan ‘extinct church’

    p. 235

Recording and study 5

  • Myron VoraxEmployed byChildren's Museum in Indianapolis

    Vorax was a conservator at the Children's Museum in Indianapolis.

    mosaic fragments

    p. 235
  • Myron VoraxRestored

    Vorax reset loose tiles, reinforced plaster backings, and painted damaged areas to simulate a tile pattern.

    mosaic fragmentsIndianapolis

    p. 235
  • Vassos KarageorghisConnected withChristie's

    Karageorghis spoke to Christie's about Cyprus's missing mosaics.

    missing Kanakaria mosaics

    p. 237
  • Vassos KarageorghisConnected withSotheby's

    Karageorghis spoke to Sotheby's about Cyprus's missing mosaics.

    missing Kanakaria mosaics

    p. 237
  • Vassos KarageorghisRecorded

    Karageorghis spoke to individuals at the British Museum about Cyprus's missing mosaics.

    With individuals at the British Museummissing Kanakaria mosaics

    p. 237

Posts and family 1

People it is cited for

8 people

Institutions it is cited for

5 institutions

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.