Thesis · 2012
Middle Cypriot White Painted Ware: A Study of Pottery Production and Distribution in Middle Bronze Age Cyprus
University of Toronto
A thesis on Middle Bronze Age White Painted Ware, following production from clay to decoration and using fabric groups and vessel styles to propose regional production centres.
Gagné examines White Painted Ware as evidence for how pottery was made and exchanged in Middle Bronze Age Cyprus. She follows manufacture from the choice and preparation of clay through forming, decoration and firing, and sets petrographic fabric groups beside vessel shapes and decorative styles. Her material is published pottery together with sherds and vessels she examined from sites across the island, with most attention to Lapithos, Vounous, Toumba tou Skourou, Dhenia, Ayia Paraskevi and Kalopsidha.
How it is organised
A first chapter introduces the Cypriot Middle Bronze Age, and a second surveys the archaeological and ceramic classifications used to study it, including the Philia culture. Chapter 3 sets out a socio-technological approach to ceramics. Chapter 4 presents the petrographic analysis, and Chapter 5 studies the style of vessels site by site. Chapter 6 returns to sampled sherds from Alambra, Ayia Paraskevi, Dhenia, Enkomi, Galinoporni, Lapithos and Politiko and relates them to the fabric groups (pp. 220–272). Chapter 7 draws conclusions on clay, forming, decoration, production and consumers, and a bibliography follows.
The argument
Gagné applies a chaîne opératoire approach, treating each vessel as the result of choices made during manufacture and asking how those choices relate to potters' knowledge, social relations and consumers. Stylistic categories alone, she argues, cannot account for production: fabric, traces of forming, shape and the syntax of decoration have to be read together.
On that basis she proposes that White Painted Ware came from several regional centres, active at different times and linked with regional prosperity. The sources she proposes are Vounous, Lapithos, Ayios Iakovos, Kythrea, the Mesaoria Plain, Kalopsidha and Toumba tou Skourou. She reads the movement of vessels between these centres and other sites as evidence of circulation and exchange, while allowing that the fabric groups do not map neatly onto single centres (pp. 208–219, 256–272).
Lapithos, in Gagné's proposal, had a broad repertory of shapes, including jugs and hemispherical bowls, and its vessels travelled to other sites. Toumba tou Skourou is associated particularly with tankards, and Kalopsidha with small jugs decorated in Cross Line Style. A Mesaoria production area is proposed as the source of pieces at Dhenia, Politiko and Ayia Paraskevi, and Kalopsidha as the likely source of most White Painted Ware at Enkomi, with some vessels from other centres (pp. 147–152, 208–219, 239–247).
The spread of the ware through settlements as well as tombs leads her to conclude that it had uses beyond burial. She also suggests that unevenly executed vessels may be the work of novices learning to pot and paint, perhaps guided by more experienced makers (pp. 278–283).
The evidence
The petrographic work rests on 68 thin sections from pottery collected at seven sites. Gagné divides them into seven fabric groups and five outliers, describes their minerals and texture, and compares them with the geology of Cyprus. The groups point to broad regions where clay may have been obtained, but not to the exact place a potter dug it. No soil samples were taken, and the sampled sites do not include every proposed production centre (pp. 70–95).
The stylistic study compares published photographs and drawings with material available for examination. Vessels are grouped by site, and for each she considers form, dimensions, fabric colour, motifs and the arrangement of decoration. Lapithos receives the longest treatment, followed by Vounous, Kazaphani, Kythrea, Toumba tou Skourou, Dhenia, Ayia Paraskevi, Politiko, Kalopsidha, Enkomi and others (pp. 96–219).
Observations of construction and decoration supply the evidence for the production sequence. Coiling is the predominant forming method, handles, necks and spouts were formed separately, and regions differ in their preferred shapes and decorative schemes (pp. 62–69, 274–278). Examined and published pieces are identified by site, tomb reference and collection or inventory number, and the appendices hold the figures and maps.
Dating
Gagné places White Painted Ware in use from the end of the Early Bronze Age to the beginning of the Late Bronze Age, approximately 1900–1400 BCE, and discusses its development in the Cypriot labels EC and MC. She gives each proposed centre its own span: Vounous ECI–MC II, Lapithos EC II–MC III, Ayios Iakovos EC III–LC II, Kythrea and Politiko MC II–III, Kalopsidha MC III–LC I, and Morphou Toumba tou Skourou MC III–Archaic. These are ranges for individual centres, not a single contemporaneous network (pp. 4, 208–209).
Limits of the evidence
The petrographic sample is small, access to some pottery was restricted, and parts of the analysis depend on published images instead of direct examination (pp. 282–283).
What it records
- In Gagné's account, White Painted Ware was in use from the end of the Early Bronze Age to the beginning of the Late Bronze Age, approximately 1900–1400 BCE.p. 4
- The petrographic sample comprises 68 thin sections from pottery collected at sites across Cyprus.p. 6
- The petrographic samples fall into seven fabric groups and five outliers.p. 70
- Gagné argues that petrography can suggest areas where clay was procured but cannot identify an exact location.p. 95
- Of 52 White Painted tankards at Toumba tou Skourou, 41 were found in Tomb 1.p. 147
- Gagné argues that Toumba tou Skourou made White Painted and other wares that circulated around Cyprus.p. 152
- White Painted Ware made up almost 43 per cent of the ceramic assemblage in Tomb 48 at Dhenia Kafkalla.p. 153
- Gagné proposes at least seven White Painted Ware production centres, not all active at the same time.p. 208
- Gagné lists Kythrea, Politiko, Kalopsidha and Morphou Toumba tou Skourou among the proposed production centres.p. 209
- The proposed production centres are inferred from tomb and settlement material, not from direct evidence of pottery manufacture.p. 209
- Gagné proposes that the Dhenia cemeteries received White Painted Ware from Lapithos early in their use and later from a Mesaoria production centre.p. 239
- Gagné proposes that Kalopsidha supplied Enkomi with most of its White Painted Ware, while some vessels may have come from other centres.p. 247
- Gagné could sample only five sherds from the Lapithos material at the University of Pennsylvania Museum.p. 253
- Seventeen of the 18 Enkomi samples belong to fabric group 3.p. 265
- The sampled Galinoporni sherds belong to three fabric groups.p. 267
- Gagné argues that the Mesaoria production centre exported White Painted Ware to the largest number of sites.p. 270
- Gagné observes that White Painted Ware has been found at most of the more powerful and influential Bronze Age sites, particularly those involved with copper production and distribution, such as Lapithos, Toumba tou Skourou and Enkomi.p. 273
- Middle Bronze Age White Painted Ware is mostly hand-built from coils, with small vessels possibly pinched from a ball of clay.p. 275
- Gagné argues that White Painted vessels found in settlements as well as tombs had uses beyond funerary contexts.p. 281
- Only 68 sherds were available for thin-section analysis.p. 282
Where to read
- Research questions, approach and chapter planpp. 4–7
- Philia culture pottery and its distributionpp. 18–22
- Middle Bronze Age settlement, burials, metallurgy and potterypp. 29–34
- Socio-technological approach and production sequencepp. 50–69
- Fabric groups, geology and limits of petrographypp. 70–95
- Lapithos vessel groups and stylistic comparisonspp. 100–127
- Toumba tou Skourou vessels and regional distributionpp. 146–152
- Kalopsidha styles and pottery productionpp. 182–191
- Proposed production-centre network and chronologypp. 208–219
- Fabric-group case studies from Alambra and Ayia Paraskevipp. 220–229
- Distribution of Dhenia pottery and proposed sourcespp. 230–239
- Clay, forming methods, decoration and consumer preferencespp. 274–282
Contents
- Chapter 1: Introduction1
- 1.1 The Cypriot Middle Bronze Age1
- 1.2 General Overview4
- Chapter 2: Problem Orientation8
- 2.3 The Philia Culture13
- 2.5 The Middle Bronze Age29
- 2.7 Traditional approaches to the study of Cypriot ceramics37
- Chapter 3: A Socio-technological Approach to the Study of Cypriot Ceramics50
- Chapter 4: Petrographic Analysis70
- Chapter 5: Determining Production Centres Based on Style96
- Lapithos100
- Vounous127
- Morphou Toumba tou Skourou146
- Dhenia152
- Kalopsidha182
- Enkomi192
- Discussion208
- Chapter 6: Fabric Groups and Their Relationship to Production Centres220
- 6.2 Alambra220
- 6.3 Ayia Paraskevi224
- 6.4 Dhenia230
- 6.5 Enkomi239
- 6.6 Galinoporni247
- 6.7 Lapithos250
- 6.8 Politiko253
- 6.9 Discussion256
- 6.10 Conclusion263
- Chapter 7273
- 7.2 Choosing and preparing the clay274
- 7.3 Choosing forming techniques and shapes275
- 7.4 Choosing motifs and decorative syntax277
- 7.5 The organization of production278
- 7.6 Consumer preferences280
- 7.7 Limitations of this study282
- 7.8 New directions for research283
- Bibliography285
Objects published here
15- White Painted jug with side spouts and framed vertical lattice panels, Lapithos, Tomb 316, L.316.118, Appendix 1, figures 32 and 33 (p. 101)
- White Painted jug with solid-coloured base, Lapithos, 69-35-50, Appendix 1, figure 35 (p. 103)
- White Painted askos with panniers and four legs, interpreted as a donkey, Lapithos, L.315 B-C.26, Appendix 1, figure 240 (p. 124)
- White Painted vessel with bovine head attached in front of the spout, Morphou Toumba tou Skourou, T.I.389, Appendix 1, figure 456 (p. 148)
- Alambra body sherd with interlocking hatched triangles and a double zigzag, Alambra, AS 439, Appendix 1, figure 872 (p. 221)
- Dhenia body sherd with a row of hatched triangles, Dhenia, 2006.44, fig. 1289 (p. 231)
- Dhenia body sherd with interlocking hatched triangles, Dhenia, 2006.58, fig. 1300 (p. 232)
- Enkomi body sherd with a wavy line and dots, Enkomi, 3219-10 A, fig. 1303 (p. 239)
- Enkomi body sherd decorated in Pendant-Line Style, Enkomi, 2987 A, fig. 1306 (p. 241)
- Enkomi body sherd, thick and gritty compared with other samples, Enkomi, 2511, fig. 1320 (p. 246)
- Galinoporni jug-neck sherd with horizontal bands, Galinoporni, fig. 1321 (p. 247)
- Lapithos jug sherd sampled from the University of Pennsylvania Museum collection, Tomb 802A, 69-35-50, fig. 1326 (p. 250)
- Lapithos small-jug sherd decorated with registers of hatched triangles, Lapithos, 32-27-208, fig. 1329 (p. 251)
- Politiko body sherd decorated with three broad stripes, Politiko, 2006.66, fig. 1332 (p. 253)
- Politiko body sherd with no slip and coarse fabric, Politiko, 2006.85, fig. 1333 (p. 253)
People, places and institutions
People
- Åströmtypology and style of White Painted Ware
- P. Dikaiosclassified Cypriot ceramics
- GjerstadBronze Age ceramic typology
- Frankelstudied White Painted Ware production and distribution
- Maguirestudied White Painted Ware decoration
- Herscherstudied regional variation and production
- Catlingsurveyed sites and collected sherds
- Nicolaouexcavated Dhenia and Kazaphani
- Hadjicostiexcavated Ayia Paraskevi
- Barlowstudied Alambra pottery fabrics
- Vermeulepublished Toumba tou Skourou material
- Wolskypublished Toumba tou Skourou material
- Crowncompared novice potters and learners
Institutions
- University of Torontoinstitution where the thesis was submitted
- Cyprus Museumcollection examined and sampled
- University of Pennsylvania Museumheld Lapithos material examined and sampled
- University of Sheffieldteaching collection sampled
- Medelhavsmuseetheld pottery studied
- Ashmolean Museumheld pottery from several sites
Places
- Lapithosmajor proposed production centre
- Morphou Toumba tou Skourouproposed production centre and pottery source
- Dheniacemeteries compared for pottery sources
- Kalopsidhasettlement and proposed production centre
- Enkomisettlement and source of sampled sherds
- Mesaoriaregion and proposed production area
- Vounouscemetery and proposed production centre
- Ayia Paraskevicemetery and source of sampled sherds
- Politikosettlement and proposed production area
- Ayios Iakovosproposed production centre
- Kythreacemetery and proposed production centre
- Alambrasettlement and source of sampled sherds
- Galinopornisite with sampled sherds
- Kazaphanicemetery used for pottery comparison
- Stephaniecemetery with White Painted vessels
- Dhioriossite with pottery sherds
- Krini Merranecropolis with imported wares
- Leondari Vounonecropolis used for pottery comparison
- Miliacemetery with imported vessels
- Boghazcoastal site with pottery finds
- Arperacemeteries with imported pottery
- Klavdhiacemetery with imported pottery
- Hala Sultan Tekkesite receiving imported pottery
- Marki Aloniastratified Philia-period site
- VasiliaBronze Age cemetery and centre
- Tarsussite with Cypriot sherds
- Troodos Massifgeological comparison region
- Kyrenia Rangegeological region of north-coast fabrics
- Karpass peninsularegion of Galinoporni
- Koukliasite in the pottery distribution discussion
- Magounda Polis tis Chrysokhouwestern site with imported pottery
- Linousite in the pottery distribution discussion
- Xylotymbou-Katapetrasite represented by pottery vessels
- Philiatype site of the Philia culture
- Sotira-KaminoudhiaPhilia settlement with pottery evidence
Also named: Department of Art, Geological Survey Department of Cyprus, CAARI, Ras Shamra.
Extent Appendix 1, figures 1–1333; Appendix 2, maps; bibliography pp. 285–300
Defines White Painted (Philia), chaîne opératoire, production centre, Fabric Group 1, Fabric Group 2, Fabric Group 3, Fabric Group 4, Fabric Group 5
Middle Bronze AgeEarly Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeChalcolithicPotteryCraft ProductionTradeChronology and DatingDaily Life
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
21 pages- Chalcolithic CyprusArticle
- Decoration and MotifsArticle
- Painted Again in the Middle CypriotArticle
- Black Slip WareCompendium
- Chalcolithic CyprusCompendium
- Drab Polished WareCompendium
- Early Bronze Age CyprusCompendium
- FlasksCompendium
- Jars and PithoiCompendium
- Middle Bronze Age CyprusCompendium
- Neighboring CulturesCompendium
- Red Polished Philia WareCompendium
- Red Polished WareCompendium
- The Chronology of Ancient CyprusCompendium
- The Pottery of Ancient CyprusCompendium
- Triangles and LozengesCompendium
- Triple Crossing LinesCompendium
- Wavy LinesCompendium
- White Painted StylesCompendium
- White Painted WareCompendium
- Zig-ZagsCompendium
Excavations it is cited for
6 projects- 1888Leondari Vouno, Nicosia: the Cyprus Exploration Fund (1888)Directed by M. R. JamesExcavation
- 1894Kition: Myres for the Cyprus Exploration FundDirected by John Linton MyresExcavation
- 1931–1932Vounous: the Cyprus Museum excavations under DikaiosDirected by Porphyrios DikaiosExcavation
- 1937–1938Dhenia-Kafkalla: J. R. Stewart's clearance of looted tombs A-H, 1937–1938Directed by J. R. B. StewartClearance and early digging
- 1937–1938Kazaphani: J. R. Stewart's tombs, 1937–1938Directed by J. R. B. StewartExcavation
- 1952North-coast survey: Catling's Dhiorios, Krini and Davlos visits (1952)Directed by Hector W. CatlingSurvey
Who did what
20 recordsExcavation 15
- 1990–2007 · p. 24
David FrankelExcavated withJennifer M. Webb
David Frankel and Jennifer M. Webb undertook test excavations together at Politiko Kokkinorotsos.
- 1927–1931 · p. 38
Einar Nilson GjerstadDug forSwedish Cyprus Expedition
Einar Gjerstad led three young archaeologists in the work associated with the Expedition's investigation of sites in Cyprus.
25 sites
- 1931–1932 · p. 39
Porphyrios DikaiosExcavated
P. Dikaios traced and cleared the tomb at Vounous and found and reconstructed the model of a ploughing scene.
model of ploughing scene
- 1952 · p. 137
Hector CatlingSurveyed
Catling conducted a survey at Dhiorios Aloupotypes.
- 1952 · p. 146
Hector CatlingSurveyed
Hector Catling surveyed Krini Merra and collected the sherds discussed in the thesis.
- p. 152
Einar Nilson GjerstadExcavated
Gjerstad first excavated the Kafkalla cemetery at Dhenia.
- 1960 · p. 153
Nicolaou and NicolaouExcavated
Nicolaou and Nicolaou excavated the Kafkalla and Mali cemeteries at Dhenia.
cemeteries of Kafkalla and Mali
- 1952 · p. 162
Hector CatlingSurveyed
Hector Catling conducted a survey at Dhenia from which the material discussed in the thesis came.
White Painted ware vessels and sherds
- 1888 · p. 163
M. R. JamesExcavated
R. James excavated the necropolis at Leondari Vouno.
- p. 164
Maria HadjicostiExcavated
Hadjicosti excavated fifteen tombs at Ayia Paraksevi.
- 1914 · p. 198
- 1924 · p. 198
Gjerstad discovered a settlement associated with the Late Bronze Age cemetery at Arpera.
associated settlement
- 1897 · p. 203
John Linton MyresExcavated
Myres carried out the excavation at Laxia tou Riou.
- p. 255
Hector CatlingFound
Hector Catling picked up two sherds in a survey; they were later in the Sheffield teaching collection.
Politiko
- p. 262
Hector CatlingSurveyed
Hector Catling's survey collected the sherds identified as Dhenia 2006.39 and 2006.57.
sherds Dhenia 2006.39 and 2006.57No. Dhenia 2006.39 and 2006.57
Recording and study 5
- 1899 · p. 37
John Linton MyresWorked withMax Ohnefalsch-Richter
Myres and Ohnefalsch-Richter contributed to the catalogue of the Cyprus Museum.
A Catalogue of the Cyprus MuseumNicosia
- p. 38
Einar Nilson GjerstadStudied
Gjerstad created a typology of Cypriot Bronze Age pottery using the classification system established by Myres and Ohnefalsch-Richter.
Bronze Age Cypriot potteryCyprus Museum
- p. 99
Laura Ann Campbell GagnéStudied
The author examined White Painted ware vessels in the Cyprus Museum and the University of Pennsylvania Museum.
Cyprus Museum; University of Pennsylvania Museum
- p. 164
Laura Ann Campbell GagnéStudied
Laura Ann Campbell Gagné studied material from the early excavations at the Cyprus Museum.
material from these early excavations
- p. 164
Laura Ann Campbell GagnéStudied
Laura Ann Campbell Gagné sampled material recovered by Hadjicosti for petrographic analysis.
material she recoveredAyia Paraskevi
Institutions it is cited for
1 institution- University of Toronto2 citations
Mentioned in
100 mentionsTomb records · 73
- Ayios Iakovos-Melia, SCE Tomb 1
Excavation report · 2012 · pp. 179, lxxix, lxxx
- Ayios Iakovos-Melia, SCE Tomb 10
Excavation report · 2012 · p. 179
- Ayios Iakovos-Melia, SCE Tomb 11
Excavation report · 2012 · p. 179
- Ayios Iakovos-Melia, SCE Tomb 12
Excavation report · 2012 · p. 179
- Ayios Iakovos-Melia, SCE Tomb 13
Excavation report · 2012 · pp. 179, 180, 195, lxxix, lxxx
- Ayios Iakovos-Melia, SCE Tomb 14
Excavation report · 2012 · pp. 179, 194, lxxix
- On Ancient Cyprus · 21listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
- Excavations · 6listed under Excavations it is cited for
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.