Article · 2015

For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution

Patty Gerstenblith

International Journal of Cultural Property

An article on United States cultural-property recovery over about twenty-five years, from private replevin suits such as the Kanakaria mosaics case to civil forfeiture and emergency import restrictions.

Gerstenblith follows changes in U.S. litigation and restitution involving cultural property over roughly twenty-five years. The Kanakaria mosaics and other recovery cases serve as her examples as she compares private replevin actions with government-led civil forfeiture and the laws and enforcement practices behind both. The sources are U.S. court cases and federal statutes, the 1970 UNESCO Convention and the Convention on Cultural Property Implementation Act; the cases include the Lydian Hoard, the gold phiale, an Egyptian sarcophagus, the Ka-Nefer-Nefer mask and a Cambodian sculpture, and Iraq and Syria test the limits of emergency import restrictions.

Civil forfeiture, she argues, has made restitution easier by shifting litigation costs to the government and reducing the obstacle of limitation periods. She also identifies over-enforcement, where legal theories are uncertain or expansive, and under-enforcement, where criminal prosecutions and emergency import controls are lacking, while uneven approaches across federal offices leave market participants unclear about what the law requires (pp. 360–366).

Her conclusion is that civil forfeiture can secure restitution but does little to deter trafficking without criminal sanctions. She calls for a coherent federal interpretation of the law, greater priority for criminal prosecution, and faster, targeted action against imports of looted objects, and her discussion of Iraq and Syria describes delays and procedural obstacles in imposing restrictions.

What it records

  • The Kanakaria mosaics comprise four depictions of the Christ Child, the Archangel Michael, and the Apostles James and Matthew.p. 358
  • The Kanakaria mosaics were looted from the apse of the church between August 1976 and October 1979.p. 358
  • Peg Goldberg bought the mosaics from Aydin Dikman after viewing them briefly in the Geneva Airport duty free zone over the weekend of 4 July 1988.p. 358
  • The Republic of Cyprus and the Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus filed suit in replevin in Indianapolis to recover the mosaics.p. 358
  • The Lydian Hoard comprised 360 objects looted from tombs in western Turkey, and the Metropolitan Museum returned the collection after Turkey's replevin action proceeded to discovery.p. 359
  • At the time of writing the United States had bilateral agreements with fifteen nations, which Gerstenblith calls a somewhat limited remedy.p. 362
  • U.S. import restrictions on Iraqi cultural materials were imposed in April 2008, five years after the looting of the Iraq National Museum.p. 368
  • Gerstenblith reports extensive looting of Syrian archaeological sites, including Apamea, Mari, Dura-Europos and Ebla.p. 368

Where to read

  • Kanakaria mosaics and private replevin litigationpp. 358–359
  • Civil forfeiture and national ownership lawspp. 360–365
  • Emergency import restrictions for Iraq and Syriapp. 367–369

Contents

  • I. the First Generation Cases358
  • Ii. Shift From First to Second Generation Cases359
  • Iii. Developing Approaches to Recovery of Cultural Objects361
  • The 1970 UNESCO Convention361
  • Civil Forfeiture: Importation Contrary to Law362
  • Iv. Too Little and Too Much: Cases of Under- and Over-enforcement363
  • Examples of Over-Enforcement363
  • The law in “Contrary to Law”363
  • Proving archaeological theft365
  • Limitations of the Law366
  • Lack of criminal enforcement366
  • Shortcomings of the CPIA in emergency situations367
  • Conclusion369

Objects published here

5
  • four mosaics from the Church of the Panagia Kanakaria, apse of the Church of the Panagia Kanakaria (p. 358)
  • Lydian Hoard, Metropolitan Museum of Art, tombs in Western Turkey (p. 359)
  • gold phiale, a ceremonial bowl, Sicily (p. 359)
  • Duryodhana, Khmer sculpture from the Temple of Prasat Chen, Sotheby's, site of Koh Ker, Cambodia (p. 365)
  • Egyptian mummy mask, Mask of Ka-Nefer-Nefer, St. Louis Art Museum (p. 364)

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

Places

  • United Statessubject of the article's legal analysis
  • Church of the Panagia Kanakariasource of the looted mosaics
  • Northern Cypruslocation of the looted churches, in the area occupied by Turkey since 1974

Also named: Goldberg Feldman Fine Arts, Inc., Lythrankomi, Aydin Dikman, Michel Van Rijn, Dr. Marion True, Dr. Vassos Karageorghis, Dumbarton Oaks, Menil Foundation, Lysi, Metropolitan Museum of Art, Apamea, Mari, Dura-Europos, Ebla.

Extent pp. 357–378; bibliography

Defines civil forfeiture, national ownership law

ModernLate AntiqueCollectingMuseumsLooting and the LawHistory of Archaeology

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

1 page

Who did what

3 records

Buying, selling and giving 2

  • Peg GoldbergBought fromAydın Dikmen

    Peg Goldberg agreed to buy the mosaics from the Turk for a little over a million dollars.

    a little over a million dollars

    1988 · p. 358
  • Peg GoldbergSold toGetty Trust

    Icons and church artPeg Goldberg tried to sell the mosaics initially to the Getty Trust.

    p. 358

Recording and study 1

People it is cited for

1 person

Institutions it is cited for

1 institution

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.