Article · 1994

The Protection of Turkey's Underwater Archaeological Heritage - Legislative Measures and Other Approaches

Janet Blake

International Journal of Cultural Property 3

An article on Turkish laws protecting underwater archaeological sites, the illicit antiquities trade and the effort to secure the return of objects held overseas.

Blake examines the protection of Turkey's underwater archaeological heritage through the development of antiquities law, regulations on diving and protected areas, and cases involving the illicit movement and return of antiquities. She places underwater protection alongside the control of the antiquities trade and litigation in US courts, drawing on Turkish legislation and regulations, reports of archaeological and underwater surveys, examples of wrecks and reported seizures. The sections move from archaeology in Turkey through the legislative framework to illicit movement and litigation.

Blake traces Turkish antiquities legislation from the 1869 Ottoman law through the 1884 and 1906 laws, the 1973 legislation and the 1983 Antiquities Law. She identifies the extension of the 1983 law to underwater sites as a change in scope and describes its rules for permits, protected areas, trade and penalties (pp. 275–279).

She argues that sites and removed artefacts must be protected as parts of an integrated archaeological record. Site protections alone cannot prevent clandestine excavation at unidentified locations, and object-focused measures must also address illicit trafficking. She considers tourism and coastal construction further pressures on underwater sites, alongside the difficulty of policing well-equipped criminals (pp. 280–281).

Blake compares US cases concerning stolen or illegally exported cultural property and examines the Turkish government's civil claim against the Metropolitan Museum of Art over a Lydian hoard, which Blake describes as ending in a 1993 out-of-court agreement for return. She discusses its implications for institutional collecting and provenance checks and the financial and evidential obstacles states face in pursuing claims (pp. 283–290).

What it records

  • The 1993 archaeological symposium in Ankara heard reports on 93 excavations and 85 survey and archaeometric projects, one of them an underwater survey.p. 273
  • The Uluburun Bronze Age wreck excavation began in 1984 and was continuing when Blake wrote.p. 274
  • The 1869 Ottoman antiquities law included provisions for dividing finds among the excavation team, landowner and state.p. 275
  • Article 35 of the 1983 law provides for designated underwater heritage areas where sport diving is forbidden and research or excavation requires permission.p. 278
  • Özgen Acar, a journalist with Cumhuriyet, is a prominent writer on the scale of antiquities leaving Turkey, in Blake's account.p. 281
  • 744 early Islamic coins were seized in Istanbul in April 1991, in Acar's account.p. 282
  • Acar and Kaylan described a hoard of more than 2,000 silver coins weighing about 26.3 kilos of silver.p. 282
  • The Turkish government and the Metropolitan Museum of Art signed a return agreement on 23 September 1993, and the objects reached Ankara by 22 October.p. 288
  • A monumental sarcophagus weighing three tons was returned to Turkey on 26 April 1994 from the Brooklyn Museum, where its owner had placed it in 1987.p. 289

Where to read

  • The 1983 Antiquities Law and underwater protectionspp. 277–280
  • Seizures and reported antiquities smugglingpp. 281–283
  • The Lydian hoard case and its settlementpp. 285–290

Contents

  • 1 Introduction: Archaeology in Turkey273
  • 2 The Development of Turkish Antiquities Legislation274
  • 3 The Current Legislative Framework276
  • 4 The Illicit Movement of Antiquities from Turkey281
  • 5 Turkish Litigation for the Retrieval of Stolen Antiquities283
  • 5.1 Relevant Provisions of the Turkish Antiquities Legislation284
  • 5.2 The Republic of Turkey v The Metropolitan Museum of Art285

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

Places

  • UluburunBronze Age wreck excavation site
  • Sea of Marmarasea with known wrecks and looting cases
  • Black Seadeep-water area with reducing conditions
  • Kekovadesignated underwater protected site
  • Kanakariasite of the looted church mosaics

Also named: M. Kaylan, Brooklyn Museum, Cemal Pulak, Yassi Ada, Cape Gelidonya.

Defines cultural property

Early Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeRomanMedievalModernLooting and the LawSeafaringHistory of ArchaeologyMuseumsCollecting

Who did what

1 record

Buying, selling and giving 1

  • Peg GoldbergBought

    Icons and church artPeg Goldberg bought the mosaics from an art dealer in 1988 for 1,080,000.

    With an art dealer from IndianapolisKanakaria church apse mosaics1,080,000Free-port area of Zurich airport

    1988 · p. 286

People it is cited for

2 people

Institutions it is cited for

1 institution

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.