Book · 1974

Middle Cypriot White Painted Pottery: An Analytical Study of the Decoration

D. Frankel

Göteborg: Paul Åströms Förlag

A study of the decoration on 1,386 Middle Cypriot White Painted vessels, using motif frequencies and statistical comparison to examine regional styles and contact across Cyprus.

Frankel analyses the painted decoration of Middle Cypriot White Painted pottery to see what it shows about relations between the regions of Cyprus. The study works from 1,386 vessels of known provenance, grouped by tomb, cemetery or site, and compares how often 81 motifs occur in each group, treating motif distributions as evidence for regional style and social contact.

How it is organised

Chapter 1 reviews Cypriot archaeological classification and chronology, sets out the analytical approach and discusses geographical and archaeological conditions. Chapter 2 presents the sample, the groups, the vessel shapes, eight geographical regions and the motif descriptions, and ends with a summary. Chapter 3 sets out the factor and cluster analyses, and chapter 4 discusses regional styles and contacts and draws conclusions. Appendix I lists the vessels in the sample, followed by Appendix II, an additional note, indexes, the bibliography, tables and figures.

The evidence

Material without known provenance is excluded, as are vessels whose decoration cannot be recognised from the available publication or condition. Motifs are described by their shape, filling and orientation and recorded against the vessel groups, with the shape classes adding descriptive context (pp. 15–20).

Frankel applies R-mode and Q-mode factor analysis to motif frequencies, and uses a Jaccard coefficient for presence-absence comparisons, with average-linkage and Ward hierarchical clustering for the relationships between groups. Standardised and unstandardised variables are compared, and figures and tables show the group correlations, motif distributions and regional patterns.

The argument

Frankel argues that decoration can be analysed as a fairly distinct attribute of pottery, whose variation may reflect spatial and social relationships as well as chronology. His method compares the frequency of motifs directly between assemblages, without first classifying individual pots into types. Similarity between groups is taken as a possible sign of social contact and kept apart from evidence for trade in specific vessels (pp. 4–8).

He describes overlapping regional styles and no simple division into two cultural areas. The Karpass shows frequent Wavy Line Style decoration, the Eastern sites linear motifs including Pendent Line and Cross Line styles, the central area small motifs arranged in complex horizontal bands, and Lapithos large, formally structured decoration with vertical panels and chequer patterns (p. 47).

Neighbouring sites relate more strongly in the analyses, and connections between areas also show in the distribution of motifs. Frankel discusses the central groups around Nicosia and Politico, the North Coast groups at Lapithos, Vounous and Palaealona, and the Eastern and Karpass groups. He suggests that copper exchange may have contributed to contact, and also considers the exchange of ideas and the movement of people as explanations for shared designs (pp. 48–51).

Dating

Frankel follows the Middle Cypriot classification and dating proposed by Åström. White Painted II Ware or associated pottery marks the beginning of the cultural stage, and the appearance of White-Slip and Base-Ring Wares marks its end. He describes the period boundary as gradual and the groups as hard to date precisely, because they often combine material from several burials.

Limits of the evidence

Frankel qualifies the interpretation on several points: group sizes are uneven, tomb assemblages may cover different lengths of time, the links between cemetery and settlement pottery are uncertain, and few stratified sequences exist. Small groups and rare designs can distort the statistical comparisons, so the results are read together with each group's composition and geographical setting (pp. 40–45).

What it records

  • The analytical sample consists of 1,386 vessels of White Painted Ware.p. 15
  • The sample leaves out about 500 vessels listed by Åström, mainly because their provenance is unknown.p. 15
  • Frankel describes 81 motifs but uses only the first 70 in the later analyses.p. 17
  • The eight geographical areas are specific to this study and are not intended as cultural divisions.p. 19
  • The sample is organised into 47 defined groups representing 33 sites.p. 30
  • The Karpass is the most distinct region in Frankel's analysis, with a high frequency of Wavy Line Style decoration.p. 47
  • Frankel characterises decoration in the central island by small motifs arranged in horizontal bands.p. 47
  • Frankel argues that most variation in the White Painted tradition reflects geographical and cultural factors rather than temporal ones.p. 51
  • Frankel considers the Middle Cypriot period probably no longer than 200 years.p. 51
  • Appendix II lists motif occurrences by group and shape and gives totals and percentages.p. 79
  • Frankel says he examined Swedish Cyprus Expedition excavation collections in Stockholm after the book went to press.p. 92

Where to read

  • Sample composition, group definitions and dating limitationspp. 15–16
  • Definitions of vessel shapes and the eight geographical regionspp. 18–19
  • Motif descriptions and distribution across groupspp. 20–30
  • Factor and cluster analyses of pottery groupspp. 33–45
  • Regional styles and proposed patterns of contactpp. 47–51
  • Kotchati pottery and relationships with North Coast, central and eastern groupspp. 48–49
  • Sample vessel listings and group composition in Appendix Ipp. 53–91
  • Motif occurrences by group and shape in Appendix IIpp. 79–91

Contents

  • Chapter 1: Introduction to the Study1
  • 1.1. The Historical and Theoretical Background1
  • 1.2. Geographical and Archaeological Considerations9
  • Chapter 2: The Material and Its Context15
  • 2.1. The Pottery and the Groups15
  • 2.2. Decoration and the Design Motifs16
  • 2.3. Group Size and Motif Occurrence17
  • 2.4. The Shapes18
  • 2.5. The Regions19
  • 2.6. The Motifs and their Distribution20
  • 2.7. Summary30
  • Chapter 3: Computer Analyses33
  • 3.1. Factor Analysis33
  • 3.2. The R-Mode Principal Components Analysis34
  • 3.3 The Q-mode Analysis38
  • 3.4 Factor Analysis: Summary39
  • 3.5 Cluster Analysis40
  • 3.6 Q-mode Clusters using a presence-absence Similarity Coefficient40
  • 3.7 Q-mode clusters using proportional occurrence42
  • 3.8 Hierarchical Cluster Analysis – Variables not Standardised42
  • 3.9 Hierarchical Cluster Analysis – Variables Standardised43
  • 3.10 Close Proximity Analysis based on proportional occurrence44
  • 3.11 R-mode clusters44
  • 3.12 Cluster Analysis – Discussion and Summary44
  • Chapter 4: Discussion and Conclusions47
  • Appendix I53
  • Appendix II79
  • Additional Note92
  • Index 1: Sites and Groups93
  • Index 2: Concordance and Index to Museum Inventory Numbers95
  • Index 3: Individual Vessels99
  • Bibliography100

Objects published here

5
  • Cup decorated with horizontal chequer and cross-hatched bands, Cyprus Museum, Kotchati, CM 1970/X-7/17, figure 19a (p. 48)
  • Vessel with Cross-Line Style decoration, Cyprus Museum, Kotchati, CM 1970/X-7/12, figure 19c (p. 48)
  • Vessel within the Central tradition, Cyprus Museum, Kotchati, CM 1970/X-7/10, figure 19d (p. 49)
  • Small jug with lattice-diamond decoration, Cyprus Museum, Chomazoudhia, CM A715 (p. 24)
  • Jug with painted animal design, Ayios Iakovos, Ayios Iakovos T.6.1 (p. 29)

People, places and institutions

People

  • H.W. Catlingassociated with Survey and Ashmolean material
  • J.R. Stewartexcavation material used in the study
  • Paul Åströmclassification followed and used for comparison
  • Einar Gjerstadexcavated stratified Bronze Age sites
  • di Cesnolanineteenth-century excavator
  • Myresdeveloped pottery seriation
  • Flinders Petriedeveloped Sequence Dating
  • Arthur Evansformulated the Minoan period divisions
  • P. Dikaiosworked on pottery typology
  • Merrilleescriticised ware classification
  • L.R. Binfordframework for cultural variation
  • Dunnellset conditions for seriation
  • Christodouloupublished a cultural geography of Cyprus

Institutions

Places

  • Lapithoslarge cemetery sample and regional style
  • Nicosiacentral group and stylistic focus
  • Politicocentral style and contact group
  • Kotchatipottery group and contact case study
  • Karpassdistinctive regional pottery style
  • VounousNorth Coast group and style antecedent
  • PalaealonaNorth Coast group and style antecedent
  • Ayios IakovosKarpass pottery group
  • Ayia Paraskevicemetery sample group
  • DhaliSouthern River Valleys group
  • DheniaWestern group with Lapithos contact
  • EnkomiEastern site and pottery group
  • Kalopsidhastratified site and pottery group
  • KythreaSouthern Foothills group
  • Larnacaregional pottery group
  • DhikomoSouthern Foothills group and route link
  • MiliaEastern pottery group
  • YeriSouthern River Valleys group
  • Vasiliapass across the Kyrenia Range
  • Troodos Mountainscopper-source region
  • MyrtouWestern pottery group
  • Chomazoudhiafindspot of Politico-area pottery
  • GalinoporniKarpass pottery group

Also named: Department of Antiquities, Cyprus.

Extent viii + 106 pp., 9 tables, 19 figs; indexes pp. 93–99; bibliography pp. 100–106

Defines Jug, Juglet, Cup, Bowl, Amphora, Jar, Tankard, Flask, Bottle

Middle Bronze AgeEarly Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgePotteryChronology and DatingTradeCraft Production

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

3 pages · 5 objects

Excavations it is cited for

4 projects

Who did what

25 records

Buying, selling and giving 1

Excavation 6

  • Einar Nilson GjerstadExcavated

    Einar Gjerstad carried out stratigraphic excavations at three Bronze Age sites.

    stratified depositsAlambra, Kalopsidha, Nikolidhes

    p. 2
  • John Linton MyresExcavated

    Myres excavated at Ayia Paraskevi.

    material from the cemetery

    1894 · p. 67
  • James Rivers Barrington StewartDug forMelbourne Cyprus Expedition

    Stewart excavated a tomb at Karmi for the Melbourne Cyprus Expedition in 1960.

    1955–1960 · p. 67
  • John Linton MyresExcavated

    Myres excavated at Larnaca Laxis tou Riou.

    1894 · p. 72
  • Basil HennessyExcavated

    Hennessy excavated tombs 10 and 13 at Myrtou Stephania.

    5 vessels from tombs 10 and 13

    1951 · p. 76
  • John Franklin DanielExcavated

    J. F. Daniel and others excavated a large portion of the Kaloriziki necropolis.

    the necropolis of KalorizikiKaloriziki, southwest Cyprus

Recording and study 18

  • David FrankelStudied

    D. Frankel examined collections from the Swedish Cyprus Expedition excavations housed in the Museum of Mediterranean and Near Eastern Antiquities in Stockholm.

    p. 92
  • H. E. J. BiggsPublished

    H. E. J. Biggs wrote an appendix on mollusca.

    Kalopsidha and Ayios Iakovos

    p. 141
  • Hans HelbaekPublished

    H. Helbaek wrote an appendix on imprints of grain.

    Kalopsidha and Ayios Iakovos

    p. 141
  • Mervyn PophamPublished

    M. R. Popham wrote an appendix on White Slip Ware.

    Kalopsidha and Ayios Iakovos

    p. 141
  • N. G. GejvallPublished

    N.-G. Gejvall wrote an appendix on the osteological material.

    Kalopsidha and Ayios Iakovos

    p. 141
  • Olivier MassonPublished

    O. Masson wrote an appendix on Cypro-Minoan inscriptions.

    Kalopsidha and Ayios Iakovos

    p. 141
  • Robert Stuart MerrilleesPublished

    R. S. Merrillees wrote an appendix on an Early Cypriote tomb group.

    Kalopsidha and Ayios Iakovos

    p. 141
  • S. BottemaPublished

    S. Bottema wrote an appendix on pollen analyses.

    Kalopsidha and Ayios Iakovos

    p. 141
  • Sven A. ErikssonPublished

    S. A. Eriksson wrote an appendix on fingerprints.

    Kalopsidha and Ayios Iakovos

    p. 141
  • T. F. WatkinsPublished

    T. Watkins wrote an appendix on the bronzes.

    Kalopsidha and Ayios Iakovos

    p. 141
  • T. WieselgrenPublished

    T. Wieselgren wrote an appendix on Iron Age sherds.

    Kalopsidha and Ayios Iakovos

    p. 141
  • James Rivers Barrington StewartPublished material ofSwedish Cyprus Expedition

    J. R. Stewart based his corpus partly on excavations of the Swedish Cyprus Expedition.

    Early Cypriote pottery and other arts and crafts

    p. 142
  • Jack L. BensonPublished material ofJohn Franklin Daniel

    Benson published the findings of Daniel’s excavations at Bamboula and Kaloriziki.

    findings from excavations at Bamboula and Kaloriziki

    1969–1973
  • David FrankelStudied

    David Frankel examined some 1500 White Painted vessels for his study.

    Cyprus, England, and Australia

  • Edith PoradaPublished

    Edith Porada contributed a section on glyptics to the volume.

    glyptics from the Kaloriziki necropolisKaloriziki, southwest Cyprus

Show 3 more
  • Jack L. BensonCatalogued

    J. L. Benson prepared a catalogue categorizing over 1100 objects from the necropolis.

    over 1100 objects from the Kaloriziki necropolisKaloriziki, southwest Cyprus

  • Paola VillaCatalogued

    Paola Villa published a catalogue of Early and Middle Bronze Age pottery from the Cesnola Collection.

    Early and Middle Bronze Age pottery of the Cesnola CollectionStanford University Museum

  • T. B. L. WebsterCatalogued

    T. B. L. Webster used and modified J. Roger Davis's catalogue of Cesnola Collection terracottas.

    446 terracotta figurines from the Cesnola CollectionStanford University Museum

Institutions it is cited for

1 institution

Mentioned in

88 mentions

Tomb records · 76

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.