Article · 2006
Une nouvelle étude de l'Apollon Chatsworth
A. Bouquillon, S. Descamps, A. Hermary and B. Mille
Revue archéologique 2006(2) 227-261
An article on the bronze Chatsworth Apollo head and the Louvre leg Br 69, their provenance, manufacture and fifth-century BCE date, reassessing whether they belong to one statue.
Bouquillon, Descamps, Hermary and Mille ask whether the bronze head known as the Chatsworth Apollo and the Louvre leg Br 69 belonged to one statue. They set archive research on the leg's provenance beside radiography, alloy analysis and core comparisons, then place the statue among Cypriot bronzes and limestone sculpture of the fifth century BCE. The first part follows the fragments from discovery to their present collections, the technical sections treat the leg and the comparative analyses, and the closing sections turn to dating and to what the statue shows of Cyprus around the middle of the century.
The head was found near the Pediaeos, north of Tamassos, in 1836, and passed through Larnaca to the Duke of Devonshire. The leg's records conflict: it is reported as a gift from a member of the Mattei family and later as a bequest from Péretié, with Saïda given as its findspot. The authors argue that De Ridder had grounds for entering it as a Mattei gift from Cyprus, and they review Duthoit's report of a bronze thigh in a Mattei house in 1862 (pp. 230–234).
The evidence
Study of the leg combines visual examination, radiography and analysis of the casting and soldering metals. The authors describe hollow lost-wax casting, boundaries between mould parts, bronze spacers, soldering joints, cold-worked areas and casting defects. Elemental analysis sets the leg's alloy beside earlier analyses of the head, and clay cores from both fragments are compared mineralogically. Thermoluminescence on the leg's core gave a date the authors regard as inconclusive (pp. 237–253).
Bronze figures from Kourion, Idalion and Vouni, and limestone sculpture from Malloura, Golgoi and Tamassos, supply the comparisons for style and proportion (pp. 234–237, 257–260).
The argument
Head and leg are very probably fragments of one statue, the authors conclude, about 2.10 m tall and standing with both feet flat on the ground as the Kourion statuette does. They place it around 460–450 BCE and ascribe it to a Cypriot artist working in a Greek style. They take up earlier proposals of a first-century BCE date, resting on technical features read as late, and argue that those features fit a provincial production of 460–450 BCE (pp. 255–257).
The statue is then related to changes in Cypriot sculpture and political history around the middle of the fifth century BCE. The authors suggest the dedication may correspond to a major event and leave its identification open, and they read the limestone heads from Malloura, Golgoi and Tamassos as evidence for how its sculptural influence spread (pp. 257–261).
What it records
- The Chatsworth Apollo statue was found near the Pediaeos, north of Tamassos, in 1836.p. 230
- The Duke of Devonshire acquired the Chatsworth head from Borrell in Smyrne in 1838 or 1839.p. 230
- In 1862 Edmond Duthoit reported seeing a bronze statue thigh in a house belonging to M. Mattei Sancti.p. 231
- The bronze leg in the Louvre reaches a maximum height of 1.07 m.p. 237
- The wall of the Louvre leg is about 7 mm thick at the points measured.p. 239
- At least six partial moulds went into casting the Louvre leg, in the authors' inference.p. 242
- The leg's bronze contains about 10 per cent tin and less than 0.1 per cent lead.p. 251
- Thermoluminescence on the leg's core gave a dose of 93 gray, which indicated a prehistoric date.p. 253
- The statue dates to around 460–450 BCE, the authors argue.p. 255
- A Cypriot artist working in a Greek style made the statue, the authors propose.p. 256
- Cores of the Chatsworth head and the Louvre leg share aragonite and other mineralogical features, the authors report.p. 257
- The statue formed by the Chatsworth head and Louvre leg probably stood about 2.10 m high, in the authors' argument.p. 257
Where to read
- Discovery accounts and the fragments' provenancepp. 230–234
- Louvre leg Br 69: casting, moulds and solderingpp. 237–250
- Alloy and casting-core comparisons between leg and headpp. 251–255
- Dating and reconstruction of the statuepp. 255–257
- Tamassos and Cypriot sculpture around the middle of the fifth centurypp. 257–261
Contents
- Origine de la statue, dispersion des fragments230
- Les bronzes figurés à Chypre au Ve siècle234
- Étude technique de la jambe Br 69237
- Les analyses comparatives des alliages de la jambe du Louvre et de la « tête Chatsworth »250
- Étude comparative des noyaux de coulée252
- Technique et datation de la « tête Chatsworth »255
- La datation de la jambe du Louvre256
- La statue de Tamassos, témoin des mutations historiques et artistiques autour du milieu du Ve siècle257
Objects published here
7- Bronze head of the Chatsworth Apollo, British Museum, Tamassos, selon l’article, 1958.4-18.1, fig. 39 (p. fig. 39)
- Bronze leg, Louvre, Département des Antiquités grecques, étrusques et romaines, Tamassos, selon l’article, Br 69, figs 3–6, 35 (p. 229)
- Bronze statuette from Kourion, Metropolitan Museum of Art, Kourion-Ayia Anna, 74.51.5679, fig. 12 (p. 235)
- Bronze lion from Cyprus, Istanbul, Musée archéologique, Chypre, origine précise inconnue, 77, figs 9–11 (p. 235)
- Limestone head from Malloura, Louvre, Malloura, AM 2936, fig. 36 (p. 259)
- Limestone head from Golgoi, Louvre, Golgoi, AM 2950, fig. 37 (p. 259)
- Fragments of a limestone head, Tamassos, fouilles H.-G. Buchholz, fig. 38 (p. 259)
People, places and institutions
People
- Edmond Duthoitreported a bronze thigh in 1862
- André De Riddercatalogued the Louvre leg
- Ernst Langlotzproposed linking the head and leg
- L. Rossrecorded accounts of the statue's discovery
- Max Ohnefalsch-Richterexcavated the sanctuary in 1889
- Louis de Clercqformed a collection with Péretié's help
- Aimé Péretiécollector and reported intermediary for the leg
Institutions
- British Museumholds the Chatsworth head
- Louvreholds the bronze leg Br 69
- Centre de Recherche et de Restauration des Musées de Francecarried out the technical and material analyses
Places
- Tamassosfindspot and sanctuary of the statue
- Pediaeosriver near the statue's findspot
- Kourionsource of bronze athlete statuettes
- Idalionsanctuary and kingdom used in comparisons
- Vounisanctuary with bronze votive sculptures
- Mallourasource of limestone sculpture compared with the statue
- Golgoisource of a limestone head used in comparison
- Saïdastated findspot of the leg in an administrative record
- Larnacawhere the head and leg were held
Also named: M. Mattei Sancti, Dyfri Williams, Veronica Tatton-Brown, Vasilia, Lapithos, Palaepaphos, Borrell, Duke of Devonshire, Cyprus Museum, Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Extent figs 1–39; maps in figs 7–8; French summary and English abstract p. 227
Cypro-ClassicalCypro-ArchaicHellenisticSculptureCopperTechnologyChronology and DatingHistory of Archaeology
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
2 pages- The First Photographs of CyprusArticle
- Cypro-Classical CyprusCompendium
Excavations it is cited for
1 project- 1889–1894Tamassos: Ohnefalsch-Richter's excavations for the Berlin Museums, 1889 and 1894Directed by Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavation
Who did what
9 recordsBuying, selling and giving 4
- 1838–1839 · p. 230
William George Spencer Cavendish, 6th Duke of DevonshireBought fromHenry Perigal Borrell
The Duke bought seven antiquities from Borrell at Smyrna, including the bronze Apollo head.
7 objects of antiquity, including a large bronze head of Apollo15 English Pounds
- p. 230
- 1882 · p. 233
Napoléon Antoine Aimé PéretiéConnected withLouis Constantin Henri François-Xavier de Clercq
Péretié supplied Louis de Clercq with nearly two thirds of his collection.
près des deux tiers de sa collection
- p. 233
Napoléon Antoine Aimé PéretiéAcquired
possiblyThe authors suggested that Péretié may have received the bronze from its true owner as an intermediary in a transaction with France.
With son véritable propriétairele bronze
Excavation 1
- 1889 · p. 230
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavated
Ohnefalsch-Richter excavated the sanctuary and uncovered bronze fragments, statuettes, and limestone sculptures.
fragments de grands bronzes, deux statuettes archaïques en bronze et sculptures en calcairesanctuaire de Tamassos
Recording and study 4
- 1905–1911 · p. 232
André de RidderPublished material ofLouis Constantin Henri François-Xavier de Clercq
De Ridder published and photographed the De Clercq collection, including the limestone female head.
Collection De Clercq, including a limestone female headNo. n° 95, pl. XV
- p. 232
André de RidderCatalogued the collection ofMusée du Louvre
De Ridder catalogued the Louvre’s ancient bronzes, including the leg identified as Br 69.
Bronzes antiques du musée, dont la jambe Br 69No. Br 69
- p. 252
Dyfri WilliamsLent toCentre de Recherche et de Restauration des Musées de France
Williams entrusted refractory-clay samples from the bronze held at the British Museum to the Centre.
échantillons de terre réfractaire prélevés à l'intérieur du bronze
- p. 252
Veronica Tatton-BrownLent toCentre de Recherche et de Restauration des Musées de France
Tatton-Brown entrusted refractory-clay samples from the bronze held at the British Museum to the Centre.
échantillons de terre réfractaire prélevés à l'intérieur du bronze
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.