Dealers

Goldberg & Feldman Fine Arts, Inc.

Indianapolis, United States

Indianapolis dealer firm sued by Cyprus and the Church of Cyprus in 1989 over the four Kanakaria mosaics; a federal court held that the mosaics belonged to the Church, and they returned in 1991.

About

The Indianapolis firm Goldberg & Feldman Fine Arts, Inc. appears in Cypriot heritage history as the defendant in one case, the replevin suit over the four mosaics from the apse of the church of Panagia Kanakaria. The firm's name is taken from the case caption1; its owner and dealer was Peg Goldberg, who bought the mosaics in 1988 in the free port of Geneva4. Later accounts describe her as the firm's president and majority shareholder6. The mosaics had come from the church of Kanakaria in the north of Cyprus. Goldberg offered them to the Getty through dealers, and the Republic of Cyprus then learned that they were in her possession in Indianapolis5.

The Republic of Cyprus and the Church of Cyprus filed suit in federal court in Indianapolis on 29 March 19891,2. On 3 August 1989 Judge Noland ruled for the Church: Indiana law gave Goldberg no valid title, and under Swiss law her inquiries before buying fell short. Hoover gives the price as 1.2 million dollars against appraisals of 3 to 6 million2,3. Goldberg's own position, as Hofstadter reports it, was that she had done nothing wrong; Hofstadter himself doubts that she knowingly bought stolen goods, while calling her "perilously passive"2.

The Court of Appeals upheld the judgment in 19909. The mosaics reached Cyprus in early September 19912, where Hofstadter saw them in a back room of the Byzantine Museum in Nicosia. Nothing is recorded of the firm's founding or its end, and its partner Feldman is not identified in the sources.

History

  1. 1988
    Was party to the 1988 purchase, in the Geneva free port, of the Kanakaria mosaics.

    (2015). Private International Law, Art and Cultural Heritage (2015), p. 99

  2. 1988
    Offered the Kanakaria mosaics to the Getty through art dealers; the Republic of Cyprus then learned that they were in Goldberg's possession in Indianapolis.

    (2012). The Parthenon Sculptures and Cultural Justice (2012), p. 957

  3. 1988
    Acquired, through its president Peg Goldberg, the Byzantine mosaics stolen from the church of Kanakaria in the north of Cyprus when they surfaced on the market in 1988.

    (1992). The Goldberg Case: A Confirmation of the Difficulty in Acquiring Good Title to Valuable Stolen Cultural Objects (1992), p. 153

  4. 29 March 1989
  5. 3 August 1989
    Judge Noland holds that the mosaics belong to the Church of Cyprus: Indiana law gave no valid title, and under Swiss law her inquiries fell short (price of 1.2m against appraisals of 3-6m, unknown seller, suspect middlemen)

    IndianapolisPeg GoldbergDan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux; Deborah Hoover (1990). Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet. Journal of Arts Management and Law 20, 37-62. Routledge

  6. 1989
    Was sued in replevin in 1989 by the Autocephalous Greek Orthodox Church of Cyprus and the Republic of Cyprus over the mosaics (717 F. Supp. 1374, S.D. Ind. 1989).

    (2009). James A.R. Nafziger; Ann M. Nicgorski, Cultural Heritage Issues: The Legacy of Conquest, Colonization, and Commerce (2009), p. 310

  7. 1989
    Was the defendant in Autocephalous Greek Orthodox Church of Cyprus and Republic of Cyprus v. Goldberg, decided in 1989 and affirmed on appeal in 1990.

    (1991). Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters (1991), p. 243

  8. 1990
  9. 1990
    Was ordered to return the four Kanakaria mosaics to the Church of Cyprus, the court finding that the purchase was made in bad faith.

    (2021). Non-State Actors in the Protection of Cultural Heritage (2021), p. 72

  10. 1991
    After the Court of Appeals upheld the ruling and review was denied, the mosaics arrive in Cyprus in early September 1991

    NicosiaDan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux

People

3 people

Staff and members · 1

Others connected · 2

Mentioned in

10 mentions

Sources

  1. 1.Patty Gerstenblith (2015). “For Better and For Worse: Evolving United States Policy on Cultural Property Litigation and Restitution”. International Journal of Cultural Property. Online
  2. 2.Dan Hofstadter (1994). Goldberg's Angel: An Adventure in the Antiquities Trade. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
  3. 3.Deborah Hoover (1990). “Museum Collections at Risk: Standards of Diligence for Protecting Your Monet”. Journal of Arts Management and Law 20, 37-62. Routledge. Online
  4. 4. (2015). Private International Law, Art and Cultural Heritage (2015), p. 99.
  5. 5. (2012). The Parthenon Sculptures and Cultural Justice (2012), p. 957.
  6. 6. (1992). The Goldberg Case: A Confirmation of the Difficulty in Acquiring Good Title to Valuable Stolen Cultural Objects (1992), p. 153.
  7. 7. (2009). James A.R. Nafziger; Ann M. Nicgorski, Cultural Heritage Issues: The Legacy of Conquest, Colonization, and Commerce (2009), p. 310.
  8. 8. (1991). Law and diplomacy in cultural property matters (1991), p. 243.
  9. 9. (2016). <i>Protecting the Cultural Heritage of Cyprus: Joining Efforts in Preventing the Illicit Trafficking of Cultural Heritage</i>. Edited by Despina Pilides and And (2016), p. 187.
  10. 10. (2021). Non-State Actors in the Protection of Cultural Heritage (2021), p. 72.

Corrections and additions

Work here, or visited recently?

Institutions can send their own description, and anyone can tell us when something has changed.

Missing from this record

  • Date of founding unknown

We would like to hear about

  • Opening hours, closures or a new address
  • What the collection holds
  • Contact details and website
  • A description from the institution itself

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.