Catalogue · 2017
The Cesnola Collection of Cypriot Art: Ancient Glass
C. S. Lightfoot
New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art
A catalogue of 520 glass vessels and objects in the Metropolitan Museum's Cesnola Collection, arranged by type and technique, with an essay on the collection's history.
The Cesnola Collection of glass in the Metropolitan Museum of Art ranges from the Late Bronze Age to the Early Byzantine period, and Lightfoot describes and illustrates it in a catalogue arranged by material, manufacture and object type. An introductory essay on the collection's history comes first, and conclusions, appendices and reference lists follow. The essay sets the collection beside published tomb groups and other Cypriot and eastern Mediterranean glass, and explains the limits of its archaeological documentation.
Collection history
Luigi Palma di Cesnola collected and excavated in Cyprus from his arrival as American consul in 1865. His excavations included Idalion, Golgoi, Throni, Salamis, Paphos and Kourion, and the glass he acquired included vessels and ornaments whose precise find circumstances were generally not recorded (pp. 11–12).
The glass was dispersed before and after the Metropolitan Museum acquired the bulk of the collection. Groups and single objects reached institutions and private collections in Europe and the United States through sales, gifts and museum purchases, among them the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, the British Museum, the Fitzwilliam Museum and the John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art. Leland Stanford negotiated for Cesnola duplicates, and the Harvard Semitic Museum received twenty-two glass vessels from Stanford. Cesnola's Atlas of the Cesnola Collection and John Myres's 1914 Handbook of the Cesnola Collection of Antiquities from Cyprus are the earlier records of the collection (pp. 11–22).
The catalogue
The entries are numbered Cat. 1–519 and run by glass type, technique and object category. It opens with early Egyptian, Mycenaean and Near Eastern glass of the Late Bronze and Early Iron Ages, then core-formed, cast and mold-blown glass, and blown tableware and containers. The introduction to each group discusses techniques, forms, dates and comparative material, with examples from Cypriot excavations and other collections (pp. 23–185).
Perfume bottles are grouped by form and size, among them candlestick unguentaria, tubular and cylinder-shaped unguentaria and kohl tubes. Large, mid-sized and miniature bottles are distinguished, and the dating of these groups is complicated by long-lived types and uncertain contexts. Entries give description, condition, measurements, date, manufacturing details, collection and accession information, references and comparative commentary, and many carry a reported or uncertain findspot where an excavated context would otherwise stand. Inventory numbers follow the pattern 74.51 (pp. 186–291).
Miscellaneous glass includes painted glass, lids, an oil lamp, fragments, utensils, gaming objects, spindle whorls, a mirror, mosaic revetment plaques and an obsidian furniture fitting. The chapter on jewellery and ornaments covers pendants, rings, bracelets and beads. Appendices list objects from the Charvet and Gréau collections, and a list of provenances by catalogue number and a concordance of Metropolitan Museum, catalogue, C.G. and Myres numbers close the volume (pp. 292–338).
The argument
Lightfoot places the glass within wider patterns of eastern Mediterranean and Black Sea production and circulation. Similar forms and techniques occur across those regions, and parallels alone do not show that a vessel was made in Cyprus. He allows that a proportion of the collection was probably produced on the island (pp. 329–330).
Limits of the evidence
Tombs could be reused, plain vessel types stayed in production for long periods, and many Cesnola objects lack recorded find circumstances. Lightfoot therefore gives catalogue dates as approximate, and he compares the Cypriot material with finds from sites and collections elsewhere without treating similarity as proof of local manufacture (pp. 12–13, 17–22, 186–187, 329–330).
What it records
- The volume describes and illustrates 520 glass vessels and objects in the Metropolitan Museum of Art.p. 6
- Cesnola is stated to have acquired 3,719 glass objects, including vessels and ornaments.p. 11
- By December 1868 Cesnola had 300 glass objects in his possession.p. 11
- The 1872 inventory by Johannes Doell, compiled for the Russian Imperial Academy of Sciences in St Petersburg, counted more than 1,800 glass pieces.p. 11
- The Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, acquired a group of 51 glass vessels from Cesnola on 16 May 1872.p. 12
- At least 223 vessels in the Ringling collection can be identified as Cesnola pieces from the museum's records and the Anderson auction catalogues.p. 15
- The Cesnola Collection of glass ranges from the Late Bronze Age to the Early Byzantine period, approximately 1500 BCE to 625 CE.p. 17
- Catalogue entry 177, a two-handled bottle, is said to come from a tomb at Kition, modern Larnaka.p. 157
- Lightfoot argues that the Cesnola glass should be described as glass found on Cyprus and not as Cypriot glass, although a significant proportion of it was probably made on the island.p. 330
Where to read
- Collection history, dispersal and museum holdingspp. 11–22
- Early glass objects and beads, catalogue entries 1–3pp. 26–29
- Core-formed glass and Mediterranean groupspp. 30–41
- Cast-glass tableware and Cypriot findspp. 42–51
- Inscribed and decorated mold-blown glasspp. 52–65
- Blown tableware, including sack-shaped and indented vesselspp. 66–125
- Blown containers, perfume bottles and candlestick unguentariapp. 126–291
- Regional production and circulation, appendices and concordancepp. 329–337
Contents
- Cesnola, Glass, and Cyprus11
- The Scope of the Collection17
- Other Collections of Cypriot Glass18
- Catalogue25
- Early Egyptian, Mycenaean, and Near Eastern Glass in the Late Bronze and Early Iron Ages (ca. 15th–7th Century B.C.)26
- Core-Formed Glass (5th–1st Century B.C.)30
- Cast Glass (1st Century B.C.–1st Century A.D.)42
- Mold-Blown Glass (1st–7th Century A.D.)52
- Blown Glass Tableware (1st–6th Century A.D.)66
- Blown Glass Containers (1st–6th Century A.D.)126
- Glass Perfume Bottles (1st–4th Century A.D.), Introduction (Cat. 229–442)186
- Miscellaneous Glass, Introduction (Cat. 443–472)292
- Glass Jewelry and Ornaments, Introduction (Cat. 473–519)310
- Conclusions329
- Appendix 1: Glass from Cyprus in the Charvet Collection (Froehner 1879)331
- Appendix 2: Glass from Cyprus in the Gréau Collection (Froehner 1903)332
- Provenances, by Catalogue Number334
- Concordance335
Objects published here
15- Two rectangular beads, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 74.51.4536, 74.51.4537, Cat. 1 (p. 27)
- Krateriskos (unguent jar), The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Said to be from a tomb at Idalion, 74.51.352, Cat. 2 (p. 28)
- Alabastron (perfume bottle), The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 74.51.312, Cat. 3 (p. 28)
- Amphoriskos (perfume bottle), The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 74.51.326, Cat. 4 (p. 34)
- Ribbed bowl, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 74.51.289, Cat. 20 (p. 48)
- Hexagonal jug with Jewish symbols, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 74.51.140, Cat. 37 (p. 64)
- Bottle in the shape of a bird, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 74.51.205, Cat. 131 (p. 128)
- Two-handled bottle identified as an amphora, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Said to be from a tomb at Kition, 74.51.108, Cat. 177 (p. 157)
- Indented flask, The Cesnola Collection, Said to be from a tomb at Idalion (modern Dali), 74.51.214, Cat. 188 (p. 164)
- Trick bottle, The Cesnola Collection, Said to be from a tomb at Kition (modern Larnaka), 74.51.150, Cat. 227 (p. 184)
- Large disk-bodied perfume bottle, The Cesnola Collection, Said to be from a tomb at Idalion (modern Dali), 74.51.16, Cat. 366 (p. 251)
- Sealed perfume bottle, The Cesnola Collection, Said to be from a tomb at Ormidia, 74.51.95, Cat. 382 (p. 264)
- Painted cylindrical bottle, The Cesnola Collection, Fragments found among debris of the Cesnola Collection in 1940, 74.51.5864, Cat. 443 (p. 294)
- Obsidian furniture attachment, The Cesnola Collection, 74.51.5871, Cat. 472 (p. 309)
- String of eye beads, The Cesnola Collection, 74.51.316, Cat. 509, Fig. 18 (p. 324)
People, places and institutions
People
- Luigi Palma di Cesnolacollected and excavated in Cyprus from 1865
- Alexander Palma di Cesnolaexcavated and collected glass
- John Myrescompiled a handbook of the collection
- Olof Vessbergstudied and classified glass from Cyprus
- John Ringlingacquired Cesnola glass
- Henry G. Marquanddonated the Charvet Collection
- General Pitt-Riverscollected Cypriot antiquities and glass
- Leland Stanfordnegotiated for Cesnola duplicates
Institutions
- The Metropolitan Museum of Artholds the Cesnola glass collection
- Cantor Arts Centerholds Cesnola glass formerly at Stanford
- Stanford Universityreceived Cesnola glass duplicates
- Toledo Museum of Artholds related glass objects
- National Museum of Irelandholds Cypriot glass, in the glass collections survey
- The Fitzwilliam Museumholds glass sold by Cesnola
- British Museumholds glass acquired from Cesnola
- Museum of Fine Arts, Bostonacquired Cesnola glass in 1872
- The John and Mable Ringling Museum of Artholds glass sold in 1928
- Harvard Semitic Museumreceived twenty-two glass vessels from Stanford
- Penn Museumholds glass from Ayios Ermoyenis
- Cyprus Museumhouses government archaeological finds
- Pitt Rivers Museumreceived Pitt-Rivers's archaeological collection
Places
- IdalionCesnola excavation and reported glass findspot
- Kourionexcavation site and glass findspot
- SalamisCypriot site with glass finds
- Paphossite with glass finds
- Amathussite with tomb and glass finds
- Potamiareported findspot of an Ennion flask
- Kitionreported tomb findspot
- LarnakaCypriot locality and glass findspot
- Ayios Ermoyenisnecropolis with glass tomb finds
- Vasa-Kambiexcavated chamber tombs with glass
- Eurychou-Phoenikastombs with glass finds
- Ayios Theodorostomb with glass vessels and coins
- Tremithusreported glass findspot
Also named: Rev. H. Hamilton Jackson, Russian consul Yusefovich, Johannes Doell, Daniel H. Weiss, Carlos A. Picón, Elizabeth J. Milleker, Bryn Mawr College, National Museums Scotland, Hood Museum of Art, Bank of Cyprus Cultural Foundation Collection, Golgoi, Throni, Karpasha, Kormakiti, Kyra, Tamassos, Aphendrika, Sinda.
Extent 519 numbered entries; a map at the start of the catalogue; bibliography pp. 338–349
Defines candlestick unguentarium, Type I, with tall neck and bulbous body, Type II, with tall neck and conical body, Type III, with tall neck and disk-shaped body, Type IV, with tall neck and bell-shaped body, Type V, with tall neck and piriform body, Type VI, with tall neck and body tapering downward
Late Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicCypro-ClassicalHellenisticRomanLate AntiqueGlass and FaienceCollectingTradeTechnologyCraft Production
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
2 pages · 1 object- Glass in Ancient CyprusCompendium
- MaterialsCompendium
Objects
Excavations it is cited for
3 projects- 1866–1875Idalion: Luigi Palma di Cesnola's excavations at DaliDirected by Luigi Palma di CesnolaClearance and early digging
- 1876–1879Salamis and Enkomi: Alessandro Palma di Cesnola's excavationsDirected by Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola and Lazaris Philippi (supervisor on Cesnola's behalf)Clearance and early digging
- 1882Salamis, Gastria and Kourion: Hake and Kitchener for the South Kensington Museum (1882)Directed by George Gordon Hake and Herbert KitchenerExcavation
Who did what
54 recordsBuying, selling and giving 41
- 1870–1876 · p. 6
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toMetropolitan Museum of Art
Cesnola agreed to sell his collection to the Metropolitan Museum for £1,200.
£1,200New York
- 1870 · p. 11
Luigi Palma di CesnolaExported
The text reports that Cesnola took some 35,500 objects from Cyprus in the 1870s.
- 1873–1876 · p. 11
Luigi Palma di CesnolaGave toImperial Ottoman Museum at Constantinople
Cesnola said that he voluntarily gave several thousand Cypriot antiquities to the Ottoman Imperial Museum.
Constantinople
- p. 11
Luigi Palma di CesnolaRecorded
A consignment of about 5,000 pieces from Cesnola's material was lost at sea off Beirut.
- p. 11
Cesnola sent a group of antiquities to Turin as a gift to his native land.
With his native land
- 1872 · p. 12
Luigi Palma di CesnolaPassed objects toMuseum of Fine Arts, Boston
The Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, acquired a lamp with gladiatorial equipment from Cesnola.
No. MFA 72.260
- 1876 · p. 13, 52, 53, 69, 82, 110, 127, 141, 186, 162, 171, 192, 284, 296, 300, 317
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toFitzwilliam Museum
Luigi Palma di Cesnola sold the flask to the Fitzwilliam Museum.
Snake-coil decorated flaskNo. GR.61.1876
- 1878 · p. 13
John HendersonBequeathed toBritish Museum
Henderson bequeathed five bowls from the Cesnola Collection to the British Museum.
No. GR 78.12-30.15, .16, .20, .27, and .29
- p. 13
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toJules Charvet
Cesnola sold the Ennion amphoriskos in Europe, and Charvet acquired it.
mold-blown blue amphoriskos signed by Ennion
- 1871 · p. 14
Augustus Henry Lane Fox Pitt RiversBought fromLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Pitt-Rivers purchased a Cesnola face bead at the 1871 Sotheby's auction.
No. 1884.76.142London
- 1881–1897 · p. 14, 103
Henry Gurdon MarquandGave toThe Metropolitan Museum of Art
Marquand donated the Charvet Collection to the Metropolitan.
New York
- 1888 · p. 14
Augustus Henry Lane Fox Pitt RiversBought
Pitt-Rivers purchased about sixty-six glass vessels from the Lawrence-Cesnola Collection sales.
With unnamed sellers at the Lawrence-Cesnola Collection salessome sixty-six glass vessels from the Lawrence-Cesnola CollectionLondon
- p. 14
Augustus Henry Lane Fox Pitt RiversGave toPitt Rivers Museum
Pitt-Rivers donated his archaeological and ethnographical objects to the Pitt Rivers Museum.
20,000 archaeological and ethnographical objects, including Cypriot antiquitiesOxford
- p. 14
Edwin Henry LawrenceBought fromLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Lawrence reported acquiring valuable relics, including glass, from Luigi Palma di Cesnola.
choice and valuable relics, including glass
- p. 14
Jules CharvetSold toHenry Gurdon Marquand
Marquand bought the Charvet Collection from Charvet.
Show 26 moreShow fewer
- 1871–1872 · p. 15
Luigi Palma di CesnolaGave toHiram Hitchcock
Cesnola gave fifty-nine lamps to Hiram Hitchcock.
- 1885–1896 · p. 15
Leland StanfordBought fromMetropolitan Museum of Art
Leland Stanford bought duplicates from the Cesnola collection in a private sale.
- 1925 · p. 15
Christine AlexanderBought fromThe Metropolitan Museum of Art
Christine Alexander purchased a glass vessel from the Metropolitan Museum.
single glass vessel
- 1936 · p. 15
John RinglingBequeathed toJohn and Mable Ringling Museum of Art
John Ringling bequeathed the lamp fragment to the John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art.
a lamp fragmentNo. SN28.931
- p. 15
F. W. CollinsPassed objects toPublic Library
The author reports that Collins acquired Cesnola glass and later deposited it at the Public Library in Roanoke.
glass from the Cesnola CollectionRoanoke, Virginia
- p. 15
John RinglingBought
Ringling acquired some of the glass sold in the Anderson Sale.
With unnamed sellers at the Anderson Saleglass from the Cesnola CollectionNew York
- p. 15
Luigi Palma di CesnolaOffered for sale
Cesnola attempted to sell his collection in London.
- 1877 · p. 20
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaGave toMuseo di Antichità di Torino
Alexander gave fifty glass objects from Salamis tombs to the museum in Turin.
fifty glass objects from tombs excavated at Salamis
- 1926 · p. 21
John Howard WilsonBought fromThe Metropolitan Museum of Art
Wilson bought duplicates from the Metropolitan; an archived receipt lists eleven glass vessels sold for $72.50.
$72.50
- 1871–1876 · p. 52, 13
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toBritish Museum
Cesnola sold a substantial series of antiquities directly to the British Museum through Birch.
more than eighty vases, terracottas and other objectsNo. 1876.9-9, 1 à 127300 livresLondon
- 1872 · p. 76, 81, 95, 87, 102, 115, 135, 133, 142, 191, 229, 236, 249, 251, 282
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toBoston Museum of Art
Cesnola sold seventy terracotta lamps and one bronze lamp directly to the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.
No. MFA 72.392
- p. 78
John HendersonPassed objects toBritish Museum
The cup formerly sold to John Henderson subsequently passed into the British Museum collection.
No. GR 78.12-30.29
- p. 78
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toJohn Henderson
Cesnola sold another cup to John Henderson in London.
- 1871–1876 · p. 84, 127, 321, 316, 318
Luigi Palma di CesnolaPassed objects toThe British Museum
Luigi Palma di Cesnola transferred the bowl to The British Museum.
hemispherical bowl resting on three small feetNo. 1876,0909.35
- p. 87
Luigi Palma di CesnolaPassed objects toLeland Stanford
possiblyThe beaker may have been one of those Cesnola sent to Governor Stanford.
No. JLS.1949; C.G. 1488
- 1917 · p. 103, 292
John Pierpont MorganGave toMetropolitan Museum
J. Pierpont Morgan gave the vessel to the Metropolitan Museum.
vessel, allegedly from MarionNo. 17.194.859
- 1871 · p. 126
Felix SladeBought
Felix Slade acquired the flask at the London sale in 1871.
flask with snake-thread decorationNo. GR 71.1-23.1
- p. 126, 175
Felix SladeBequeathed toBritish Museum
Felix Slade bequeathed the flask to the British Museum.
flask with snake-thread decorationNo. GR 71.1-23.1
- p. 127
Cesnola sold a tall, sack-shaped jar in London; it later passed via Felix Slade to the British Museum.
With unnamed buyerNo. BM GR 71.10-4.5
- 1884 · p. 132
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toLeland Stanford
Cesnola sold five saucer lamps to Leland Stanford, Sr.
No. JLS.1802, JLS.1803, JLS.1807, 1966.385, JLS.1804
- p. 175
Felix SladeBought fromLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Felix Slade bought a flask from Cesnola.
No. BM GR 71.7-13.8
- 1926 · p. 186
John Howard WilsonBought
John Howard Wilson purchased thirteen perfume bottles in 1926; they are now kept in the Wilson Museum, Castine, Maine.
No. w08164, w08171, w08172, w08192, w08199, w08210, w0822, w08222, w08230, w08238, w08773, w08784, and probably w08658
- 1928 · p. 240, 287
John RinglingBought fromMetropolitan Museum of Art
John Ringling bought lot 507 at the 1928 sale of duplicates from the Cesnola collection.
cruche avec une figurine tenant une oinochoéNo. n° 507New York City
- 1928 · p. 251
John RinglingBought
Ringling bought a large part of the original Cesnola Collection at the auction.
With unnamed sellers
- p. 251, 257, 263
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toStanford
Cesnola sold a large example to Stanford; it is now in the Iris & B. Gerald Cantor Center for Visual Arts, Stanford University.
large perfume bottleNo. JLS.1910
- 1871 · p. 310
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toAugustus Henry Lane Fox Pitt Rivers
General Pitt-Rivers acquired a face bead at the Cesnola sale in London.
Excavation 7
- p. 11
Luigi Palma di CesnolaExcavated
Cesnola collected and excavated antiquities at several Cypriot sites.
antiquities, including glassIdalion, Golgoi, Throni, Salamis, Paphos, and Kourion
- p. 11
Luigi Palma di CesnolaExcavated
possiblyThe text reports that Cesnola was said to have opened several thousand tombs at Idalion in two years.
- 1870–1879 · p. 14
Edwin Henry LawrenceFinancedAlessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola
Lawrence supplied Cesnola with money to begin excavating on his own account.
a sum of moneyCyprus
- 1876–1879 · p. 52, 70
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaExcavated
Alessandro carried out archaeological research and collecting between 1876 and 1879.
Cypriot antiquitiesCyprus
- p. 141, 184, 292, 310, 322
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaFound
At least one more example of this type of large container was found by Alexander Palma di Cesnola at Salamis.
- 1876–1879 · p. 287
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaExcavated
Alexander Palma di Cesnola excavated some of the pig-shaped rattles between 1876 and 1879.
No. 1665-1677
- 1882 · p. 305
Herbert KitchenerExcavated withGeorge Gordon Hake
Horatio Herbert Kitchener and George Gordon Hake excavated an unguentarium from Salamis.
No. GR 1982, 0729.54
Recording and study 4
- 2017 · p. 8
Christopher S. LightfootStudied
Lightfoot visited the Ringling Museum to inspect and collate Cesnola glass.
Sarasota, Florida
- 1914 · p. 11
John Linton MyresCatalogued the collection ofLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Myres catalogued and described objects from the Cesnola collection in his Handbook.
No. Handbook, nos. 1 à 5985New York
- p. 15
Luigi Palma di CesnolaPhotographed
Cesnola photographed his collection in Cyprus and during attempts to sell it in London.
glass in his collectionCyprus and London
- p. 309
Federico CaròStudied
Federico Carò analyzed the obsidian object for the Metropolitan's Department of Scientific Research.
An obsidian furniture attachmentNo. C.G. 65
Posts and family 2
- 1999 · p. 6
Christopher S. LightfootEmployed byThe Metropolitan Museum of Art
Lightfoot joined the Museum as an associate curator in 1999.
- p. 14
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaSibling ofLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Scott-Stevenson identified Major Cesnola as the Consul's brother.
Larnaca
People it is cited for
6 people- Christopher S. Lightfoot3 citations
- H. Hamilton Jackson3 citations
- Augustus Henry Lane Fox Pitt Rivers2 citations
- Elizabeth J. Milleker2 citations
- Robin Symes
- Russian consul Yusefovich
Institutions it is cited for
6 institutions- Bryn Mawr College6 citations
- Cantor Arts Center4 citations
- Robin Symes Ltd2 citations
- National Museum of Ireland
- Stanford University
- Toledo Museum of Art
Mentioned in
53 mentionsTomb records · 47
- Amathus-Eastern Necropolis, Department of Antiquities Tomb 423
Discussion · 2017 · pp. 317, 346
One was also found with burial II, dated ca. 50 B.C.-A.D. 150, in tomb 423 at Amathus.
- Amathus-Western Necropolis, Department of Antiquities Tomb 631
Discussion · 2017 · p. 305
- Amathus-Western Necropolis, Loulloupis Tomb 515
Discussion · 2017 · p. 293
- Amathus, BM Tomb 108
Discussion · 2017 · p. 327
- Amathus, BM Tomb 114
Discussion · 2017 · p. 322
- Amathus, BM Tomb 136
Discussion · 2017 · pp. 42, 293
- On Ancient Cyprus · 2listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
- Excavations · 3listed under Excavations it is cited for
- Objects · 1listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.