Curator

Marion True

fl. 1986–1996 · United States

Getty curator of antiquities from 1986 to 2005 who co-organised the 1990 Chalcolithic Cyprus symposium, alerted Cyprus to the stolen Kanakaria mosaics, and was later tried in Italy and Greece.

Biography

Marion True was curator of antiquities at the J. Paul Getty Museum from 1986 to 2005, and in Cypriot archaeology she is remembered for two things: she worked with Vassos Karageorghis on the Getty's 1990 conference and exhibition on Chalcolithic Cyprus, and she told the Cypriot authorities when the stolen Kanakaria mosaics were offered to her museum3,4,5.

Training and the Getty

True was born in Tahlequah, Oklahoma, in 19486. She graduated from New York University in 1970 with honours in classics and fine arts, and finished a master's degree in classical archaeology there two years later6. For about a decade she did curatorial work at the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston and at Harvard's Fogg Art Museum, taught at Harvard and worked in commercial galleries6. She joined the Getty in 1982 as assistant to the antiquities curator Jiri Frel, became associate curator when he left, and took charge of the department in 1986, the year Harvard gave her a doctorate for a thesis on Greek red-figure vases6. As curator she recommended what the museum should buy, while approval rested with the director, the Trust's chief executive and the trustees7.

Chalcolithic Cyprus

The Getty's own collection included a Cypriot limestone "Figure of a Fertility Goddess" dated 3000–2500 B.C. (83.AA.38), sold to the museum by Galerie Uraeus in 19838. Karageorghis wrote that on a visit to Malibu in 1987 he discussed with the director and his colleagues a conference at the museum early in 1990 surveying the Chalcolithic phase of Cypriot prehistory, and that the presence in the collection of "a major work of Chalcolithic stone sculpture from Cyprus" increased the interest of Walsh and his associates9. The published proceedings record that Karageorghis, then Director of the Department of Antiquities, first suggested the exhibition and symposium in 1987, and that he proposed the meeting of scholars working together with True4. True, Karageorghis and Walter Hopps of the Menil Collection selected the objects in the museums of Cyprus for the exhibition Cyprus Before the Bronze Age9. Karageorghis thanked John Walsh, True and Kenneth Hamma of the Getty's antiquities department for organising the conference and exhibition9. The foreword to the published proceedings, Chalcolithic Cyprus, signed by Walsh and Athanasios Papageorghiou, thanks True and Karageorghis for their "inspiration and leadership"4. One contributor thanked True for agreeing to include a note on a figurine although it had not been on the programme4.

The Kanakaria mosaics

Four mosaic fragments stolen from a church in the north of Cyprus, under Turkish occupation since the Turkish invasion of 1974, came into the hands of Peg Goldberg, who tried first to sell them to the Getty5,10. The accounts of the approach differ: Byrne-Sutton writes that two dealer acquaintances of Goldberg contacted the Getty in October 1988 and January 198911. Hofstadter writes that Geza von Habsburg telephoned True to offer the pieces for $20 million, and that she warned him of possible flaws in the seller's title2. Gerstenblith says the Getty did not collect Byzantine art and that True at once called Karageorghis, who as a friend and colleague had asked her to alert him to significant objects coming out of the occupied north5. Byrne-Sutton writes that she informed the Department of Antiquities and the plaintiffs' Washington lawyers, which let them find the mosaics and their possessor11. Cyprus and the Church then sued in Indianapolis and won at all levels of the federal courts; the mosaics are now in the Church's Byzantine Museum in Nicosia5,10. Patty Gerstenblith, as the Church's lawyer, took True's deposition in that suit, and says her tip-off triggered the recovery5.

Policy, the house on Paros and the trials

Walsh testified that True often raised concerns about acquisitions and pushed to toughen the Getty's standards in 1987 and 19967. Brodie calls her the driving force behind the Getty's guidelines for unprovenanced antiquities3. Gerstenblith, reviewing Chasing Aphrodite, judges her "divided against herself": in public she called for diligence and transparency, while in private she supported the Getty's "do not ask the specific question" approach5.

The sources disagree about the loan for her house on Paros: Brodie says she bought it in 1995 with a four-year $400,000 loan from Christos Michaelides, partner of the dealer Robin Symes3. Mackenzie and his co-authors say the Michaelides loan was repaid a year later with a $400,000 loan from Barbara and Lawrence Fleischman, whose collection the Getty had just acquired12. The Getty said its own inquiry found she had failed to report parts of the purchase, and that she chose to retire to prepare her defence; the Los Angeles Times says she was asked to retire, in October 20057,13.

Italy charged her in 2005 with conspiracy to receive stolen goods and archaeological artefacts, which she denied13. The Rome trial began on 16 November 2005, and on 13 October 2010 it ended when the court ruled that the limitation period had expired, before her defence had called witnesses14,15. One chronicle of the year records this as an "acquittal", while Brodie says the trial was abandoned without verdict3,16. In Greece prosecutors charged her in 2006 over a gold funerary wreath the Getty had bought, and on 27 November 2007 an Athens court dismissed the most serious charges as time-barred7,17. A separate charge over antiquities found at the Paros house in 2006 was still pending in November 2007; her lawyer Harry Stang said they were in the house when she bought it18,19. Brodie writes that she was never convicted3. True herself wrote in 2011 that her trial had ended in "neither condemnation nor vindication", and called the process "politically motivated"20.

Life and work

  1. 1988

    1. With Vassos Karageorghis (then Director of Antiquities) and John Walsh (Director, Getty Museum), proposed the collaborative GCI/Department of Antiquities project on mosaic conservation at Paphos (1988-89), which produced the Orpheus mosaic conservation.

      PaphosNicholas Stanley Price (ed.) (1991). The Conservation of the Orpheus Mosaic at Paphos, Cyprus. Getty Conservation Institute, p. vii

    2. October

      Geza von Habsburg telephoned her to offer the Kanakaria mosaic pieces to the Getty for $20 million; Hofstadter writes that she had excellent relations with Karageorghis, warned Habsburg of possible flaws in the seller's title and notified Cyprus that four Early Christian works had suspiciously appeared on the market.

      MalibuDan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, p. 65

    3. Getty antiquities curator who declined the c. $20m resale of the Kanakaria mosaics in 1988 and alerted Vassos Karageorghis.

      Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade

  2. Undated

    n.d.

    1. Curator of Antiquities at the Getty Museum; declined the offer of the mosaics and notified Cypriot officials.

      Anne McC. Sullivan (1991). Law and Diplomacy in Cultural Property Matters. In Museum Management and Curatorship. pp. 219–243. Butterworth-Heinemann Ltd. p. 236.

    2. Of the Getty Museum; informed the Department of Antiquities of Cyprus of the contacts about the mosaics, enabling their location to be found.

      Quentin Byrne-Sutton (1992). The Goldberg Case: A Confirmation of the Difficulty in Acquiring Good Title to Valuable Stolen Cultural Objects. p. 154.

Through their hands

1 record
  1. n.d.

    RecordTrue declined Goldberg's offer and notified Cypriot officials.

    Kanakaria mosaicsGetty Museum, Malibu, CaliforniaSullivan 1991, p. 236

Connections

9 people

Recording and study

2 records
Employed by1
Other work1
  • Marion True alerted the Cypriot authorities after consulting about the mosaics.

    With the Cypriot authoritiesKaiser 1990, p. 206

Mentioned in

21 mentions

Documents · 9

Institutions · 2

  • Getty Conservation Institute

    1988

    Proposal for a collaborative conservation project initiated by Vassos Karageorghis (Director of Antiquities), John Walsh (Director, J. Paul Getty Museum) and…

    Price 1991

  • J. Paul Getty Museum

    Curator (1988) · 1988

    Getty staff took part in the conservation of the Orpheus mosaic at Nea Paphos with the Getty Conservation Institute and the Department of Antiquities…

    Price 1991, p. vii; Price 1991

Sources

  1. 1.Nicholas Stanley Price (ed.) (1991). The Conservation of the Orpheus Mosaic at Paphos, Cyprus. Getty Conservation Institute.
  2. 2.Dan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
  3. 3.Neil Brodie (2012). “Marion True”. Trafficking Culture encyclopedia. Online
  4. 4.Vassos Karageorghis, Marion True (eds) (1991). Chalcolithic Cyprus. J. Paul Getty Museum.
  5. 5.Patty Gerstenblith (2012). “[Review of Jason Felch and Ralph Frammolino, Chasing Aphrodite]”. IFAR Journal Incorporating Stolen Art Alert 13.
  6. 6.Suzanne Muchnic (2005). “Getty curator Marion True, indicted over acquisitions, has often spoken on ethical issues”. Los Angeles Times. Online
  7. 7.Jason Felch, Ralph Frammolino (2006). “Getty lets her take fall, ex-curator says”. Los Angeles Times. Online
  8. 8.J. Paul Getty Museum. Figure of a Fertility Goddess, 83.AA.38 [collection record]. Online
  9. 9.Vassos Karageorghis (1990). Cyprus Before the Bronze Age: Art of the Chalcolithic Period. J. Paul Getty Museum.
  10. 10.Patty Gerstenblith (2015). “For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution”. International Journal of Cultural Property 22.
  11. 11.Quentin Byrne-Sutton (1992). “The Goldberg Case: A Confirmation of the Difficulty in Acquiring Good Title to Valuable Stolen Cultural Objects”. International Journal of Cultural Property 1.
  12. 12.Simon Mackenzie, Neil Brodie, Donna Yates, Christos Tsirogiannis (2020). Trafficking Culture: New Directions in Researching the Global Market in Illicit Antiquities. Routledge.
  13. 13.Martha Lufkin (2005). “Now former Getty antiquities curator Marion True goes on trial this month”. The Art Newspaper. Online
  14. 14.Martha Lufkin (2005). “Ex-Getty antiquities curator appears in Italian court”. The Art Newspaper. Online
  15. 15.Elisabetta Povoledo (2010). “Rome Trial of Ex-Getty Curator Ends”. The New York Times, C1. Online
  16. 16. (2011). “[Chronicle of events in the art and cultural property world, October 2010]”. International Journal of Cultural Property 18.
  17. 17.United Press International (2007). “Most charges dropped against curator”. UPI. Online
  18. 18. (2007). “Greek Charges Dropped”. Illicit Cultural Property (blog). Online
  19. 19.Nikolas Zirganos, Jason Felch (2006). “Greek Officials Raid House of Ex-Getty Curator”. Los Angeles Times, A36. Online
  20. 20.Marion True (2011). “Neither condemned nor vindicated”. The Art Newspaper 220. Online
  21. 21.Patty Gerstenblith (2015). “For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution”. International Journal of Cultural Property. Online
  22. 22.Timothy Kaiser (1990). “The Antiquities Market”. Journal of Field Archaeology 17, 205-210. Online
  23. 23.V. Karageorghis (ed.), M. True (ed.) (1991). “Chalcolithic Cyprus”. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research. Malibu, American Schools of Oriental Research, with the J. Paul Getty Museum.
  24. 24.Anne McC. Sullivan (1991). “Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters”. Museum Management and Curatorship 10, 219-243. Routledge. Online
  25. 25.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
  26. 26.Anne McC. Sullivan (1991). Law and Diplomacy in Cultural Property Matters. In Museum Management and Curatorship. pp. 219–243. Butterworth-Heinemann Ltd. p. 236.. Online
  27. 27.Quentin Byrne-Sutton (1992). The Goldberg Case: A Confirmation of the Difficulty in Acquiring Good Title to Valuable Stolen Cultural Objects. p. 154.. Online
  28. 28.Cultural Property Crime (2014).
  29. 29.Timothy Kaiser, 1990, The Antiquities Market.
  30. 30.N. Stanley Price (ed.), 1991, The Conservation of the Orpheus Mosaic at Paphos, Cyprus.
  31. 31.V. Karageorghis et al., 1991, Chalcolithic Cyprus.
  32. 32.2012, Review essay on Felch and Frammolino, Chasing Aphrodite (IFAR Journal, vol. 13 no. 3).
  33. 33.Stanley Price (ed.) 1991, The Conservation of the Orpheus Mosaic at Paphos.
  34. 34.N. Stanley Price (ed.), 1991, The Conservation of the Orpheus Mosaic at Paphos, Cyprus, Getty Conservation Institute.
  35. 35.Patty Gerstenblith, 2015, For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution.
  36. 36.Nicholas Stanley Price (ed.), 1991, The Conservation of the Orpheus Mosaic at Paphos, Cyprus, p. vii; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
  37. 37.IFAR Journal Incorporating Stolen Art Alert (2012).
  38. 38.Marion True; Christopher Hudson; Benedicte Gilman; Andrea P. A. Belloli; Mary Holtman; Karen Schmidt; Elizabeth Burke Kahn; Patrick Dooley; Patricia Inglis; Thea Piegdon; William R. Biers; H. A. Shapiro; Mary B. Moore; B. B. Shefton; Beth Cohen; Carina Weiβ; Susan B. Matheson; D. C. Kurtz; Herbert Hoffmann; S. Schwarz; Jacques Heurgon, Greek Vases in the J. Paul Getty Museum Volume 4 (1989).
  39. 39.The Parthenon Sculptures and Cultural Justice (2012).
  40. 40.Patty Gerstenblith, For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution; Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
  41. 41.A Terracotta Pendant from Kalavassos-Ayious (1991).

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Date of birth unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.