Chapter · 2001
The fight for the past: Watkins vs. Warren (1885-6) and the control of excavation
Michael Given; edited by V. Tatton-Brown
In Cyprus in the 19th Century AD: Fact, Fancy and Fiction, 255-260. London: British Museum
A chapter on the 1885–86 dispute between Charles Watkins and Falkland Warren over excavation at Frangissa, read as a case of the colonial government's control of archaeology in Cyprus.
Given uses the dispute of 1885–86 between Charles Watkins and Falkland Warren over excavation at Frangissa to discuss archaeology under colonial rule in Cyprus. He draws on correspondence in the Cyprus State Archives, the Cyprus Herald's published trial transcript and reports on the finds, and argues that archaeological work was shaped by competition for control of excavation and interpretation as well as by scholarly interest.
Warren's permit application for Paraskevi, Pera and Acanthou was approved through a process in which he occupied the roles of both applicant and Chief Secretary. The Frangissa excavation followed in October 1885, under Ohnefalsch-Richter's direction. The enclosure there held statue bases, limestone and terracotta statuette fragments, an altar and bilingual inscriptions, and from Pera came a painted vase and glass-working debris. Watkins challenged Warren's actions in court in December; Warren won, and Watkins was ordered to pay costs (pp. 255–260).
Given presents the trial and the treatment of the finds as examples of the colonial establishment asserting control over excavation and the past. Officials could use their authority to restrict private excavators, and archaeological claims about Cyprus also supported imperial justifications for rule.
What it records
- Falkland Warren applied in early August 1885 for permission to excavate at Paraskevi, Pera and Acanthou.p. 255
- Max Ohnefalsch-Richter discovered Frangissa, southeast of Pera, on 4 October 1885.p. 257
- Charles Watkins sent Max Ohnefalsch-Richter £10 to hire the land at Frangissa.p. 257
- Falkland Warren rejected Charles Watkins's application to excavate at Frangissa on 17 November 1885.p. 258
- Charles Watkins relied on Article 17 of the 1874 Ottoman Antiquities Law in his case against Warren.p. 259
- Warren won the case against Watkins, who had to pay costs.p. 259
- Professor Wright's 1886–87 account attributed the two bilingual inscriptions to Warren's excavations at Frangissa, Given reports.p. 259
Where to read
- Permit applications and the government's control of excavationpp. 255–257
- The Frangissa excavation and its findspp. 257–258
- Watkins's trial, the land contract and Article 17pp. 258–259
Contents
- The Permit255
- Archaeology and Colonial Society255
- The Excavation257
- The Trial258
- Conclusion259
- Acknowledgements260
- Bibliography260
Objects published here
3- Two bilingual inscriptions in Phoenician and Cypriote, Frangissa, near Tamassos (p. 259)
- Terracotta colossus, Cyprus Museum, Frangissa (p. 257)
- Painted vase with a hunting scene, Pera, pl. 137:6 (p. 257)
People, places and institutions
People
- Falkland George Edgeworth WarrenChief Secretary and excavator
- Charles Watkinsprivate excavator and plaintiff
- Max Ohnefalsch-Richterarchaeologist who directed the excavation
- W.H. BennettChief Clerk and Museum Committee secretary
- Christophi Christodouloswitness to the land contract
- Ulick BurkeWatkins's advocate
- William CollyerWarren's defence lawyer
- Charles Walpolejudge in Watkins's case
- Yianni Hadjiloizoulandowner at Frangissa
Institutions
- Chief Secretary's Officegovernment office handling permits
- Cyprus Museummuseum and applicant for excavation
- Cyprus Museum Committeegovernment-dominated museum committee
- District Court of Larnacacourt that heard Watkins's case
- Cyprus State Archivesrepository of government correspondence
Places
- Frangissasite of the 1885 excavation
- Peraexcavation locality near Tamassos
- Tamassosancient town near Frangissa
- Nicosiasite of Ohnefalsch-Richter's house
Also named: Abramo, George Smith, Sir Robert Biddulph, Claude Cobham, Hugh Sinclair, Herbert Kitchener, Tankerville Chamberlayne, Roland Michell, John Williamson, Frank Christian, Edward Carletti, Professor Wright, Imperial Ottoman Bank, Municipal Council of Larnaca, Paraskevi, Acanthou, Larnaca.
Extent pp. 255–260; bibliography p. 260
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 pageExcavations it is cited for
2 projects- 1885–1886Idalion: the sanctuary of Aphrodite dug for Charles WatkinsDirected by Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavation
- 1885Tamassos-Frangissa: Ohnefalsch-Richter's excavations for Colonel Warren, 1885Directed by Max Ohnefalsch-Richter and Falkland WarrenExcavation
Who did what
18 recordsBuying, selling and giving 5
- 1878 · p. 256
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaHad objects seized
Many of Alessandro Palma di Cesnola's finds were confiscated, ending his activity on the island.
many of his findsCyprus
- p. 256
Claude Delaval CobhamRecorded
probablyCobham’s house held Cesnola’s confiscated finds for about eleven years.
Alessandro di Cesnola’s confiscated findsClaude Cobham’s house
- 1885 · p. 258
Charles F. WatkinsIn litigation withFalkland Warren
Watkins sued Warren, claiming a third of the antiquities and a third for damages over Warren’s trespass.
one third of the antiquities and damages for trespassLarnaca
- p. 258
Falkland WarrenAcquired
A contract for Warren gave him rights to material found on the land in return for 10 shillings to the owner.
With the ownerrights for all material found on the land10 shillingsnear Pera
- p. 259
Falkland WarrenOwned
Wright’s account described the inscriptions as Warren’s property and said he discovered them during his excavations at Frangissa.
two bilingual inscriptions, Phoenician and Cypriote
Excavation 12
- 1885 · p. 255
W. H. BennettConnected withFalkland Warren
Bennett approved Warren’s excavation application as Honorary Secretary of the Cyprus Museum Committee.
- 1883–1885 · p. 257
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterDug forFalkland Warren
Ohnefalsch-Richter worked for Warren at Frangissa from 17 October to 2 November 1885.
sanctuary finds, including votive offerings and bilingual inscriptionsNo. ICS 215; ICS 216
- 1885 · p. 257
Charles F. WatkinsFinancedMax Ohnefalsch-Richter
Ch. Watkins provided the funds necessary for Max Ohnefalsch-Richter's excavation.
excavation of the sanctuaryIdalion
- 1885 · p. 257
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterDirected excavations
Ohnefalsch-Richter directed the excavation at ancient Tamassos near Pera.
- 1885 · p. 257
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavated
Ohnefalsch-Richter excavated the enclosure and its finds at Frangissa; the work was complete by 7 November.
a walled enclosure, statue bases and limestone and terracotta statuettes
- p. 257
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterConnected withYianni Hadjiloizou
Ohnefalsch-Richter contracted to hire a piece of land from Yoannui H. Loizi Argyre for excavation.
182 c. p.Frangissa
- p. 258
Falkland WarrenRefused a permit toCharles F. Watkins
Warren informed Watkins that his application to excavate at Frangissa had been rejected.
- p. 258
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterPassed objects toCharles F. Watkins
Ohnefalsch-Richter passed his rights under the land contract to Watkins.
Frangissa
- p. 258
Ulick BurkeEmployed byCharles F. Watkins
Burke acted as Watkins’ advocate in the case against Warren.
- p. 258
William CollyerConnected withFalkland Warren
Collyer was Warren’s defence lawyer in the case.
- p. 259
AbramoPassed objects toMax Ohnefalsch-Richter
Christophi Christodoulos testified that he and Abramo gave the contract to Richter.
a contract
- p. 259
Christophi ChristodoulosHelpedMax Ohnefalsch-Richter
Christodoulos showed Ohnefalsch-Richter the site and arranged his meeting with the landowner.
Frangissa
Recording and study 1
- p. 259
Edward CarlettiPhotographed
Carletti photographed artefacts from Frangissa while they were in Warren’s house.
People it is cited for
17 people- Falkland Warren15 citations
- Charles F. Watkins13 citations
- Yianni Hadjiloizou11 citations
- W. H. Bennett10 citations
- Christophi Christodoulos8 citations
- Ulick Burke8 citations
- Charles Walpole7 citations
- William Collyer7 citations
- Abramo4 citations
- George Smith4 citations
- W. Wright4 citations
- Edward Carletti3 citations
- Frank Christian3 citations
- Charles Christian2 citations
- John William Williamson
- Robert Biddulph
- Ronald Storrs
Institutions it is cited for
4 institutions- Chief Secretary's Office, Cyprus Government3 citations
- District Court of Larnaca3 citations
- Cyprus Museum2 citations
- Imperial Ottoman Bank2 citations
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.