Collector

Willem Otto Arie Lans

fl. 1970–2013 · Netherlands

Dutch owner of four 16th-century apostle icons from Christos Antiphonitis, whom the Church of Cyprus sued in the Netherlands from 1995; a Dutch court found him a buyer in good faith.

Biography

Willem Otto Arie Lans was a Dutchman in whose possession four 16th-century icons from the iconostasis of the church of Christos Antifonitis, near the occupied village of Kalograia, were found1. His dates of birth and death are not known; in 2013 the Cyprus Mail called the buyers of the icons "an elderly Dutch couple"2.

The icons

By the Church's case as Matyk reports it, the icons disappeared from the Antiphonitis church after the Turkish occupation of northern Cyprus in July and August 19743. The Cyprus Mail wrote that "it is assumed" they were removed in 1975 and bought through an Armenian art dealer by the couple between 1975 and 19772. As Stephan Matyk reports the court's finding, Lans bought them in the 1970s in the Netherlands from the art dealer Edouard Dergazarian for about NLG 200,0003. He lent them to the exhibition "Important Icons from Private Collections" at the Prinsenhof Museum in Delft, from 17 December 1976 to 15 January 19773.

In 1995, by the accounts of the Cyprus Mail and the ARCA blog, the couple tried to sell the icons through Christie's, which referred the couple to the Cypriot authorities because of the icons' suspicious provenance2,4. The couple then contacted Tasoula Hadjitofi, consul of Cyprus in the Netherlands, who informed the authorities2.

The case

The sources disagree on when the case began, 1995 or 1996: Matyk writes that on 25 July 1995 the icons of John, Mark, Paul and Peter were in Lans's dwelling, and that the Church attached them that day and they were taken into judicial custody3. About Cyprus, edited by Polly Lyssiotis, instead dates the find to October 1996 and says the Department of Antiquities and the Church of Cyprus began proceedings the same month1.

The suit was in private law; Lans's defence first contested that the icons came from Antiphonitis, then deferred to the court on that point, and he claimed he had bought them in good faith and was owner under Dutch law in any case3. On 4 February 1999 the District Court of Rotterdam decided The Autocephalous Greek Orthodox Church in Cyprus v. Willem O. A. Lans and dismissed the Church's claims, including that he had not acted in good faith3. The court reasoned that bad faith could not easily explain why he had lent the icons to the exhibition and later offered them for sale3. Matyk calls it apparently the first case in which the 1954 Protocol was invoked in a private-law suit, one that "could be considered to create a serious precedent"3. The Hague Court of Appeal upheld the judgment5. The ARCA blog says the appeal court found the claim time-barred in 20024.

The return

The Netherlands adopted its Cultural Property Originating From Occupied Territory Act in 2007 with specific reference to this case5. In 2011 the Cypriot Minister of Foreign Affairs formally asked the Dutch for the return of the four icons4. On 18 September 2013 the Dutch Director General of Culture and Media handed them to the Ambassador of Cyprus, the first return under the Protocol by the Netherlands and apparently the first in the world6.

Life and work

  1. 1999

    1. 1999–2013

      With his wife bought four 16th-c. Antiphonitis iconostasis icons from Dikmen; won the Cyprus claims at Rotterdam (1999) and The Hague (2002); icons returned 2013 under the 2007 Act. Never charged.

      Christiana O'Connell-Schizas, 2014, The Dikmen Conspiracy: the Illicit Removal, Journey and Trade of Looted Ecclesiastical Antiquities from Occupied Cyprus, Journal of Art Crime, pp. 15-34

Connections

1 person

Mentioned in

2 mentions

Documents · 1

Sources

  1. 1.Polly Lyssiotis (ed.). About Cyprus.
  2. 2.Peter Stevenson (2013). “Returned icons given a new home”. Cyprus Mail. Online
  3. 3.Stephan Matyk (2000). “The Restitution of Cultural Objects and the Question of Giving Direct Effect to the Protocol to the Hague Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict 1954”. International Journal of Cultural Property 9, 341–346. Online
  4. 4.Christiana O'Connell-Schizas (2013). After decade-long fight, Cyprus recovers icons of apostles from the Antiphonitis church in Kalograia. Online
  5. 5.Adinda van de Walle and Gabriele Kuchenbecker. “Netherlands/Cyprus, Repatriation of Cultural Property”. ICRC, IHL in Action. Online
  6. 6.Cyprus and the Netherlands (2013). “Mutual Presentation of Cyprus and the Netherlands on the return of 4 icons from the Netherlands to Cyprus under the Protocol of the Hague Convention of 1954”. 10th meeting of the High Contracting Parties to the Hague Convention, UNESCO, 16 December 2013. Online
  7. 7.Christiana O'Connell-Schizas, 2014, The Dikmen Conspiracy: the Illicit Removal, Journey and Trade of Looted Ecclesiastical Antiquities from Occupied Cyprus, Journal of Art Crime.

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Date of birth unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.