Edited volume · 2010
The Development of Pre-State Communities in the Ancient Near East: Studies in Honour of Edgar Peltenburg
D. Bolger and L. C. Maguire (eds.)
Oxford: Oxbow Books
A collection of 24 papers on pre-state communities in Anatolia, Cyprus, the Levant and Mesopotamia, in honour of Edgar Peltenburg, grouped in five thematic parts.
Bolger and Maguire bring together papers on pre-state communities in Anatolia, Cyprus, the Levant and Mesopotamia, written in honour of Edgar Peltenburg. The introduction frames the essays around diversity, scale and context, and presents the volume as a challenge to unilinear models of social change. The papers are grouped by the questions they ask rather than by region or period. Cypriot studies of pottery, burial and settlement appear alongside work on sites in Syria, Mesopotamia, Iran and Anatolia.
How it is organised
An introduction by the editors leads into five thematic parts. Part One, Social Organisation and Complexity in Pre-state Communities, has Marc Verhoeven on social complexity and archaeology, Peter M. M. G. Akkermans on round houses in the northern Levant c. 6500–6000 BC, Demetra Papaconstantinou on Abandonment Processes and Closure Ceremonies in Prehistoric Cyprus, David Frankel on A Different Chalcolithic: A Central Cypriot Scene, and Hermann Genz on ‘public buildings’ in the Early Bronze Age southern Levant (pp. 9–55).
Part Two, Early Urban Communities and the Emergence of the State, opens with Tony Wilkinson on The Tell: Social Archaeology and Territorial Space, followed by Lindy Crewe on Rethinking Kalopsidha: From Specialisation to State Marginalisation, Anne Porter on From Kin to Class – and Back Again! Changing Paradigms of the Early Polity, Marcella Frangipane on the structuring of power at the rise of hierarchical societies, and Lisa Cooper on States of Hegemony: Early Forms of Political Control in Syria during the Third Millennium BC (pp. 56–94).
Part Three, Technology, Economy and Society, contains Olivier Nieuwenhuyse on pottery production in the Burnt Village at Late Neolithic Tell Sabi Abyad, Louise Steel on Late Cypriot Ceramic Production: Heterarchy or Hierarchy?, Gordon Thomas on early lime plaster technology in the Levant, Danielle Stordeur on Domestication of Plants and Animals, Domestication of Symbols?, and Paul Croft on animal remains from the 1969–1970 seasons at Philia-Drakos Site A (pp. 95–138).
Part Four, Agency, Identity and Gender, has Bill Finlayson on agency in the Pre-Pottery Neolithic A, Stuart Campbell on the painted pottery of prehistoric northern Mesopotamia, Diane Bolger on Gender and Social Complexity in Prehistoric and Protohistoric Cyprus, Louise C. Maguire on The Painting Process of White Painted and White Slip Wares: Communities of Practice, and Jennifer M. Webb on The Ceramic Industry of Deneia: Crafting Community and Place in Middle Bronze Age Cyprus (pp. 139–182).
Part Five, Insularity, Ethnicity and Cultural Interaction, has Carole McCartney on Outside the Corridor? The Neolithisation of Cyprus, Joanne Clarke on connections between Cyprus and the Near East in the later Neolithic, Douglas Baird on Was Catalhoyuk a Centre?, and Andrew McCarthy on The Birth of Ethnicity in Iran (pp. 183–224).
The papers
For the Neolithic and Chalcolithic of Cyprus, Papaconstantinou studies house abandonment and floor assemblages at Ayios Epiktitos-Vrysi, and Frankel builds a central Cypriot Chalcolithic picture from Politiko-Kokkinorotsos, with comparison to Kissonerga-Mosphilia and Lemba-Lakkous. Croft sets the Philia-Drakos animal bones beside those of Vrysi and Paralimni-Nissia. McCartney's Neolithisation paper runs through Mylouthkia, Shillourokambos, Tenta, Khirokitia, Asprokremnos and Ais Yiorkis and defines the phases Cypro-EPPNB, Cypro-MPPNB, Cypro-LPPNB and Khirokitian. Clarke looks at the later Neolithic, with incised stones and obsidian at Kalavasos-Kokkinoyia and pottery parallels with Arjoune in central Syria (pp. 31–45, 131–136, 183–206).
For the Bronze Age, Crewe follows pottery and imports at Kalopsidha and the site's changing role beside Enkomi. Steel discusses Late Cypriot pottery production with reference to Kalavasos-Ayios Dhimitrios and the Kalavasos region, Base Ring production at Phaneromeni and a proposed production centre for WPWM III at Kition. Maguire's paper treats the positions and sequences of painting on White Painted and White Slip wares, with a White Painted V amphora from Boghaz and a Fine Line Style jug from Kythrea as examples. Bolger's paper on gender takes in Late Cypriot burial at Kalavasos-Ayios Dhimitrios and Iron Age cemeteries at Kouklia-Skales and Kourion-Kaloriziki. Webb's paper concerns the Deneia tombs, their Red Polished forms and the local ceramic identity they show, with parallels at Lapithos (pp. 65–70, 106–116, 155–180).
The remaining papers range beyond Cyprus. Cooper examines Eblaite influence along the Middle Euphrates against the rival power of Mari and the elite burials at Tell Banat. Thomas takes up lime plaster at Hayonim Cave and ‘Ain Mallaha, and Stordeur symbols and figurines from Jerf el Ahmar, Tell Aswad and ‘Ain Ghazal. Campbell's examples of Halaf pottery decoration come from Domuztepe and Arpachiyah. Baird compares a late Aceramic Neolithic assemblage from Sancak, a survey site on the Konya Plain, with Çatalhöyük, and McCarthy writes on the birth of ethnicity in Iran, with cylinder-seal craft traditions at Susa (pp. 88–105, 117–128, 146–155, 205–222).
What it records
- Bolger and Maguire group the contributions by the issues they address, in five thematic parts.p. 4
- Occupation at Politiko-Kokkinorotsos falls between about 2880 and 2670 cal BCE on 12 AMS dates, as Frankel reports.p. 5
- Maguire's study of White Painted ware reconstructs the painting process from brushstroke sequences on more than 200 vessels, as the introduction describes it.p. 6
- Frankel interprets Politiko-Kokkinorotsos as a hunters' camp, perhaps used seasonally for woodland forays and processing animal products.p. 42
- Trench 3 and Gjerstad's house at Kalopsidha yielded at least 26 imported Canaanite jars, Crewe records.p. 68
- Cooper argues that Ebla's political hold over the Euphrates Valley was loose and transitory.p. 92
- Nieuwenhuyse reports that 400–670 people may have relied on the Level 6 Burnt Village at Tell Sabi Abyad, with perhaps 120 residents permanently settled there.p. 99
- Fallow deer make up 66.5% of the identified mammalian remains in the Philia-Drakos Site A assemblage, Croft records.p. 132
- Croft estimates that deer supplied 82% of the meat at Philia-Drakos, with caprines supplying 8% and pig 10%.p. 135
- Webb reports 1,286 documented tombs at Deneia-Kafkalla and Mali, and estimates that the original number was two to three times higher.p. 175
- Webb argues that Deneia's community-wide pottery style helped integrate recently nucleated groups and distinguish them from their neighbours.p. 179
- McCartney's chronology places the Cypro-EPPNB between 8400 and 7900 BCE and the Cypro-LPPNB between 7500 and 6400 BCE.p. 189
- Obsidian makes up 98% of the chipped-stone assemblage from Sancak.p. 210
Where to read
- Volume framework and chapter summariespp. 4–7
- House abandonment and floor assemblages at Ayios Epiktitos-Vrysipp. 31–36
- Politiko-Kokkinorotsos evidence and proposed hunting-camp functionpp. 39–44
- Kalopsidha pottery, imports and changing role relative to Enkomipp. 65–70
- Philia-Drakos, Vrysi and Nissia faunal comparisonspp. 131–136
- White Painted and White Slip painting positions and sequencespp. 164–173
- Deneia tombs, Red Polished forms and local ceramic identitypp. 175–180
- Cypriot Neolithisation and evidence for mainland connectionspp. 183–206
Contents
- Introduction: The Development of Pre-state Communities in the Ancient Near EastDiane Bolger, Louise C. Maguire1
- Part One: Social Organisation and Complexity in Pre-state Communities9
- Social Complexity and Archaeology: A Contextual ApproachMarc Verhoeven12
- Late Neolithic Architectural Renewal: The Emergence of Round Houses in the Northern Levant, c. 6500–6000 BCPeter M. M. G. Akkermans24
- Abandonment Processes and Closure Ceremonies in Prehistoric Cyprus: In Search of RitualDemetra Papaconstantinou31
- A Different Chalcolithic: A Central Cypriot SceneDavid Frankel39
- Thoughts on the Function of ‘Public Buildings’ in the Early Bronze Age Southern LevantHermann Genz47
- Part Two: Early Urban Communities and the Emergence of the State53
- The Tell: Social Archaeology and Territorial SpaceTony Wilkinson56
- Rethinking Kalopsidha: From Specialisation to State MarginalisationLindy Crewe65
- From Kin to Class – and Back Again! Changing Paradigms of the Early PolityAnne Porter73
- Different Models of Power Structuring at the Rise of Hierarchical Societies in the Near East: Primary Economy versus Luxury and Defence ManagementMarcella Frangipane80
- States of Hegemony: Early Forms of Political Control in Syria during the Third Millennium BCLisa Cooper88
- Part Three: Technology, Economy and Society95
- A Household Affair? Pottery Production in the Burnt Village at Late Neolithic Tell Sabi AbyadOlivier Nieuwenhuyse95
- Late Cypriot Ceramic Production: Heterarchy or Hierarchy?Louise Steel106
- The Domestication of Stone: Early Lime Plaster Technology in the LevantGordon Thomas117
- Domestication of Plants and Animals, Domestication of Symbols?Danielle Stordeur123
- Herds Lost in Time: Animal Remains from the 1969–1970 Excavation Seasons at the Ceramic Neolithic Settlement of Philia-Drakos Site A, CyprusPaul Croft131
- Part Four: Agency, Identity and Gender
- Agency in the Pre-Pottery Neolithic ABill Finlayson140
- Understanding Symbols: Putting Meaning into the Painted Pottery of Prehistoric Northern MesopotamiaStuart Campbell146
- Gender and Social Complexity in Prehistoric and Protohistoric CyprusDiane Bolger155
- The Painting Process of White Painted and White Slip Wares: Communities of PracticeLouise C. Maguire164
- The Ceramic Industry of Deneia: Crafting Community and Place in Middle Bronze Age CyprusJennifer M. Webb173
- Part Five: Insularity, Ethnicity and Cultural Interaction183
- Outside the Corridor? The Neolithisation of CyprusCarole McCartney183
- Contextualising Neolithic Cyprus: Preliminary Investigations into Connections between Cyprus and the Near East in the Later NeolithicJoanne Clarke195
- Was Catalhoyuk a Centre? The Implications of a Late Aceramic Neolithic Assemblage from the Neighbourhood of CatalhoyukDouglas Baird205
- The Birth of Ethnicity in Iran: Mesopotamian-Elamite Cross-Cultural Relations in Late PrehistoryAndrew McCarthy215
Objects published here
2- White Painted V amphora from Boghaz, University of New England, Boghaz, 74/13/1, Fig. 20.1 (p. 167)
- White Painted V Fine Line Style vessel from Kythrea Tomb 1, Cyprus Museum, Kythrea Tomb 1, A710, Fig. 20.2 (p. 169)
People, places and institutions
People
- Eddie PeltenburgHonouree of the volume
Places
- DeneiaMiddle Bronze Age cemetery and pottery assemblage
- ÇatalhöyükNeolithic community compared with Sancak
- SancakKonya Plain survey site with a lithic assemblage
- SusaSite of cylinder-seal craft traditions
- Politiko-KokkinorotsosChalcolithic site and proposed hunting camp
- KalopsidhaBronze Age settlement and pottery production centre
- EnkomiCoastal centre in the discussion of Kalopsidha
- Deneia-KafkallaCemetery in the Deneia complex
- MaliCemetery in the Deneia complex
- Ayios Epiktitos-VrysiLate Neolithic settlement studied for house abandonment
- Tell Sabi AbyadLate Neolithic pottery production case study
- Philia-Drakos Site ACeramic Neolithic animal bone assemblage
- Paralimni-NissiaCeramic Neolithic animal bone comparison
- EblaState and centre of hegemony
- MariRival regional power to Ebla
- Euphrates ValleyRegion examined for Eblaite influence
- Tell BanatEuphrates settlement with elite burials
- Göbekli TepeNeolithic example of ritual imagery
- Kissonerga-MosphiliaChalcolithic site used for comparison
- Lemba-LakkousChalcolithic settlement used for comparison
- Kalavasos-Ayios DhimitriosLate Cypriot pottery and burial comparison
- Kouklia-SkalesIron Age cemetery with burial evidence
- Kourion-KalorizikiIron Age cemetery with Tomb 40
- Gastri-AlaasLate Cypriot III cemetery evidence
- BoghazFindspot of a White Painted V amphora
- KythreaFindspot of a Fine Line Style jug
- LapithosSource of ceramic parallels for Deneia
- KalavasosLate Cypriot pottery production region
- ShillourokambosNeolithic settlement sequence
- Kissonerga-MylouthkiaNeolithic wells and contact evidence
- Kalavasos-TentaNeolithic settlement sequence and architecture
- Khirokitia-VounoiNeolithic settlement with mainland connections
- Ayia Varvara-AsprokremnosEarly Neolithic forager site
- Kritou Marottou-Ais YiorkisNeolithic site with grain storage
- Kalavasos-KokkinoyiaLate Neolithic incised stones and obsidian
- ArjouneCentral Syrian source of pottery parallels
- Jerf el AhmarPre-Pottery Neolithic A symbols and burials
- Tell AswadPre-Pottery Neolithic B figurines and modelled skulls
- ‘Ain GhazalPre-Pottery Neolithic B figurines and plaster statues
- Hayonim CaveNatufian lime plaster evidence
- ‘Ain MallahaNatufian settlement architecture
- DomuztepeHalaf naturalistic pottery decoration
- ArpachiyahHalaf pottery with bucrania motifs
Also named: Phaneromeni, Kition.
Defines social complexity, heterarchy, White Painted Ware, Cypro-EPPNB, Cypro-MPPNB, Cypro-LPPNB, Khirokitian, communities of practice, Piedmont Jemdet Nasr style, Mesopotamian Jemdet Nasr style
NeolithicChalcolithicEarly Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricPotterySettlementsChronology and DatingBurialForeign Contacts
Chapters in our registers
1 in our registersCited on Ancient Cyprus
3 pages · 7 objects- Painted Again in the Middle CypriotArticle
- The Red Polished WorldArticle
- DheniaSite
Objects
Black Polished Juglet with Incised Decoration and Circled BossesLarge Red Polished Jug with Horned Handle and Pierced LugRed Polished Beak-Spouted Juglet with Incised CirclesRed Polished Jug with Concentric Circles and Line PanelsRed Polished Jug with Concentric Circles and a Squared Side-SpoutRed Polished One-Handled Jar with Concentric Circles, Deneia StyleRed Polished Spouted Jug with Relief Bands and a Snake
Excavations it is cited for
5 projects- 1923–1924Alambra and Kalopsidha: Gjerstad's Bronze Age soundings (1923–1924)Directed by Einar Nilson GjerstadExcavation
- 1959Kalopsidha: the Swedish stratigraphic campaign of 1959Directed by Paul ÅströmSounding
- 1965–1970Philia-Drakos: the Edinburgh excavationsDirected by Trevor WatkinsExcavation
- 1969–1973Ayios Epiktitos-Vrysi: the Birmingham and Glasgow expeditionDirected by Edgar J. Peltenburg and P. S. GellingExcavation
- 2006–2007Politiko-Kokkinorotsos: Frankel and Webb's excavationDirected by David Frankel and Jennifer M. WebbExcavation
Who did what
19 recordsExcavation 6
- 1990–2007 · p. 5
David FrankelExcavated withJennifer M. Webb
David Frankel and Jennifer M. Webb undertook test excavations together at Politiko Kokkinorotsos.
- 1965–1970 · p. 16
T. F. WatkinsExcavated
Trevor Watkins excavated the Ceramic Neolithic settlement at Philia-Drakos.
Philia-Drakos settlement
- 1967 · p. 16
Edgar J. PeltenburgExcavated
Eddie Peltenburg assisted at the Philia-Drakos excavation.
- 1969–1973 · p. 16
Edgar J. PeltenburgRecorded
Eddie Peltenburg's field projects began with excavations at Ayios Epiktitos-Vrysi.
- 1924 · p. 65
- 1959 · p. 65
Paul ÅströmExcavated
Paul Åström's excavation opened trenches 1–5 at Kalopsidha on 24 August 1959.
Recording and study 13
- 1926 · p. 8
Einar Nilson GjerstadPublished
Einar Gjerstad published the excavated Bronze Age house at Kalopsidha.
- 1968 · p. 16
Paul CroftStudied
Paul Croft examined some of the bone recovered at Philia-Drakos during the 1968 season.
- 2008 · p. 16
Paul CroftStudied
Paul Croft began systematically examining and documenting the Philia-Drakos animal-remains assemblage.
- p. 18
Stuart CampbellWorked withEdgar J. Peltenburg
Stuart Campbell worked on projects with Eddie Peltenburg in Cyprus and Syria.
- 1991 · p. 20
Louise MaguireStudent ofEdgar J. Peltenburg
Louise Maguire completed her doctoral thesis under Eddie Peltenburg’s supervision.
Middle Cypriot Bronze Age pottery in Tell el-Dab’a and the LevantTell el-Dab’a and the Levant
- p. 21
Jennifer M. WebbStudied
Jennifer M. Webb examined the ceramic industry of Deneia and its social context.
- p. 31
Demetra PapaconstantinouStudied
Demetra Papaconstantinou re-examined material from a Late Neolithic site, focusing on the abandonment of its structures.
material and abandonment of structuresAyios Epiktitos-Vrysi
- p. 39
- p. 41
Carole McCartneyStudied
Carole McCartney analysed the chipped stone assemblage from Politiko-Kokkinorotsos.
5,704 chipped stone artefacts
- 1894 · p. 65
John Linton MyresStudied
J. L. Myres first investigated the tombs and settlement remains at Kalopsidha.
- 1966 · p. 65
Paul ÅströmPublished
Paul Åström published a summary of his excavations and earlier work at Kalopsidha.
Kalopsidha excavation results
- p. 134
A. LeggeStudied
A. J. Legge examined the taxonomic composition of faunal samples from Vrysi by context type.
faunal samples from Ayios Epiktitos-VrysiAyios Epiktitos-Vrysi
- p. 220
Andrew McCarthyStudied
Andrew McCarthy compared Mittanian style seals from Enkomi and Alalakh using T-tests.
Mentioned in
48 mentionsTomb records · 33
- Ayia Irini-Palaeokastro, Ismea Tomb 21
Discussion · 2010 · p. 171
- Ayios Iakovos-Melia, SCE Tomb 8
Discussion · 2010 · p. 160
- Deneia-Kafkalla, Astrom Tomb 6
Discussion · 2010 · p. 178
- Deneia-Kafkalla, Latrobe Tomb 782
Discussion · 2010 · p. 177
- Deneia-Kafkalla, Latrobe Tomb 789
Discussion · 2010 · pp. 177, 178
- Deneia-Kafkalla, Nicolaou Tomb 48
Discussion · 2010 · p. 176
- On Ancient Cyprus · 3listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
- Excavations · 5listed under Excavations it is cited for
- Objects · 7listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.