Chapter · 2001

Excavations in Cyprus and the 'Mycenaean Question'

J. Lesley Fitton; edited by V. Tatton-Brown

In Cyprus in the 19th Century AD 149-152. Oxbow

A chapter on how nineteenth-century scholars dated Cypriot Bronze Age finds called Mycenaean, and on the effect of excavation and recording on their reading of the British Museum's Enkomi, Amathus and Kourion finds.

Fitton traces how scholars of the late nineteenth century classified and dated Bronze Age material from Cyprus identified as Mycenaean, concentrating on Alexander Murray's reading of the British Museum excavations at Enkomi, Amathus and Kourion, published as Murray, Smith and Walters' Excavations in Cyprus. The chapter sets Newton's compressed scheme and Murray's seventh-century dating against the higher dates of Tsountas and Manatt, Helbig and Evans, and describes how links with Egypt and the dating of finds from Gurob fed arguments for an earlier Greek Bronze Age.

Murray dated the material to the seventh century BC, Fitton argues, because he understood it as Greek and wished to associate it with east Greek art. He discounted evidence connecting it with Egypt, scarabs included, and handled comparisons with Gurob glass vessels cautiously. Fitton calls this reading partisan while allowing that the evidence and chronology were uncertain at the time. She points to weaknesses in excavation and recording, among them the preferential saving of Mycenaean vases and the loss of plainer local wares, and discusses Enkomi ivories, glass vessels, a scarab and an imported stirrup jar (pp. 149–151).

The British Museum publication, Fitton concludes, reflects nineteenth-century approaches to excavation, recording and interpretation. It still recognised an octopus stirrup jar from Tomb 50 as probably imported from Crete and read writing on terracotta balls as resembling pictographs discussed by Arthur Evans (p. 152).

What it records

  • Charles Newton linked the finds from Mycenae with material from Ialysos and Cyprus.p. 149
  • Alexander Murray described the material as Mycenaean but dated it to the seventh century BC.p. 149
  • Helbig placed Mycenaean material in the fourteenth century BC and associated it with an early phase of Phoenician culture.p. 150
  • The scarab from Enkomi Tomb 93 bears the name of Queen Ti, wife of Amenhotep III.p. 150
  • Enkomi Tomb 66 is said to have held three glass vessels shaped like pomegranates.p. 151
  • The excavators tended to save Mycenaean vases and discard plainer local wares, which distorted the picture the tombs gave, Fitton argues.p. 151
  • The large pseudamphora from Tomb 50 was described as probably imported from Crete.p. 152

Where to read

  • Newton's and Murray's dating schemespp. 149–150
  • Scarabs and glass vessels from Enkomipp. 150–151
  • Excavation methods, recording and local warespp. 151–152

Objects published here

5
  • Scarab bearing the name of Queen Ti, British Museum, Enkomi, Tomb 93, GR1897.4–1.608, Excavations pl IV no. 608, pl IV (p. 150)
  • Glass vase shaped like a pomegranate, British Museum, Enkomi, Tomb 66, GR 1897.4–1.1052 (p. 151)
  • Glass vase shaped like a pomegranate, British Museum, Enkomi, Tomb 66, GR 1897.4–1.1053 (p. 151)
  • Glass vase shaped like a pomegranate, British Museum, Enkomi, Tomb 66, GR 1897.4–1.1056 (p. 151)
  • Large pseudamphora, Enkomi, Tomb 50, fig 128 (p. 152)

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

  • British Museumconducted excavations in Cyprus

Places

  • Enkomisource of tomb finds discussed
  • Kourionsource of British Museum excavation finds
  • Ialysoscomparison for Mycenaean material
  • Mycenaecomparison for Mycenaean finds
  • Gurobsource of pottery and glass comparisons
  • Cretesource proposed for a stirrup jar
  • Cameirossource of material compared with Enkomi finds
  • Aiginasource of a Mycenaean treasure

Also named: Olivier Masson, Queen Ti, Amenhotep III, Amathus.

Extent pp. 149–152

Defines Mycenaean Question

Late Bronze AgeModernChronology and DatingHistory of ArchaeologyPotteryForeign Contacts

Who did what

8 records

Recording and study 5

  • Alexander Stuart MurrayWorked withArthur Hamilton Smith

    Alexander Murray published Excavations in Cyprus with Smith as a collaborator.

    Excavation results from Enkomi, Amathus and Kourion

    1900 · p. 149
  • Alexander Stuart MurrayWorked withHenry Beauchamp Walters

    Alexander Murray published Excavations in Cyprus with Walters as a collaborator.

    Excavation results from Enkomi, Amathus and Kourion

    1900 · p. 149
  • Alexander Stuart MurrayPublished material ofBritish Museum

    Alexander Murray published results from the British Museum excavations in Cyprus.

    Excavation results from Enkomi, Amathus and Kourion

    1900 · p. 149
  • Arthur Hamilton SmithPublished material ofBritish Museum

    A.H. Smith collaborated with Murray and Walters on the publication of British Museum excavation results.

    Excavation results from Enkomi, Amathus and KourionCyprus

    1900 · p. 149
  • Henry Beauchamp WaltersPublished material ofBritish Museum

    H.B. Walters collaborated with Murray and Smith on the publication of British Museum excavation results.

    Excavation results from Enkomi, Amathus and KourionCyprus

    1900–1902 · p. 149

Posts and family 3

People it is cited for

1 person

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.