Lawyer / legislator
Thomas R. Kline
fl. 1989–2016 · United States
Washington lawyer who was lead counsel for the Church and Republic of Cyprus in the 1989 Indianapolis suit that recovered the Kanakaria mosaics, and worked for Cyprus for almost 25 years.
Biography
Thomas R. Kline was the Washington lawyer who, in 1989, led the suit of the Church and Republic of Cyprus in Indianapolis to recover the Kanakaria mosaics, and he went on working with both on the protection of Cypriot heritage for almost 25 years2.
Before the mosaics
The Washingtonian in 2009 described him as a New York native who studied art and art history at Columbia University and whose mother was an artist3. According to the same profile, he taught high-school social studies for four years after college3. After law school at Columbia and a judicial clerkship he came to Washington in 1976 and became a trial lawyer at the Justice Department3. In the early 1980s he moved into private practice, working for a series of firms and eventually Manatt Phelps, which represented the Republic of Cyprus3. The profile gave his age as 62 in 2009, which puts his birth about 19473. Dan Hofstadter describes him at Manatt, Phelps, Rothenberg & Phillips as a specialist in environmental and antitrust law1.
The Kanakaria case
Kline says he became involved after U.S. Customs refused to intervene, leaving the Church and the Republic no choice but to sue2. Dan Hofstadter calls him Cyprus's chief attorney, and Kline calls himself lead counsel; two later writers describe him as a member of the legal team1,2,4,5. The district court's opinion lists him first among the Manatt, Phelps lawyers for the plaintiffs, with Thomas E. Starnes, Douglas E. Lavin and June L. Walton, and with John David Hoover and Sally F. Zweig in Indianapolis6. Neither he nor Joe Emerson, who acted for the dealer Peg Goldberg, had ever tried an antiquities case, Hofstadter says1. Kline says they obtained a temporary injunction and went to trial 60 days later2.
From the start, Hofstadter writes, Kline told his colleagues to assume there was no Aydin Dikmen unless some evidence showed otherwise1. He argued that the deal had only a fleeting connection to Switzerland and that Indiana law should govern, and, in the alternative, that under Swiss law Goldberg was no good-faith purchaser1. His pretrial brief said Goldberg wanted to profit from "the plunder of others"1.
Goldberg first saw Kline during her own deposition, taken in late April and early May, mostly at a legal reporting service in downtown Indianapolis, Hofstadter writes1. In 1989 he also deposed Marion True of the Getty Museum, and he later wrote that a dealer friend of Goldberg's had offered the mosaics to True for $20 million and that True alerted Vassos Karageorghis, then Director of Antiquities8. A 2014 conference volume credits him with finding a Dumbarton Oaks publication with photographs of the mosaics and introducing it in court9.
At trial Kline did not call Michel van Rijn, feeling that his presence might win Goldberg some sympathy1. Asked what he would have done if offered the deal, Cyprus's Byzantine expert Gary Vikan answered, "Walked"1,8. On the morning of 2 June Kline called Robert Fitzgerald to the witness stand and asked him whether van Rijn had paid Dikmen only $350,000, and where the $650,000 had gone1. Kline later named three points: Cyprus's diligence in alerting experts, museums, UNESCO and ICOM; Goldberg's rolodex entry marked "IFAR OK", which he photographed and enlarged for his opening; and the damage the mosaics suffered on the flight from Geneva to Indianapolis7.
Goldberg took the stand on the penultimate day and was cross-examined by Kline1. Hofstadter writes that Kline refrained from pressing the thesis of her complicity in fencing the mosaics, and he calls the cross-examination, which Kline's colleagues named the "cross of Goldberg", an unqualified disaster for her1. On 3 August 1989 Judge James E. Noland awarded possession of the mosaics to the Church of Cyprus6.
After the trial Kline moved his practice to the Washington office of Andrews & Kurth, and he appeared from there on the appeal1,10. When Savo's statement was taken in May 1990 he called it "untimely" and said the plaintiffs would boycott it; Emerson's motion to set the judgment aside on it was denied three months after it was filed1. The Seventh Circuit heard the appeal on 16 January 1990 and on 24 October 1990 affirmed that Goldberg must return the mosaics to the Church of Cyprus10. Alphas dates the return of the four fragments to Cyprus to 19914.
Later work for Cyprus and beyond
Kline says the litigation revealed the identity of the presumed smuggler and let the Church and the government pursue him in Germany, where there have been many recoveries2. He reports that the Church recovered six icons offered at a New York auction house as part of a settlement, and that the seller of gospel covers agreed to return them once confronted with the facts2. In 2012 he urged Cyprus to uncouple culture from politics and to engage the Turkish Cypriots in protecting their shared heritage2. He gave the keynote at the 2011 Nicosia workshop, and one reviewer judges that his chapter does an excellent job of outlining the many factors placing cultural property at risk on the island5,11.
William Honan, who had covered the Kanakaria case, suggested him to Willi Korte for the Quedlinburg hunt, which Kline joined on a $200 retainer3. He represented the church of St. Servatii in Quedlinburg in recovering medieval treasures taken by an American Army officer after World War II12. With Korte he worked on the 1996 Goodman case, and his firm says he litigated the first US case setting standards for treating a forced sale ordered by the Nazis as theft3,12. He taught museum and cultural property law at George Washington University from 2000, became managing partner of Andrews Kurth's Washington office, and was president of the Lawyers' Committee for Cultural Heritage Preservation8,12. On 13 October 2016 he joined Cultural Heritage Partners, PLLC, in Washington as a partner12.
Life and work
1989
- Chosen as Cyprus's chief attorney in the replevin suit over the Kanakaria mosaics against Peg Goldberg, with the Church of Cyprus as plaintiff; Hofstadter says he specialised in environmental and antitrust law and had never tried an antiquities case. Over a two-month discovery period more than twenty depositions were taken.
- Argued in the alternative: Indiana law (no good title from a thief) or, if Swiss law applied, that Goldberg was not a good-faith purchaser. Hofstadter reports he urged colleagues to assume there was no 'Aydin Dikmen' unless evidence showed otherwise.
April–May
Took Goldberg's deposition in Indianapolis.May–June
At the trial before Judge James E. Noland, called Robert Fitzgerald on 2 June and asked whether Michel van Rijn paid Aydin Dikmen only $350,000, the figure in a middlemen's agreement produced by Ronald Faulk; later cross-examined Goldberg (the 'cross of Goldberg'), which Hofstadter calls an unqualified disaster for her. Hofstadter says Kline did not press complicity in the fencing of the mosaics, 'couldn't prove it and didn't need it'. Van Rijn was not called, because Kline felt his presence might elicit sympathy for her.3 August
Judge Noland ruled in favour of Cyprus (a year to the day before the motion to set aside judgment was filed on 3 Aug 1990, per Hofstadter); the Court of Appeals upheld the decision.- Named in 1 CyBC (ΡΙΚ) film record 1989: 5 August 1989: CANAKARIA MOSAIC - DI 1989 KANAKARIA MOSAICS - TRIAL - 1989 (lawyer of the Cypriot Government and the Church of Cyprus)
1990
August–November
Hofstadter says Kline was 'more than a little worried' by Joe Emerson's 3 Aug 1990 motion to set aside judgment (based on Savo's statement); it was denied three months later.
1992
1992–1994
Told Dan Hofstadter he suspected 'Dikmen' was a constructed identity (quoted by Hofstadter comparing him to an 'identity' in Le Carré), and said 'Maybe you're Dikmen'; Hofstadter calls him Cyprus's former attorney.
Undated
n.d.
- Attorney who represented Cyprus in the Kanakaria mosaics restitution case and introduced a Dumbarton Oaks publication as evidence.
Through their hands
3 records- n.d.Agency
AgencyIcons and church artThomas R. Kline served as lead counsel for the Church of Cyprus in litigation over the Kanakariá mosaics.
Agent for the Church of CyprusIndianapolis, IndianaKline 2012, p. 463
- n.d.Agency
AgencyIcons and church artThomas R. Kline served as lead counsel for the Republic of Cyprus in litigation over the Kanakariá mosaics.
Agent for the Republic of CyprusIndianapolis, IndianaKline 2012, p. 463
- n.d.Agency
AgencyIcons and church artThomas Kline was a member of the legal team representing the Church of Cyprus and the Republic of Cyprus in the Kanakaria case.
Agent for Church of CyprusPanagia Kanakaria mosaic fragmentsAlphas 2017, p. 35
Connections
6 peopleSales, gifts & bequests
Disputes & the law
- In litigation with Joe Emersonthe Kanakaria mosaics suit Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989–1990
- In litigation with Peg GoldbergKline (Manatt, Phelps, Washington) was chief counsel for Cyprus and the Church; cross-examined her at trial Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989–1990
Scholarship
- Corresponded with Dan Hofstadterthanked 'above all' for help with legal questions Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1992–1994
Colleagues & contacts
- Worked with Constantine LeventisprobablyHofstadter calls Leventis (Cyprus's ambassador to UNESCO) 'a key figure for Kline' Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989
- Worked with Gary Vikanexpert witness for the plaintiffs' counsel, Kanakaria case Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade1989
- Worked with Republic of CyprusT. R. Kline, 2012, Confronting complexity in the preservation of cultural property: Monuments, art, antiquities, archives, and history. What can Cyprus teach us?, p. 462; Different legal Issues Related to the Protection of Cultural Property in Peacetime and Wartime (2012), p. 4622012
Recording and study
2 records- Worked with2
Thomas R. Kline worked with the Republic of Cyprus to protect Cypriot cultural heritage.
Worked with the Republic of CyprusKline 2012, p. 462
Thomas R. Kline worked with the Church of Cyprus to protect Cypriot cultural heritage.
Worked with the Church of CyprusKline 2012, p. 462
Mentioned in
14 mentionsDocuments · 5
- Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade
1994
trial counsel for Cyprus
Hofstadter 1994
- Confronting complexity in the preservation of cultural property: Monuments, art, antiquities, archives, and history. What can Cyprus teach us?
Agent, partnership · pp. 462, 463
Thomas R. Kline served as lead counsel for the Church of Cyprus in litigation over the Kanakariá mosaics.
Kline 2012
- From a Bronze Age Tomb in Cyprus to the Estate of a Gentleman in Sussex: Measures Taken and Problems Faced in the Investigations on the Illicit Trade of Antiquities
Agent · p. 35
Thomas Kline was a member of the legal team representing the Church of Cyprus and the Republic of Cyprus in the Kanakaria case.
Alphas 2017
- Digital Heritage: Progress in Cultural Heritage: Documentation, Preservation, and Protection: 5th International Conference, EuroMed 2014, Limassol, Cyprus, November 3-8, 2014, Proceedings
Ioannides et al. 2014
- Protecting the Cultural Heritage of Cyprus: Joining Efforts in Preventing the Illicit Trafficking of Cultural Heritage
Pilides & McCarthy 2014
On Ancient Cyprus · 1
Institutions · 4
- Church of Cyprus
Specialist (1989–1990) · 1989
Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus v. Goldberg, Indianapolis: Judge Noland held the four Kanakaria mosaics belonged to the Church of Cyprus, which…
Hofstadter 1994
- Goldberg & Feldman Fine Arts, Inc.
1989
Named as defendant firm in Cyprus's replevin suit in federal court in Indianapolis over the four Kanakaria mosaics bought by Peg Goldberg
Gerstenblith 2015; Hofstadter 1994
- Manatt, Phelps, Rothenberg & Phillips
Partner (1989–1990) · 1989
Its attorney Thomas Kline was chief attorney for the Republic of Cyprus and the Church of Cyprus in the federal suit in Indianapolis (filed 29 March 1989) to…
Hofstadter 1994
- Andrews & Kurth
Partner (from 1994) · 1994
Named in the author's acknowledgments as the firm of Thomas R. Kline (Washington office), who had been chief attorney for Cyprus and the Church in the…
Hofstadter 1994
- People · 4listed under Connections
Sources
- 1.Dan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
- 2.Thomas R. Kline (2012). “Confronting Complexity in the Preservation of Cultural Property: Monuments, Art, Antiquities, Archives, and History. What Can Cyprus Teach Us?”. Proceedings of the Annual Meeting (American Society of International Law) 106, 462-469. Online
- 3.Susan Baer (2009). “Searching for Masterpieces”. Washingtonian (1 November 2009). Online
- 4.Eleni Alphas (2017). “From a Bronze Age Tomb in Cyprus to the Estate of a Gentleman in Sussex: Measures Taken and Problems Faced in the Investigations on the Illicit Trade of Antiquities”. Four Decades of Hiatus in Archaeological Research in Cyprus: Towards Restoring the Balance, 30-43. Verlag Holzhausen.
- 5.[reviewer not read] (2016). “[Review of D. Pilides and A. McCarthy (eds), Protecting the Cultural Heritage of Cyprus, 2014]”. Public Archaeology (Taylor & Francis), doi 10.1080/00310328.2016.1251034.
- 6.United States District Court, S.D. Indiana (Noland, J.) (1989). “Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus and the Republic of Cyprus v. Goldberg & Feldman Fine Arts, Inc., and Peg Goldberg”. Federal Supplement 717, 1374-1405.
- 7.IFAR (1992). “The Cyprus and Quedlinburg Cases: A Lawyer's View of Two Recoveries”. IFAR Reports and The Art Loss Register.
- 8.Thomas R. Kline (2012). “The Fall and Rise of Marion True and the Getty Museum: a review of Chasing Aphrodite”. IFAR Journal 13, no. 3, 54-62.
- 9.Marinos Ioannides et al. (eds.) (2014). Digital Heritage: Progress in Cultural Heritage: Documentation, Preservation, and Protection. 5th International Conference, EuroMed 2014.
- 10.United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit (Bauer, C.J.) (1990). “Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus and the Republic of Cyprus v. Goldberg and Feldman Fine Arts, Inc., and Peg Goldberg”. Federal Reporter, 2nd series 917, 278-294.
- 11.[reviewer not read]. “[Review of D. Pilides and A. McCarthy (eds), Protecting the Cultural Heritage of Cyprus, 2014]”. University of Chicago Press journal, doi 10.1086/684954.
- 12.Cultural Heritage Partners, PLLC (2016). Renowned Art Law Attorney Tom Kline Joins Cultural Heritage Partners. Online
- 13.T. R. Kline (2012). “Confronting complexity in the preservation of cultural property: Monuments, art, antiquities, archives, and history. What can Cyprus teach us?”. Proceedings of the Annual Meeting (American Society of International Law) 106, 462-469.
- 14.Efthymia Alphas (2017). “From a Bronze Age Tomb in Cyprus to the Estate of a Gentleman in Sussex: Measures Taken and Problems Faced in the Investigations on the Illicit Trade of Antiquities”. Four Decades of Hiatus in Archaeological Research in Cyprus: Towards Restoring the Balance, 30-43. Verlag Holzhausen.
- 15.Cyprus Broadcasting Corporation (ΡΙΚ), film and video archive, Digital Herodotus item 5082: «CANAKARIA MOSAIC - DI 1989 ΨΗΦΙΔΩΤΑ ΚΑΝΑΚΑΡΙΑΣ - ΔΙΚΗ - 1989», 5 August 1989, 00:04:36, at 01'47''. Online
- 16.Marinos Ioannides; Nadia Magnenat-Thalmann; Eleanor Fink; Roko Žarnić; Alex-Yianing Yen; Ewald Quak (2014). Digital Heritage: Progress in Cultural Heritage: Documentation.
- 17.Dan Hofstadter, 1994, Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade.
- 18.T. R. Kline, 2012, Confronting complexity in the preservation of cultural property: Monuments, art, antiquities, archives, and history. What can Cyprus teach us?.
- 19.Different legal Issues Related to the Protection of Cultural Property in Peacetime and Wartime (2012).
- 20.Autocephalous Greek-Orthodox Church of Cyprus v. Goldberg, 717 F. Supp. 1374 (S.D. Ind. 1989).
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- Date of birth unknown
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.