Book · 1994
Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade
New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux
A narrative investigation of an Indianapolis dealer's purchase of four mosaics from Panagía Kanakariá, the Republic of Cyprus's lawsuit to recover them, and the wider trade in Cypriot religious art.
Hofstadter follows the purchase of four Early Christian mosaics by the Indianapolis dealer Peg Goldberg and the Republic of Cyprus's lawsuit to recover them. The mosaics came from the church of Panagía Kanakariá in the occupied north, and the Church of Cyprus said they had been removed after the Turkish invasion of 1974. The narrative moves between the federal trial of 1989, Goldberg's later efforts to challenge its outcome, and Hofstadter's own reporting in the Netherlands, Germany and Cyprus. From the purchase and the lawsuit it widens into an inquiry into intermediaries, collectors, museums, officials and alleged trafficking in Cypriot religious art, resting on trial testimony, depositions, purchase documents and interviews.
How it is organised
A prologue, The Bazaar, presents the Grand Bazaar as a setting for bargaining, performance and uncertain accounts of goods. Chapter 1 introduces Goldberg and Bob Fitzgerald, then recounts the Amsterdam meetings, the proposed purchase and the history of the mosaics. Legal preparation and the Indianapolis trial follow, then the judgment and Goldberg's appeal.
Chapter 4 follows Hofstadter's meetings with Michel van Rijn and Savo Kujundžić in the Netherlands, and the chapters after it continue the reporting in Vienna, Munich and Cyprus. Chapters 6 and 7 describe the return of the four mosaics to Cyprus, interviews with officials and dealers, and Hofstadter's assessment of the conflicting accounts (pp. 172–241).
The evidence
Hofstadter describes the 1977 Dumbarton Oaks monograph by A. H. S. Megaw and E. J. W. Hawkins as a published photographic record of the church and its mosaics, and explains how the pre-invasion images help identify the fragments Goldberg bought. Testimony from Walter Hopps and Dominique de Menil concerns the recovery and temporary display arrangements for frescoes from the church of St. Themonianos near Lysi, as well as their reported contacts with Aydin Dikmen and the return of two Kanakariá roundels.
Later chapters add interviews with Vassos Karageorghis, Ali Kanli, Ahmet Kadir Dinç and Mehmet Rasih Savarona, alongside reports from Turkish Cypriot journalists and officials. Their accounts differ, and Hofstadter identifies many claims as allegations or as the speaker's version of events (pp. 177–204).
The argument
Hofstadter presents the mosaics case as a dispute over ownership and due diligence, complicated by inconsistent testimony and unclear transactions. At trial Cyprus argued that the Church had never sold or given away the mosaics, and Goldberg maintained that she had bought them in good faith. He examines whether Indiana or Swiss law applied, when Cyprus tried to recover the pieces, what had been published about the mosaics, and the purchase documents and money flows. He also tests competing explanations, among them a confidence scheme and claims that Cypriot officials had earlier dealt with Dikmen, and he separates reported testimony from what he can establish (pp. 75–82).
Judge Noland's decision of 3 August 1989 also found Goldberg's inquiries inadequate when Swiss law was considered as an alternative. The Court of Appeals upheld it, and in 1991 the Supreme Court declined to hear Goldberg's appeal (pp. 82–107).
Several central questions stay open, including who possessed the other missing fragments and who appeared in Geneva as the seller, and the book ends without resolving the conflicting versions of the sale (pp. 220–241).
Dating
The chronology runs from the invasion of 1974 and the occupation of the north, through the report of the missing mosaics, the return of two roundels in 1984, with the other known fragments still missing, and Goldberg's agreement of July 1988, to the Indianapolis trial in late May and early June 1989 and the appeals that continued through 1991, when the four mosaics returned to Cyprus (pp. 44–172).
What it records
- The Church of Cyprus said that the Panagía Kanakariá mosaics had been removed after the Turkish invasion of 1974.p. 17
- Peg Goldberg agreed on 3 July 1988 to buy the four Kanakariá mosaics for a little over a million dollars.p. 44
- A 1977 Dumbarton Oaks volume holds photographs of the Kanakariá church, its frescoes and its mosaics.p. 45
- In November 1979 the Republic of Cyprus learned that the Kanakariá church still stood but its mosaics were gone.p. 47
- The roundels of Jude and Bartholomew from Kanakariá resurfaced in the Republic of Cyprus in 1984.p. 47
- The Republic of Cyprus filed its recovery action in federal court in Indianapolis on 29 March 1989.p. 54
- Judge James E. Noland ruled that the four mosaics belonged to the Church of Cyprus and ordered them delivered to it.p. 82
- Noland applied Indiana law because the Church of Cyprus had never sold or given the mosaics to anyone.p. 82
- Gary Vikan testified that Yanni Petsopoulos offered the Lysi frescoes to Dumbarton Oaks before approaching the Menil Foundation.p. 103
- The four mosaics arrived in Cyprus in early September 1991.p. 172
- Hofstadter saw the returned mosaics in a back room of the Byzantine Museum in Nicosia.p. 172
- Karageorghis told Hofstadter that he bought antiquities from Ahmet Aziz for Cypriot collections in the period of the enclaves.p. 184
- Turkish Cypriot informants connected Hasan Harman to many church thefts on the island.p. 188
- The informants named Mustafa Avçibaşı, Kemal Köse and Ahmet Kadir Dinç as Harman's associates.p. 189
- A Turkish Cypriot source said that a case against Aydin Dikmen over the theft of the Lysi frescoes had been opened in Famagusta District.p. 189
- In November 1991 an icon of Saint John Prodrome was withdrawn from a Sotheby's sale after protests by the Church of Cyprus.p. 210
- The Church of Cyprus's attorneys presented affidavits on the icon's original place in a church in northern Cyprus.p. 210
- The High Court of Justice in London ordered the icon held by an art shipper until the question of rightful possession was decided.p. 211
Where to read
- Goldberg’s purchase, intermediaries and the Geneva transactionpp. 36–50
- Trial evidence, legal arguments and Noland’s rulingpp. 55–82
- Menil Foundation and the Lysi frescoespp. 61–64
- Savo Kujundžić’s testimony and claims about the missing piecespp. 98–101
- Reports on antiquities theft in the occupied northpp. 182–203
- Ahmet Kadir Dinç and Mehmet Rasih Savarona interviewedpp. 191–204
- Hofstadter’s account of the mosaics’ uncertain whereaboutspp. 220–224
Objects published here
6- North Archangel mosaic, Church of Panagía Kanakariá, Lythrankomí (p. 41)
- Roundel of James, Church of Panagía Kanakariá, Lythrankomí (p. 40)
- Roundel of Matthew, Church of Panagía Kanakariá, Lythrankomí (p. 40)
- Hand and Feet of Mary and Christ fragment, Church of Panagía Kanakariá, Lythrankomí (p. 47)
- Roundels of Saint Jude and Saint Bartholomew, Church of Panagía Kanakariá, Lythrankomí (p. 47)
- Icon of Saint John Prodrome, Iconostasis of a church in a northern Cypriot village (p. 210)
People, places and institutions
People
- Peg GoldbergIndianapolis dealer who bought the four mosaics
- Aydin Dikmennamed in accounts as source of the mosaics
- Bob Fitzgeralddealer and intermediary in the purchase
- Michel van Rijndealer Hofstadter meets in the Netherlands
- Ronald Faulklawyer and intermediary in the transaction
- James E. Nolandfederal judge who decided the case
- Thomas R. Klinetrial counsel for Cyprus
- Joe Emersontrial counsel for Goldberg
- Nick Frenzelbanker and Goldberg's lender
- Gary Vikanart expert who testified at trial
- Walter HoppsMenil Collection curator who gave a deposition
- Dominique de Menilcollector and founder of the Menil Foundation
- Vassos KarageorghisCypriot director of antiquities, interviewed by Hofstadter
- Constantine LeventisCyprus ambassador who testified
- Yanni Petsopoulosdealer in the Lysi fresco negotiations
- Savo Kujundžićengineer and source for Goldberg
- Ahmet Kadir DinçTurkish Cypriot dealer interviewed by Hofstadter
- Ali Kanlidirector of the Turkish Cypriot antiquities department
- Özgen Acarjournalist reporting on antiquities trafficking
Institutions
- Church of Cyprusclaimed ownership and sought the mosaics' return
- Republic of Cyprusplaintiff in the recovery action
- Dumbarton Oaks Center for Byzantine Studiessponsored the Kanakariá monograph
- Menil Foundationbought the Lysi frescoes under an agreement
- Merchants National Bankfinanced Goldberg's purchase
- Sotheby'sauction house in accounts of Cypriot antiquities
- Ortamnewspaper publishing reports on antiquities theft
- Byzantine Museumheld the returned mosaics in Nicosia
Places
- Panagía Kanakariáchurch from which the mosaics were removed
- Lythrankomívillage where Panagía Kanakariá stands
- Lysilocation of the church of St. Themonianos
- St. Themonianossource of frescoes bought by the Menil Foundation
- Antiphonitismonastery named in reports of missing art
Also named: Stewart Bick, Geza von Habsburg, John de Menil, Demos Christou, E. J. W. Hawkins, A. H. S. Megaw, Christie's, Cumhuriyet, Amathounta.
ModernLate AntiqueMedievalLooting and the LawCollectingMuseumsHistory of ArchaeologyReligion and Cult
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 pageWho did what
49 recordsBuying, selling and giving 43
- p. 17
Peg GoldbergBought
Icons and church artPeg Goldberg bought four Early Christian devotional mosaics in Europe for a little more than a million dollars, using money borrowed from an Indiana bank.
four Early Christian devotional mosaics, each about two feet squarea little more than a million dollars
- p. 37
Ronald FaulkAgent forRobert Fitzgerald
Ronald Faulk represented Bob Fitzgerald in connection with the proposed purchase.
mosaics
- p. 41
- p. 43
Ronald FaulkAgent forMichel van Rijn
Ronald Faulk was also Michel van Rijn’s legal counsel in the proposed purchase.
mosaics
- 1988 · p. 44, 163
Peg GoldbergBought fromAydın Dikmen
Peg Goldberg agreed to buy the mosaics from the Turk for a little over a million dollars.
a little over a million dollars
- p. 48
Michel van RijnSold toStewart Bick
Stewart Bick acquired half of Michel's interest in the mosaics.
- p. 48
Robert FitzgeraldSold toStewart Bick
Stewart Bick acquired half of Bob's interest in the mosaics.
- p. 49
Geza von HabsburgAgent forPeg Goldberg
Geza von Habsburg proposed arranging a private sale of Peg Goldberg's mosaics.
- p. 49
Geza von HabsburgSold toJ. Paul Getty Museum
Geza von Habsburg offered the pieces to the Getty for $20 million.
$20 million
- 1989 · p. 50
Peg GoldbergRecorded
Icons and church artA new agreement allowed Peg and the other signatories to buy the items by exercising Michel's option.
With the Turkish gentlemanthe Hand and Feet plus Andrew
- p. 50
Michel van RijnRecorded
Icons and church artMichel said he had persuaded the Turkish gentleman to sell the Hand and Feet and Andrew.
With the Turkish gentlemanthe Hand and Feet plus Andrew
- 1989 · p. 54
Peg GoldbergConnected withRepublic of Cyprus
The Republic of Cyprus filed a recovery action against Peg Goldberg for the mosaics.
four Kanakariá mosaicsIndianapolis
- 1983 · p. 61
Dominique de MenilAcquired
Icons and church artDominique de Menil participated in the Menil Foundation's acquisition of two frescoes from a Turkish businessman in Munich.
With a Turkish businessmantwo Byzantine frescoes
- 1983 · p. 61
Yanni PetsopoulosAgent forDominique de Menil
Yanni Petsopoulos took Walter Hopps and Dominique de Menil to see the frescoes in Dikmen’s possession.
two Byzantine frescoesMunich
- 1984 · p. 64
Aydın DikmenPassed on
probablyIcons and church artAccording to Hopps, Dikmen returned mosaics that turned up in Cyprus in 1984.
With CyprusKanakariá mosaics
Show 28 moreShow fewer
- p. 70
Michel van RijnBought fromAydın Dikmen
possiblyKline asked whether Michel van Rijn had paid Aydin Dikmen $350,000 for the mosaics.
$350,000
- p. 70
Ronald FaulkAcquired
Faulk's deposition stated that he received $80,000 as compensation for his services.
$80,000
- 1989 · p. 81
Peg GoldbergBought
Icons and church artA purchase agreement dated July 3, 1989 showed Peg paid $1.08 million for the mosaics.
With the middlemen$1.08 million
- 1989 · p. 82
Peg GoldbergConnected withChurch of Cyprus
Judge Noland ruled that the mosaics belonged to the Church of Cyprus and should be delivered into its custody.
four mosaics
- 1984 · p. 97
Constantine LeventisBought fromAydın Dikmen
possiblyPeg said Dikmen told her that Leventis had paid him for four other Kanakariá mosaics in 1984.
about 180,000 Deutsche marks
- 1983 · p. 103
Dominique de MenilReceived fromAydın Dikmen
Dominique de Menil acquired two objects besides the Lysi frescoes from Dikmen's Munich flat.
two objects, including a jewel-studded Sumerian idol
- p. 103
Yanni PetsopoulosSold toGary Vikan
Yanni Petsopoulos offered the frescoes to Gary Vikan for $600,000, and Vikan rejected them as illicit antiquities.
Lysi frescoes$600,000Dumbarton Oaks
- 1979 · p. 104
Dominique de MenilBought fromGeorge Zacos
Dominique de Menil acquired antiquities worth $120,000 from George Zacos for her future museum.
$120,000
- p. 112
Aydın DikmenSold toMichel van Rijn
Icons and church artMichel van Rijn said Aydin Dikmen sold him the Saint Peter panel that later reached the British Museum.
Saint Peter icon panel
- p. 112
Gary VikanAgent forDumbarton Oaks
Icons and church artGary Vikan arranged to buy the panel for Dumbarton Oaks.
Saint Peter icon panel
- p. 112
Michel van RijnPassed objects toStavros Mihalarias
Icons and church artMichel van Rijn passed the Saint Peter panel to Stavros Mihalarias for restoration and sale.
Saint Peter icon panelLondon
- p. 112
Stavros MihalariasSold toBritish Museum
Icons and church artStavros Mihalarias cleaned the Saint Peter panel and sold it to the British Museum for £175,000.
Saint Peter icon panel£175,000
- p. 117
Michel van RijnReceived fromAydın Dikmen
Michel van Rijn said he had obtained the Hand of Mary and Feet of Christ from Aydin Dikmen.
- p. 119
Yanni PetsopoulosConnected withAydın Dikmen
Hopps said Petsopoulos pressed Dikmen to deliver the mosaics into Constantine Leventis's custody.
two Kanakariá mosaics
- p. 132
Yanni PetsopoulosConsigned toAydın Dikmen
Savo said Petsopoulos had taken many things on consignment from Dikmen to sell in London.
- 1988 · p. 161
Peg GoldbergBought fromRonald Faulk
Peg Goldberg gave Ronald Faulk cash in exchange for claim tickets to the pieces.
Geneva
- p. 178
Michel van RijnOffered for sale
Icons and church artKyprianou said van Rijn had offered swaps and deals, which the Cypriots rejected.
With the Cypriotsstolen icons
- 1963–1974 · p. 182, 183
Vassos KarageorghisBought
AllegedMakarios Drousiotis’s articles alleged that Karageorghis bought antiquities for the Cypriot state from illicit Turkish Cypriot operators.
With illicit Turkish Cypriot operators
- p. 189
Aydın DikmenRecorded
A case against Dikmen for the theft of the Lysi frescoes had been opened in Famagusta District.
- p. 210
Stavros MihalariasBought fromMichel van Rijn
possiblyIcons and church artMihalarias claimed he could not recall having acquired the British Museum's Saint Peter from van Rijn.
- p. 210
Yanni PetsopoulosConsigned toSotheby's
Icons and church artThe icon had been consigned to Sotheby's by the Menil Foundation’s former agent Yanni Petisopoulos.
icon of Saint John Prodrome
- 1993 · p. 212
Yanni PetsopoulosPassed objects toChurch of Cyprus
Icons and church artPetsopoulos returned the icon of Saint John Prodrome to the Church of Cyprus.
- p. 212
Yanni PetsopoulosReceived fromChurch of Cyprus
possiblyIcons and church artTwo unconnected sources told the author that Petsopoulos had secretly received £8,000 from the Church of Cyprus.
£8,000
- 1988 · p. 217
Michel van RijnSold toPeg Goldberg
Icons and church artMichel van Rijn sold mosaics to Peg Goldberg as part of the transaction in which she paid the dealers $1.08 million.
four 6th-century Byzantine mosaics$282,500the free-port area of the Geneva airport
- 1988 · p. 217
Robert FitzgeraldHelpedPeg Goldberg
Icons and church artRobert Fitzgerald informed Peg Goldberg that the four mosaics were available.
Amsterdam
- p. 218
Robert FitzgeraldGave toMichel van Rijn
possiblyIcons and church artMichel said Bob offered him a suitcase containing fifty thousand Swiss francs after returning from Geneva.
a suitcase with money from the mosaics dealfifty thousand Swiss francsAmsterdam
- p. 228
Aydın DikmenPassed objects toMichel van Rijn
possiblyThe author said some prize items Dikmen obtained later found their way to Michel van Rijn.
prize items from the Kyrenia Castle robbery
- p. 228, 212
Aydın DikmenPassed objects toYanni Petsopoulos
Petsopoulos said Dikmen had sent him photographs of pieces that did not interest him.
photos of pieces
Recording and study 4
- 1977 · p. 45
Arthur Hubert Stanley MegawWorked withErnest Hawkins
Icons and church artPeter Megaw collaborated with E.J.W. Hawkins on a publication about the church.
The Church of the Panayia Kanakaria at Lythrankomi
- 1977 · p. 45
Arthur Hubert Stanley MegawPublished
Icons and church artPeter Megaw co-authored a publication about The Church of the Panayia Kanakaria at Lythrankomi.
No. DOS XIV
- p. 61
Dominique de MenilFoundedMenil Collection
Dominique de Menil founded the Menil Collection, a museum based on her own holdings and named after her late husband.
- 1964–1974 · p. 132
Aydın DikmenConnected withVassos Karageorghis
possiblySavo claimed that Karageorghis commissioned Dikmen to photograph Byzantine churches inaccessible to Greek Cypriot authorities.
photographs of Byzantine churchesCyprus
Posts and family 2
- p. 60
Walter HoppsEmployed byThe Menil Collection
Walter Hopps was curator of contemporary art at the Menil Collection in Houston.
- p. 68
Gary VikanEmployed byWalters Art Gallery
Gary Vikan was curator of medieval art at the Walters Art Gallery in Baltimore.
People it is cited for
23 people- Aydın Dikmen52 citations
- Peg Goldberg46 citations
- Yanni Petsopoulos23 citations
- Michel van Rijn21 citations
- Thomas R. Kline17 citations
- Constantine Leventis12 citations
- Walter Hopps11 citations
- Joe Emerson9 citations
- Ronald Faulk9 citations
- Gary Vikan8 citations
- Robert Fitzgerald8 citations
- Dominique de Menil7 citations
- Otto N. Frenzel III7 citations
- Ali Kanli6 citations
- Stewart Bick6 citations
- Geza von Habsburg5 citations
- James E. Noland5 citations
- Stavros Mihalarias5 citations
- Özgen Acar5 citations
- Marion True4 citations
- Demos Christou
- Ernest Hawkins
- John de Menil
Institutions it is cited for
16 institutions- Baker & Daniels8 citations
- Church of Cyprus6 citations
- Goldberg & Feldman Fine Arts, Inc.5 citations
- Merchants National Bank5 citations
- US District Court, Southern District of Indiana5 citations
- Andrews & Kurth4 citations
- Manatt, Phelps, Rothenberg & Phillips4 citations
- Arnold & Porter3 citations
- Department of Antiquities and Museums (Turkish Cypriot administration)3 citations
- Byzantine Museum and Art Gallery, Archbishop Makarios III Foundation2 citations
- Cumhuriyet2 citations
- Menil Collection2 citations
- Christie's
- Dumbarton Oaks
- Sotheby's
- A. G. Leventis Foundation
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.