Article · 1990
Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet
Deborah Hoover
Journal of Arts Management and Law 20(1) 37-62. Routledge
An article on U.S. title-dispute cases over stolen art and antiquities, including the Kanakaria mosaics, and on diligence practices for museums.
Hoover reviews U.S. title disputes over stolen art, consigned works and antiquities, and asks what the decisions mean for how museums acquire objects and respond to thefts. Her central claim is that courts expect purchasers to investigate suspicious circumstances and expect theft victims to make a sustained, targeted effort to locate missing objects. She develops the demand-refusal and due-diligence standards from Menzel v. List, DeWeerth v. Baldinger and Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus v. Goldberg.
The Cyprus case follows the Byzantine mosaics looted from the apse of the church at Panagia Kanakaria in Lythrankomi, from the theft to their purchase by Peg Goldberg, the litigation in Indiana and the court's order (pp. 45–49). A further section describes the stolen-art files kept by IFAR, INTERPOL and the FBI, with their contents and the procedures for reporting a loss and requesting a search.
Hoover concludes that museums should keep regular inventories, report thefts promptly, notify relevant institutions and experts, and record their inquiries into title. Before an acquisition they should investigate before signing, or allow time for further checks, especially where the seller, the price or the provenance raises questions (pp. 51–55).
What it records
- After the theft of the Kanakaria mosaics, the Cyprus Department of Antiquities contacted UNESCO, ICOM, the British Museum, the Louvre, major auction houses and Dumbarton Oaks.p. 45
- Peg Goldberg and the seller Aydin Dikman negotiated the price of the Kanakaria mosaics down from 3 million to 1.2 million.p. 46
- The court held that Peg Goldberg's cursory inquiries were inadequate to qualify her as a good-faith purchaser of the mosaics.p. 49
- The court ordered the mosaics returned to their owner, the Church of Cyprus, because Goldberg did not acquire good title under either Swiss or Indiana law.p. 49
- Hoover recommends that museums hold regular inventories and, as theft victims, make a sustained and well-planned effort to locate missing objects.p. 51
- By the end of 1989 the stolen-art file of the International Foundation for Art Research held more than 30,000 entries, and Hoover gives its recovery rate as approximately 12 percent.p. 53
- IFAR Reports appeared ten times a year, and each issue's Stolen Art Alert listed approximately one hundred stolen works.p. 53
Where to read
- Kanakaria mosaics and the Goldberg litigationpp. 45–49
- Museum acquisition and theft-response procedurespp. 51–53
- IFAR, INTERPOL and FBI stolen-art resourcespp. 53–55
Contents
- The Early Cases: Standards of Diligence Emerge38
- Recent Cases: Standards of Diligence Firmly Entrenched41
- The Museum and Stolen Art: Practical Considerations50
- Stolen Art Archives53
- Conclusion55
- Notes56
Objects published here
1- Four Byzantine mosaics from the apse of the Church of Panagia Kanakaria, Church of Panagia Kanakaria, Lythrankomi (p. 45)
People, places and institutions
People
- Peg Goldbergbought and resold the mosaics
- Michel van Rijndealer in the negotiations
- Aydin Dikmanseller of the mosaics
- Dr. Gary Vikanwitness for the Church of Cyprus
Institutions
- Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprusclaimed and recovered the mosaics
- Republic of Cyprusco-plaintiff in the mosaics case
- Cyprus Department of Antiquitiesreported the theft of the mosaics
- Getty Museumits curator recognised the mosaics
- International Foundation for Art Researchkeeps a stolen-art archive
- INTERPOLcirculates stolen-art information
- Metropolitan Museum of Artdefendant in a Turkish antiquities claim
Places
- Church of Panagia Kanakariaoriginal home of the mosaics
Also named: Robert Fitzgerald, Ronald Faulk, Lythrankomi, UNESCO, ICOM, British Museum, Louvre, Dumbarton Oaks.
Extent pp. 37–62
Who did what
10 recordsBuying, selling and giving 10
- 1988 · p. 45
Peg GoldbergMetRobert Fitzgerald
Peg Goldberg met Robert Fitzgerald while she was on a buying trip in Amsterdam.
four mosaics
- 1988 · p. 45
Peg GoldbergMetMichel van Rijn
Peg Goldberg met Michel van Rijn about the mosaics.
- 1988 · p. 45
Peg Goldberg met Ronald Faulk about the mosaics.
- 1988 · p. 45
Robert FitzgeraldHelpedPeg Goldberg
Icons and church artRobert Fitzgerald informed Peg Goldberg that the four mosaics were available.
Amsterdam
- 1988 · p. 46
Peg GoldbergBought fromAydın Dikmen
Peg Goldberg agreed to buy the mosaics from the Turk for a little over a million dollars.
a little over a million dollars
- p. 46
Gary VikanTestified aboutChurch of Cyprus
Dr. Gary Vikan testified that the church's search for the mosaics was consistent with current practices in the art world.
- p. 46
Peg Goldberg, Robert Fitzgerald, and Ronald Faulk met Aydin Dikman in Geneva.
the mosaics
- p. 46
Ronald Faulk met Aydin Dikman in Munich during the negotiations.
the mosaics
- 1983–1985 · p. 59
Aydın DikmenSold toMenil Foundation
Aydin Dikmen offered the fresco fragments for purchase by the Menil.
thirteenth century Byzantine mural fragments
- p. 59
Peg GoldbergRecorded
Peg Goldberg entered into side agreements with various parties to divide the resale profits.
With various partiesthe mosaics
People it is cited for
2 people- Peg Goldberg13 citations
- Michel van Rijn5 citations
Institutions it is cited for
2 institutionsCorrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.