Book · 2012
Materia Magica: The Archaeology of Magic in Roman Egypt, Cyprus, and Spain
Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press
A study of magical practice through archaeological context and objects, with case studies of Karanis in Egypt, Amathous in Cyprus and Empúries in Spain.
Wilburn examines how archaeological remains can be identified and interpreted as evidence of magical practice. He sets out an object-centred method and applies it to material from Karanis in Egypt, Amathous in Cyprus and Empúries in Spain, working from papyri, ostraca, figurines, animal bones and curse tablets and from their findspots, associated objects and deposition.
For Egypt he draws on the Greek and Demotic Magical Papyri as comparative evidence, and cautions that their recipes give no universal template for other places.
How it is organised
An introduction opens with the curse tablets from the Via Appia near Rome and outlines the three case studies. Chapter 1, Finding Magic in the Archaeological Record, and chapter 2, Materia Magica, establish the approach and classify the materials used in rites: inscribed objects, images and figurines, plants, animals and natural ingredients, and household objects repurposed for magical use (pp. 54–94). Chapters 3 to 5 take Karanis, Amathous and Empúries in turn, and chapter 6 reviews the method and draws the cases together. Two appendices describe the University of Michigan excavations at Karanis and list bones from Areas 262 and 265; a bibliography and index follow.
The argument
Magical practice, Wilburn argues, is best understood through the individual object's history, its archaeological context and the process by which it was deposited. Comparative texts help identify and interpret material, and each local find is then tested against its own context. He stresses the limits that incomplete or uncertain excavation records impose, and the risk of treating unusual objects as magical without adequate contextual support (pp. 12–53).
The concluding chapter treats magic as a practice that could be known within a community while remaining partly concealed, and returns to the need for careful contextual records (pp. 260–269).
The cases range from the first century CE to the fourth or fifth. The Amathous tablets are dated by palaeography and letter forms, and the Empúries chapter discusses tablets spanning the fourth or third century BCE to the Roman period while dating the Ballesta group, from its historical and archaeological context, to the first century CE.
Karanis
The Karanis evidence includes Gemellus's account of an alleged magical attack involving a brephos, a fever amulet from beneath House 242, an ostracon from Structure C403, objects found beneath Structure 165, and decorated bones from Areas A262 and A265. Wilburn interprets them from excavation diaries, associated finds, museum objects and comparison with texts, and points out that the excavation records often lack precise stratigraphy or complete information about associations.
Wilburn reads the ostracon as part of a proposed rite to protect grain, and the lead amulet, mud figurine and bone pins beneath Structure 165 as a possible erotic rite. From these examples Wilburn distinguishes literate ritual from practices represented by objects without intelligible text. He proposes functions by comparing the objects with textual sources and contexts, and leaves the function of the painted bones unresolved. Local practice, he argues, could adapt magical forms and signs without closely following the surviving papyrus models (pp. 140–168).
Amathous
The Amathous case combines published inscriptions, collection and accession records, accounts of the tablets' discovery, and analysis of the lead and selenite objects. The tablets were reconstructed from holdings in the British Museum and the Bibliothèque Nationale, and the account of their acquisition names Charles Christian, who offered tablets to the British Museum, Gerald Handcock, who acquired tablets for it, and A. S. Murray, its antiquities conservator (pp. 177–179). The cache came from a shaft near Agios Tychonas, and the Cyprus Department of Antiquities and the French School excavated at the Amathous agora.
Wilburn reads similarities in the tablets' hands, formulae and epigraphic features as evidence for several practitioners who shared models and a place of deposition. The commissioners include Soterianos, also called Limbaros, who curses Ariston, and Alexandros, also called Makedonios, who commissions curses against officials. He treats the shaft as a possible conduit to the underworld, while recognising uncertainty over its original use and the precise location of the find, and notes that the evidence does not establish that the practitioners were attached to a temple (pp. 177–218, 263–264).
Empúries
At Empúries the three Ballesta tablets lay in cremation urns within one enclosure of the cemetery. The case draws on the tablets, their urns and cremation remains, the excavation reports and the cemetery context; Almagro Basch excavated and published the Empúries cemeteries. Wilburn interprets the curses against provincial authorities, which name the legate Titus Aurelius Fulvus and the Augustan legate Rufus and procurator Maturus, as possible resistance to Roman rule (pp. 220–253).
What it records
- Three case studies examine magical practice: Karanis in Egypt, Amathous in Cyprus and Empúries in Spain.p. 9
- A fever amulet from beneath House 242 at Karanis measures 10 by 7.5 centimetres.p. 109
- The Karanis assemblage from Areas A262 and A265 includes eighty-four decorated animal and human bones.p. 140
- The Amathous tablets are dated by palaeography and letter forms to the late second or third century CE.p. 172
- Pierre Aupert and D. Jordan documented the route by which the Amathous tablets passed from Cyprus to collections in France and Britain.p. 177
- Wilburn argues that practitioners repurposed the Amathous shaft, which may first have been a well or tomb, as a ritual conduit to the underworld.p. 184
- More than two hundred lead tablets and thirty selenite tablets can be reconstructed from fragments of the Amathous cache in the British Museum and the Bibliothèque Nationale; only sixteen lead and six selenite tablets have been published.p. 187
- Wilburn argues that at least three spell templates and several practitioners lie behind the Amathous tablets.p. 187
- Cremations 21, 22 and 23 at the Ballesta cemetery, Empúries, each contained a coarseware pitcher and a curse tablet within one enclosure.p. 220
- Wilburn argues that the Ballesta tablets were deposited with the dead near the time of burial and rejects later intrusion.p. 224
- The urn of Ballesta Tablet 2 held cremated remains and four fragmentary nail shafts; the tablet measures 5.7 by 6.0 cm.p. 225
- Wilburn argues that archaeological context can reveal local ritual practice, and that incomplete excavation records limit interpretation.p. 259
Where to read
- Via Appia curse tablets and archaeological contextpp. 1–8
- Working definition of magic and object-centred methodpp. 12–53
- Material categories and their use in magical ritespp. 54–94
- Gemellus's petition and the brephos incidentpp. 95–104
- Fever amulet beneath House 242pp. 109–117
- Ostracon from Structure C403 and a proposed grain-protection ritepp. 118–129
- Figurine, hairpins and possible erotic rite beneath Structure 165pp. 129–139
- Painted bones from Areas A262 and A265pp. 140–160
Contents
- Introduction1
- Cursing on the Via Appia, Rome1
- The Scope of This Book9
- Chapter 1: Finding Magic in the Archaeological Record12
- Looking at Magic12
- The Elusiveness of Magical Practice in the Roman Period20
- Ritual and Magic in the Archaeological Record25
- Object-Specific Inquiry34
- Locating Ritual Events Through Archaeological Contexts40
- Mediterranean Magic and Local Magic51
- Chapter 2: Materia Magica54
- Inscribed Objects65
- Images and Figurines74
- Plants, Animals, and Natural Ingredients83
- Household Objects Repurposed for Magical Use90
- Context and Magic93
- Chapter 3: Identifying the Remains of Magic in the Village of Karanis95
- An Official Accusation of Magic95
- Situating the Village105
- A Fever Amulet beneath House 242109
- A Magical Ostracon in Structure C403118
- A Love-Inducing Ritual under Structure 165129
- A Large Deposit of Painted Bones140
- Contextual Magic at Karanis160
- Chapter 4: Practitioners and Craft at Amathous, Cyprus169
- Finding Magic Rituals without the Magical Papyri169
- Historical Background173
- The Archaeological Context177
- The Material Evidence of the Curse Tablets184
- The Inscribed Texts187
- The Practitioners at Amathous200
- The Social Context of the Tablets209
- Chapter 5: Three Curses from Empúries and Their Social Implications219
- Historical Background221
- The Archaeological Context of the Ballesta Tablets224
- The Inscriptions and Their Historical Context232
- Curse Tablets and Deposition with the Dead238
- The Inscriptions and Resistance to Roman Rule246
- Chapter 6: The Archaeology of Magic254
- A Critique of the Method255
- Local Contexts and the Archaeology of Magic260
- Covert Resistance and Public Magic261
- Practitioners and Practice263
- Objects and Magical Technology in the Mediterranean264
- Coda: Back on the Via Appia269
- Appendix 1: The Excavations at Karanis275
- The Occupation Layers279
- Appendix 2: Bones from Karanis Areas 262 and 265284
- Bibliography287
Objects published here
13- Fever amulet for Sarapion, University of Michigan Papyrus Collection, Fill beneath House 242, Karanis, P.Mich. inv. 5302a, P.Mich. XVIII 768, plate 7 (p. 109)
- Magical ostracon with text including a woman and child, University of Michigan Collection, Room J, Structure C403, Karanis, O.Mich. inv. 9883, O.Mich. inv. 9883, plate 9 (p. 118)
- Headless terracotta statuette of Harpocrates, Kelsey Museum of Archaeology, Structure C403, Karanis, K.M. inv. 6453, plate 10 (p. 127)
- Lead amulet rolled and suspended on cord, Kelsey Museum of Archaeology, Below Structure 165, Karanis, K.M. inv. 24255, plate 12 (p. 130)
- Roughly made female mud figurine, Kelsey Museum of Archaeology, Below Structure 165, Karanis, K.M. inv. 7525, plate 13 (p. 131)
- Three bone pins associated with the female figurine, Kelsey Museum of Archaeology, Below Structure 165, Karanis, K.M. inv. 21776, plate 14 (p. 132)
- Painted bovine femur with line and undulating-line patterns, Kelsey Museum of Archaeology, Area 265, Karanis, K.M. inv. 10099.070; joined to K.M. inv. 3503.062, plate 16
- Lead curse tablet DT 22, commissioned by Soterianos, also called Limbaros, against Ariston, British Museum, Cache from a shaft near Agios Tychonas, BM 1891,4–18.1, DT 22, plate 20 (p. 170)
- Selenite tablet with suspension holes, British Museum, Cache from a shaft near Agios Tychonas, 1891,4–18.59, plate 21 (p. 185)
- Selenite curse tablet NGD 115, British Museum and Bibliothèque Nationale, Amathous cache, NGD 115 (p. 196)
- Ballesta Tablet 1, lead tablet from Cremation 21, Ballesta Cremation 21, Empúries, Ballesta Tablet 1, plate 24a (p. 224)
- Ballesta Tablet 2, lead tablet from Cremation 22, Ballesta Cremation 22, Empúries, Ballesta Tablet 2, plate 24b (p. 225)
- Ballesta Tablet 3, triangular lead tablet from Cremation 23, Ballesta Cremation 23, Empúries, Ballesta Tablet 3, plate 24c (p. 225)
People, places and institutions
People
- Pierre Aupertdocumented the tablets' route and excavation work
- D. Jordanstudied and published Amathous tablets
- Gemelluslandholder whose petition describes a magical attack
- Juliusnamed in Gemellus's account
- Sarapionpatient named in a fever amulet
- Soterianoscommissioned a curse tablet at Amathous
- Aristontarget of an Amathous curse tablet
- Theodorosnamed as governor of Cyprus on a tablet
- Alexandroscommissioned curses against officials
- Timontarget in Amathous tablets
- Charles Christianoffered Amathous tablets to the British Museum
- A. S. MurrayBritish Museum antiquities conservator
- Gerald Handcockacquired tablets for the British Museum
- Martin Almagro Baschexcavated and published Empúries cemeteries
- Titus Aurelius Fulvusnamed as provincial legate in tablets
- Rufusnamed as Augustan legate in tablets
- Maturusnamed as Augustan procurator in tablets
Institutions
- British Museumholds part of the Amathous cache
- Bibliothèque Nationaleholds part of the Amathous cache
- Kelsey Museum of Archaeologyholds Karanis objects and records
- University of Michiganconducted the Karanis excavations
- Cyprus Department of Antiquitiesexcavated at the Amathous agora
- French Schoolexcavated at the Amathous agora
Places
- Karaniscase study of village ritual and objects
- Amathouscase study of Roman-period curse tablets
- Empúriescase study of the Ballesta cemetery tablets
- Via Appiaopening example of a tablet cache
- Romesetting of the Via Appia cache
- Egyptsource of the magical papyri
- Fayumregion of Karanis and the papyri
- Agios Tychonaslocality of the Amathous cache
- Ballesta cemeterycemetery containing three curse tablets
Also named: Spain, Kerkesoucha, Sotas.
Extent 25 plates, maps of Karanis; bibliography pp. 287–326; index pp. 327–342
Defines materia magica, ousia, selenite, muzzling deposit
RomanLate AntiqueModernReligion and CultWritingBurialHistory of ArchaeologyDaily Life
Excavations it is cited for
2 projects- 1893–1894Amathus: the British Museum (Turner Bequest) excavationDirected by Arthur Hamilton Smith and John Linton MyresExcavation
- 1975–todayAmathus: the French School at Athens missionDirected by Pierre Aupert, Antoine Hermary, Jean-Yves Empereur and othersExcavation
Who did what
18 recordsBuying, selling and giving 7
- p. 170
Wilhelm FroehnerBequeathed toCabinet des médailles
Froehner bequeathed his object collection to the Cabinet des médailles.
sa collection d'objetsParis
- 1889 · p. 178
Alexander Stuart MurrayBought fromCharles Christian
Murray expressed interest in the tablets and sent Christian a payment of thirty-five pounds.
Amathous tabletsthirty-five pounds
- 1890 · p. 178
J. HandcockGave toBritish Museum
Handcock gave the British Museum the majority of the tablets from the cache.
lead and selenite tablets from the cache
- p. 178
J. HandcockCorresponded withAlexander Stuart Murray
Handcock corresponded with Murray about the next stage of acquiring the tablets.
Amathous tablets
- p. 178
J. HandcockCorresponded withCecil Smith
probablyHandcock corresponded with Murray's assistant, C. Smith, about the acquisition process.
Amathous tablets
- p. 202
Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaGave toAriodante Fabretti
Cesnola gave three tablets without precise provenance to Senator Fabretti of Turin.
- p. 258
J. HandcockAgent forBritish Museum
Capt. Handcock acquired the cache for the British Museum.
cache of tablets from Amathous
Excavation 4
- 1975–1984 · p. 174
Pierre AupertDirectedmission française de l'École française d'archéologie d'Athènes
Pierre Aupert directed the French School expedition's first excavation season at Amathous.
Archaic to Classical building remains
- 1976–1996 · p. 174
Pavlos FlourentzosDirectedService des Antiquités
P. Flourentzos directed the Service des Antiquités' excavations in the Ayia Mavri sector.
Secteur d’Ayia Mavri
- 1893 · p. 175
Arthur Hamilton SmithExcavated
Smith conducted excavations in 1893; the tombs known north of the site were then about half a mile from Agios Tychonas.
Amathous
- p. 193
Pierre AupertFound
Aupert discovered a late seventh-century lead tablet from Amathous.
a late seventh-century tablet on lead
Recording and study 3
- p. 177
Pierre AupertWorked withDavid Jordan
Aupert and Jordan documented the tablets' route from Cyprus to collections in France and Britain.
Amathous tablets
- p. 193
Pierre AupertPublished
Aupert published a late seventh-century lead tablet from Amathous.
- p. 196
David JordanPublished
Jordan published the selenite tablet NGD 115 from the Amathous cache.
No. NGD 115
Posts and family 4
- 1870 · p. 170
Wilhelm FroehnerEmployed byMusée du Louvre
Froehner held a post as conservateur-adjoint at the Louvre until September 1870.
- 1904 · p. 179
Cecil SmithEmployed byBritish Museum
Smith succeeded Murray as Keeper at the British Museum in 1904.
- 1904 · p. 179
Cecil SmithSucceededAlexander Stuart Murray
Smith succeeded Murray as Keeper in 1904.
- p. 179
Cecil SmithEmployed byVictoria and Albert Museum
Smith left the British Museum to head the Victoria and Albert Museum.
People it is cited for
19 people- Pierre Aupert7 citations
- Charles Christian4 citations
- Cecil Smith3 citations
- Ariodante Fabretti2 citations
- Béatrice Blandin2 citations
- David Jordan2 citations
- J. Handcock2 citations
- J.-P. Prête2 citations
- Sabine Fourrier2 citations
- Thomas Kiely2 citations
- Thomas W. Davis2 citations
- Wilhelm Froehner2 citations
- Despina Pilides
- Eleni Procopiou
- Louisa MacDonald
- Pavlos Flourentzos
- Sophocles Hadjisavvas
- Veronica Tatton-Brown
- Yiannis Violitis
Institutions it is cited for
1 institutionCorrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.