Article · 2018
Illicit excavation: the trial of Alessandro Palma di Cesnola in Cyprus in 1878
The Antiquaries Journal 98 297-317
An article on the 1878 arrest and trial of Alessandro Palma di Cesnola for excavating at Enkomi, the Ottoman antiquities law applied to him, and the disposal of his seized antiquities.
Stanley-Price reconstructs the 1878 arrest and trial of Alessandro Palma di Cesnola for unauthorised excavation at Enkomi. He draws on confidential correspondence among British officials, sworn statements by workmen and witnesses, a summary of the court proceedings and Cesnola's own published accounts, and follows the case from Wolseley's ban on excavation after Britain took over the administration of Cyprus, through the verdict and Cesnola's claims to American citizenship and diplomatic standing, to the disposal of his antiquities.
The court applied the Ottoman antiquities law of 1874, which required official authorisation for excavation and provided for seizure and penalties. Later changes are traced through the Ottoman law of 1884, the proposed law of 1896 and the Cyprus law of 1905 (pp. 299–300, 313). Stanley-Price argues that the British authorities first meant to deal leniently with Cesnola and that his protest at the arrest led to a formal trial, in which the British assessor shaped the verdict and Cesnola's claims were found unsupported. He also argues that British Museum interest in controlling excavation helped prompt Wolseley's ban, and that financial and moral pressure contributed to Cesnola's decision to go on digging.
The quantity of antiquities that Cesnola excavated and purchased for Edwin Lawrence, his sponsor in London, remains unknown. The article follows the Lawrence collection through its sales and the transfer of some confiscated pieces to the Cyprus Museum (pp. 311–314).
What it records
- Article 7 of the Ottoman antiquities law of 1874 prohibited excavation for antiquities and treasures without official authorisation and the landowner's consent.p. 299
- Cesnola's excavations at Enkomi employed about sixty men at the start and stopped on 2 October 1878; Lazaris Philippi supervised the work.p. 303
- Finds from the Enkomi workmen were stored in a ruined house, whose keys Panagia Hadji Cristofi lent to Lazaris Philippi.p. 303
- The assessor found Cesnola guilty and imposed a fine of four liras, which Wolseley remitted, with confiscation of the antiquities seized at Enkomi and Ormidia.p. 310
- Cesnola reported that three years of purchases and digging produced 14,000 objects for the collection sent to Edwin Lawrence in London.p. 312
- Four sales of the Lawrence collection between 1883 and 1892 comprised 3,463 lots.p. 312
- Some of the antiquities seized from Cesnola eventually entered the Cyprus Museum.p. 312
Where to read
- Ottoman antiquities law and the 1878 excavation banpp. 298–300
- Enkomi excavations, arrest and trial evidencepp. 302–310
- Seizure and later disposal of the Lawrence–Cesnola antiquitiespp. 311–314
Contents
- Introduction297
- The Law Under Which Alessandro Palma Di Cesnola Was Charged298
- Alessandro Palma Di Cesnola's Illicit Excavations300
- Arrest of Alessandro Palma Di Cesnola and His Reaction305
- The Trial of Alessandro Palma Di Cesnola307
- Court procedure and verdict307
- Alessandro Palma Di Cesnola's Defence310
- The Capitulations and diplomatic status310
- Disposal of Alessandro Palma Di Cesnola's Antiquities311
- Review: the 1878 Ban on Excavations313
- Acknowledgments314
- Abbreviations and Bibliography314
- Primary sources315
- Secondary sources315
People, places and institutions
People
- Alessandro Palma di Cesnolaexcavator tried in 1878
- Sir Garnet Wolseleyhigh commissioner of Cyprus
- Luigi Palma di Cesnolabrother and earlier excavator
- George Greavesgovernment chief secretary
- Henry G WhiteLarnaca commissioner and trial assessor
- E Spencerinvestigated excavations at Enkomi
- Achilleus Vondizianoreported the excavations to authorities
- Lazaris Philippisupervised excavations for Cesnola
- Panagia Hadji Cristofilent keys to the house holding finds
- Claude Delaval Cobhaminterpreted at Cesnola’s trial
- Henry Brackenburyprosecutor at Cesnola’s trial
- C T NewtonBritish Museum keeper who reported on Cyprus
- Edwin H Lawrencesponsor of Cesnola’s collecting
Institutions
- British Museumproposed government control of excavation
- Cyprus Museumeventual recipient of some seized finds
Places
Also named: Christophi Andrea, Constantini Hadji Tochi, Christodoulo/Christobulo Georgi, Alessandro Koukomo, Georgi Zoneno, Società Piemontese di Archeologia e Belle Arti.
Extent pp. 297–317, 4 figs, 1 map; bibliography
ModernLooting and the LawHistory of ArchaeologyCollectingMuseumsTrade
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
2 pages- The Legal Export of Cypriot AntiquitiesCompendium
- OrmideiaSite
Excavations it is cited for
1 project- 1876–1879Salamis and Enkomi: Alessandro Palma di Cesnola's excavationsDirected by Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola and Lazaris Philippi (supervisor on Cesnola's behalf)Clearance and early digging
Who did what
36 recordsBuying, selling and giving 15
- 1870–1876 · p. 297
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toMetropolitan Museum of Art
Cesnola agreed to sell his collection to the Metropolitan Museum for £1,200.
£1,200New York
- p. 299
George Henry BokerAgent forLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Boker obtained a firman for Luigi Palma di Cesnola’s digging and helped him export his finds.
firman for digging and exported findsCyprus
- p. 299
Luigi Palma di CesnolaGave toGeorge Henry Boker
Luigi Palma di Cesnola gave Boker gold trinkets from his collection.
- p. 301
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaAgent forEdwin Henry Lawrence
Alessandro Palma di Cesnola returned to Cyprus to acquire antiquities for Edwin H Lawrence.
- p. 303
Panagia Hadji CristofiLent toLazaris Philippi
Panagia Hadji Cristofi lent Lazaris Philippi the keys to the house where he stored the finds.
keys to a ruined houseEnkomi
- p. 305, 312
E. SpencerSeized antiquities fromAlessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola
Spencer seized pottery and glass objects found in Panagia’s house during his investigation.
Panagia's house, Enkomi
- p. 311
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaOwned
The Ormidia house contained large quantities of antiquities associated with Alessandro Palma di Cesnola.
antiquities held at the Ormidia house
- 1877 · p. 312
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaGave toSociété Piémontaise d'archéologie et Beaux-arts
Alessandro gave a small collection of antiquities to the Société Piémontaise d'archéologie et Beaux-arts.
a small collection of Cypriot antiquitiesTurin
- 1883–1892 · p. 312
Edwin Henry LawrenceAuctioned
Edwin H Lawrence sent his collection to auction; four sales totalled 3,463 lots.
With unnamed buyersLawrence's collection, 3,463 lotsLondon
- p. 312
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaPassed objects toEdwin Henry Lawrence
Cesnola packed unearthed relics for conveyance to Lawrence in England and dispatched them in his first cargo.
the relics which had then been unearthed
- p. 312
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaHad objects seized
British authorities seized antiquities stored at Enkomi and Ormidia.
pottery, glass and other antiquities
- p. 312
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaExported
The first shipment of antiquities left for London in the winter of 1876–7.
first shipment ('six large cases')
- p. 312
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaGave
Alessandro Palma di Cesnola said he gave antiquities to visitors.
With visitors
- p. 312
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaGave
Alessandro Palma di Cesnola donated some antiquities to members of his family in Italy.
With members of his family
- p. 312
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaHad objects seized
Police removed over 1,500 items from the Ormidia house after the trial.
over 1,500 antiquities
Excavation 16
- p. 297
Luigi Palma di CesnolaExcavated
Luigi Palma di Cesnola amassed a collection by purchasing casual finds and paying villagers to dig at archaeological sites.
With villagersantiquitiesCyprus
- p. 300
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaStudent ofLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Luigi Palma di Cesnola instructed Alessandro Palma di Cesnola in his methods and how to manage workmen and local Turkish officials.
Cyprus
- 1877 · p. 301
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaDirected excavations
After his workman brought finds from Salamis, Cesnola ordered his men there and followed.
- p. 302
Alessandro KoukomoDug forAlessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola
Alessandro Koukomo dug for Alessandro Palma di Cesnola at Enkomi before being employed to fill excavation pits.
- p. 302
George GreavesRefused a permit toAlessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola
Greaves told Cesnola that excavation was forbidden when he requested permission to dig.
excavation permitNicosia
- p. 303
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaEmployedLazaris Philippi
Lazaris Philippi was Alessandro Palma di Cesnola’s servant.
- p. 303
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaEmployedGeorgi Zoneno
Alessandro Palma di Cesnola engaged Georgi Zoneno, who worked until 2 October 1878.
Larnaca
- p. 303
Lazaris PhilippiEmployedChristophi Andrea
Lazaris Philippi employed Christophi Andrea on the Enkomi excavations.
- p. 303
Lazaris PhilippiEmployedConstantini Hadji Tochi
Lazaris Philippi employed Constantini Hadji Tochi on the Enkomi excavations.
- p. 303
Lazaris PhilippiEmployedChristodoulos Georgi
Lazaris Philippi employed Christodoulo/Christobulo Georgi among the Enkomi workmen.
- 1878 · p. 304
Achilleus VondizianoRecorded
Achilleus Vondiziano reported Alessandro’s excavation work at Enkomi to a police captain.
With a police captainexcavations at Enkomi
- 1878 · p. 305
E. SpencerRecorded
Spencer went to Enkomi to locate and investigate the excavation site.
- p. 309
Lazaris PhilippiDug forAlessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola
Lazaris Philippi supervised excavations on Alessandro Palma di Cesnola’s behalf.
Enkomi
- 1880–1881 · p. 313
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaConnected withBritish Museum
Alessandro Palma di Cesnola offered to direct excavations for the British Museum, which declined his offer.
proposed excavations in CyprusCyprus
- 1880 · p. 313
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaConnected withCharles Newton
Alessandro Palma di Cesnola applied to Newton to direct excavations in Cyprus for the British Museum.
proposed excavations in Cyprus
Show 1 moreShow fewer
- 1870–1879 · p. 314
Edwin Henry LawrenceFinancedAlessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola
Lawrence supplied Cesnola with money to begin excavating on his own account.
a sum of moneyCyprus
Recording and study 4
- 1877–1904 · p. 297
Luigi Palma di CesnolaEmployed byNew York Metropolitan Museum of Art
The trustees hired Cesnola to unpack, arrange and classify the collection.
$500 a monthNew York
- p. 301
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaStudied
Alessandro Palma di Cesnola spent several months studying the Oriental collections at the British Museum.
British Museum, London
- 1880 · p. 314
Samuel BirchConnected withAlessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola
Dr. Samuel Birch inspected Major di Cesnola's collection of Cypriote antiquities at Holland Park.
- p. 314
Samuel BirchHelpedAlessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola
Birch helped Alessandro Palma di Cesnola in his earlier studies in London.
antiquities studies
Posts and family 1
- 1861–1886 · p. 313
Charles NewtonEmployed byBritish Museum
Charles Newton was Keeper of Greek and Roman Antiquities in the British Museum.
People it is cited for
31 people- Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola39 citations
- E. Spencer16 citations
- George Greaves15 citations
- Lazaris Philippi14 citations
- Garnet Joseph Wolseley13 citations
- Achilleus Vondiziano10 citations
- Claude Delaval Cobham10 citations
- Henry Brackenbury10 citations
- William Hepworth Dixon10 citations
- Richard L. Hippisley8 citations
- Georgi Zoneno7 citations
- Panagia Hadji Cristofi7 citations
- Alessandro Koukomo6 citations
- Christodoulos Georgi6 citations
- Henry G. White6 citations
- George Henry Boker5 citations
- Gregori Haji Lambrou5 citations
- Nicolaos Vondiziano5 citations
- Christophi Andrea4 citations
- Constantini Hadji Tochi4 citations
- Johannes Kyriaki4 citations
- Luigi Palma di Cesnola4 citations
- W. Rees Davies4 citations
- Charles Newton3 citations
- Charles W. Dilke2 citations
- Lucia Vagnetti2 citations
- Safvet Pasha2 citations
- Laurent Dubois
- Major B. Seager
- Robert Hamilton Lang
1 more
Institutions it is cited for
11 institutions- Government of Cyprus (British colonial administration)15 citations
- US Consular Agency, Paphos5 citations
- Cyprus Police4 citations
- Istanbul Archaeology Museums4 citations
- Legislative Council of Cyprus4 citations
- Royal Engineers4 citations
- Military Police, Cyprus3 citations
- Chief Secretary's Office, Cyprus Government2 citations
- Cyprus Museum
- Società Piemontese di Archeologia e Belle Arti
- United States Legation, Constantinople
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.