Article · 1984
Cesnola et le trésor de Curium (I)
Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 1
An article on the accounts of Cesnola's Curium treasure, setting his published story of an underground temple treasury against the testimony of the workers who dug at Curium.
Masson follows the dispute over the so-called Curium treasure through Cesnola's career in Cyprus. His first period of activity ran from 1866 to 1872 and a second from late 1873 to September 1876. In private letters of 1875 Cesnola referred to a royal tomb; his later account describes a four-chamber underground temple treasury, and the controversy over it ran from 1883 to 1885.
Against that account Masson sets the testimony of the former workers Théocharis and Christofis and reports by Ohnefalsch-Richter. They place the richest burial in the plain east of the hill, near the old church of Ayios Ermoyenis, and describe its contents as lying mixed together instead of sorted into rooms by material (pp. 20–21).
Masson argues that Cesnola transformed and minimised the results of work in the Ayios Ermoyenis necropolis before presenting the finds as a single treasure from a subterranean temple chamber, and he concludes that rich tombs did exist at Curium. He also quotes Cesnola's reply in the Mail and Express of October 1885 and the comments of later scholars (pp. 22–23).
What it records
- Cesnola sold his first collection to the founders of the Metropolitan Museum of Art after negotiations with other countries, Masson reports.p. 17
- Cesnola excavated at the sanctuary of Apollo Hylates, according to Masson, and later scholars accepted the provenance of the terracottas attributed to the site.p. 17
- An 1883 investigation at the site of Cesnola's reported treasure found undisturbed earth at shallow depth, in the account Masson quotes.p. 20
- Christofis Christodoulou states that the richest burial at Curium had three chambers instead of four and held a large deposit of bones.p. 21
- According to Théocharis, the four-chamber tomb lay in the large necropolis outside the city.p. 21
- Christofis Christodoulou says that the gold and silver objects were packed into three or four cigar boxes.p. 21
- Théocharis says that the bracelet dedicated to the Paphian king Etewandros came from a different tomb at Curium, outside the four-chamber treasure tomb.p. 21
- Cesnola stated in 1885 that every object the museum classifies as found at Curium came from four rooms there.p. 22
Where to read
- Workers’ accounts of the four-chamber tomb and its contentspp. 20–21
- Cesnola’s 1885 response and his letters about the treasurepp. 22–23
- The reported tombs in the plain near Ayios Ermoyenispp. 18–21
Objects published here
1- Gold bracelet bearing the dedication of Etewandros, king of Paphos, Curium, a tomb other than the four-chamber tomb, according to Théocharis (p. 21)
People, places and institutions
People
- Luigi Palma di Cesnolaconsul and excavator, author of the treasure account
- Théocharisworker who testified about the tombs
- Christofis Christodoulouworker who testified about the tombs
- Max Ohnefalsch-Richterinvestigated the site and collected testimony
- Henri de Morganpublished the workers’ testimony
- J.H. and S.H. Youngpublished on terracottas from Kourion
- J. Myresquestioned Cesnola’s terracotta claims
Institutions
- Metropolitan Museum of Artbought Cesnola’s first collection
Places
Also named: Kition, Amathonte, Soloi, Kythéra, Williamson, Chard.
Extent pp. 16–26, partial map of the plain east of Kourion
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 page- KourionSite
Excavations it is cited for
6 projects- 1866–1870Kition: Luigi Palma di Cesnola's ExcavationsDirected by Luigi Palma di CesnolaClearance and early digging
- 1867–1873Golgoi: Cesnola's excavations at Ayios PhotiosDirected by Luigi Palma di CesnolaClearance and early digging
- 1874–1876Amathus: Cesnola's tomb clearanceDirected by Luigi Palma di CesnolaClearance and early digging
- 1874–1875Kourion: Luigi Palma di Cesnola's excavationsDirected by Luigi Palma di CesnolaClearance and early digging
- 1883–1884Kourion: Ohnefalsch-Richter's excavations for Warren, Brown and Lady BrasseyDirected by Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavation
- 1883Kourion: Williamson & Co. and Major Chard's syndicate tomb digsDirected by John William Williamson, Major Chard and Alexandros of LimassolClearance and early digging
Who did what
21 recordsBuying, selling and giving 1
- 1870–1876 · p. 17
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toMetropolitan Museum of Art
Cesnola agreed to sell his collection to the Metropolitan Museum for £1,200.
£1,200New York
Excavation 13
- 1869 · p. 16
Cesnola brought to light small Phoenician inscriptions of Kition at Batsalos hill.
petites inscriptions phéniciennes de Kitioncolline de Batsalos, à l'ouest de la ville
- 1870 · p. 16
Cesnola’s discovery of a colossal head near Athiénou brought scholarly attention to his work.
tête colossaleprès du village d'Athiénou, sur un site dépendant de l'ancienne cité de Golgoi
- p. 16
Luigi Palma di CesnolaDirected excavations
Cesnola gathered peasants whose work brought antiquities, including large statues, to light at the temple site.
une série d'antiquités, notamment de grandes statuesemplacement d'un temple à Golgoi
- 1875 · p. 18
Cesnola, guided by his trusted men, discovered a group of rich tombs east of Kourion's acropolis.
groupe de tombesà l'est de l'acropole de Kourion
- p. 19
Cesnola's official account said the Curium Treasure had been found in an underground four-chamber structure on the acropolis at Kourion.
Trésor de CuriumKourion, sur l'acropole
- 1883–1885 · p. 20
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterDug forFalkland Warren
Ohnefalsch-Richter worked for Warren at Frangissa from 17 October to 2 November 1885.
sanctuary finds, including votive offerings and bilingual inscriptionsNo. ICS 215; ICS 216
- 1883–1884 · p. 20
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterDug forSamuel Brown
Max Ohnefalsch-Richter excavated at Kourion for S. Brown.
tombs in the Graeco-Phoenician necropolis
- 1883–1886 · p. 20
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterDug forJohn William Williamson
Ohnefalsch-Richter served as Government Inspector during excavations commissioned by Williamson and Chard.
région de Kourion
- 1883 · p. 20
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterDug forMajor Chard
Ohnefalsch-Richter served as Government Inspector during excavations commissioned by Williamson and Chard.
région de Kourion
- p. 21
Christofis stated that he was the first to discover the rich burial east of the hill.
sépulture de trois chambresplaine à l'est de la colline, près de la vieille église d'Agios Armornis
- p. 21
Théocharis stated that he had discovered three fine tombs in the necropolis outside the city.
trois tombes fort bellesgrande nécropole hors de la ville
- p. 22
In a letter, Cesnola claimed he had discovered a royal tomb containing gold, silver, and bronze objects.
tombe royale; objets en or, en argent et en bronzeCurium
- 1874 · p. 24
Theocharis KoutsocherisDug forLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Koutsocheris testified that he worked in Cesnola’s excavations and was ordered to dig at Amathus.
stone-built tombs and sarcophagi
Recording and study 6
- 1865–1867 · p. 16
Dominique Albert Edouard Tiburce Colonna-CeccaldiRecorded
Colonna-Ceccaldi was active at Larnaca and Dali in Cyprus during his consular posting.
Larnaca; Dali
- 1877–1904 · p. 16
Luigi Palma di CesnolaEmployed byNew York Metropolitan Museum of Art
The trustees hired Cesnola to unpack, arrange and classify the collection.
$500 a monthNew York
- 1885 · p. 20
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterWorked withFerdinand Dümmler
Ohnefalsch-Richter and Dr Dümmler examined the spot where Cesnola said he found the Curium Treasure.
- p. 20
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterStudied
Ohnefalsch-Richter reported locating the mosaic site without a subterranean chamber and noted rich tombs in the plain.
emplacement de la mosaïque; nécropole dans la plaineacropole et plaine de Kourion
- 1875 · p. 22
Luigi Palma di CesnolaCorresponded withClarence Cook
Cesnola wrote to Clarence Cook about his Curium discoveries and claimed he had found a royal tomb and valuable objects.
Cesnola’s Curium discoveries
- 1875 · p. 23
Luigi Palma di CesnolaCorresponded withHiram Hitchcock
Cesnola wrote to Hiram Hitchcock about the discovery of the Amathus sarcophagus.
Posts and family 1
- 1865–1876 · p. 16
Luigi Palma di CesnolaEmployed byEtats-Unis
Cesnola served as United States consul in Cyprus from 1865 to 1876.
Chypre
People it is cited for
6 people- Theocharis Koutsocheris5 citations
- Christofis Christodoulou2 citations
- Constantinas Sava2 citations
- George Menardos
- Giannis
- William James Stillman
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.