Article · 1994

Ohnefalsch-Richter - Cesnola: ou la recherche des cruches à terres cuites tenant une oinochoe

Frieda Vandenabeele

Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 22 19-31

An article tracing Cypriot jugs that carry a terracotta figure holding an oinochoe, from Ohnefalsch-Richter's excavations to museum collections and the Cesnola collection.

Vandenabeele follows jugs with a terracotta figure holding an oinochoe from Max Ohnefalsch-Richter's excavations to the museums that now hold them, and then to the Cesnola collection. Early publications, excavation records, museum inventories and sale documentation are compared to identify individual vessels and to test their recorded findspots. In museum research she found at least a hundred previously unpublished examples, and she places the first appearance of the type in Cypro-Archaic II, with a continuation through the Hellenistic period and possibly into the Roman.

Objects associated with Ohnefalsch-Richter fall into six groups according to how they entered collections or can be identified, among them documented purchases at the Hoffmann sale, identifications from published illustrations, later gifts, objects retained in Cyprus and illustrated vessels that remain lost. Vandenabeele argues that comparing the 1899 and 1935 Cyprus Museum catalogues rarely establishes a secure match, since the inventories describe and classify the vessels differently (pp. 21–27). C 418, labelled only "Marion" in the Nicosia collection, is matched to earlier illustrations and associated with Marion-Arsinoé necropolis I, tomb 26, while other matches stay uncertain.

What it records

  • Ohnefalsch-Richter excavated 441 tombs at Marion-Arsinoé in 1886, distributed across necropoles I, II and III as 127, 261 and 53 tombs.p. 19
  • One third of Ohnefalsch-Richter's finds, certainly including jugs of this type, remained in Cyprus and never left the island, Vandenabeele states.p. 20
  • Vandenabeele began researching the jug type when Guy Donnay asked her to organise an exhibition around the Nicolas Severis collection.p. 20
  • Vandenabeele says the jug type first appears in Cypro-Archaic II and continues into the Hellenistic period, possibly the Roman period.p. 20
  • The Louvre acquired 22 jugs at the 1887 Hoffmann sale, the largest group of this type bought by a foreign museum.p. 22
  • Vandenabeele identified 79 previously unpublished jugs or fragments of the type in the 1935 Nicosia Museum inventory.p. 24
  • Seven jugs of the type were held by the Metropolitan Museum and recorded as purchased by subscription between 1874 and 1876.p. 28
  • Four jugs were offered in the 1928 sale of duplicates from the Cesnola collection, and two were later traced to museums.p. 29

Where to read

  • Ohnefalsch-Richter's excavations and six categories of object identificationpp. 19–27
  • Cyprus Museum inventories and identifications of individual jugspp. 24–26
  • Cesnola collection, 1928 sale and later museum locationspp. 28–30

Contents

  • Max Ohnefalsch-Richter19
  • Luigi Palma di Cesnola28

Objects published here

5
  • Jug with Eros and Psyche holding the oinochoe together, Musée de Nicosie, Marion-Arsinoé, nécropole I, tombe 26, C 418, pl. IV: 1 (p. 25)
  • Plain White VII jug with a figure holding an oinochoe, Musée de Nicosie, Amathonte, tombe 97, C 387, pl. IV: 4-5 (p. 25)
  • Jug from Kourion, Musée de Nicosie, Kourion, C 409, pl. IV: 6 (p. 26)
  • Bichrome Red II (V) jug, Muzeum - Zamer w Goluchowie, Marion-Arsinoé, nécropole II, tombe 118, Inv. 209, pl. II: 1-3 (p. 23)
  • Bichrome Red III (VII) jug, Walters Art Gallery, 48.2043, pl. VII: 1 (p. 29)

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

  • Musée Royal de Mariemontvenue of the 1982 Cyprus exhibition
  • Musée du Louvreholds jugs bought at the Hoffmann sale
  • Musée de Nicosieholds jugs inventoried in 1935
  • Metropolitan Museumholds jugs from the Cesnola collection
  • British Museumholds jugs acquired in 1887 and 1876
  • Nationalmuseet de Copenhagenholds three Hoffmann-sale jugs
  • Walters Art Galleryholds a jug traced from the 1928 sale
  • The John and Mabel Ringling Museum of Artholds two jugs associated with John Ringling

Places

  • Marion-Arsinoésite of Ohnefalsch-Richter's necropolis excavations
  • Kourionexcavation site and reported production centre
  • Amathontesource of jugs and fragments

Also named: Nicolas Severis, Annie Caubet, Polis Chrysochous.

Extent pp. 19–32, VII pls; plan of the Marion-Arsinoé necropoles

Cypro-ArchaicCypro-ClassicalHellenisticRomanModernPotteryFigurinesCollectingMuseumsHistory of Archaeology

Excavations it is cited for

3 projects

Who did what

26 records

Buying, selling and giving 12

  • Max Ohnefalsch-RichterSold

    A part of Ohnefalsch-Richter's collection was sold at the Hoffmann sale in Paris.

    With acheteurs non nommés à la vente Hoffmannune partie de la collection d'Ohnefalsch-Richter

    1887 · p. 20
  • Max Ohnefalsch-RichterDispersed a collection

    His collection and the jugs discussed in the article were dispersed across Europe.

    collection et vases

    p. 20
  • Peter Julius LoytvedBought

    J. Loytved bought the jug in Beirut in 1886.

    cruche Plain White VIINo. I.N. 955Beyrouth

    1886 · p. 24
  • Peter Julius LoytvedSold toNy Carlsberg Glyptotek

    J. Loytved sold the jug to the museum in the same year he bought it.

    cruche Plain White VII I.N. 955No. I.N. 955

    p. 24
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toMetropolitan Museum of Art

    Cesnola agreed to sell his collection to the Metropolitan Museum for £1,200.

    £1,200New York

    1870–1876 · p. 28
  • Arnold GentheBought fromTrustees of the Metropolitan Museum of Art

    Arnold Genthe acquired lot 508 at the 1928 sale of duplicates from the Cesnola collection.

    cruche avec une figurine tenant une oinochoéNo. n° 508New York City

    1928 · p. 29
  • J. A. PlimptonBought fromTrustees of the Metropolitan Museum of Art

    J. A. Plimpton acquired lot 506 at the 1928 sale of duplicates from the Cesnola collection.

    cruche avec une figurine tenant une oinochoéNo. n° 506New York City

    1928 · p. 29
  • John RinglingBought fromMetropolitan Museum of Art

    John Ringling bought lot 507 at the 1928 sale of duplicates from the Cesnola collection.

    cruche avec une figurine tenant une oinochoéNo. n° 507New York City

    1928 · p. 29
  • John RinglingAcquired

    John Ringling acquired a lamp fragment in 1928.

    No. SN28.931

    1928 · p. 29
  • Mrs Samuel C. LamportBought fromTrustees of the Metropolitan Museum of Art

    Mme S. C. Lamport bought lot 509 at the 1928 sale of duplicates from the Cesnola collection.

    cruche avec une figurine tenant une oinochoéNo. n° 509New York City

    1928 · p. 29
  • Robert Weeks de ForestOffered for sale

    As president of the Trustees, Robert W. De Forest put four jugs from the Cesnola collection up for public sale as duplicates.

    With acheteurs non nommésquatre cruches avec une figurine tenant une oinochoéNo. 506, 507, 508 et 509New York City

    1928 · p. 29
  • Mrs Samuel C. LamportGave toWalters Art Gallery

    A jug from Mme S. C. Lamport's estate was given to the Walters Art Gallery in 1952.

    cruche Bichrome Red III (VII)No. 48.2043Baltimore

    1952 · p. 29

Excavation 5

  • Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavated

    Max Ohnefalsch-Richter undertook excavations at Kourion that produced jugs with terracottas holding an oinochoé.

    cruches à terres cuites tenant une oinochoé

    1883 · p. 19
  • Max Ohnefalsch-RichterFound

    Ohnefalsch-Richter discovered three necropolises at Marion-Arsinoé.

    trois nécropoles

    1885 · p. 19
  • Max Ohnefalsch-RichterExcavated

    Ohnefalsch-Richter undertook extensive excavations at Marion-Arsinoé in 1886, opening 441 tombs, principally in the eastern necropolis.

    Marion-Arsinoé, principalement la nécropole orientale

    1886 · p. 19
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaExcavated

    Cesnola excavated at Kourion and the sanctuary of Apollo Hylates in 1874–1875.

    Kourion et sanctuaire d'Apollon Hylatès

    1874–1875 · p. 28
  • Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaFound

    Alessandro Palma di Cesnola found a jug of a late type, probably Hellenistic.

    brocca piriforme avec une figurine féminine portant un petit vaseNo. fig. 294-295

    p. 30

Recording and study 8

  • Guy DonnayConnected withFrieda Vandenabeele

    Guy Donnay asked Frieda Vandenabeele to organize a small exhibition of Cypriot art around the Nicolas Severis collection.

    collection Nicolas Severis

    1981 · p. 20
  • Frieda VandenabeeleStudied

    Vandenabeele examined previously unpublished examples in museums in Cyprus and abroad.

    au moins une centaine d'exemplaires inéditsmusées de Chypre et musées d'Europe, Israël, Canada et États-Unis

    p. 20
  • Paul HerrmannStudied

    Herrmann analyzed the development and purpose of the jugs in his study of the Marion cemetery.

    cruches à terres cuites tenant une oinochoéMarion-Arsinoé

    p. 21
  • Frieda VandenabeeleStudied

    Vandenabeele studied the Nicosia Museum jugs and fragments, except for three that had been exchanged with M. Petrakides.

    vases ou fragments de vase, sauf trois échangésMusée de Nicosie

    p. 24
  • Frieda VandenabeelePhotographed

    Vandenabeele photographed the Nicosia Museum jugs and fragments, except for three that had been exchanged with M. Petrakides.

    vases ou fragments de vase, sauf trois échangésMusée de Nicosie

    p. 24
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaEmployed byNew York Metropolitan Museum of Art

    The trustees hired Cesnola to unpack, arrange and classify the collection.

    $500 a monthNew York

    1877–1904 · p. 28
  • John Howard YoungPublished

    Young published an article describing the jug and arguing that it had been made at Kourion around 330–300 BCE.

    cruche Bichrome Red III (VII)No. 48.2043

    1953 · p. 29
  • Alessandro (Alexander) Palma di CesnolaPublished

    Alessandro Palma di Cesnola published the jug in Salamina (Cipro).

    brocca piriforme avec figure féminineNo. fig. 294-295Torino

    1887 · p. 30

Posts and family 1

  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaEmployed byEtats-Unis

    Cesnola served as United States consul in Cyprus from 1865 to 1876.

    Chypre

    1865–1876 · p. 28

People it is cited for

1 person

Institutions it is cited for

1 institution

Mentioned in

31 mentions

Tomb records · 28

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.