Article · 2016
Ethnicity and musical identity in the lyric landscape of early Cyprus
Greek and Roman Musical Studies 4
An article on lyre images in Late Bronze and Iron Age Cyprus, arguing for local musical traditions shaped by contact with Aegean and Levantine cultures.
Franklin examines how lyre images relate to cultural identity in Cyprus from the Late Bronze Age through the Iron Age. He reassesses the reading of round-based lyres as Aegean, presents a Late Bronze Age faience bowl as evidence for Levantine musical connections, and analyses the different lyre forms on Cypro-Phoenician symposium bowls. The sections are headed The Current Picture, A Lost 'Daughter of Kinyras' in the Cyprus Museum, Round-Based Lyres between East and West, and East Meets West: The Cypro-Phoenician Symposium Bowls.
The evidence
The Late Bronze Age material centres on a broken faience bowl in the Cyprus Museum, in which Franklin sees a female lyre-player beside a dancer and the god Bes. He compares its instrument and costume with Levantine, Egyptian and Anatolian images, and brings in related faience scenes and the processed tortoise-shells from the Uluburun wreck (pp. 150–153).
For the early Iron Age he turns to an eleventh-century kálathos from Kouklia, the Kaloriziki vase and the Hubbard amphora, and matches their details against images from the Aegean and the eastern Mediterranean, among them lyres with zigzag arms. A table then classifies the ensembles and lyre forms on symposium bowls from Lefkandi, Golgoi, Idalion, Kourion, Salamis, Olympia and other findspots, following Markoe's phases (pp. 157–162).
The argument
Franklin challenges the assumption that round-based lyres on early Iron Age Cyprus mark Aegean immigration. He proposes that they may be Cypro-Aegean hybrids with roots on the island, and that Cyprus lay in a contested zone between the customary eastern and western lyre categories (pp. 148–157).
On the symposium bowls he treats the contrast between eastern and western lyre forms as culturally meaningful, while cautioning that it does not map neatly onto Phoenician and Aegean identities. The western lyres on bowls found in Cyprus, and on the Olympia bowl, he proposes Cypriot workshops, allowing for circulation and mixed cultural settings. He concludes that pre-Greek Cyprus had musical connections with the Levant and that its round-based lyres cannot be taken as straightforward evidence of Aegean identity (pp. 157–165).
Dating
Franklin dates the faience bowl stylistically to the fourteenth–thirteenth century (LC II) and the early Iron Age imagery from the eleventh century onwards. He dates the symposium bowls to c. 900–600 BCE and organises the examples by Markoe's phases I–IV, noting uncertainty in the typological dating.
What it records
- The Cyprus Museum faience bowl is unprovenanced and dated stylistically to the fourteenth–thirteenth century (LC II).p. 150
- The Cyprus Museum bowl is Inv. G63, 4.2 cm high and 13.2 cm in diameter.p. 150
- The left-hand figure on the bowl is a female lyre-player accompanying the dancer, in Franklin's reading, with the god Bes overseeing the performance.p. 151
- R. Eichmann and S. Psaroudakes concluded that processed tortoise-shells from the Uluburun wreck were intended for Egyptian-style lutes.p. 153
- An eleventh-century kálathos from Kouklia shows a warrior holding a round-based lyre.p. 154
- Franklin proposes that round-based lyres in early Iron Age Cyprus may have been Cypro-Aegean hybrids with roots on the island before the Iron Age.p. 157
- Franklin dates the Cypro-Phoenician symposium bowls discussed to c. 900–600 BCE.p. 157
- Franklin proposes that the western lyre on the Olympia bowl most likely came from a Cypriot workshop.p. 164
Where to read
- The Cyprus Museum faience bowl and its lyre-playerpp. 150–153
- The Kouklia kálathos and early round-based lyrespp. 154–157
- Musicians and cult scenes on the symposium bowlspp. 159–161
- Eastern and western lyre forms and their findspotspp. 161–165
Contents
- The Current Picture146
- A Lost 'Daughter of Kinyras' in the Cyprus Museum150
- Round-Based Lyres between East and West153
- East Meets West: The Cypro-Phoenician Symposium Bowls157
Objects published here
6- Broken faience bowl with a female lyre-player, Cyprus Museum, Unprovenanced, G63, Figure 1 (p. 150)
- Egyptianizing faience dish with a female lute-player, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, Said to be from near Idalion, 74.51.5074 (p. 152)
- Eleventh-century proto-bichrome kálathos with a warrior holding a lyre, Kouklia, T.9:7, Figure 2 (p. 154)
- Hubbard amphora with funerary musical scenes, Cyprus Museum, Famagusta district, 1938/XI-2/3, Figure 4 (p. 156)
- Symposium bowl Cy3 with a musical scene, Idalion, 74.51.5700, Cy3, Figure 5 (p. 173)
- Symposium bowl G3 with a western-type lyre, Olympia, Athens 7941, G3, Figure 9 (p. 176)
People, places and institutions
People
- P. Dikaiosdescribed the faience bowl
- Besgod overseeing the bowl scene
- KinyrasCypriot culture-hero linked to the lyre
- Lawergrenproposed eastern and western lyre categories
- Deger-Jalkotzyread lyre features as Aegean markers
- Fariselliinterpreted scenes on symposium bowls
- Sherrattdiscussed Cypriot hybridity and Aegean imagery
- Markoeclassified symposium bowls into phases
- Coldstreamcompared the Kouklia vase with Kinyras
Institutions
- Cyprus Museumholds the faience bowl Inv. G63
Places
- Kouklia/Old Paphosfindspot of an eleventh-century kálathos
- Enkomisanctuary with fragmentary terracotta figurines
- Kourionfindspot of several symposium bowls
- Idalionfindspot of a bowl and faience dish
- Salamisfindspot of a symposium bowl and terracottas
- KitionPhoenician political centre and cult analogy
- Uluburunwreck with processed tortoise-shells
- Lefkandifindspot of a bowl and lyre imagery
- Megiddofindspot of an eleventh-century jug with a lyrist
- Nimrudsource of comparative ivories and bowl imagery
- Olympiafindspot of bowl G3
- Cretefindspot region for symposium bowls
- Ugaritsource of musical and cult comparisons
- Golgoiattributed source of an Egyptianizing statue
- Kalorizikifindspot of a late tenth-century vase
Extent pp. 146–176, 9 figs, 1 map; bibliography
Late Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicReligion and CultForeign ContactsIconographyChronology and Dating
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 pageWho did what
2 recordsRecording and study 2
- 1961 · p. 150
Porphyrios DikaiosPublished
P. Dikaios described the faience bowl in a guide to the Cyprus Museum.
No. Nicosia, Inv. G63
- p. 151
John Curtis FranklinStudied
J. C. Franklin reconstructed the bowl’s figure as a musician playing a Levantine-type lyre.
faience bowlNo. Nicosia, Inv. G63Cyprus Museum
Mentioned in
3 mentionsTomb records · 2
- Kourion-Kaloriziki, Dikaios Tomb 11
Discussion · 2016 · p. 155
Nicosia, Kaloriziki Tomb 11, no. 5: Dikaios 1936-1937, 71; Rutten 1939, 442; Karageorghis & des Gagniers 1974, 1.33, 2.97 (no. IX.1).
- Maroni-Tsaroukkas, BM Tomb 17
Objects from the tomb · 2016 · p. 152
London, BM (18)98.12-1.145, from Maroni, tomb 17: Johnson 1980, 24, no. 136, pl. XXVI.136
- On Ancient Cyprus · 1listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.