Scholar · Critic / journalist

Henri de Morgan

1854–1910 · France

French prehistorian and collector in New York who wrote an unpublished manuscript against Cesnola and in 1884-85 attacked the Curium treasure and the Soli finds in L'Homme.

Biography

Henri de Morgan was a French prehistorian and explorer who, from New York, waged a campaign of writing against Luigi Palma di Cesnola's account of his Cypriot discoveries6,7.

Family and early work

The obituary in L'Homme préhistorique gives his full name as Henry-Charles-Marie-Ferdinand Dieudonné de Morgan and calls him the son of Eugène de Morgan, with whom he explored the Campigny site when very young7. His brother was Jacques de Morgan, the excavator of Susa8,9. The sources disagree on which brother was the elder: Boucher calls Jacques the elder, while Masson in 1984 calls Henri the elder6,8. They also disagree on the year of his birth, 1854 or 1841. Boucher, the Cleveland Museum of Art, Apollo and Masson in 2001 give 1854, but Masson in 1984 gave 18411,6,8,10,11.

His first studies were of the prehistoric and Merovingian periods in northern France, which he began at twenty according to the Journal des débats and at about twenty-five according to Le Figaro9,12. To the American Numismatic and Archaeological Society, of which he was a member, he presented a paper "On some Frank sepultures of the sixth, seventh and eighth centuries", read for him by Frederick Vors13. In it he said that the excavations had lasted over four years and that more than eight hundred tombs were explored at Blangy, Nesle, Criel and Mareuil13. A notice by his brother Jacques, quoted by Masson, says that Henri continued his studies in England and then went to America, where he made many geological and prehistoric journeys14. Boucher says he settled in the United States from 1876 and that he seems to have acted as representative of the dealers Rollin et Feuardent, seeking American archaeological and ethnological objects for them6.

The case against Cesnola

Boucher explains his part in the Cesnola affair, with a "sans doute", by his links with the dealers who had organised Cesnola's London sale of 1871 and by his presence in New York close to the Metropolitan Museum6. Masson wrote that we do not learn when or how the young de Morgan decided to go to war against Cesnola14. He wrote a manuscript, "Archéologie chypriote. Une enquête sur certaines découvertes en Chypre. L'affaire Cesnola", now in the library of the Musée d'Archéologie nationale at Saint-Germain-en-Laye as Manuscrits no. 14153, of 238 folios6. Masson dates it to about 1882-83, since the latest of its pasted clippings date from those years, and notes that the author's name, which appears on the binding, had been erased on the original14.

The manuscript opens with a map tracing Cesnola's shifting attributions of provenance, and draws on American, French and European press clippings, extracts of letters to which de Morgan had privileged access, extracts of Cesnola's books and a close enquiry into objects shown at the Metropolitan Museum6. Its sections run from the period before the alleged Golgoi temple to temples, towns and necropoleis and, last, the Curium treasure14. Wilhelm Froehner recorded in his journal on 22 November 1883 that de Morgan had written a large manuscript on Cesnola's finds, and on the same date wrote to Eugène de Morgan that his son's manuscript seemed to him "extrêmement important"2,14.

The work also set out to defend Gaston Feuardent, whom Cesnola had indirectly accused in the New York Times of 11 March 1881 of stealing an anthropomorphic vase, and who then sued him for libel6. De Morgan claimed to close the debate by showing that the vase had been lot 31 in the London sale of 1 May 1871, bought by Feuardent and sold in France to Alexandre Bertrand in 18746. Boucher says the manuscript identifies the vase with certainty6. Masson in 2001 thought Cesnola innocent in this affair and noted that the New York jury found for him in 18841.

L'Homme, 1884-85

The book was never published, but de Morgan used the enquiry for several articles6. In Masson's words, seized by "une sorte de passion" for the affair and "une véritable hostilité" against Cesnola, he translated the 1883 documents into French and printed them in L'Homme in 1884 and 18858. On 10 August 1884 L'Homme carried his "Le prétendu trésor de Curium", which reproduced in translation the letter of Max Ohnefalsch-Richter dated Limassol, 6 October 18838,15. Vayson de Pradenne reports his conclusion that, on the testimony of Theocharis and Richter's enquiry, the treasure was "une mystification inventée de toutes pièces par le soi-disant explorateur"16. The New York Times quoted his line that if Cesnola had not discovered the treasure, "he has at least the name of having invented it"17.

In a signed article in the Courrier de l'art he called the account in Cyprus "un roman et rien de plus", noted that Cesnola's consular appointment was signed by President Johnson and not Lincoln, and counted six shipments of 166 cases and baskets in place of 360 large cases18. A further note, "L.-P. di Cesnola et ses prétendues découvertes à Soli" (L'Homme, 10 November 1884), used the Halm album, Froehner's catalogue and the editions of Cyprus to show how Cesnola's provenances wandered16. Marangou says that article reported an old photographic album of the Cesnola Collection held by an artist in New York working under the name G. R. Halm, with a handwritten note by Cesnola beside each photograph4. De Morgan concluded that Cesnola had identified a temple of Cybele at Soli from a statue he had earlier said he found at Salamis16. In 1885 he published the French text of the Christofis testimony and Cesnola's letter to Clarence Cook of 23 August 18758.

Olivier Masson wrote in 1984 that de Morgan spread Ohnefalsch-Richter's first-hand testimony to a wider public and that his conclusion was generally adopted8. Masson found that the manuscript's Curium section added nothing essential to the articles, and valued it for its ephemeral documents, "anecdotique et polémique, mais très vivante"14. In 2001 Masson called it "un livre venimeux" by "un autre curieux personnage", left "heureusement" in manuscript1. Boucher judges it rich and worth closer study6.

New York sales, Egypt and death

His collection of Greek art, with iridescent glass, vases and terracotta figurines, was sold at the American Art Galleries in New York on 12-13 March19. On 16 January 1909 the Fifth Avenue Art Galleries sold Greek vases, glass, gems and coins selected and catalogued by him10. In 1906-7 and 1907-8 he dug in Upper Egypt, partly for the Brooklyn Museum, and some objects went to Saint-Germain-en-Laye14,20.

He died at the château d'Orliénas (Rhône) on 13 November 1909, of a "congestion cérébrale", leaving a son of five7,12. Masson gave the year as 19101,8. The notices disagree on his age: 54 in L'Homme préhistorique, his fifty-fifth year in The Numismatist, and fifty-six in the Journal des débats and the Chronique des arts7,12,21,22.

Life and work

  1. 1868

    1. 1868–1883

      Wrote an unpublished book-manuscript against Cesnola (1883, Musée des Antiquités Nationales), copying notes from Froehner's notebook on Cesnola's 1868–70 letters.

      Masson 1990, 'Correspondances chypriotes', Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 14.2n. 41

  2. 1875

    1. 1875–1885

      Published (1885) Cesnola's 1875 letter to Clarence Cook; a 'de Morgan Collection' was the subject of a Feuardent paper (1878).

      Cahiers CEC 1 (1984) p. 8; Marangou 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola, p. 328

  3. 1884

    1. 10 November

      Article in L'Homme reporting that a New York artist, G. R. Halm, held an old photographic album of the Cesnola collection annotated by Cesnola

      A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 97

Connections

4 people

Mentioned in

14 mentions

Documents · 10

Institutions · 1

  • Musée d'Archéologie nationale

    1883

    Henri de Morgan's unpublished manuscript 'Archéologie chypriote. Une enquête sur certaines découvertes en Chypre. L'affaire Cesnola' later enters the museum's…

    Boucher 2012; Masson 1990

Sources

  1. 1.Veronica Tatton-Brown (ed.) (2001). Cyprus in the 19th Century AD: Fact, Fancy and Fiction. Oxford, Oxbow.
  2. 2.Marie-Christine Hellmann (1991). “W. Froehner et Chypre”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 16, 17-28. Online
  3. 3.O. Masson (1990). “Correspondances chypriotes: lettres des frères Colonna-Ceccaldi et de L. Palma di Cesnola à W. Froehner”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 14, 29-44. Online
  4. 4.A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
  5. 5.G. L. Feuardent (1885). The Cesnola Collection and the De Morgan Collection.
  6. 6.Anaïs Boucher (2012). “La collection chypriote du musée d'Archéologie nationale (MAN) de Saint-Germain-en-Laye”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 42, 159-179. Online
  7. 7. (1910). “Henry de Morgan [obituary]”. L'Homme préhistorique.
  8. 8.O. Masson (1984). “Cesnola et le trésor de Curium (I)”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 1.
  9. 9. (1909). “[Death notice of Henri de Morgan]”. Le Figaro.
  10. 10. (2023). “[Attic red-figure vessel, accession 2023.3: provenance record]”. Cleveland Museum of Art online collection.
  11. 11. (1982). “[Article on the Brooklyn Museum Egyptian collection]”. Apollo.
  12. 12. (1909). “[Death notice of Henry de Morgan]”. Journal des débats politiques et littéraires.
  13. 13.American Numismatic and Archaeological Society. Proceedings of the American Numismatic and Archaeological Society (bound run 1878-1886).
  14. 14.O. Masson (1984). “Cesnola et le trésor de Curium (II)”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 2.
  15. 15. (1884). “[Note on the Cesnola affair]”. Courrier de l'art.
  16. 16.André Vayson de Pradenne (1932). Les fraudes en archéologie préhistorique.
  17. 17. (1884). “[Report on the Cesnola controversy, translated from the Courrier de l'art]”. The New York Times 34.
  18. 18.Henri de Morgan (1884). “[Article on Cesnola's Cyprus and the Curium treasure]”. Courrier de l'art.
  19. 19. (1901). Greek Art: Iridescent Glass, Greek Vases, Terra Cotta Figurines and Groups: the Collection of Henry de Morgan. American Art Galleries, New York.
  20. 20.Encyclopedia of the Archaeology of Ancient Egypt.
  21. 21.J. de L. (1910). “Obituary: Henri de Morgan”. The Numismatist 23.
  22. 22. (1909). “[Death notice of Henry de Morgan]”. La Chronique des arts et de la curiosité.
  23. 23.Masson 1990, 'Correspondances chypriotes', Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 14.2n. 41.
  24. 24.Cahiers CEC 1 (1984) p. 8; Marangou 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola.
  25. 25.Marie-Christine Hellmann, 1991, W. Froehner et Chypre.
  26. 26.Hellmann 1991, 'W. Froehner et Chypre', CCEC 16.
  27. 27.O. Masson (ed. E. Masson) 2001, 'Luigi Palma di Cesnola – ultimes considérations', in Tatton-Brown (ed.), Cyprus in the 19th Century AD.
  28. 28.Anaïs Boucher, 2012, La collection chypriote du musée d'Archéologie nationale (MAN) de Saint-Germain-en-Laye.
  29. 29.M.-C. Hellmann, 1991, W. Froehner et Chypre; Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904.
  30. 30.M.-C. Hellmann, 1991, W. Froehner et Chypre.
  31. 31.Ernest Leroux, Revue Archeologique (quatrieme Serie Tome.5) (1905).
  32. 32.The New York Times 1884-11-24: Vol 34 Iss 10366 (1884).
  33. 33.Revue archéologique.
  34. 34.Bursian, Konrad, 1830-1883, [from old catalog] ed; Müller, Iwan Philipp Eduard, Ritter von, 1830-1917, [from old catalog] ed; Seyffert, Oskar, 1841-1906, [from old catalog] ed, Jahresbericht über die Fortschritte der klassischen Altertumswissenschaft (1894).
  35. 35.Vayson de Pradenne, André (1888-1939), Les fraudes en archéologie préhistorique : avec quelques exemples de comparaison en archéologie générale et sciences naturelles (1932).

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.