Critic / journalist · Consul / diplomat · Scholar

William James Stillman

1828–1901 · United States

American artist, journalist and former consul at Candia who attacked Cesnola in the press from 1876 and in 1885 reported on the Cesnola Collection for a New York society.

Biography

William James Stillman, an American artist, journalist and diplomat, was one of the chief critics of Luigi Palma di Cesnola and of his Cypriot collection in the Metropolitan Museum, and wrote the 1885 report on it for the American Numismatic and Archaeological Society9,14.

Consul and journalist

Stillman was born at Schenectady, New York, on 1 June 1828 and graduated from Union College in 184815. In 1849 he made his first trip to Europe, met Ruskin and Rossetti and came home a disciple of the Pre-Raphaelites; in the late 1850s he and John Durand founded the art paper The Crayon15. He was appointed US consul at Rome in 1861 and later in Crete15. An 1868 guide lists him as consul at Candia in the same table that lists Cesnola as consul in Cyprus16. In spring 1880 the governor of Crete told him a permit to dig would be granted to the United States, and he was sent to Candia in January 1881 to prepare the work17. Stillman chose a ruin on the acropolis of Knossos, but the firman was refused18. One account says this was possibly because of his sympathies with the Cretans; another says he had involved himself in the Cretan insurrection of 1866 to 1868 and had to leave the island in March 188117,19. Soon after his removal from the post in Crete he joined The Times, whose correspondent he was for thirty years15,20.

The campaign against Cesnola

A letter in The Times signed W.J.S. is dated 30 November 1876; according to Cesnola it called him and Heinrich Schliemann "gropers"21. Cesnola told Schliemann it was supposed to have been suggested by Charles Newton, which he could not believe, and that he had never met Stillman, "a nasty envious dog"21,22. The two printed versions of that letter differ: Marangou reads "A few days ago", Masson "A few years ago"21,22.

In The Nation of 5 April 1881 Stillman wrote that Schliemann and Cesnola had made digging in Turkey harder by evading the Turkish law, and that Washington should have dismissed Consul Cesnola10. In The Critic of 16 June 1883, writing from Florence, he said he had never seen Cesnola to his knowledge and that the matter "disgraces New York City"23. In a letter of 9 June 1884 he judged pieces of the Cesnola jewellery medieval or machine-made and concluded that Cesnola "was no judge of antique jewelry"24. From London on 29 September 1884 he relayed findings of Max Ohnefalsch-Richter, and the New York Times of 26 October 1884 reported him passing on the statement of the digger Theocharis that the best objects from thousands of tombs had been "united in a single treasure invented by L. P. Di Cesnola"6,25. The Springfield Republican, reprinted in the New York Times, reported that he set Cesnola not beside Layard or Newton but "with the Shapiras"25.

The 1885 report

On 20 January 1885 the Society elected Stillman a resident member and asked him to examine the evidence and report9,21. Adelson calls this "an ingenious plan" to give currency to his views9. Stillman said he could now collate evidence he could procure "by a personal visit to the excavations"9. The report was given on 28 March 1885 and privately printed21,26. As Marangou summarises it, Stillman faulted the assigning of pieces to the Temple of Golgoi though found elsewhere, called the coatings that hid repairs to the sculptures illegitimate, and concluded that the Curium treasure came from tombs scattered around Curium, not from "under the mosaic"21. The report included the affidavit of Christofis, a worker present at the find21. Given says the workers gave their testimony to Ohnefalsch-Richter in 1885, and Marangou that Stillman made the two foremen turn against Cesnola21,27. Cesnola answered the report in the New York Mail and Express of 25 October 188521.

Adelson judged the report "extremely effective"21. In May 1886 Cesnola warned Schliemann that Stillman was "a despicable reptile"21. In December 1888 The Owl published a letter from Stillman, then in Rome, arguing that a Cyprus antiquities law without enough incentives for excavators would harm Cypriot archaeology21. Reinach held that his work on the Venus de Milo and other archaeological questions was of little value but that he took a useful part in the Cesnola controversy, and in 1905 called the accusations against Cesnola "never refuted"20,28.

The sources disagree on the date of his death: Reinach and the Dictionary of American Biography give 6 July 1901, while The Editor and Publisher gives 8 July, at his home at Frimley Green, Surrey, aged 7315,20,29.

Life and work

  1. 1876

    1. 30 November

      Letter signed W.J.S. in The Times attacking Cesnola and Newton's circle; Cesnola wrote to Schliemann that it called 'you and I gropers' and urged Schliemann to answer it.

      LondonA. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 65; A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 89

  2. 1880

    1. Sent by the Archaeological Institute of America to investigate the possibilities of archaeological work at Knossos and Gortyn; Greek-Turkish troubles made work impossible.

      CreteEric M. Meyers (ed.) (1997). The Oxford Encyclopedia of Archaeology in the Near East. New York, Oxford University Press

  3. 1884

    1. 1 March

      ANS special meeting passed resolutions on the Feuardent case.

      New YorkA. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 328

  4. 1885

    1. 20 January

      Robert Hewitt offered an ANS resolution regarding Stillman's proposed trip to Cyprus; the resolution asked Stillman, as archaeologist and member, to examine the evidence on provenance of the Cypriote Collection in the Metropolitan Museum and report, so the Society could decide on further investigation.

      New York(1881-1897). Feuardent and Cesnola, 1881-1897 (ANS Early Correspondence 1858-1908). American Numismatic Society; A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 328

    2. 28 March

      Report to the ANS: the collection contained many objects of great value but its utility was impaired by (1) reckless attribution of findspots (especially assigning pieces to the Temple of Golgoi), (2) repairs and concealed original surfaces (notably the archaic sarcophagus) and (3) assigning an important part to a single deposit, the 'Curium Treasure', whose supposed deposit did not exist. He placed the treasure's objects in tombs scattered round Kourion. Included the affidavit of Christofis Christodoulou (published in L'Homme 25 Mar 1885).

      New YorkA. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, pp. 337-339; A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds

    3. Marangou says Stillman 'managed to make both Theocharis and Christofis, the two "loyal" foremen of Cesnola, turn against him'; Cesnola replied in the New York Mail and Express of 25 Oct 1885 (answering the Times and Sun editorials of that day).

      A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 337; A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 343

    4. Reported on 28 Mar 1885 to the American Numismatic and Archaeological Society that the Cesnola collection was repaired, misattributed, and the 'Curium Treasure' a composite with fakes.

      Balandier 2001, 'Cyprus, a new archaeological frontier in the XIXth century', in Tatton-Brown (ed.), Cyprus in the 19th Century AD, p. 9

  5. 1886

    1. Cesnola warned Schliemann against Stillman, then Times correspondent in Athens, as a 'despicable reptile, a scoundrel, a liar' (Cesnola's own words).

      A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 67

  6. 1888

    1. December

      Letter in The Owl (Dec 1888) from Rome urging that Cyprus's proposed antiquities law offer excavators incentives, on the Italian model (permit only; free export of finds, state having first option to buy).

      RomeA. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 357

  7. Undated

    n.d.

    1. American consul in Crete who tried to investigate Knossos after Sandwith failed to interest the BM.

      K. Lapatin, 2002, Mysteries of the Snake Goddess: Art, Desire and the Forging of History, p. 59

    2. Said in the recorded talk «Masons' Marks and the Circulation of Builders in the Bronze Age Aegean and Cyprus» (Archaeological Research Unit - University of Cyprus, 2024-10-21): US consul in Crete who published in 1881 his account of marks inscribed on walls at Knossos.

      Maud Devolder, «Masons' Marks and the Circulation of Builders in the Bronze Age Aegean and Cyprus», recorded lecture, 62nd Public Lecture Series, Archaeological Research Unit - University of Cyprus, published on YouTube 2024-10-21, at 0:06:06

Connections

10 people

Mentioned in

19 mentions

Institutions · 1

  • American Numismatic Society

    Member (January 1885 – 1885) · 1885

    William J. Stillman, elected a resident member in January 1885, was asked by resolution (offered by Robert Hewitt, 20 January 1885) to examine the evidence on…

    Marangou 2000, p. 328; Marangou 2000, p. 328, p. 337; Feuardent & Cesnola 1908

Sources

  1. 1.A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
  2. 2. (1881-1897). “Feuardent and Cesnola, 1881-1897 (ANS Early Correspondence 1858-1908)”. American Numismatic Society.
  3. 3.Eric M. Meyers (ed.) (1997). The Oxford Encyclopedia of Archaeology in the Near East. New York, Oxford University Press.
  4. 4.W. J. Stillman (1885). Report of W. J. Stillman on the Cesnola Collection. New York, Thompson and Moreau.
  5. 5.W. J. Stillmann (1884). “(article in) L'homme, Journal illustré des sciences anthropologiques / The Studio. Journal of Fine Arts N.S. 5”. 58-60.
  6. 6.W. J. Stillman (1884). “Recent Investigations in Cyprus”. New York Times, 8.
  7. 7.O. Masson (1984). “Cesnola et le trésor de Curium (I)”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 1.
  8. 8.S. Reinach (1883). Manuel de philologie classique.
  9. 9.Howard L. Adelson (1958). The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958. American Numismatic Society.
  10. 10.New York Times (1882). “[Letter to the editor on General di Cesnola and the temple of Golgoi]”. The New York Times, 6 April 1882.
  11. 11.Courrier de l'art (1884-11-28). Courrier de l'art, 28 November 1884. p. 19.
  12. 12.S. Trowbridge (1936). “Dictionary of American Biography (entry W. J. Stillman)”.
  13. 13.Revue archéologique (1901). “Revue archéologique 1901 (obituary notice of Stillman)”. p. 937.
  14. 14.Jahresbericht über die Fortschritte der classischen Altertumswissenschaft (1894). “[Report on the archaeology of Cyprus]”. Jahresbericht über die Fortschritte der classischen Altertumswissenschaft (Bursian), Bd. 26.
  15. 15.The Editor and Publisher (1901). “Death of W. J. Stillman”. The Editor and Publisher, vol. 1 no. 3, 13 July 1901.
  16. 16.W. Pembroke Fetridge (1868). The American Travellers' Guides: Hand-books for travellers in Europe and the East.
  17. 17.La Chronique des arts et de la curiosité (1901). “[Notice on the excavations at Knossos]”. La Chronique des arts et de la curiosité, supplément à la Gazette des beaux-arts, 1901.
  18. 18.W. J. Stillman (1901). The Autobiography of a Journalist.
  19. 19.[author not seen] (2004). “[Essay on Minoan masons' marks]”. CHARIS: Essays in Honor of Sara A. Immerwahr (Hesperia Supplement).
  20. 20.Salomon Reinach (1901). “Nouvelles archéologiques et correspondance”. Revue archéologique, 3e série, 39 (July-December 1901).
  21. 21.A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
  22. 22.Olivier Masson (1994). “L. Palma di Cesnola, H. Schliemann et l'éditeur John Murray”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 21, 7-14. Online
  23. 23.W. J. Stillman (1883). “Mr. Stillman and the Museum of Art [letter to the editors, from Florence]”. The Critic (New York), vol. 3, 16 June 1883.
  24. 24.W. J. Stillman (1884). “[Letter to the editor on the Cesnola jewellery in the Metropolitan Museum, dated New York, 9 June 1884]”. The New York Times, 14 June 1884.
  25. 25.New York Times (1884). “The Cesnola Verdict: Mr. Stillman on the Cypriote Antiquities”. The New York Times, 26 October 1884 (reprinting a New-York letter to the Springfield Republican).
  26. 26.The American (1885). “[Note on Stillman's report on the Cesnola Collection]”. The American (Philadelphia), vol. 10 no. 257, 11 July 1885.
  27. 27.Michael Given (2025). “Over the landscape, in the landscape? Knowledge and agency in Cypriot archaeology, 1870-1910”. Empire & Excavation: Critical perspectives on archaeology in British-period Cyprus, 1878-1960. Leiden, Sidestone Press.
  28. 28.Salomon Reinach (1905). “Chronique d'Orient”. Revue archéologique, 4e série, 5.
  29. 29.American Council of Learned Societies (1943). Dictionary of American Biography [Index, volumes 1-20].
  30. 30.Olivier Masson (1994). “L. Palma di Cesnola, H. Schliemann et l'éditeur John Murray”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 21, 7-14.
  31. 31.K. Lapatin, 2002, Mysteries of the Snake Goddess: Art, Desire and the Forging of History.
  32. 32.Maud Devolder, «Masons' Marks and the Circulation of Builders in the Bronze Age Aegean and Cyprus», recorded lecture, 62nd Public Lecture Series, Archaeological Research Unit - University of Cyprus, published on YouTube 2024-10-21, at 0:06:06. Online
  33. 33.Balandier 2001, 'Cyprus, a new archaeological frontier in the XIXth century', in Tatton-Brown (ed.), Cyprus in the 19th Century AD.
  34. 34.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
  35. 35.American Numismatic Society, 1881, Feuardent and Cesnola, 1881-1897 (ANS Early Correspondence 1858-1908, folder with Adelson index).
  36. 36.Howard L. Adelson, 1958, The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958.
  37. 37.Marangou 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola, pp. 263, 328-352, 361, 402 (notes); Cahiers CEC 40 (2010) p. 20.
  38. 38.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds(pp. 337-340).
  39. 39.1885, Le Scandale du Metropolitan Museum of Art de New-York, Courrier de l'art (1885), 'Le Scandale du Metropolitan Museum'.
  40. 40.Vayson de Pradenne, André (1888-1939), Les fraudes en archéologie préhistorique : avec quelques exemples de comparaison en archéologie générale et sciences naturelles (1932).
  41. 41.British Museum. Department of Printed Books, A subject index of modern works added to the library of the British museum in the years 1880-[95] (1886).
  42. 42.W. J. Stillman, 1884, Recent Investigations in Cyprus.
  43. 43.Olivier Masson, 1994, L. Palma di Cesnola, H. Schliemann et l'éditeur John Murray.
  44. 44.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds(pp. 65-67), 361-363.
  45. 45.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds(p. 352).
  46. 46.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds(pp. 338-339).
  47. 47.W. J. Stillman, 1884, Recent Investigations in Cyprus, p. 8; Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds(p. 337).
  48. 48.American Numismatic Society, 1881/1897, Feuardent and Cesnola, 1881-1897 (ANS Early Correspondence, folder index), index p. 1.
  49. 49.H. L. Adelson, 1958, The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958.
  50. 50.Jahresbericht über die Fortschritte der klassischen Altertumswissenschaft.
  51. 51.Society of Biblical Archæology (London, England), Proceedings of the Society of Biblical Archaeology (1879).
  52. 52.Bursian, Konrad, 1830-1883, [from old catalog] ed; Müller, Iwan Philipp Eduard, Ritter von, 1830-1917, [from old catalog] ed; Seyffert, Oskar, 1841-1906, [from old catalog] ed, Jahresbericht über die Fortschritte der klassischen Altertumswissenschaft (1894).
  53. 53.Abraham, Fritz, 1841- [from old catalog] ed; Hermann, Johann, 1842- [from old catalog] ed; Meyer, Edmund, 1840-1905, [from old catalog] ed, Jahresberichte der geschichtswissenschaft; im auftrage der Historischen gesellschaft zu Berlin herausgegeben .. (1889).
  54. 54.Catalogue Général des Livres Imprimés : Auteurs 1950: Vol 178 (1950).
  55. 55.Howard L. Adelson, The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958 (1958).
  56. 56.Thomas Kiely; Anna Reeve; Lindy Crewe, Empire & Excavation: Critical perspectives on archaeology in British-period Cyprus, 1878–1960 (2025).
  57. 57.Olivier Masson, L. Palma di Cesnola, H. Schliemann et l'éditeur John Murray (1994).
  58. 58.Revue archéologique (1901-07).
  59. 59.Dinsmoor William B, Business Organization And Public Control Second Edition (1941).
  60. 60.Marangou 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola.
  61. 61.W. J. Stillman, 'Recent Investigations in Cyprus', letter dated London 29 Sept 1884, New York Times 17 Oct 1884.

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.