Article · 2014
Using Open-Source Data to Identify Participation in the Illicit Antiquities Trade: A Case Study on the Cypriot Civil War
European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 20
An article on participation in looting and collecting Cypriot antiquities before and during the 1963–74 civil war, read from the findspots in two Louvre catalogues and the Pierides and Severis collections.
Hardy uses collection catalogues, demographic information and historical records to follow the development of the Cypriot antiquities trade and the communities involved in looting, before and during the civil war. He compares two pre-conflict collections in the Musée du Louvre, one of Bronze Age and one of Chalcolithic-to-Roman antiquities, with the Pierides and Leto and Costakis Severis collections formed during the conflict. A timeline runs from the Ottoman conquest in 1571 through changes in antiquities law under Ottoman and British rule to the Republic of Cyprus in 1960, the civil war from 1963, the Turkish invasion of 1974 and the 1983 declaration of the "Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus".
Hardy classifies the findspot information in the catalogues and cross-references it with community demographics and historical context. He treats some qualified findspots as reliable enough for analysis, leaves objects found outside Cyprus out of the comparison between communities, and notes that missing or vague provenance limits the results (pp. 463–466).
Hardy argues that the provenance data contradict the account of a trade in which Turkish Cypriots looted and Greek Cypriots collected. Hardy finds that the pre-conflict samples broadly reflect the demographic proportions of the two communities. In the conflict-period collections the findspots indicate disproportionate Turkish Cypriot participation, alongside evidence of Greek Cypriot looting and collecting, and the ratios differ among the collections; Hardy cautions that the samples are too small for precise estimates. He also argues that state policy and archaeological interpretation helped sustain a misleading account of the trade (pp. 466–472).
What it records
- The 1973 amnesty legalised the private collections of the programme's silent partners, Hardy reports.p. 462
- Of 319 objects in the pre-conflict public collection, 214 were neither scientifically excavated, found through survey nor found accidentally, Hardy reports.p. 466
- Of 19 Louvre Bronze Age objects with fairly reliable findspots, Hardy classifies 16 as probably looted by Greek Cypriots and three by Turkish Cypriots.p. 467
- Of 66 Louvre Chalcolithic-to-Roman antiquities with fairly reliable findspots, Hardy classifies 60 as probably looted by Greek Cypriots and six by Turkish Cypriots.p. 468
- Of 16 conflict-period antiquities with findspots in the 1973 Pierides catalogue, Hardy classifies ten as probably looted by Turkish Cypriots and six by Greek Cypriots.p. 469
- The June 1972 Pierides inventory counted 2,236 objects and the 2008 inventory around 4,000, Hardy reports.p. 469
- Of 17 conflict-period antiquities with findspots in the 1985 Pierides catalogue, Hardy classifies nine as probably looted by Turkish Cypriots and eight by Greek Cypriots.p. 470
- All 288 objects catalogued in the 1999 and 2010 Severis collection volumes were probably looted during the civil war, Hardy states; 211 have no provenance information.p. 470
- Of 77 Severis collection objects with findspots, Hardy classifies 42 as probably looted by Turkish Cypriots and 35 by Greek Cypriots.p. 470
- Karageorghis recorded the looting of the Alaas cemetery in 1973 and the presence of 93 objects from the site in the Hadjiprodromou Collection, Hardy reports.p. 472
Where to read
- Method, provenance categories and limitations of the collection datapp. 463–466
- Louvre collection samples and pre-conflict community participationpp. 467–468
- Pierides and Severis collection samples from the civil-war periodpp. 469–471
Contents
- Introduction459
- The Early History of the Illicit Trade in Cypriot Antiquities461
- The Looting Crisis462
- Methodology463
- Adapting the Cycladic Method for the Cypriot Market463
- The Limitations of the Data465
- Results466
- The Immediate Implications of the Data466
- Those who Live Together, Loot Together: Illicit Excavation Under Colonial Rule467
- The Musée du Louvre’s pre-Conflict Collection of Bronze Age Cypriot Antiquities467
- The Musée du Louvre’s pre-Conflict Collection of Chalcolithic to Roman Cypriot Antiquities467
- An Impression of Participation in the pre-Conflict Trade468
- Bicommunal Business Amidst Civil War469
- The Pierides Foundation Museum Collection469
- The Leto and Costakis Severis Collection470
- An Impression of Participation in the Conflict Antiquities Trade471
- Conclusion471
- References472
People, places and institutions
People
- Demetrios Zeno Pieridescollector of the Pierides collection
- Vassos Karageorghisarchaeologist and author of collection catalogues
- Sophocles Hadjisavvaslater antiquities director cited on illicit collections
- Pavlos Flourentzosarchaeologist discussing a terracotta findspot
- Greg Deftereoslooting ethnographer cited on provenance descriptions
- Stella Lubsen-Admiraalauthor of the Zintilis collection catalogue
- Robert Hamilton LangBritish vice-consul and antiquities collector
- Luigi Palma di CesnolaAmerican consul and antiquities collector
- Wilfrid Jerome Farrellcritic of the Cyprus Museum Committee
- Max Ohnefalsch-Richterarchaeologist whose work was funded by sales
- Kyriakos Nikolaoucurator distinguishing find types
Institutions
- Musée du Louvrerepository of the pre-conflict collections analysed
- Pierides Foundation Museumrepository of a conflict-period collection
- Department of Antiquitiesstate authority for antiquities policy
Places
- Dalifindspot of Louvre antiquities
- Athienoufindspot discussed in provenance analysis
- Alaascemetery reported looted during the civil war
Also named: Costakis and Leto Severis Foundation, Paul Åström's Forlag.
Extent pp. 459–474, 4 figs
ModernChalcolithicEarly Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeLate AntiqueRomanCollectingLooting and the LawHistory of ArchaeologyMuseumsTrade
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 pageWho did what
6 recordsBuying, selling and giving 5
- 1870–1876 · p. 461
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toMetropolitan Museum of Art
Cesnola agreed to sell his collection to the Metropolitan Museum for £1,200.
£1,200New York
- 1870 · p. 461
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toLouvre
The Louvre acquired objects at Cesnola's Paris sale.
objets de ses collections
- 1871–1876 · p. 461
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toBritish Museum
Cesnola sold a substantial series of antiquities directly to the British Museum through Birch.
more than eighty vases, terracottas and other objectsNo. 1876.9-9, 1 à 127300 livresLondon
- p. 461
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toImperial Ottoman Museum
In negotiations with Doell, the Imperial Museum's agent, Cesnola estimated his collection's value at 270,000 to 400,000 francs.
between 270.000 and 400.000 francs
- p. 467
Demetrios Z. PieridesConnected withDepartment of Antiquities
possiblyPierides was said to have acted in consultation with the Department of Antiquities.
Recording and study 1
- p. 461
Demetrios Z. PieridesConnected withRobert Hamilton Lang
Pierides introduced antiquarianism to his vice-consul, Robert Hamilton Lang.
People it is cited for
16 people- Thanos N. Zintilis7 citations
- Vassos Karageorghis5 citations
- P. Hopkirk3 citations
- Stella M. Lubsen-Admiraal3 citations
- Carolyn Elliott2 citations
- Demosthenis C. Severis2 citations
- Leto Severis2 citations
- Anastasia Leriou
- Greg Deftereos
- N. Brodie
- Paul Åström
- Pavlos Flourentzos
- Robert Hamilton Lang
- Sophocles Hadjisavvas
- Demetrios Pierides
- Wilfrid Jerome Farrell
Institutions it is cited for
4 institutions- Costakis and Leto Severis Foundation2 citations
- Pierides Museum2 citations
- University of Sussex2 citations
- Musée du Louvre
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.