Article · 2017
Cypriot Antiquities from the Cesnola Collections in the Nicholson Museum at the University of Sydney
Craig Barker and Robert S. Merrillees
Mediterranean Archaeology 30 51-71
An article on how Cypriot antiquities from the Cesnola collections reached the Nicholson Museum at the University of Sydney by purchase, exchange and loan, and on identifying the pieces.
Barker and Merrillees trace how antiquities formerly associated with Luigi and Alessandro Palma di Cesnola entered the Nicholson Museum: through a purchase from the Metropolitan Museum of Art in 1927, an exchange with Stanford University in 1953 and material transferred through Cambridge in 1947. Their sources are the letters between W. J. Woodhouse, the Metropolitan Museum and intermediaries, a 1927 purchase list, accession records, ink and pencil markings, labels, photographs and museum handbook illustrations, together with the Cambridge loan list and the Ransom collection numbers on Cypriot objects.
They argue that the 1927 purchase comprised 24 items, one beyond the surviving list of 23, and that the accessioning of some pieces was delayed or confused with the Cambridge Loan. A further group linked to Alessandro Palma di Cesnola through the Ransom collection and the Cambridge transfer is listed by accession number, with some attributions and provenances stated to remain uncertain (pp. 65–71).
The objects range from the Early and Middle Bronze Age through the Late Bronze Age, Cypro-Geometric and Cypro-Archaic periods to Roman glass, and the authors keep labels such as Red Polished III, White Painted III, Late Cypriot II and Cypro-Geometric III for individual pieces.
What it records
- The Nicholson Museum holds at least 29 artefacts that the authors trace to the Cesnola brothers' original collections.p. 52
- In January 1927 Gisela M. A. Richter offered 23 Cypriot objects for $342, charging the University of Sydney $290.70 after a discount for public institutions.p. 58
- The 1927 purchase list describes a large two-handled jug as red polished ware, priced at $40.p. 59
- Barker and Merrillees identify NM48.277, a flask with a pinched rib, as the ribbed Roman glass vessel in the 1927 purchase.p. 62
- Leland Stanford bought part of Luigi Palma di Cesnola's Cypriot collection from the Metropolitan Museum of Art in 1896.p. 67
- The Nicholson Museum files hold a four-page list of Cypriot pottery on loan from Cambridge, which names 195 objects in total.p. 68
- Barker and Merrillees identify at least 29 items from the Luigi Palma di Cesnola Collection in Sydney, 24 from the 1927 purchase and five from the 1953 exchange.p. 71
- Barker and Merrillees attribute at least 28 Nicholson Museum items to Alessandro Palma di Cesnola's holdings and their 1947 transfer via Cambridge.p. 71
Where to read
- Woodhouse’s 1926–27 correspondence and the purchase listpp. 56–60
- Identification of the 1927 objects and accession markingspp. 61–66
- The Stanford exchange and Cambridge loan provenancespp. 67–70
Contents
- Introduction51
- Luigi and Alessandro Palma di Cesnola52
- The Nicholson Museum and Its Cypriot Collection53
- The Cesnola Purchase of 192755
- Correspondence Relating to the Purchase56
- Identifying the Cypriot Antiquities Purchased in 192761
- Glass62
- Pottery62
- Early Bronze Age62
- Middle Bronze Age63
- Late Bronze Age64
- Early Iron Age64
- Stone Sculpture65
- Other Cesnola Material in the Nicholson Collection66
- The Stanford University Exchange of 195367
- The Cambridge Loan of 194767
- Conclusion70
Objects published here
7- Roman glass flask with pinched rib, Nicholson Museum, Cyprus, NM48.277, pl. 15: 2 (p. 62)
- Red Polished III amphora, Nicholson Museum, Cyprus, NM48.270, pl. 16: 2 (p. 62)
- Bichrome IV juglet with bird decoration, Nicholson Museum, Cyprus, NM48.263, pl. 24: 2 (p. 65)
- Small white limestone head of a male figure, Nicholson Museum, Cyprus, NM47.391, pl. 27:1 (p. 65)
- Mycenaean IIIA:2 Ware pithoid jar, Nicholson Museum, Alambra (reported), NM53.21, pl. 30: 1 (p. 67)
- Bichrome III shallow bowl, Nicholson Museum, Cyprus, NM47.291 (p. 69)
- White Painted II–III deep bowl, Nicholson Museum, Cyprus, NM48.268, pl. 25: 2 (p. 66)
People, places and institutions
People
- Luigi Palma di Cesnolacollected Cypriot antiquities
- Alessandro Palma di Cesnolacollected Cypriot antiquities
- Sir Charles Nicholsonfounded the museum through a benefaction
- W. J. Woodhousearranged the 1927 purchase
- A. D. Trendallcurator during the Cambridge loan
- J. R. B. Stewartbuilt the post-war Cypriot collection
- Arthur Stanley Riggsreferred Woodhouse to the Metropolitan Museum
- Ruth H. Gebhardwrote about the museum sale
- Gisela M. A. Richterselected objects for the 1927 purchase
- A. W. Lawrencearranged the Cambridge transfer
- Leland Stanfordpurchased Cesnola material in 1896
- Frank Ransomdonated the Ransom collection
- William Ransomcollector of antiquities
- J. Webbcatalogued Nicholson Museum Cypriot material
Institutions
- Nicholson Museumholds the Cypriot material discussed
- University of Sydneyrecipient of the 1927 purchase
- Metropolitan Museum of Artsold Cesnola material to Sydney
- Stanford Universitysource of the 1953 exchange
- University of Cambridgesource of the 1947 loan
- Fitzwilliam Museumone source of the Cambridge loan
- Museum of Archaeology and Anthropologyreceived the Ransom collection
Places
- Alambrareported provenance of five exchanged vessels
Also named: H. W. Kent, C. A. Lawler, Museum of Classical Archaeology, Kourion, Larnaca, Soli, Paphos, Salamis.
Extent pp. 51–71, pls 15–32
ModernEarly Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicCypro-ClassicalHellenisticRomanCollectingMuseumsPotteryGlass and FaienceSculpture
Excavations it is cited for
2 projects- 1874–1875Kourion: Luigi Palma di Cesnola's excavationsDirected by Luigi Palma di CesnolaClearance and early digging
- 1876–1879Salamis and Enkomi: Alessandro Palma di Cesnola's excavationsDirected by Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola and Lazaris Philippi (supervisor on Cesnola's behalf)Clearance and early digging
Who did what
17 recordsBuying, selling and giving 10
- 1870–1876 · p. 51
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toMetropolitan Museum of Art
Cesnola agreed to sell his collection to the Metropolitan Museum for £1,200.
£1,200New York
- 1898 · p. 53
Sir Charles NicholsonGave toNicholson Museum
The jar appears to have been presented by Sir Charles Nicholson sometime after his initial bequest and before 1898.
Mycenaean IIIC:1 squat jarNo. NM98.02
- p. 53
Luigi Palma di CesnolaExported
The article reported that Luigi Palma di Cesnola subsequently removed the recovered antiquities from Cyprus.
35,573 antiquities
- p. 55
James Rivers Barrington StewartGave toNicholson Museum
Stewart donated items from his own collection to the Nicholson Museum.
Sydney
- 1926 · p. 56
William John WoodhouseCorresponded withArthur Stanley Riggs
Woodhouse wrote to Riggs about buying antiquities for the Nicholson Museum.
antiquities for purchase
- 1927 · p. 58
William John WoodhouseBought fromMetropolitan Museum of Art
Woodhouse purchased 23 Cypriote objects from the Metropolitan Museum of Art for the Nicholson Museum.
23 Cypriote objects, including glass, sculpture, vases and terracottas$290.70—the equivalent of £60
- 1885–1896 · p. 67
Leland StanfordBought fromMetropolitan Museum of Art
Leland Stanford bought duplicates from the Cesnola collection in a private sale.
- p. 67
Arthur Dale TrendallWorked withA. W. Lawrence
Trendall arranged with Lawrence for Cypriot material to be transferred to the Nicholson Museum on permanent loan.
a collection of Cypriot material on permanent loanCambridge to Sydney
- 1923 · p. 68
Frank RansomGave toMuseum of Archaeology and Anthropology
Frank Ransom presented antiquities and money for display cases to the Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology.
Cypriot and British antiquities250 pounds for the purchase of casesCambridge
- p. 68
William RansomBought
probablyOne of the two Ransoms, probably William, purchased Cypriot items from a Lawrence-Cesnola sale.
With Lawrence-Cesnola sale
Excavation 2
- 1865–1877 · p. 52
Luigi Palma di CesnolaExcavated
Luigi Palma di Cesnola carried out extensive excavations at several Cypriot sites while serving in Larnaca.
antiquities at sites including Kourion, Larnaca, Soli and PaphosKourion, Larnaca, Soli and Paphos
- 1876 · p. 52
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaExcavated
Alessandro Palma di Cesnola resumed large-scale clearing of ancient tombs and sites, especially around Salamis, in 1876.
especially the area around Salamis
Recording and study 1
- p. 51
Luigi Palma di CesnolaRival ofHeinrich Schliemann
The article described Cesnola as a contemporary and rival of Heinrich Schliemann.
Posts and family 4
- p. 51
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSibling ofAlessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola
Luigi Palma di Cesnola and Alessandro Palma di Cesnola were brothers.
- 1954–1962 · p. 54
James Rivers Barrington StewartEmployed byNicholson Museum
Stewart was Honorary Curator of the Nicholson Museum from 1954 until his death in 1962.
Sydney
- p. 55
William John WoodhouseEmployed byNicholson Museum
Woodhouse served as Honorary Curator of the Nicholson Museum.
Sydney
- 1939–1954 · p. 61
Arthur Dale TrendallEmployed byNicholson Museum
Trendall served as curator of the Nicholson Museum.
Sydney
People it is cited for
16 people- William Ransom12 citations
- Arthur Dale Trendall11 citations
- William John Woodhouse11 citations
- Frank Ransom9 citations
- Arthur Stanley Riggs6 citations
- Gisela Marie Augusta Richter6 citations
- H. W. Kent6 citations
- Leland Stanford6 citations
- Ruth H. Gebhard5 citations
- Sir Charles Nicholson5 citations
- Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di Cesnola4 citations
- A. W. Lawrence3 citations
- James Rivers Barrington Stewart3 citations
- C. Lawler2 citations
- Jennifer M. Webb2 citations
- Luigi Palma di Cesnola2 citations
Institutions it is cited for
7 institutions- Nicholson Museum35 citations
- Metropolitan Museum of Art6 citations
- Cantor Arts Center4 citations
- Stanford University4 citations
- Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology, Cambridge3 citations
- University of Sydney
- Fisher Library, University of Sydney
Mentioned in
6 mentionsTomb records · 4
- Bellapais-Vounous, BSA Tomb 118
Objects from the tomb · 2017 · p. Plate 19
in front: bronze dagger [Bellapais Vounous Tomb 118 No. 47]
- Bellapais-Vounous, BSA Tomb 125
Objects from the tomb · 2017 · p. Plate 19
Red Polished III decorated knob-lug bowl Bellapais Vounous Tomb 125 No. 25
- Bellapais-Vounous, BSA Tomb 126
Objects from the tomb · 2017 · p. Plate 19
Red Polished III jug [Bellapais Vounous Tomb 126 No. 2]
- Bellapais-Vounous, BSA Tomb 142
Objects from the tomb · 2017 · p. Plate 19
Red Polished III amphora [Bellapais Vounous Tomb 142 No. 11]
- Excavations · 2listed under Excavations it is cited for
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.