Museum
Menil Collection
Houston, United States · founded 1954
Houston foundation that redeemed the thirteenth-century Lysi murals in 1983–84 on behalf of the Church of Cyprus, had them conserved in London, showed them in Houston and returned them in 2012.
About
In 1983 the Menil Foundation of Houston became the intermediary for the return of the Lysi murals, wall paintings of the thirteenth century from the church of St Themonianos in the occupied north of Cyprus. In June of that year the Menil's acting registrar heard that an important Byzantine work was coming onto the market, and Yanni Petsopoulos showed him photographs of the murals. Dominique de Menil, Walter Hopps, Petsopoulos and other Menil officials then met two Turkish men in Munich, one of them, in the Foundation's account, Aydın Dikmen, and saw the fragments in a flat1.
Late in October 1983 Dominique de Menil consulted Vassos Karageorghis, Director of the Department of Antiquities, in Nicosia. On 1 November the Foundation resolved to redeem the murals on behalf of the Church of Cyprus, and on 11 November it was agreed that they would be restored under Foundation auspices and lent to it for display in Houston. The Cypriot Council of Ministers and the Archbishop approved the arrangement on 29 December. The sum Dikmen demanded was placed in a Swiss escrow account, to be released only after the fragments reached London and had been tested in a laboratory1.
The murals were moved from Munich to London in January 1984. A conservation studio was set up there in July under Laurence J. Morocco (the title page of the Foundation's volume spells the name Morrocco), with Carol Mancusi-Ungaro as the Menil's chief conservator. The 26 dome pieces and 12 apse pieces reached Houston in April 1988, and Annemarie Weyl Carr gave a preliminary report on them at the Byzantine Studies Conference there that October1. A final protocol of 24 March 1987 between the Church and the Foundation gathered the earlier agreements and entrusted the murals to the Foundation for fifteen years from 1 January 19861. They were shown in a chapel designed by Françoise de Menil3.
Dan Hofstadter reports that in 1989, in the Indianapolis case over the Kanakaria mosaics, Hopps and Dominique de Menil were deposed, and that her testimony showed the Foundation had bought from Dikmen and that the Cypriot government had known of it2.
The de Menil collection's other Cypriot pieces are few. A Chalcolithic picrolite figurine 8.4 cm high, without recorded provenance, appears in Desmond Morris's The Art of Ancient Cyprus6, and Christine Winkelmann catalogues a second Chalcolithic figurine (C 368) in the D. and J. de Menil collection5. The Lysi murals went back to Cyprus in 2012, when the Houston chapel was deconsecrated in March3.
The Cypriot collection
No permanent Cypriot antiquities collection documented here. The Menil Foundation held the Lysi frescoes as custodian for the Church of Cyprus from 1988 until their return in 2012; Winkelmann and Morris record Chalcolithic Cypriot figurines in the D. and J. de Menil collection. (2012)
Annemarie Weyl Carr, Laurence J. Morrocco (1991). A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus. Austin, University of Texas Press, with the Menil Foundation; Christine Winkelmann (2020). The Neolithic and Chalcolithic Figurines of Cyprus. Münster, Zaphon
History
- June 1983The acting registrar of the Menil Collection heard of an important Byzantine work coming onto the market; Yanni Petsopoulos in London showed him two photographs of Byzantine murals. Dominique de Menil, Walter Hopps, Petsopoulos and the Menil officials then met two Turkish men in Munich, one of them the alleged collector Aydin Dikmen, and saw the fragments in a flat.
MunichYanni PetsopoulosDominique de MenilWalter HoppsAydın DikmenBertrand DavezacAnnemarie Weyl Carr, Laurence J. Morrocco (1991). A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus. Austin, University of Texas Press, with the Menil Foundation
- October–November 1983Late in October 1983 Dominique de Menil consulted Vassos Karageorghis, Director of the Department of Antiquities, in Nicosia. On 1 November the Menil Foundation resolved to redeem the Lysi murals on behalf of the Church of Cyprus, and on 11 November it was agreed they would be restored under Foundation auspices and lent to the Foundation for display in Houston.
NicosiaDominique de MenilVassos KarageorghisHerbert BrownellAnnemarie Weyl Carr, Laurence J. Morrocco (1991). A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus. Austin, University of Texas Press, with the Menil Foundation
- 1984The murals were moved from Munich to London in January 1984, and in July a conservation studio was set up for their reassembly under Laurence Morrocco, with Carol Mancusi-Ungaro as the Menil's chief conservator. The author of the 1991 volume states the Foundation recovered them in 1984 on behalf of the Archbishopric.
LondonLaurence J. MoroccoCarol Mancusi-UngaroAnnemarie Weyl Carr, Laurence J. Morrocco (1991). A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus. Austin, University of Texas Press, with the Menil Foundation
- 1984The foundation bought Cypriot frescoes from Dikmen in 1984.
(1991). Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters (1991), p. 236
- 1984The foundation bought the Lysi frescoes on behalf of the Greek Orthodox Church of Cyprus and later showed them in a chapel in Houston.
- 24 March 1987A final protocol between the Church of Cyprus and the Menil Foundation incorporated the earlier agreements (including one of 5 December 1985): custody entrusted to the Foundation for fifteen years from 1 January 1986, with a consecrated shelter possible from 1 January 1989.
HoustonWalter HoppsArchbishop ChrysostomosAnnemarie Weyl Carr, Laurence J. Morrocco (1991). A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus. Austin, University of Texas Press, with the Menil Foundation
- 1988Restoration of the 26 dome and 12 apse pieces was completed and the murals reached the Menil Collection in Houston in April 1988; Annemarie Weyl Carr gave a preliminary report at the Byzantine Studies Conference in Houston in October 1988.
HoustonAnnemarie Weyl CarrLaurence J. MoroccoAnnemarie Weyl Carr, Laurence J. Morrocco (1991). A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus. Austin, University of Texas Press, with the Menil Foundation
- 1989In the Indianapolis case over the Kanakaria mosaics, Walter Hopps and Dominique de Menil were deposed; her testimony showed the Menil Foundation had also bought from Dikmen, and that the Cypriot government had known of it. This is Hofstadter's account.
HoustonWalter HoppsDominique de MenilPeg GoldbergAydın DikmenDan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux
- 1990The museum lent objects, among them cat. 29, 32 and 35, to the exhibition of Cypriot Chalcolithic art shown in Houston from 27 April to 26 August 1990.
- 1997The foundation paid for the conservation of the frescoes from the church at Lysi and built a replica church in Houston in 1997 to house them.
- 2012The Menil Collection returned the Lysi frescoes to Cyprus; the chapel designed by Francoise de Menil was deconsecrated in March 2012, per Parpas's preface. Wikipedia dates the announcement of permanent return to February 2012.
HoustonDominique de MenilC. A. Stewart (ed.), T. W. Davis (ed.), A. Weyl Carr (ed.) (2014). Cyprus and the Balance of Empires: Art and Archaeology from Justinian I to the Coeur de Lion. CAARI / ASOR; Menil Collection. Wikipedia
- UndatedThe foundation restored and displayed the frescoes in Houston on long-term loan, with title remaining with the Church of Cyprus.
(2012). The Parthenon Sculptures and Cultural Justice (2012), p. 1008
- UndatedWith the Government of Cyprus, the foundation bought back the frescoes of the church of Agios Efimianos found in Munich, to be shown in Houston for 15 years.
(2021). Cyprus: 10000 years of history and civilization (2021), p. 30
- UndatedThe museum paid Dikman for frescoes and agreed to keep them on loan for 15 years before returning them to Cyprus.
(1991). Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters (1991), p. 235
- UndatedThe foundation bought from Aydin Dikmen Byzantine frescoes detached from the church of St Euphemianos.
- UndatedNamed in Byzantine Frescoes Rescued; Byzantine Frescoes Return to Cyprus.
(1997). Byzantine Frescoes Rescued. Cyprus Today 35, 78. Nicosia, Ministry of Education and Culture, p. 78; (2012). Byzantine Frescoes Return to Cyprus. Cyprus Today 50, 14–17. Nicosia, Ministry of Education and Culture, p. 17
Acquisitions and dealings
7 recordsGifts, purchases, bequests and loans
- 1983–1985Purchase
PurchaseAydın Dikmen
Aydin Dikmen offered the fresco fragments for purchase by the Menil.
thirteenth century Byzantine mural fragmentsFincham 2015, p. 305Hoover 1990, p. 59Ioannides et al. 2012, p. VI
- n.d.Purchase
PurchaseAydın Dikmen
AllegedIcons and church artAydin Dikmen sold the detached frescoes to the De Menil Foundation.
frescoes from the apse and the dome of the church of St EuphemianosChrysostomides & Dendrinos 2006, p. 107
People’s work with it
- 1983
Herbert BrownellAgent for
Herbert Brownell represented the Menil Foundation in matters concerning the Lysi murals.
Carol Mancusi-UngaroEmployed by
Carol Mancusi-Ungaro was chief conservator of The Menil Collection.
Dominique de MenilFounded
Dominique de Menil founded the Menil Collection, a museum based on her own holdings and named after her late husband.
Walter HoppsEmployed by
Walter Hopps was curator of contemporary art at the Menil Collection in Houston.
People
13 peopleStaff and members · 12
- Bertrand Davezacstaff (1983–1991) · worked for it · member or staffCarr & Morrocco 19911983
- Christos Mavrellisofficial (1983–1983)Carr & Morrocco 19911983
- Dominique de Menilpresident (from 1983) · benefactorCarr & Morrocco 19911983–1984
- Elsian Cozensother (1983–1983)Carr & Morrocco 19911983
- Herbert Brownellother (from 1983) · acted for it · worked for itCarr & Morrocco 19911983
- Walter Hoppsdirector (1983–1989) · director of The Menil Collection (Carr & Morrocco 1991); 'curator of contemporary art' (Hofstadter 1994) · worked for itCarr & Morrocco 1991Hofstadter 19941983
- Yanni Petsopoulosother (1983–1984) · agent for the Lysi frescoes redemption; Hofstadter later calls him the Menil Foundation's 'former agent'; consulting specialist on the Lysi restoration (Morrocco) · acted for itCarr & Morrocco 19911983–1984
- Carol Mancusi-Ungarostaff (1984–1988) · chief conservator · worked for itCarr & Morrocco 19911984
- Laurence J. Moroccoother (1984–1988) · commissioned conservator for the reassembly and restoration of the Lysi murals (private practice, not staff) · worked for itCarr & Morrocco 19911984–1988
- Peter Riceother (1984–1984)Carr & Morrocco 19911984
- Francoise de Menilother (1990s – 2012)Stewart et al. 20142002–2012
- Annemarie Weyl Carrother (from 1984)Carr & Morrocco 1991
Sellers and consignors · 1
- Aydın Dikmenseller (1983–1984) · sold objectsCarr & Morrocco 19911983–1988
Objects
Lysi (St Themonianos) frescoes: 26 dome and 12 apse segments, 13th century, cut from the church in the north of Cyprus
from Lysivia Aydın Dikmen1984Annemarie Weyl Carr, Laurence J. Morrocco (1991). A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus. Austin, University of Texas Press, with the Menil Foundation
Picrolite figurine, Chalcolithic, no provenance, h. 8.4 cm (de Menil Collection, Houston)
Chalcolithic Cypriot figurine (Winkelmann C 368), D. and J. de Menil Collection
Christine Winkelmann (2020). The Neolithic and Chalcolithic Figurines of Cyprus. Münster, Zaphon
Mentioned in
29 mentionsDocuments · 12
- A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus
Agent, employed · 1983 · pp. 7, 10, 12
Herbert Brownell represented the Menil Foundation in matters concerning the Lysi murals.
Carr & Morrocco 1991
- The Rescue, Stewardship, and Return of the Lysi Frescoes by the Menil Foundation
Sale, employed · 1983 · pp. 305, 306
Aydin Dikmen offered the fresco fragments for purchase by the Menil.
Fincham 2015
- Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade
Founded · p. 61
Dominique de Menil founded the Menil Collection, a museum based on her own holdings and named after her late husband.
Hofstadter 1994
- "Sweet Land..." Lectures on the History and Culture of Cyprus
Chrysostomides & Dendrinos 2006
- About Cyprus
Lyssiotis 2008
- Cyprus and the Balance of Empires: Art and Archaeology from Justinian I to the Coeur de Lion
Stewart et al. 2014
On Ancient Cyprus · 2
Institutions · 2
- Church of Cyprus
Object from them, borrowed from · 1986
38 thirteenth-century fresco fragments from Lysi (St Themonianos)
Carr & Morrocco 1991
- Government of the Republic of Cyprus
Partner of
Cyprus 2021, p. 30
- People · 13listed under People
Sources
- 1.Annemarie Weyl Carr, Laurence J. Morrocco (1991). A Byzantine Masterpiece Recovered: The Thirteenth-Century Murals of Lysi, Cyprus. Austin, University of Texas Press, with the Menil Foundation.
- 2.Dan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
- 3.C. A. Stewart (ed.), T. W. Davis (ed.), A. Weyl Carr (ed.) (2014). Cyprus and the Balance of Empires: Art and Archaeology from Justinian I to the Coeur de Lion. CAARI / ASOR.
- 4.“Menil Collection”. Wikipedia. Online
- 5.Christine Winkelmann (2020). The Neolithic and Chalcolithic Figurines of Cyprus. Münster, Zaphon.
- 6.Desmond Morris (1985). The Art of Ancient Cyprus, with a check-list of the author's collection. Oxford, Phaidon Press in association with Jonathan Cape.
- 7. (1991). Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters (1991), p. 236.
- 8. (2016). <i>Protecting the Cultural Heritage of Cyprus: Joining Efforts in Preventing the Illicit Trafficking of Cultural Heritage</i>. Edited by Despina Pilides and And (2016), p. 187.
- 9. (1990). The J. Paul Getty Museum; Vassos Karageorghis; Edgar J. Peltenburg; Pavlos Flourentzos, Cyprus Before The Bronze Age: Art of the Chalcolithic Period (1990), p. 4.
- 10. (2008). Polly Lyssiotis, About Cyprus (2008), p. 53.
- 11. (2012). The Parthenon Sculptures and Cultural Justice (2012), p. 1008.
- 12. (2021). Cyprus: 10000 years of history and civilization (2021), p. 30.
- 13. (1991). Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters (1991), p. 235.
- 14. (2006). Julian Chrysostomides; Charalambos Dendrinos, “Sweet Land …” Lectures on the History and Culture of Cyprus (2006), p. 107.
- 15. (1997). “Byzantine Frescoes Rescued”. Cyprus Today 35, 78. Nicosia, Ministry of Education and Culture. Online
- 16. (2012). “Byzantine Frescoes Return to Cyprus”. Cyprus Today 50, 14–17. Nicosia, Ministry of Education and Culture. Online
Corrections and additions
Work here, or visited recently?
Institutions can send their own description, and anyone can tell us when something has changed.
We would like to hear about
- Opening hours, closures or a new address
- What the collection holds
- Contact details and website
- A description from the institution itself
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.